Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

ISAIM

Quadratizations of symmetric pseudo-Boolean functions: sub-linear bounds on the number of auxiliary variables

Endre Boros, Yves Crama, Elisabeth Rodríguez-Heck

Published Jan 4, 2018• 7 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The problem of minimizing a pseudo-Boolean function with no additional constraints arises in a variety of applications.A quadratization is a quadratic reformulation of the nonlinear problem obtained by introducing a set of auxiliary binary variables which can be optimized using quadratic optimization techniques.Using the well-known result that a pseudo-Boolean function can be uniquely expressed as a multilinear polynomial, any pseudo-Boolean function can be quadratized by providing a quadratization for negative monomials and one for positive monomials.A desirable property for a quadratization is to introduce small number of auxiliary variables.For the case of negative monomials there exists a quadratization using a single auxiliary variable which is, in addition, submodular.However, much less is known for positive monomials.The best lower bound on the number of variables required by a quadratization in the literature is n-1 2 .We present here new quadratizations of the positive monomial that significantly improve this lower bound decreasing it to a logarithmic bound.This lower bound is derived from a more general result, stating that a quadratization with a logarithmic number of variables can be defined for exact kout-of-n functions, which is a more general class of symmetric functions.Moreover, for exact k-out-of-n functions we also prove that a logarithmic number of variables is necessary when requiring certain symmetry conditions to the quadratization.Finally, we provide quadratizations for general symmetric functions using O( √ n) auxiliary variables.This upper bound nicely matches a lower bound of Ω( √ n) variables that was recently introduced.

Related papers

Efficient QUBO transformation for Higher Degree Pseudo Boolean Functions

Amit Verma, Mark W. Lewis, Gary A. Kochenberger

Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) is recognized as a unifying framework for modeling a wide range of problems. Problems can be solved with commercial solvers customized for solving QUBO and since QUBO have degree two, it is useful to have a method for transforming higher degree pseudo-Boolean problems to QUBO format. The standard transformation approach requires additional auxiliary variables supported by penalty terms for each higher degree term. This paper improves on the existing cubic-to-quadratic transformation approach by minimizing the number of additional variables as well as penalty coefficient. Extensive experimental testing on Max 3-SAT modeled as QUBO shows a near 100% reduction in the subproblem size used for minimization of the number of auxiliary variables.

arXiv:2107.11695•Jul 24, 2021•12 citations

A Simple Heuristic for Expressing a Truth Table as a Quadratic Pseudo-Boolean Function

Scott Pakin

Quadratic pseudo-Boolean functions (i.e., quadratic functions with real-valued coefficients and two-valued variables) are the native input to quantum annealers and also a common problem format to optimize with the QAOA algorithm on circuitmodel quantum computers. In both cases, large, complex optimization problems can be expressed in terms of combinations of simpler problems. A key challenge in problem set-up lies in finding the coefficients for the constituent sub-problems. These need to be chosen such that the function is minimized on valid inputs and is higher elsewhere. One difficulty is that it is not possible in general to solve for a sub-problem’s coefficients without introducing ancillary variables, the number of which and their corresponding per-row values being unknown a priori. These unknowns lead to solving for a sub-problem’s coefficients being an NP-complete problem.In this paper we present a simple heuristic that considers a prioritized subset of the exponential number of possibilities for each per-row ancillary variable. Using this heuristic, coefficients can be found substantially faster than would be possible using a brute-force search and with less software complexity than is required by prior approaches.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Oct 1, 2021•2 citations

Quadratic Optimization in 0–1 Variables

Alain Billionnet

This chapter introduces some theoretical and algorithmic aspects of quadratic optimization in bivalent variables, which is, in general, an NP-hard problem. It discusses the central problem of quadratic optimization in 0–1 variables without constraints. The chapter reviews some results in the constraint case. It also discusses a property of pseudo-Boolean functions that is relatively rare in optimization. The chapter examines a formulation of the problem of maximizing a quadratic pseudo-Boolean functions (qpBf) using a mixed integer linear program. It focuses on the optimization of a function of bivalent variables subject to some constraints. This optimization model is extremely general and the chapter limits to the problem of optimizing a quadratic pseudo-Boolean function with linear constraints. The chapter shows that the optimal value of the dual Lagrangian problem is equal to the optimal value of the continuous relaxation of the classical linearization of the initial problem.

