Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Constructive Role of Decisions: Implications from a quantum Approach

Emmanuel M. Pothos

Published Dec 1, 2016• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Abstract : The last interim report was submitted Jan. 2015. This grant had two objectives. The first was to explore the nature of constructive influences indecision making. The second concerned understanding decision making in Prisoner's Dilemma. **First objective; constructive judgments. This isthe idea that sometimes making a decision can alter the underlying relevant mental state. Simply put, if a person is uncertain whether e.g. aradar signal represents a threat or not, then being asked to decide (Does this signal represent a threat?) changes the underlying mentalrepresentations. If the person decides that the radar does represent a threat, he/she would perceive it as more threatening, than previously.This is an important idea since it impacts on our understanding of how questions, ratings, other cognitive measurements can actually alter themental states. Part of the motivation for studying this question is our expertise with quantum theory, an innovative mathematical framework forunderstanding cognition, which has to predict that the resolution of any e.g. question alters the mental state in a specific way. Up to the pointof the first report, we had validated the main idea (as outlined in the grant proposal), with two main publications (appr. six distinctexperiments; note, several other outcomes had been produced within this grant). Between the last report and the end of the grant wepursued a mathematically more sophisticated and empirically more ambitious demonstration, which related to the impact of increasing thedensity of intermediate judgments on an eventual determination. We found, as our model predicted, that a higher density of intermediatejudgments slowed down opinion change. We think this finding is important for AFOSR. For example, consider the issue of trust in anautonomous agent: suppose an operator monitors the performance of the agent.

Related papers

What are the future prospects for quantum cognition and decision?

Jerome R. Busemeyer, Peter Bruza

Quantum theory has inspired many new ideas for understanding Cognition and decision making. Given the nascent state of this field, many new challenges still remain. What are the strengths and unique contributions of these ideas? What are likely next steps in its development? How can it be applied to practical problems in cognitive science? Is this a rational or an irrational system of reasoning? What, if any, are its connections to neuroscience? Should the hard problem of consciousness be considered? These are questions that we try to address in this chapter, albeit at times in a limited way. We end with a debate with a fictitious skeptic (actually previous reviewers) of these ideas. Let us start by reviewing what we have covered so far. Contributions to cognition and decision We begin by summarizing the conclusions reached in previous chapters regarding the usefulness of quantum theory for modelling phenomena in cognition and decision. Chapter 1 provided some motivation and Chapter 2 provided a theoretical introduction to quantum theory. Chapter 3 presented a quantum model to account for question order effects on survey research. An exact and parameter-free test was derived from the model, which produced surprisingly accurate predictions for results obtained from three different large Gallup poll survey studies. Chapter 4 described a quantum model of probability judgments to account for findings that produce violations of classic probability theory, including conjunction and disjunction fallacies and order effects on inference.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 26, 2012•0 citations

A quantum probability perspective on the nature of psychological uncertainty

Lee C. White, Emmanuel M. Pothos, Jerome R. Busemeyer

Making a choice between alternatives can influence our subsequent evaluation of the selected option (e.g.Sharot, Velasquez & Dolan, 2010).Thus, in resolving psychological uncertainty, the act of making a judgment itself appears to have a constructive role in subsequent related decisions.This study focuses on emotional ambivalence and the development of affective evaluations over two stages, such that (just) making an intermediate evaluation in the first stage is shown to influence the overall affective evaluation in the second stage.Models based on classical probability theory, which assume that an intermediate evaluation simply reads off an existing internal state, cannot accommodate this result in a natural way.An explanation is offered with a quantum probability model, which, under specific circumstances, requires the measurement of an internal state to have a constructive role.The predictions of the quantum probability model were supported by the empirical results.

Cognitive Science•Jan 1, 2013•6 citations

Quantum Cognition

Emmanuel M. Pothos, Jerome R. Busemeyer

Uncertainty is an intrinsic part of life; most events, affairs, and questions are uncertain. A key problem in behavioral sciences is how the mind copes with uncertain information. Quantum probability theory offers a set of principles for inference, which align well with intuition about psychological processes in certain cases: cases when it appears that inference is contextual, the mental state changes as a result of previous judgments, or there is interference between different possibilities. We motivate the use of quantum theory in cognition and its key characteristics. For each of these characteristics, we review relevant quantum cognitive models and empirical support. The scope of quantum cognitive models encompasses fallacies in decision-making (such as the conjunction fallacy or the disjunction effect), question order effects, conceptual combination, evidence accumulation, perception, over-/underdistribution effects in memory, and more. Quantum models often formalize psychological ideas previously expressed in heuristic terms, allow unified explanations of previously disparate findings, and have led to several surprising, novel predictions. We also cast a critical eye on quantum models and consider some of their shortcomings and issues regarding their further development.

