Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Some Reminiscences and Reflections

Abner Shimony

Published Jan 1, 2002• 4 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Section 5.1 considers the question, Why Was Bell the Discoverer of Bell's Theorem?, and proposes his moral character as an answer. Section 5.2 gives three reminiscences of encounters with Bell. Section 5.3 proposes that the nonlocality exhibited by Bell's Theorem and the Bell-inspired experiments is best understood in the framework of the pregeometry of Michael Heller and collaborators, which is based upon the noncommutative geometry of Alain Connes.

Related papers

The Bell and GHZ theorems: a possible three-photon interference experiment and the question of nonlocality

Давид Николаевич Клышко

Physics Letters A•Jan 1, 1993•111 citations

An exposition of Bell's theorem

Abner Shimony

The purpose of this lecture is to give a self-contained demonstration of a version of Bell's theorem and a discussion of the significance of the theorem and the experiments which it inspired. The lecture should be comprehensible to people who have had no previous acquaintance with the literature on Bell's theorem, but I hope that explicitness about premisses and consequences will make it useful even to those who are familiar with the literature. All versions of Bell's theorem are variations, and usually generalizations, of the pioneering paper of J. S. Bell of 1964, entitled “On the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen Paradox.” All of them consider an ensemble of pairs of particles prepared in a uniform manner, so that statistical correlations may be expected between outcomes of tests performed on the particles of each pair. If each pair in the ensemble is characterized by the same quantum state φ, then the quantum mechanical predictions for correlations of the outcomes can in principle be calculated when the tests are specified. On the other hand, if it is assumed that the statistical behavior of the pairs is governed by a theory which satisfies certain independence conditions (always similar to the Parameter and Outcome Independence conditions stated below, though the exact details vary from version to version of Bell's theorem), then it is possible to derive a restriction upon the statistical correlations of the outcomes of tests upon the two particles.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•1 citation

A threshold for Bell violation under Lipschitz-restricted observables, and its critical exponent

Ilkka Linnas

Bell inequalities normally ask what correlations are possible once the available measurements have been chosen. This paper asks an earlier question: what determines which measurements are available in the first place? The proposed framework uses the Dirac operator of noncommutative geometry to assign a geometric cost to each dichotomic observable. A measurement is available only when its cost is within the apparatus budget. This restriction can create a sharp threshold: below it, the maximum CHSH value remains exactly classical, while above it, Bell violation becomes possible. The way the violation emerges reflects the local geometry around the least costly nonclassical measurements. The paper develops this threshold theory, examines the symmetry imposed by Connes’ real structure, studies the role of different observable components, and supports the analytical results with independent numerical verification and exact-arithmetic threshold certificates.

•Sep 2, 2026•0 citations

PHILOSOPHICAL MOTIVATIONS OF BELL'S THEOREM AND THE EXPERIMENTER'S PROBLEM

John F. Clauser

•Apr 1, 1976•0 citations

7th International Workshop DICE2014 Spacetime – Matter – Quantum Mechanics

Hans-Thomas Elze, Lajos Diósi, Leone Fronzoni +4 more

Presented in this volume are the Invited Lectures and the Contributed Papers of the Seventh International Workshop on Decoherence, Information, Complexity and Entropy – DICE 2014 , held at Castello Pasquini, Castiglioncello (Tuscany), September 15-19, 2014. These proceedings are intended to reflect the lively exchange of ideas during the meeting for the interested public and the wider scientific community, as well as to provide a document of the scientific works presented. The number of participants has continued to grow, which may correspond to an increasing attraction, if not need, of such conference: Our very intention has always been to bring together leading researchers, advanced students, and renowned scholars from various areas, in order to stimulate new ideas and their exchange across the borders of specialization. In this way, the series of meetings successfully continued from the beginning with DICE 2002, followed by DICE 2004, DICE 2006, DICE 2008, DICE 2010, and DICE 2012. This time, DICE 2014 brought together more than 120 participants representing more than 30 countries. It has been a great honour and inspiration that we had with us Nobel Prize laureate Gerard 't Hooft (Utrecht - Keynote Lecture ''The Cellular Automaton Interpretation and Bell's Theorem'' ), Fields Medal winner Alain Connes (Paris - Keynote Lecture ''Quanta of geometry'' ), Professor Avshalom Elitzur (Rehovot - Keynote Lecture ''Voices of silence, novelties of noise: on some quantum hairsplitting methods with nontrivial consequences'', in this volume) and Professor Mario Rasetti (Torino - Keynote Lecture ''The topological field theory of data: a possible new venue for data mining'' , in this volume). The opening Keynote Lecture ''History of electroweak symmetry breaking'' was presented by Sir Tom Kibble (London), co-discoverer of the Higgs mechanism, Sakurai Prize laureate and winner of, i.a., Dirac and Einstein Medals.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•1 citation

