Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Topics in Computing with Quantum Oracles and Higher-Dimensional Many-Body Systems

Imdad S. B. Sardharwalla

Published Jun 8, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Since they were first envisioned, quantum computers have oft been portrayed as devices of limitless power, able to perform calculations in a mere instant that would take current computers years to determine. This is, of course, not the case. A huge amount of effort has been invested in trying to understand the limits of quantum computers---under which circumstances they outperform classical computers, how large a speed-up can be gained, and what draws the distinction between quantum and classical computing. In this Ph.D. thesis, I investigate a few intriguing properties of quantum computers involving quantum oracles and classically-simulatable quantum circuits. In Part I I study the notion of black-box unitary operations, and procedures for effecting the inverse operation. Part II looks at how quantum oracles can be used to test properties of probability distributions, and Part III considers classes of quantum circuits that can be simulated efficiently on a classical computer. In more detail, Part I studies procedures for inverting black-box unitary operations. Known techniques are generally limited in some way, often requiring ancilla systems, working only for restricted sets of operators, or simply being too inefficient. We develop a novel procedure without these limitations, and show how it can be applied to lift a requirement of the Solovay-Kitaev theorem, a landmark theorem of quantum compiling. Part II looks at property testing for probability distributions, and in particular considers a special type of access known as the \textit{conditional oracle}. The classical conditional oracle was developed by Canonne et al. in 2015 and subsequently greatly explored. We develop a quantum version of this oracle, and show that it has advantages over the classical process. We use this oracle to develop an algorithm that decides whether or not a mixed state is fully mixed. In Part III we study classically-simulatable quantum circuits in more depth. Two well-known classes are Clifford circuits and matchgate circuits, which we briefly review. Using these as inspiration, we use the Jordan-Wigner transform to develop new classes of non-trivial quantum circuits that are also classically simulatable.

DOI
10.17863/cam.10797

Related papers

Quantum circuits: power and limitations

Steven Thomas Homer, Debajyoti Bera

Quantum computation was proposed as an alternate computing process in the late-20th century, when classical computing models faced limitation in solving quantum mechanical problems. Major breakthroughs came in the 1990s, when quantum algorithms for integer factoring and black-box searching were invented that are faster than the best classical algorithms known even today. In this thesis, we look at quantum circuits with limited depth and size and analyse their power and limitations. Computer Science is about the study of computational problems, many of which are motivated by real-world applications. We are interested as much in an actual method to solve a problem as in its unsolvability. In computational complexity theory we separate out the actual problem from the computing apparatus (e.g. a Turing machine, an AND-OR circuit) and analyse the hardness of the computation, due both to the intrinsic complexity of the problem and to the underlying model. In this thesis, we consider quantum circuits built with a universal set of gates and show that non-constant depth is required to compute a particular function (parity) and other similar functions. The parity function, extensively studied previously, was shown to take non-constant depth for classical circuits too, thus providing an evidence of an inherent hardness in the function itself. On the other hand we show that the quantum circuit model is rich enough to build a universal circuit (one circuit that can simulate all circuits) that has roughly the same depth or size as the simulated circuit. We also consider a fault model in which some of the inputs to a gate might not be connected to the gate's output. We ask if we can detect the faulty inputs by testing the gate on different inputs. Our goal is to minimise the number of tests. We show that this is very hard for general gates but for certain gates it can be provably easier to detect faulty inputs. We even show that quantum algorithms can provably outperform classical algorithms for these gates. These results give us a sense of wherein lies the power of quantum computation and quantum circuits in particular.

•Jan 1, 2010•3 citations

Simulating quantum computers with probabilistic methods

Maarten Van den Nest

The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. From a fundamental point of view, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-up over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. In this talk we discuss novel classical simulation methods that are centered on probabilistic methods ('weak simulation'). We show how these techniques outperform existing methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities ('strong simulation'). Using weak simulation methods, several new classes of simulatable quantum circuits are generated. For example, we show that various concatenations of matchgate, Toffoli, Clifford, bounded-depth, Fourier transform an! d other circuits are classically simulatable. Finally, we focus on famous quantum algorithms and investigate the origin of their computational power, or their lack thereof.