Wiley eBooks•Jul 10, 2014•2 citations

All 4-variable functions can be perfectly quadratized with only 1 auxiliary variable

Nike Dattani, Hou Tin Chau

We prove that any function with real-valued coefficients, whose input is 4 binary variables and whose output is a real number, is perfectly equivalent to a quadratic function whose input is 5 binary variables and is minimized over the new variable. Our proof is constructive: we provide quadratizations for all possible 4-variable functions. There exists 4 different classes of 4-variable functions that each have their own 5-variable quadratization formula. Since we provide 'perfect' quadratizations, we can apply these formulas to any 4-variable subset of an n-variable function even if n >> 4. We provide 5 examples of functions that can be quadratized using the result of this work. For each of the 5 examples we compare the best possible quadratization we could construct using previously known methods, to a quadratization that we construct using our new result. In the most extreme example, the quadratization using our new result needs only N auxiliary variables for a 4N-variable degree-4 function, whereas the previous state-of-the-art quadratization requires 2N (double as many) auxiliary variables and therefore we can reduce by the cost of optimizing such a function by a factor of 2^1000 if it were to have 4000 variables before quadratization. In all 5 of our examples, the range of coefficient sizes in our quadratic function is smaller than in the previous state-of-the-art one, and our coefficient range is a factor of 7 times smaller in our 15-term, 5-variable example of a degree-4 function.

arXiv:1910.13583•Oct 29, 2019•7 citations

Sharp sparse quadratization of weighted quartic Boolean costs

Robert Barritz

A quadratization represents a Boolean cost by minimizing a quadratic cost over auxiliary variables. For a four-variable family with one positive quartic coefficient and six sufficiently negative quadratic coefficients, this work determines the exact uniform error with at most six genuine pair interactions, allowing any finite auxiliary set. The optimum is the minimum of an explicit quadratic fallback and thirty-nine scalar capacities, explained by three response mechanisms. Interval endpoints and rational max flow construct attaining nonnegative rational networks with at most two auxiliary variables, without optimization linear programs. A structural lower bound covers all finite auxiliary sets. The paper also gives the separate one-auxiliary seven-, eight- and nine-interaction formulas, the one-auxiliary six-interaction procedure with 57 rational linear programs, and an exact interaction frontier. Absolute costs are retained. The results are proof-supported candidate theorems for this structured family; no claim about arbitrary quartic targets or hardware performance is made.

•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

Quadratic reformulations for the optimization of pseudo-boolean functions

Yves Crama, Sourour Elloumi, Amélie Lambert +1 more

We investigate various solution approaches for the uncon-strained minimization of a pseudo-boolean function. Moreprecisely, we assume that the original function is expressedas a real-valued polynomial in 0-1 variables, of degree threeor more, and we consider a generic family of two-step ap-proaches for its minimization. First, a quadratic reformu-lation step aims at transforming the minimization probleminto an equivalent constrained or unconstrained quadratic0-1 minimization problem (where “equivalent” means herethat a minimizer of the original function can be easily de-duced from a minimizer of the reformulation). Second, anoptimization step handles the obtained equivalent quadraticproblem.We provide a unified presentation of several quadratic re-formulation schemes proposed in the literature, e.g., (An-thony et al. 2017; Buchheim and Rinaldi 2007; Rodr ́ıguez-Heck 2018; Rosenberg 1975), and we review several meth-ods that can be applied in the optimization step, includinga standard linearization procedure (Fortet 1959) and moreelaborate convex quadratic reformulations, as in (Billionnetand Elloumi 2007; Billionnet, Elloumi, and Lambert 2012,2016; Elloumi, Lambert, and Lazare 2021). We discuss theimpact of the reformulation scheme on the efficiency of theoptimization step and we illustrate our discussion with somecomputational results on different classes of instances.

