Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Comment on "Quantum mechanics of Hyperion"

Maximilian Schlosshauer

Published May 31, 2006• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In a recent paper [N. Wiebe and L. E. Ballentine, Phys. Rev. A 72, 022109 (2005)], the authors claim that, contrary to a previous suggestion by W. H. Zurek [Phys. Scri. T 76, 186 (1998)], environmental decoherence is not required to prevent chaotically tumbling satellites such as Hyperion from exhibiting nonclassical behavior within a short time span. We argue that this claim results (i) from a fundamentally different assumption about the interpretation of the quantum formalism, and (ii) from a misunderstanding of the aim of Zurek's paper and of the meaning of decoherence.

Related papers

Classicality without Decoherence: A Reply to Schlosshauer

L. E. Ballentine

Schlosshauer has criticized the conclusion of Wiebe and Ballentine (Phys. Rev. A 72:022109, 2005 ) that decoherence is not essential for the emergence of classicality from quantum mechanics. I reply to the issues raised in his critique, which range from the interpretation of quantum mechanics to the criterion for classicality, and conclude that the role of decoherence in these issues is much more restricted than is often claimed.

Foundations of Physics•Oct 1, 2008•19 citations

Why We Don't Need Quantum Planetary Dynamics: Decoherence and the Correspondence Principle for Chaotic Systems

Wojciech Hubert Zurek, Juan Pablo Paz

Violation of correspondence principle may occur for very macroscopic byt isolated quantum systems on rather short timescales as illustrated by the case of Hyperion, the chaotically tumbling moon of Saturn, for which quantum and classical predictions are expected to diverge on a timescale of approximately 20 years. Motivated by Hyperion, we review salient features of ``quantum chaos'' and show that decoherence is the essential ingredient of the classical limit, as it enables one to solve the apparent paradox caused by the breakdown of the correspondence principle for classically chaotic systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/9612037•Talk given at•Dec 12, 1996•12 citations

Comment on "Environmental memory effects and quantum resource hierarchies in polarized hyperon--antihyperon systems"

Saeed Haddadi

We comment on the recent work [Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 988 (2026)], which investigates quantum resources in polarized hyperon--antihyperon systems using correlated dephasing channels with memory. Although the use of experimentally reconstructed spin-density matrices to characterize quantum correlations in hyperon production may be a good motivation, we argue that the interpretation of the hyperon--antihyperon pair as an open quantum system undergoing correlated environmental decoherence is not physically established. In particular, no physical environment or system--environment interaction responsible for the assumed correlated dephasing channel is identified, and hadronization cannot simply be interpreted as such an environmental dephasing process. Consequently, the claimed non-Markovianity, information backflow, and memory-assisted protection of quantum resources should be regarded as properties of a phenomenological channel rather than established physical effects in hyperon--antihyperon production. We also identify several technical and conceptual issues concerning the dephasing dynamics, entanglement quantification, basis dependence of coherence, and the claimed hierarchy of quantum resources. These issues call for a substantial revision of the physical interpretation and quantitative conclusions of the work. We hope that the present Comment will help clarify the distinction between phenomenological quantum-channel modeling and physically established dynamical mechanisms in high-energy particle systems, and thereby provide useful guidance for future studies and help avoid similar conceptual and technical issues.

quant-pharXiv:2609.01686•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

Deconstructing decoherence

J. R. Anglin, Juan Pablo Paz, Wojciech Hubert Zurek

The study of environmentally induced superselection and of the process of decoherence was originally motivated by the search for the emergence of classical behavior out of the quantum substrate, in the macroscopic limit [W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. D 24, 1516 (1981); 26, 1862 (1982)]. This limit, and other simplifying assumptions, have allowed the derivation of several simple results characterizing the onset of environmentally induced superselection; but these results are increasingly often regarded as a complete phenomenological characterization of decoherence in any regime. This is not necessarily the case: the examples presented in this paper counteract this impression by violating several of the simple general rules. This is relevant because decoherence is now beginning to be tested experimentally [C. Monroe et al., Science 272, 1131 (1996); M. Brune et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4887 (1996)], and one may anticipate that, in at least some of the proposed applications (e.g., quantum computers), only the basic principle of ``monitoring by the environment'' will survive. The phenomenology of decoherence may turn out to be significantly different.