Annual Review of Psychology•Sep 21, 2021•231 citations

Dissertations on decision-making: similarity, constructive judgements, morality and social dilemmas

Albert Barqué-Duran

The present thesis (mostly) concerns the application of alternative mathematical methods to understand patterns in human cognition and to model them. The different chapters presented in this thesis show research that concerns the application of quantum probability (QP) theory in the modeling of human decision-making. Quantum probability (QP) theory is a theory for how to assign probabilities to events. QP theory can be thought of as the probability rules from quantum mechanics, without any of the physics. This work is not about the application of quantum physics to brain physiology. Rather, we are interested in QP theory as a mathematical framework for cognitive modelling. This theory is potentially relevant in any behavioural situation that involves uncertainty. QP theory is analogous to classical probability theory, though QP theory and classical probability (CP) theory are founded from different sets of axioms (the Kolmogorov and Dirac/von Neumann axioms respectively) and so are subject to alternative constraints. In this thesis we show that especially over the last decade, there has been a growing interest in decision-making and cognitive models using a quantum probabilistic (QP) framework. We see how this development encompasses publications in major journals (see Pothos and Busemeyer, 2013; Wang et al., 2014; and Yearsley and Pothos, 2014; among others), special issues, and dedicated workshops, as well as several comprehensive books (Busemeyer and Bruza, 2012; Khrennikov, 2010; and Haven and Khrennikov, 2010). However, uncertainty itself is neither ethical nor unethical – yet it is inherent to most situations in which, for instance, moral judgments and decisions have to be made. For a descriptive understanding of judgment and decisions in moral situations, it is an important lesson to acknowledge both the cognitive side (bounded rationality) and the environment (ecological rationality) – and thus the uncertainty of the world and how the mind deals with it. This thesis also shows significant interest in moral and social psychology. Specifically, we consider present technologies that suggest a need for evaluating alternative contexts for ethical decision-making. How the research on human-machine interaction feeds back into humans’ understanding of themselves as moral agents? This key question ultimately relates to the nature of ethical theory itself. Overall, this dissertation presents and addresses not only standard aspects of decision- making processes, such as similarity judgments (Chapters 1 to 4) or the constructive role of articulating impressions (Chapter 5), but also standard aspects of social psychology, such as moral judgments (Chapters 6 and 7) and game theory (Chapter 8). As stated in the Declarations section, the present thesis is a combination of a standard and a publication- based dissertation.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

The Quantum Theory in Decision Making

Dionysios P. Kalogeras

Humans do not always make the most rational decisions. As studies have shown, even when logic and reasoning point in one direction, sometimes humans “walk” to the opposite route, motivated by personal bias or simply wishful thinking. This paradoxical human behavior has resisted explanation by classical decision theory for over a decade. Scientists have shown that a quantum probability model can provide a simple explanation for human decision-making. In military, decision-making process is considered to be the most neuralgic one. With the recent interest in quantum computing and quantum information theory, there has been an effort to recast classical game theory using quantum probability amplitudes, and hence study the effect of quantum superposition, interference and entanglement on the agents’ optimal strategies. Apart from unsolved problems in quantum information theory, quantum game theory and decision –making, may be useful in studying quantum communication since that can be considered as a game where the objective is to maximize effective communication. This paper discusses the idea of using quantum theory to decision making. 1 HellemicArmy 14, Kanigos Str., Piraeus 18534, Greece.

•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation

Contextuality and assessment of guilt

Bartosz W. Wojciechowski

According to the axioms of classical probability theory, a person is in a certain state with respect to certain judgement and cognition at each given instant, and it is possible to assign a probability to a cognitive response with a specific value at each moment. It is established and quantifiable, and its existence may be disclosed. However, there has been evidence of so-called constructive influences in decision-making, whereby a decision appears to alter the underlying mental state. Quantum accounting, unlike classical theory, permits a person to exist in an indeterminate condition, known as a superposition state, at all times. This implies that one cannot assume that psychological states are characterized by specific values that can be recorded by a psychological measurement at every moment. The act of choosing one choice over another, for instance, produces a preference for the selected option. In this chapter, we will discuss the findings of a study conducted on a group of 60 lawyers (judges, prosecutors and attorneys at law) and 30 non-lawyers. We will investigate the positive effect of expressing an intermediate judgement on the suspect’s guilt on the total rating of guilt. With the application of the quantum probability theory, we present a cognitive model that formalizes such a constructive process.