Bell Nonlocality, Signal Locality and Unpredictability (or What Bohr Could Have Told Einstein at Solvay Had He Known About Bell Experiments)

Eric G. Cavalcanti, Howard M. Wiseman

arXiv:0911.2504•Foundations of Physics•Jul 5, 2012•62 citations
Section 5.1 considers the question, Why Was Bell the Discoverer of Bell's Theorem?, and proposes his moral character as an answer. Section 5.2 gives three reminiscences of encounters with Bell. Section 5.3 proposes that the nonlocality exhibited by Bell's Theorem and the Bell-inspired experiments is best understood in the framework of the pregeometry of Michael Heller and collaborators, which is based upon the noncommutative geometry of Alain Connes.
The purpose of this lecture is to give a self-contained demonstration of a version of Bell's theorem and a discussion of the significance of the theorem and the experiments which it inspired. The lecture should be comprehensible to people who have had no previous acquaintance with the literature on Bell's theorem, but I hope that explicitness about premisses and consequences will make it useful even to those who are familiar with the literature. All versions of Bell's theorem are variations, and usually generalizations, of the pioneering paper of J. S. Bell of 1964, entitled “On the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen Paradox.” All of them consider an ensemble of pairs of particles prepared in a uniform manner, so that statistical correlations may be expected between outcomes of tests performed on the particles of each pair. If each pair in the ensemble is characterized by the same quantum state φ, then the quantum mechanical predictions for correlations of the outcomes can in principle be calculated when the tests are specified. On the other hand, if it is assumed that the statistical behavior of the pairs is governed by a theory which satisfies certain independence conditions (always similar to the Parameter and Outcome Independence conditions stated below, though the exact details vary from version to version of Bell's theorem), then it is possible to derive a restriction upon the statistical correlations of the outcomes of tests upon the two particles.
Bell inequalities normally ask what correlations are possible once the available measurements have been chosen. This paper asks an earlier question: what determines which measurements are available in the first place? The proposed framework uses the Dirac operator of noncommutative geometry to assign a geometric cost to each dichotomic observable. A measurement is available only when its cost is within the apparatus budget. This restriction can create a sharp threshold: below it, the maximum CHSH value remains exactly classical, while above it, Bell violation becomes possible. The way the violation emerges reflects the local geometry around the least costly nonclassical measurements. The paper develops this threshold theory, examines the symmetry imposed by Connes’ real structure, studies the role of different observable components, and supports the analytical results with independent numerical verification and exact-arithmetic threshold certificates.
Presented in this volume are the Invited Lectures and the Contributed Papers of the Seventh International Workshop on Decoherence, Information, Complexity and Entropy – DICE 2014 , held at Castello Pasquini, Castiglioncello (Tuscany), September 15-19, 2014. These proceedings are intended to reflect the lively exchange of ideas during the meeting for the interested public and the wider scientific community, as well as to provide a document of the scientific works presented. The number of participants has continued to grow, which may correspond to an increasing attraction, if not need, of such conference: Our very intention has always been to bring together leading researchers, advanced students, and renowned scholars from various areas, in order to stimulate new ideas and their exchange across the borders of specialization. In this way, the series of meetings successfully continued from the beginning with DICE 2002, followed by DICE 2004, DICE 2006, DICE 2008, DICE 2010, and DICE 2012. This time, DICE 2014 brought together more than 120 participants representing more than 30 countries. It has been a great honour and inspiration that we had with us Nobel Prize laureate Gerard 't Hooft (Utrecht - Keynote Lecture ''The Cellular Automaton Interpretation and Bell's Theorem'' ), Fields Medal winner Alain Connes (Paris - Keynote Lecture ''Quanta of geometry'' ), Professor Avshalom Elitzur (Rehovot - Keynote Lecture ''Voices of silence, novelties of noise: on some quantum hairsplitting methods with nontrivial consequences'', in this volume) and Professor Mario Rasetti (Torino - Keynote Lecture ''The topological field theory of data: a possible new venue for data mining'' , in this volume). The opening Keynote Lecture ''History of electroweak symmetry breaking'' was presented by Sir Tom Kibble (London), co-discoverer of the Higgs mechanism, Sakurai Prize laureate and winner of, i.a., Dirac and Einstein Medals.