Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of Frontiers of Fundamental Physics 14 — PoS(FFP14)

Do Quanta Need a New Logic?

John J. Stachel

Published Sep 15, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

What is Logic? My answer consists of three steps: Logic is about Language, Language is about the World. Panlogism is the attempt to "short circuit" this process by identifying the real object and the "concrete-in-thought." It leads to the assertion: Logic is about the World. If we abandon panlogism, we see that quantum logics (note the plural!) are just different ways of reformulating the same content. The danger: is that, If we accept the idea of one unique quantum logic, that provides all the answers, this prevents us from confronting the real questions about quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.22323/1.224.0218

Related papers

Conclusion

Peter Gibbins

Quantum logic is the logic of the high-level language in which we describe what is true and false of quantum systems. I use the term ‘highlevel’ in its computational sense. The language whose logic quantum logic is, is inexpressive. It has no machinery for describing probabilities, only truths and falsehoods and perhaps whatever is in between. Quantum logic conceals from its user the underlying details of the formalism of quantum mechanics, and the details (whatever they may be) of the underlying ‘machine’, the physical world. Quantum logic encourages a top-down view of the quantum world. Quantum mechanics, as done by the practising physicist, is bottom-up. The program of feeding back quantum logic into our metalevel discussion of realism fails. Quantum logic does not licence quantummechanical realism. It cannot override or rewrite the bottom-up view. The program itself is odd in that quantum logic is most naturally thought of as expressing quantum-mechanical antirealism, just as quantum mechanics itself is most naturally interpreted antirealistically. Thus quantum logic is consonant with nonlocality, in the sense that it does not allow one to derive the Bell inequalities. The conditional in quantum logic nicely expresses the effect of ideal measurements on quantum systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 25, 1987•0 citations

The Metalogic of Quantum Logic

Peter Mittelstaedt

In order to establish the object language of quantum physics, we begin with a quantum mechanical system S (atom, nucleus, elementary particle) and consider propositions A,B,… about this system S which can be proved or disproved by measuring processes. These propositions will be called elementary propositions. We will assume here that elementary propositions are value definite, i.e.,there always exists an experimental testing procedure which decides between truth and falsity of the respective proposition. The logical connectives A ∧ B (A and B), A ∨ B (A or B), A → B (A then B) and ┐ A (not A) will be defined by means of dialogs. A dialog is a formalized kind of discussion between two participants, the proponent P who asserts a certain proposition and the opponent 0 who attempts to refute it.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1978•1 citation

Quantum Logic and Meaning

Geoffrey Paul Hellman

In concluding their major survey, “Quantum Logics,” Greechie and Gudder (1975) listed four outstanding directions for future research, the last of which was, “Explain the meaning of the word ‘logic’ in the title of this paper.” Broadly speaking, there are two radically different points of view on this. There is the view that, taken strictly, ‘logic’ is a misnomer: quantum logic studies certain algebraic structures naturally arising from the formal, apparatus of quantum theory, structures which may afford insights into quantum physics, on a number of levels, but which do not in any way involve giving up or replacing classical logical laws. (Cf., e.g., Jauch (1968, p. 77).) In contrast, there is the view that the non-Boolean structures arising from the Hilbert space formalism should be taken as giving rise to a genuine non-classical logic, in conflict with classical logic, but appropriate to the description of quantum mechanical reality.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1980•19 citations

Metaheuristics on quantum computers: Inspiration, simulation and real execution

Zakaria Abdelmoiz Dahi, Enrique Alba

Quantum-inspired metaheuristics are solvers that incorporate principles inspired from quantum mechanics into classical-approximate algorithms using non-quantum machines. Due to the uniqueness of quantum principles, the inspiration of quantum phenomena and the way it is done in fundamentally different non-quantum systems rather than real or simulated quantum computers raise important questions about these algorithms’ design and the reproducibility of their results in real or simulated quantum devices. Thus, this work’s contribution stands in a first step towards answering those questions as an attempt to identify key findings in the existing literature that should be considered or adapted in order to build hybrid or fully-quantum algorithms that can be used in quantum machines. This is done by proposing and studying four inspired, simulated and real quantum cellular genetic algorithms that, as far as the authors’ knowledge, are the first quantum structured metaheuristics studied in the three quantum realms using a quantum simulator with 32 quantum bits and a real quantum machine employing 15 superconducting quantum bits. The users’ mobility management in cellular networks is taken as a validation problem using 13 real-world instances. The comparisons have been made against 6 diverse algorithms using 9 comparison metrics. Thorough statistical tests and parameters’ sensitivity analysis have been also conducted. The experiments allowed answering several questions, including how quantum hardware influences the studied-algorithms’ search process. They also enabled opening new perspectives in quantum metaheuristics’ design.