Routledge eBooks•Aug 1, 2023•0 citations
Abstract : The last interim report was submitted Jan. 2015. This grant had two objectives. The first was to explore the nature of constructive influences indecision making. The second concerned understanding decision making in Prisoner's Dilemma. **First objective; constructive judgments. This isthe idea that sometimes making a decision can alter the underlying relevant mental state. Simply put, if a person is uncertain whether e.g. aradar signal represents a threat or not, then being asked to decide (Does this signal represent a threat?) changes the underlying mentalrepresentations. If the person decides that the radar does represent a threat, he/she would perceive it as more threatening, than previously.This is an important idea since it impacts on our understanding of how questions, ratings, other cognitive measurements can actually alter themental states. Part of the motivation for studying this question is our expertise with quantum theory, an innovative mathematical framework forunderstanding cognition, which has to predict that the resolution of any e.g. question alters the mental state in a specific way. Up to the pointof the first report, we had validated the main idea (as outlined in the grant proposal), with two main publications (appr. six distinctexperiments; note, several other outcomes had been produced within this grant). Between the last report and the end of the grant wepursued a mathematically more sophisticated and empirically more ambitious demonstration, which related to the impact of increasing thedensity of intermediate judgments on an eventual determination. We found, as our model predicted, that a higher density of intermediatejudgments slowed down opinion change. We think this finding is important for AFOSR. For example, consider the issue of trust in anautonomous agent: suppose an operator monitors the performance of the agent.
Quantum theory has inspired many new ideas for understanding Cognition and decision making. Given the nascent state of this field, many new challenges still remain. What are the strengths and unique contributions of these ideas? What are likely next steps in its development? How can it be applied to practical problems in cognitive science? Is this a rational or an irrational system of reasoning? What, if any, are its connections to neuroscience? Should the hard problem of consciousness be considered? These are questions that we try to address in this chapter, albeit at times in a limited way. We end with a debate with a fictitious skeptic (actually previous reviewers) of these ideas. Let us start by reviewing what we have covered so far. Contributions to cognition and decision We begin by summarizing the conclusions reached in previous chapters regarding the usefulness of quantum theory for modelling phenomena in cognition and decision. Chapter 1 provided some motivation and Chapter 2 provided a theoretical introduction to quantum theory. Chapter 3 presented a quantum model to account for question order effects on survey research. An exact and parameter-free test was derived from the model, which produced surprisingly accurate predictions for results obtained from three different large Gallup poll survey studies. Chapter 4 described a quantum model of probability judgments to account for findings that produce violations of classic probability theory, including conjunction and disjunction fallacies and order effects on inference.
Making a choice between alternatives can influence our subsequent evaluation of the selected option (e.g.Sharot, Velasquez & Dolan, 2010).Thus, in resolving psychological uncertainty, the act of making a judgment itself appears to have a constructive role in subsequent related decisions.This study focuses on emotional ambivalence and the development of affective evaluations over two stages, such that (just) making an intermediate evaluation in the first stage is shown to influence the overall affective evaluation in the second stage.Models based on classical probability theory, which assume that an intermediate evaluation simply reads off an existing internal state, cannot accommodate this result in a natural way.An explanation is offered with a quantum probability model, which, under specific circumstances, requires the measurement of an internal state to have a constructive role.The predictions of the quantum probability model were supported by the empirical results.
Uncertainty is an intrinsic part of life; most events, affairs, and questions are uncertain. A key problem in behavioral sciences is how the mind copes with uncertain information. Quantum probability theory offers a set of principles for inference, which align well with intuition about psychological processes in certain cases: cases when it appears that inference is contextual, the mental state changes as a result of previous judgments, or there is interference between different possibilities. We motivate the use of quantum theory in cognition and its key characteristics. For each of these characteristics, we review relevant quantum cognitive models and empirical support. The scope of quantum cognitive models encompasses fallacies in decision-making (such as the conjunction fallacy or the disjunction effect), question order effects, conceptual combination, evidence accumulation, perception, over-/underdistribution effects in memory, and more. Quantum models often formalize psychological ideas previously expressed in heuristic terms, allow unified explanations of previously disparate findings, and have led to several surprising, novel predictions. We also cast a critical eye on quantum models and consider some of their shortcomings and issues regarding their further development.
