Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B

Reflection off a reflecting surface in quantum mechanics: Where do the reflections actually occur?

Edward B. Manoukian

Published Jun 1, 1987• 11 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf02726576

Related papers

Reflection off a reflecting surface in quantum mechanics: Where do the reflections actually occur?

Edward B. Manoukian

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Aug 1, 1987•10 citations

Reflection off a reflecting surface in quantum mechanics. -III

Edward B. Manoukian

Il Nuovo cimento della Società italiana di fisica. B/Il Nuovo cimento B•Jul 1, 1990•3 citations

Does Free Particle Quantum Mechanics Introduce a New Conservation Law? Part 2

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In Part 1, we argued that 1-D reflection-refraction cannot be solved using Newtonian mechanics, but can be solved by introducing the notion of dynamic or instantaneous probabilities exp(ipx). We suggested that the problem is discrete in time and space (i.e. reflection occurs separately from refraction) and that to link the two one requires probabilities exp(ipx)s which allow for OR (addition) equations regardless of discontinuities in space and time. In this note, we suggest that one may actually bypass the dynamic probabilities exp(ipx)s, but that this would require extra information. In other words, the exp(ipx)s (i.e. quantum mechanics) seems to be justified on the basis of nature using minimal information as well as on this minimal information being tied to x. In particular, an n1-n2 index of refraction junction at x=0 means that there is discontinuity in space at x=0 and that p2=n2*p while p1=n1*p. For simplicity, consider n1=1. This means that the information present at the junction is n1 and n2. This information, however, is tied to x because n1 holds for x= -infinite to 0 and n2 for x=0 to infinite. N1 and n2 are directly tied to space x and this we argue is important. One could impose the notion of a black box at the junction which assigns fixed probabilities for reflection and refraction independent of n2 for n1=1. In such a case, these independent probabilities could take on any values and so one could not possibly use exp(ipx)s and conservation to calculate reflection and refraction probabilities. There would be no free particle quantum mechanics. It is because one insists that n2 is the only information in the problem that one cannot then associate extra information with the reflection and refraction probabilities. In such a case, one only has n2 to work with and so one has discontinuous values of momentum at different x points. In other words, there is only n1 and n2 as information and these are necessarily tied to position x. A Newtonian approach cannot solve such a case, but a dynamic probability scheme can as shown in Part 1. This scheme, however, is only justified if nature uses a least information scheme with n2 and n1 (the indices of refraction) describing all of the necessary information and this information is tied to x. If it were not tied to x, then one could not use a dynamic probability and the usual probability 1=probability(reflect)+probability(refract) is not sufficient to solve the problem. Given that n2 and n1 are associated with dynamics of the problem, i.e. p1=n1*p , the reflected photon has -p1 and p2=n2*p and that there is a discontinuity in p’s as well as in x and time and the only way to obtain addition equations involving all three disconnected pieces is through a dynamic probability which allows one to combine events that occur at different times and in different x regions, but at the same time allows one to include x as well into the problem as it is linked with the dynamic probability. Actually, the dynamic probability contains x and t, exp(-iEt+ipx), but there is an uncertainty in both, i.e. delta t = hbar/E and delta x = hbar/p. This is how this mechanism bypasses the determinism of Newtonian mechanics and discontinuitites and allows one to have a dynamic probability conservation law Aexp(ipx) + Bexp(-ipx) = Cexp(ip2x) where p=p1 for n1=1. We note that the justification for the existence of a dynamic probability (at least mathematically is given in (1).

•Sep 11, 2026•0 citations

Non-destructive quantum reflection of helium dimers and trimers from a plane ruled grating

Bum Suk Zhao, Weiqing Zhang, Wieland Schöllkopf

We report on the non-destructive scattering and diffraction of He, He2 and He3 from a plane ruled reflection grating. At grazing incidence the normal component of the particle’s wave-vector is sufficiently small to allow for quantum reflection at the attractive Casimir–van der Waals particle–surface interaction potential. Quantum reflection occurs tens of nanometres in front of the surface, before the dimers and trimers reach the region where the surface-induced forces would inevitably cause the breakup of the fragile bonds. The reflected particles are identified via their mass-dependent diffraction angles and by mass spectrometry. The intensity distributions of the observed diffraction patterns are discussed in terms of the grating’s blaze angle.