Future Generation Computer Systems•Dec 23, 2021•19 citations

Quantum logic: what it can and can't do

Peter Gibbins

What do we expect of a quantum logical interpretation of quantum mechanics worthy of the name? In what sense should it resolve the paradoxes? What scope should it have? Should quantum logic, if it is successful in the micro world, replace classical logic in the macro world and in mathematics?

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 25, 1987•0 citations

Schrodinger's Rabbits: The Many Worlds of Quantum

Colin Bruce

For the better part of a century, attempts to explain what was really going on in the quantum world seemed doomed to failure. But recent technological advances have made the question both practical and urgent. A brilliantly imaginative group of physicists at Oxford University have risen to the challenge. This is their story. At long last, there is a sensible way to think about quantum mechanics. The new view abolishes the need to believe in randomness, long-range spooky forces, or conscious observers with mysterious powers to collapse cats into a state of life or death. But the new understanding comes at a price: we must accept that we live in a multiverse wherein countless versions of reality unfold side-by-side. The philosophical and personal consequences of this are awe-inspiring. The new interpretation has allowed imaginative physicists to conceive of wonderful new technologies: measuring devices that effectively share information between worlds and computers that can borrow the power of other worlds to perform calculations. Step by step, the problems initially associated with the original many-worlds formulation have been addressed and answered so that a clear but startling new picture has emerged. Just as Copenhagen was the centre of quantum discussion a lifetime ago, so Oxford has been the epicenter of the modern debate, with such figures as Roger Penrose and Anton Zeilinger fighting for single-world views, and David Deutsch, Lev Vaidman and a host of others for many-worlds. An independent physicist living in Oxford, Bruce has had a ringside seat to the debate. In his capable hands, we understand why the initially fantastic sounding many-worlds view is not only a useful way to look at things, but logically compelling. Parallel worlds are as real as the distant galaxies detected by the Hubble Space Telescope, even though the evidence for their existence may consist only of a few photons.