arXiv:quant-ph/9611045•Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1997•125 citations

Comment on ‘‘Intrinsic decoherence in quantum mechanics’’

J. Finkelstein

Milburn has recently proposed a model [Phys. Rev. A 44, 5401 (1991)] in which quantum states evolve into statistical mixtures of stationary states. One might think that this would imply that any observable quantity would become independent of time. We argue that, on the contrary, the decoherence implied by Milburn's model would have no observable effect at all.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1993•11 citations

Comment on “Decoherence, Chaos, and the Second Law”

Giulio Casati, Boris V. Chirikov

A Comment on the Letter by Wojciech Hubert Zurek and Juan Pablo Paz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2508 (1994). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.Received 26 August 1994DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.75.350©1995 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 1995•51 citations
In a recent paper [N. Wiebe and L. E. Ballentine, Phys. Rev. A 72, 022109 (2005)], the authors claim that, contrary to a previous suggestion by W. H. Zurek [Phys. Scri. T 76, 186 (1998)], environmental decoherence is not required to prevent chaotically tumbling satellites such as Hyperion from exhibiting nonclassical behavior within a short time span. We argue that this claim results (i) from a fundamentally different assumption about the interpretation of the quantum formalism, and (ii) from a misunderstanding of the aim of Zurek's paper and of the meaning of decoherence.
Violation of correspondence principle may occur for very macroscopic byt isolated quantum systems on rather short timescales as illustrated by the case of Hyperion, the chaotically tumbling moon of Saturn, for which quantum and classical predictions are expected to diverge on a timescale of approximately 20 years. Motivated by Hyperion, we review salient features of ``quantum chaos'' and show that decoherence is the essential ingredient of the classical limit, as it enables one to solve the apparent paradox caused by the breakdown of the correspondence principle for classically chaotic systems.
We comment on the recent work [Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 988 (2026)], which investigates quantum resources in polarized hyperon--antihyperon systems using correlated dephasing channels with memory. Although the use of experimentally reconstructed spin-density matrices to characterize quantum correlations in hyperon production may be a good motivation, we argue that the interpretation of the hyperon--antihyperon pair as an open quantum system undergoing correlated environmental decoherence is not physically established. In particular, no physical environment or system--environment interaction responsible for the assumed correlated dephasing channel is identified, and hadronization cannot simply be interpreted as such an environmental dephasing process. Consequently, the claimed non-Markovianity, information backflow, and memory-assisted protection of quantum resources should be regarded as properties of a phenomenological channel rather than established physical effects in hyperon--antihyperon production. We also identify several technical and conceptual issues concerning the dephasing dynamics, entanglement quantification, basis dependence of coherence, and the claimed hierarchy of quantum resources. These issues call for a substantial revision of the physical interpretation and quantitative conclusions of the work. We hope that the present Comment will help clarify the distinction between phenomenological quantum-channel modeling and physically established dynamical mechanisms in high-energy particle systems, and thereby provide useful guidance for future studies and help avoid similar conceptual and technical issues.
The study of environmentally induced superselection and of the process of decoherence was originally motivated by the search for the emergence of classical behavior out of the quantum substrate, in the macroscopic limit [W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. D 24, 1516 (1981); 26, 1862 (1982)]. This limit, and other simplifying assumptions, have allowed the derivation of several simple results characterizing the onset of environmentally induced superselection; but these results are increasingly often regarded as a complete phenomenological characterization of decoherence in any regime. This is not necessarily the case: the examples presented in this paper counteract this impression by violating several of the simple general rules. This is relevant because decoherence is now beginning to be tested experimentally [C. Monroe et al., Science 272, 1131 (1996); M. Brune et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4887 (1996)], and one may anticipate that, in at least some of the proposed applications (e.g., quantum computers), only the basic principle of ``monitoring by the environment'' will survive. The phenomenology of decoherence may turn out to be significantly different.