•Jan 3, 2022•0 citations
The problem of minimizing a pseudo-Boolean function with no additional constraints arises in a variety of applications.A quadratization is a quadratic reformulation of the nonlinear problem obtained by introducing a set of auxiliary binary variables which can be optimized using quadratic optimization techniques.Using the well-known result that a pseudo-Boolean function can be uniquely expressed as a multilinear polynomial, any pseudo-Boolean function can be quadratized by providing a quadratization for negative monomials and one for positive monomials.A desirable property for a quadratization is to introduce small number of auxiliary variables.For the case of negative monomials there exists a quadratization using a single auxiliary variable which is, in addition, submodular.However, much less is known for positive monomials.The best lower bound on the number of variables required by a quadratization in the literature is n-1 2 .We present here new quadratizations of the positive monomial that significantly improve this lower bound decreasing it to a logarithmic bound.This lower bound is derived from a more general result, stating that a quadratization with a logarithmic number of variables can be defined for exact kout-of-n functions, which is a more general class of symmetric functions.Moreover, for exact k-out-of-n functions we also prove that a logarithmic number of variables is necessary when requiring certain symmetry conditions to the quadratization.Finally, we provide quadratizations for general symmetric functions using O( √ n) auxiliary variables.This upper bound nicely matches a lower bound of Ω( √ n) variables that was recently introduced.
Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) is recognized as a unifying framework for modeling a wide range of problems. Problems can be solved with commercial solvers customized for solving QUBO and since QUBO have degree two, it is useful to have a method for transforming higher degree pseudo-Boolean problems to QUBO format. The standard transformation approach requires additional auxiliary variables supported by penalty terms for each higher degree term. This paper improves on the existing cubic-to-quadratic transformation approach by minimizing the number of additional variables as well as penalty coefficient. Extensive experimental testing on Max 3-SAT modeled as QUBO shows a near 100% reduction in the subproblem size used for minimization of the number of auxiliary variables.
Quadratic pseudo-Boolean functions (i.e., quadratic functions with real-valued coefficients and two-valued variables) are the native input to quantum annealers and also a common problem format to optimize with the QAOA algorithm on circuitmodel quantum computers. In both cases, large, complex optimization problems can be expressed in terms of combinations of simpler problems. A key challenge in problem set-up lies in finding the coefficients for the constituent sub-problems. These need to be chosen such that the function is minimized on valid inputs and is higher elsewhere. One difficulty is that it is not possible in general to solve for a sub-problem’s coefficients without introducing ancillary variables, the number of which and their corresponding per-row values being unknown a priori. These unknowns lead to solving for a sub-problem’s coefficients being an NP-complete problem.In this paper we present a simple heuristic that considers a prioritized subset of the exponential number of possibilities for each per-row ancillary variable. Using this heuristic, coefficients can be found substantially faster than would be possible using a brute-force search and with less software complexity than is required by prior approaches.
This chapter introduces some theoretical and algorithmic aspects of quadratic optimization in bivalent variables, which is, in general, an NP-hard problem. It discusses the central problem of quadratic optimization in 0–1 variables without constraints. The chapter reviews some results in the constraint case. It also discusses a property of pseudo-Boolean functions that is relatively rare in optimization. The chapter examines a formulation of the problem of maximizing a quadratic pseudo-Boolean functions (qpBf) using a mixed integer linear program. It focuses on the optimization of a function of bivalent variables subject to some constraints. This optimization model is extremely general and the chapter limits to the problem of optimizing a quadratic pseudo-Boolean function with linear constraints. The chapter shows that the optimal value of the dual Lagrangian problem is equal to the optimal value of the continuous relaxation of the classical linearization of the initial problem.
We prove that any function with real-valued coefficients, whose input is 4 binary variables and whose output is a real number, is perfectly equivalent to a quadratic function whose input is 5 binary variables and is minimized over the new variable. Our proof is constructive: we provide quadratizations for all possible 4-variable functions. There exists 4 different classes of 4-variable functions that each have their own 5-variable quadratization formula. Since we provide 'perfect' quadratizations, we can apply these formulas to any 4-variable subset of an n-variable function even if n >> 4. We provide 5 examples of functions that can be quadratized using the result of this work. For each of the 5 examples we compare the best possible quadratization we could construct using previously known methods, to a quadratization that we construct using our new result. In the most extreme example, the quadratization using our new result needs only N auxiliary variables for a 4N-variable degree-4 function, whereas the previous state-of-the-art quadratization requires 2N (double as many) auxiliary variables and therefore we can reduce by the cost of optimizing such a function by a factor of 2^1000 if it were to have 4000 variables before quadratization. In all 5 of our examples, the range of coefficient sizes in our quadratic function is smaller than in the previous state-of-the-art one, and our coefficient range is a factor of 7 times smaller in our 15-term, 5-variable example of a degree-4 function.
A quadratization represents a Boolean cost by minimizing a quadratic cost over auxiliary variables. For a four-variable family with one positive quartic coefficient and six sufficiently negative quadratic coefficients, this work determines the exact uniform error with at most six genuine pair interactions, allowing any finite auxiliary set. The optimum is the minimum of an explicit quadratic fallback and thirty-nine scalar capacities, explained by three response mechanisms. Interval endpoints and rational max flow construct attaining nonnegative rational networks with at most two auxiliary variables, without optimization linear programs. A structural lower bound covers all finite auxiliary sets. The paper also gives the separate one-auxiliary seven-, eight- and nine-interaction formulas, the one-auxiliary six-interaction procedure with 57 rational linear programs, and an exact interaction frontier. Absolute costs are retained. The results are proof-supported candidate theorems for this structured family; no claim about arbitrary quartic targets or hardware performance is made.
We investigate various solution approaches for the uncon-strained minimization of a pseudo-boolean function. Moreprecisely, we assume that the original function is expressedas a real-valued polynomial in 0-1 variables, of degree threeor more, and we consider a generic family of two-step ap-proaches for its minimization. First, a quadratic reformu-lation step aims at transforming the minimization probleminto an equivalent constrained or unconstrained quadratic0-1 minimization problem (where “equivalent” means herethat a minimizer of the original function can be easily de-duced from a minimizer of the reformulation). Second, anoptimization step handles the obtained equivalent quadraticproblem.We provide a unified presentation of several quadratic re-formulation schemes proposed in the literature, e.g., (An-thony et al. 2017; Buchheim and Rinaldi 2007; Rodr ́ıguez-Heck 2018; Rosenberg 1975), and we review several meth-ods that can be applied in the optimization step, includinga standard linearization procedure (Fortet 1959) and moreelaborate convex quadratic reformulations, as in (Billionnetand Elloumi 2007; Billionnet, Elloumi, and Lambert 2012,2016; Elloumi, Lambert, and Lazare 2021). We discuss theimpact of the reformulation scheme on the efficiency of theoptimization step and we illustrate our discussion with somecomputational results on different classes of instances.