•Oct 13, 2004•8 citations
What is Logic? My answer consists of three steps: Logic is about Language, Language is about the World. Panlogism is the attempt to "short circuit" this process by identifying the real object and the "concrete-in-thought." It leads to the assertion: Logic is about the World. If we abandon panlogism, we see that quantum logics (note the plural!) are just different ways of reformulating the same content. The danger: is that, If we accept the idea of one unique quantum logic, that provides all the answers, this prevents us from confronting the real questions about quantum mechanics.
Quantum logic is the logic of the high-level language in which we describe what is true and false of quantum systems. I use the term ‘highlevel’ in its computational sense. The language whose logic quantum logic is, is inexpressive. It has no machinery for describing probabilities, only truths and falsehoods and perhaps whatever is in between. Quantum logic conceals from its user the underlying details of the formalism of quantum mechanics, and the details (whatever they may be) of the underlying ‘machine’, the physical world. Quantum logic encourages a top-down view of the quantum world. Quantum mechanics, as done by the practising physicist, is bottom-up. The program of feeding back quantum logic into our metalevel discussion of realism fails. Quantum logic does not licence quantummechanical realism. It cannot override or rewrite the bottom-up view. The program itself is odd in that quantum logic is most naturally thought of as expressing quantum-mechanical antirealism, just as quantum mechanics itself is most naturally interpreted antirealistically. Thus quantum logic is consonant with nonlocality, in the sense that it does not allow one to derive the Bell inequalities. The conditional in quantum logic nicely expresses the effect of ideal measurements on quantum systems.
In order to establish the object language of quantum physics, we begin with a quantum mechanical system S (atom, nucleus, elementary particle) and consider propositions A,B,… about this system S which can be proved or disproved by measuring processes. These propositions will be called elementary propositions. We will assume here that elementary propositions are value definite, i.e.,there always exists an experimental testing procedure which decides between truth and falsity of the respective proposition. The logical connectives A ∧ B (A and B), A ∨ B (A or B), A → B (A then B) and ┐ A (not A) will be defined by means of dialogs. A dialog is a formalized kind of discussion between two participants, the proponent P who asserts a certain proposition and the opponent 0 who attempts to refute it.
In concluding their major survey, “Quantum Logics,” Greechie and Gudder (1975) listed four outstanding directions for future research, the last of which was, “Explain the meaning of the word ‘logic’ in the title of this paper.” Broadly speaking, there are two radically different points of view on this. There is the view that, taken strictly, ‘logic’ is a misnomer: quantum logic studies certain algebraic structures naturally arising from the formal, apparatus of quantum theory, structures which may afford insights into quantum physics, on a number of levels, but which do not in any way involve giving up or replacing classical logical laws. (Cf., e.g., Jauch (1968, p. 77).) In contrast, there is the view that the non-Boolean structures arising from the Hilbert space formalism should be taken as giving rise to a genuine non-classical logic, in conflict with classical logic, but appropriate to the description of quantum mechanical reality.
Quantum-inspired metaheuristics are solvers that incorporate principles inspired from quantum mechanics into classical-approximate algorithms using non-quantum machines. Due to the uniqueness of quantum principles, the inspiration of quantum phenomena and the way it is done in fundamentally different non-quantum systems rather than real or simulated quantum computers raise important questions about these algorithms’ design and the reproducibility of their results in real or simulated quantum devices. Thus, this work’s contribution stands in a first step towards answering those questions as an attempt to identify key findings in the existing literature that should be considered or adapted in order to build hybrid or fully-quantum algorithms that can be used in quantum machines. This is done by proposing and studying four inspired, simulated and real quantum cellular genetic algorithms that, as far as the authors’ knowledge, are the first quantum structured metaheuristics studied in the three quantum realms using a quantum simulator with 32 quantum bits and a real quantum machine employing 15 superconducting quantum bits. The users’ mobility management in cellular networks is taken as a validation problem using 13 real-world instances. The comparisons have been made against 6 diverse algorithms using 9 comparison metrics. Thorough statistical tests and parameters’ sensitivity analysis have been also conducted. The experiments allowed answering several questions, including how quantum hardware influences the studied-algorithms’ search process. They also enabled opening new perspectives in quantum metaheuristics’ design.
For the better part of a century, attempts to explain what was really going on in the quantum world seemed doomed to failure. But recent technological advances have made the question both practical and urgent. A brilliantly imaginative group of physicists at Oxford University have risen to the challenge. This is their story. At long last, there is a sensible way to think about quantum mechanics. The new view abolishes the need to believe in randomness, long-range spooky forces, or conscious observers with mysterious powers to collapse cats into a state of life or death. But the new understanding comes at a price: we must accept that we live in a multiverse wherein countless versions of reality unfold side-by-side. The philosophical and personal consequences of this are awe-inspiring. The new interpretation has allowed imaginative physicists to conceive of wonderful new technologies: measuring devices that effectively share information between worlds and computers that can borrow the power of other worlds to perform calculations. Step by step, the problems initially associated with the original many-worlds formulation have been addressed and answered so that a clear but startling new picture has emerged. Just as Copenhagen was the centre of quantum discussion a lifetime ago, so Oxford has been the epicenter of the modern debate, with such figures as Roger Penrose and Anton Zeilinger fighting for single-world views, and David Deutsch, Lev Vaidman and a host of others for many-worlds. An independent physicist living in Oxford, Bruce has had a ringside seat to the debate. In his capable hands, we understand why the initially fantastic sounding many-worlds view is not only a useful way to look at things, but logically compelling. Parallel worlds are as real as the distant galaxies detected by the Hubble Space Telescope, even though the evidence for their existence may consist only of a few photons.