Molecular Physics•Jun 19, 2013•15 citations

Geometric Aspects of Space-Time Reflection Symmetry in Quantum Mechanics

Carl M. Bender, Dorje C. Brody, Lane P. Hughston +1 more

Springer proceedings in physics•Jan 1, 2016•2 citations

Quantum Reflection of Atoms from a Surface

Springer eBooks•Dec 12, 2005•0 citations
In Part 1, we argued that 1-D reflection-refraction cannot be solved using Newtonian mechanics, but can be solved by introducing the notion of dynamic or instantaneous probabilities exp(ipx). We suggested that the problem is discrete in time and space (i.e. reflection occurs separately from refraction) and that to link the two one requires probabilities exp(ipx)s which allow for OR (addition) equations regardless of discontinuities in space and time. In this note, we suggest that one may actually bypass the dynamic probabilities exp(ipx)s, but that this would require extra information. In other words, the exp(ipx)s (i.e. quantum mechanics) seems to be justified on the basis of nature using minimal information as well as on this minimal information being tied to x. In particular, an n1-n2 index of refraction junction at x=0 means that there is discontinuity in space at x=0 and that p2=n2*p while p1=n1*p. For simplicity, consider n1=1. This means that the information present at the junction is n1 and n2. This information, however, is tied to x because n1 holds for x= -infinite to 0 and n2 for x=0 to infinite. N1 and n2 are directly tied to space x and this we argue is important. One could impose the notion of a black box at the junction which assigns fixed probabilities for reflection and refraction independent of n2 for n1=1. In such a case, these independent probabilities could take on any values and so one could not possibly use exp(ipx)s and conservation to calculate reflection and refraction probabilities. There would be no free particle quantum mechanics. It is because one insists that n2 is the only information in the problem that one cannot then associate extra information with the reflection and refraction probabilities. In such a case, one only has n2 to work with and so one has discontinuous values of momentum at different x points. In other words, there is only n1 and n2 as information and these are necessarily tied to position x. A Newtonian approach cannot solve such a case, but a dynamic probability scheme can as shown in Part 1. This scheme, however, is only justified if nature uses a least information scheme with n2 and n1 (the indices of refraction) describing all of the necessary information and this information is tied to x. If it were not tied to x, then one could not use a dynamic probability and the usual probability 1=probability(reflect)+probability(refract) is not sufficient to solve the problem. Given that n2 and n1 are associated with dynamics of the problem, i.e. p1=n1*p , the reflected photon has -p1 and p2=n2*p and that there is a discontinuity in p’s as well as in x and time and the only way to obtain addition equations involving all three disconnected pieces is through a dynamic probability which allows one to combine events that occur at different times and in different x regions, but at the same time allows one to include x as well into the problem as it is linked with the dynamic probability. Actually, the dynamic probability contains x and t, exp(-iEt+ipx), but there is an uncertainty in both, i.e. delta t = hbar/E and delta x = hbar/p. This is how this mechanism bypasses the determinism of Newtonian mechanics and discontinuitites and allows one to have a dynamic probability conservation law Aexp(ipx) + Bexp(-ipx) = Cexp(ip2x) where p=p1 for n1=1. We note that the justification for the existence of a dynamic probability (at least mathematically is given in (1).
We report on the non-destructive scattering and diffraction of He, He2 and He3 from a plane ruled reflection grating. At grazing incidence the normal component of the particle’s wave-vector is sufficiently small to allow for quantum reflection at the attractive Casimir–van der Waals particle–surface interaction potential. Quantum reflection occurs tens of nanometres in front of the surface, before the dimers and trimers reach the region where the surface-induced forces would inevitably cause the breakup of the fragile bonds. The reflected particles are identified via their mass-dependent diffraction angles and by mass spectrometry. The intensity distributions of the observed diffraction patterns are discussed in terms of the grating’s blaze angle.