•Jan 1, 2016•58 citations

From simulatability to universality of continuous-variable quantum computers

Cameron Calcluth

(Abridged.) Quantum computers promise to solve some problems exponentially faster than traditional computers, but we still do not fully understand why this is the case. While the most studied model of quantum computation uses qubits, which are the quantum equivalent of a classical bit, an alternative method for building quantum computers is gaining traction. Continuous-variable devices, with their infinite range of measurement outcomes, use systems such as electromagnetic fields. Given this infinite-dimensional structure, combined with the complexities of quantum physics, we are left with a natural question: when are continuous-variable quantum computers more powerful than classical devices? This thesis investigates this question by exploring the boundary of which circuits are classically simulatable and which unlock a quantum advantage over classical computers. A series of proofs are presented demonstrating the efficient simulatability of progressively more complex circuits, even those with high amounts of Wigner negativity. Specifically, circuits initiated with highly Wigner-negative Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill states, which form a grid-like structure in phase space, can be simulated in polynomial time.

arXiv:2505.21618•May 27, 2025•0 citations

Classical Simulation of Quantum Systems

Maarten Van den Nest, Frank Verstraete

The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. On a fundamental level, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power that is harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-ups over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. On the other hand, classical simulation of many-body systems is a challenging task, as the dimension of the Hilbert space scales with the number of particles. Therefore, to understand the properties of the systems, suitable approximation methods need to be employed. The lectures will be divided into two parts. In the first part we discuss classical simulation of quantum computation from several perspectives. We review a number of well-known examples of classically simulatable quantum computations, such as the Gottesman-Knill theorem, matchgate simulation and tensor contraction methods. We further discuss simulation methods that are centred on classical sampling methods (‘weak simulation’), and illustrate how these techniques outperform methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities (‘strong simulation’). The second part focuses on "Entanglement and variational wavefunctions in quantum many body physics". We review the idea of entanglement in quantum many-body systems and how it helps us to understand the success of numerical renormalization group methods. In particular we will discuss a few variational wave-function based methods for simulating strongly correlated quantum systems, which include (1) matrix product states (2) multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz (3) projected entangled pair states and (4) continuous matrix product states for quantum field theories.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Simulation of quantum many body systems

Maarten Van den Nest, Frank Verstraete

The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. On a fundamental level, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power that is harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-ups over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. On the other hand, classical simulation of many-body systems is a challenging task, as the dimension of the Hilbert space scales with the number of particles. Therefore, to understand the properties of the systems, suitable approximation methods need to be employed. The lectures will be divided into two parts. In the first part we discuss classical simulation of quantum computation from several perspectives. We review a number of well-known examples of classically simulatable quantum computations, such as the Gottesman-Knill theorem, matchgate simulation and tensor contraction methods. We further discuss simulation methods that are centred on classical sampling methods (‘weak simulation’), and illustrate how these techniques outperform methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities (‘strong simulation’). The second part focuses on "Entanglement and variational wavefunctions in quantum many body physics". We review the idea of entanglement in quantum many-body systems and how it helps us to understand the success of numerical renormalization group methods. In particular we will discuss a few variational wave-function based methods for simulating strongly correlated quantum systems, which include (1) matrix product states (2) multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz (3) projected entangled pair states and (4) continuous matrix product states for quantum field theories.

•Jul 20, 2010•0 citations

Simulating quantum computers with probabilistic methods

Maarten Van den Nest

We investigate the boundary between classical and quantum computational power. This work consists of two parts. First we develop new classical simulation algorithms that are centered on sampling methods. Using these techniques we generate new classes of classically simulatable quantum circuits where standard techniques relying on the exact computation of measurement probabilities fail to provide efficient simulations. For example, we show how various concatenations of matchgate, Toffoli, Clifford, bounded-depth, Fourier transform and other circuits are classically simulatable. We also prove that sparse quantum circuits as well as circuits composed of CNOT and $\exp[{i\theta X}]$ gates can be simulated classically. In a second part, we apply our results to the simulation of quantum algorithms. It is shown that a recent quantum algorithm, concerned with the estimation of Potts model partition functions, can be simulated efficiently classically. Finally, we show that the exponential speed-ups of Simon's and Shor's algorithms crucially depend on the very last stage in these algorithms, dealing with the classical postprocessing of the measurement outcomes. Specifically, we prove that both algorithms would be classically simulatable if the function classically computed in this step had a sufficiently peaked Fourier spectrum.