The present thesis (mostly) concerns the application of alternative mathematical methods to understand patterns in human cognition and to model them. The different chapters presented in this thesis show research that concerns the application of quantum probability (QP) theory in the modeling of human decision-making. Quantum probability (QP) theory is a theory for how to assign probabilities to events. QP theory can be thought of as the probability rules from quantum mechanics, without any of the physics. This work is not about the application of quantum physics to brain physiology. Rather, we are interested in QP theory as a mathematical framework for cognitive modelling. This theory is potentially relevant in any behavioural situation that involves uncertainty. QP theory is analogous to classical probability theory, though QP theory and classical probability (CP) theory are founded from different sets of axioms (the Kolmogorov and Dirac/von Neumann axioms respectively) and so are subject to alternative constraints. In this thesis we show that especially over the last decade, there has been a growing interest in decision-making and cognitive models using a quantum probabilistic (QP) framework. We see how this development encompasses publications in major journals (see Pothos and Busemeyer, 2013; Wang et al., 2014; and Yearsley and Pothos, 2014; among others), special issues, and dedicated workshops, as well as several comprehensive books (Busemeyer and Bruza, 2012; Khrennikov, 2010; and Haven and Khrennikov, 2010). However, uncertainty itself is neither ethical nor unethical – yet it is inherent to most situations in which, for instance, moral judgments and decisions have to be made. For a descriptive understanding of judgment and decisions in moral situations, it is an important lesson to acknowledge both the cognitive side (bounded rationality) and the environment (ecological rationality) – and thus the uncertainty of the world and how the mind deals with it. This thesis also shows significant interest in moral and social psychology. Specifically, we consider present technologies that suggest a need for evaluating alternative contexts for ethical decision-making. How the research on human-machine interaction feeds back into humans’ understanding of themselves as moral agents? This key question ultimately relates to the nature of ethical theory itself. Overall, this dissertation presents and addresses not only standard aspects of decision- making processes, such as similarity judgments (Chapters 1 to 4) or the constructive role of articulating impressions (Chapter 5), but also standard aspects of social psychology, such as moral judgments (Chapters 6 and 7) and game theory (Chapter 8). As stated in the Declarations section, the present thesis is a combination of a standard and a publication- based dissertation.
Humans do not always make the most rational decisions. As studies have shown, even when logic and reasoning point in one direction, sometimes humans “walk” to the opposite route, motivated by personal bias or simply wishful thinking. This paradoxical human behavior has resisted explanation by classical decision theory for over a decade. Scientists have shown that a quantum probability model can provide a simple explanation for human decision-making. In military, decision-making process is considered to be the most neuralgic one. With the recent interest in quantum computing and quantum information theory, there has been an effort to recast classical game theory using quantum probability amplitudes, and hence study the effect of quantum superposition, interference and entanglement on the agents’ optimal strategies. Apart from unsolved problems in quantum information theory, quantum game theory and decision –making, may be useful in studying quantum communication since that can be considered as a game where the objective is to maximize effective communication. This paper discusses the idea of using quantum theory to decision making. 1 HellemicArmy 14, Kanigos Str., Piraeus 18534, Greece.
According to the axioms of classical probability theory, a person is in a certain state with respect to certain judgement and cognition at each given instant, and it is possible to assign a probability to a cognitive response with a specific value at each moment. It is established and quantifiable, and its existence may be disclosed. However, there has been evidence of so-called constructive influences in decision-making, whereby a decision appears to alter the underlying mental state. Quantum accounting, unlike classical theory, permits a person to exist in an indeterminate condition, known as a superposition state, at all times. This implies that one cannot assume that psychological states are characterized by specific values that can be recorded by a psychological measurement at every moment. The act of choosing one choice over another, for instance, produces a preference for the selected option. In this chapter, we will discuss the findings of a study conducted on a group of 60 lawyers (judges, prosecutors and attorneys at law) and 30 non-lawyers. We will investigate the positive effect of expressing an intermediate judgement on the suspect’s guilt on the total rating of guilt. With the application of the quantum probability theory, we present a cognitive model that formalizes such a constructive process.