arXiv:0911.1624•Quantum Information and Computation•Sep 1, 2011•118 citations
Since they were first envisioned, quantum computers have oft been portrayed as devices of limitless power, able to perform calculations in a mere instant that would take current computers years to determine. This is, of course, not the case. A huge amount of effort has been invested in trying to understand the limits of quantum computers---under which circumstances they outperform classical computers, how large a speed-up can be gained, and what draws the distinction between quantum and classical computing. In this Ph.D. thesis, I investigate a few intriguing properties of quantum computers involving quantum oracles and classically-simulatable quantum circuits. In Part I I study the notion of black-box unitary operations, and procedures for effecting the inverse operation. Part II looks at how quantum oracles can be used to test properties of probability distributions, and Part III considers classes of quantum circuits that can be simulated efficiently on a classical computer. In more detail, Part I studies procedures for inverting black-box unitary operations. Known techniques are generally limited in some way, often requiring ancilla systems, working only for restricted sets of operators, or simply being too inefficient. We develop a novel procedure without these limitations, and show how it can be applied to lift a requirement of the Solovay-Kitaev theorem, a landmark theorem of quantum compiling. Part II looks at property testing for probability distributions, and in particular considers a special type of access known as the \textit{conditional oracle}. The classical conditional oracle was developed by Canonne et al. in 2015 and subsequently greatly explored. We develop a quantum version of this oracle, and show that it has advantages over the classical process. We use this oracle to develop an algorithm that decides whether or not a mixed state is fully mixed. In Part III we study classically-simulatable quantum circuits in more depth. Two well-known classes are Clifford circuits and matchgate circuits, which we briefly review. Using these as inspiration, we use the Jordan-Wigner transform to develop new classes of non-trivial quantum circuits that are also classically simulatable.
Quantum computation was proposed as an alternate computing process in the late-20th century, when classical computing models faced limitation in solving quantum mechanical problems. Major breakthroughs came in the 1990s, when quantum algorithms for integer factoring and black-box searching were invented that are faster than the best classical algorithms known even today. In this thesis, we look at quantum circuits with limited depth and size and analyse their power and limitations. Computer Science is about the study of computational problems, many of which are motivated by real-world applications. We are interested as much in an actual method to solve a problem as in its unsolvability. In computational complexity theory we separate out the actual problem from the computing apparatus (e.g. a Turing machine, an AND-OR circuit) and analyse the hardness of the computation, due both to the intrinsic complexity of the problem and to the underlying model. In this thesis, we consider quantum circuits built with a universal set of gates and show that non-constant depth is required to compute a particular function (parity) and other similar functions. The parity function, extensively studied previously, was shown to take non-constant depth for classical circuits too, thus providing an evidence of an inherent hardness in the function itself. On the other hand we show that the quantum circuit model is rich enough to build a universal circuit (one circuit that can simulate all circuits) that has roughly the same depth or size as the simulated circuit. We also consider a fault model in which some of the inputs to a gate might not be connected to the gate's output. We ask if we can detect the faulty inputs by testing the gate on different inputs. Our goal is to minimise the number of tests. We show that this is very hard for general gates but for certain gates it can be provably easier to detect faulty inputs. We even show that quantum algorithms can provably outperform classical algorithms for these gates. These results give us a sense of wherein lies the power of quantum computation and quantum circuits in particular.
The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. From a fundamental point of view, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-up over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. In this talk we discuss novel classical simulation methods that are centered on probabilistic methods ('weak simulation'). We show how these techniques outperform existing methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities ('strong simulation'). Using weak simulation methods, several new classes of simulatable quantum circuits are generated. For example, we show that various concatenations of matchgate, Toffoli, Clifford, bounded-depth, Fourier transform an! d other circuits are classically simulatable. Finally, we focus on famous quantum algorithms and investigate the origin of their computational power, or their lack thereof.
(Abridged.) Quantum computers promise to solve some problems exponentially faster than traditional computers, but we still do not fully understand why this is the case. While the most studied model of quantum computation uses qubits, which are the quantum equivalent of a classical bit, an alternative method for building quantum computers is gaining traction. Continuous-variable devices, with their infinite range of measurement outcomes, use systems such as electromagnetic fields. Given this infinite-dimensional structure, combined with the complexities of quantum physics, we are left with a natural question: when are continuous-variable quantum computers more powerful than classical devices? This thesis investigates this question by exploring the boundary of which circuits are classically simulatable and which unlock a quantum advantage over classical computers. A series of proofs are presented demonstrating the efficient simulatability of progressively more complex circuits, even those with high amounts of Wigner negativity. Specifically, circuits initiated with highly Wigner-negative Gottesman-Kitaev-Preskill states, which form a grid-like structure in phase space, can be simulated in polynomial time.
The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. On a fundamental level, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power that is harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-ups over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. On the other hand, classical simulation of many-body systems is a challenging task, as the dimension of the Hilbert space scales with the number of particles. Therefore, to understand the properties of the systems, suitable approximation methods need to be employed. The lectures will be divided into two parts. In the first part we discuss classical simulation of quantum computation from several perspectives. We review a number of well-known examples of classically simulatable quantum computations, such as the Gottesman-Knill theorem, matchgate simulation and tensor contraction methods. We further discuss simulation methods that are centred on classical sampling methods (‘weak simulation’), and illustrate how these techniques outperform methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities (‘strong simulation’). The second part focuses on "Entanglement and variational wavefunctions in quantum many body physics". We review the idea of entanglement in quantum many-body systems and how it helps us to understand the success of numerical renormalization group methods. In particular we will discuss a few variational wave-function based methods for simulating strongly correlated quantum systems, which include (1) matrix product states (2) multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz (3) projected entangled pair states and (4) continuous matrix product states for quantum field theories.
The study of quantum computations that can be simulated efficiently classically is of interest for numerous reasons. On a fundamental level, such an investigation sheds light on the intrinsic computational power that is harnessed in quantum mechanics as compared to classical physics. More practically, understanding which quantum computations do not offer any speed-ups over classical computation provides insights in where (not) to look for novel quantum algorithmic primitives. On the other hand, classical simulation of many-body systems is a challenging task, as the dimension of the Hilbert space scales with the number of particles. Therefore, to understand the properties of the systems, suitable approximation methods need to be employed. The lectures will be divided into two parts. In the first part we discuss classical simulation of quantum computation from several perspectives. We review a number of well-known examples of classically simulatable quantum computations, such as the Gottesman-Knill theorem, matchgate simulation and tensor contraction methods. We further discuss simulation methods that are centred on classical sampling methods (‘weak simulation’), and illustrate how these techniques outperform methods that rely on the exact computation of measurement probabilities (‘strong simulation’). The second part focuses on "Entanglement and variational wavefunctions in quantum many body physics". We review the idea of entanglement in quantum many-body systems and how it helps us to understand the success of numerical renormalization group methods. In particular we will discuss a few variational wave-function based methods for simulating strongly correlated quantum systems, which include (1) matrix product states (2) multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz (3) projected entangled pair states and (4) continuous matrix product states for quantum field theories.
We investigate the boundary between classical and quantum computational power. This work consists of two parts. First we develop new classical simulation algorithms that are centered on sampling methods. Using these techniques we generate new classes of classically simulatable quantum circuits where standard techniques relying on the exact computation of measurement probabilities fail to provide efficient simulations. For example, we show how various concatenations of matchgate, Toffoli, Clifford, bounded-depth, Fourier transform and other circuits are classically simulatable. We also prove that sparse quantum circuits as well as circuits composed of CNOT and exp⁡[iθX]\exp[{i\theta X}]exp[iθX] gates can be simulated classically. In a second part, we apply our results to the simulation of quantum algorithms. It is shown that a recent quantum algorithm, concerned with the estimation of Potts model partition functions, can be simulated efficiently classically. Finally, we show that the exponential speed-ups of Simon's and Shor's algorithms crucially depend on the very last stage in these algorithms, dealing with the classical postprocessing of the measurement outcomes. Specifically, we prove that both algorithms would be classically simulatable if the function classically computed in this step had a sufficiently peaked Fourier spectrum.