Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Dynamics of Systems with Spin

Dr. Manuel Dorado

Published Jan 1, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The incorporation of spin within classical mechanics suggests the following revision: the Euler equations, or the concept of a time-derivative operator relative to different reference frames, should be our new theoretical paradigm. From here, the existence of formal developments valid both in classical and in quantum mechanics are explored through the analysis of topics such as: the dynamics of a particle with spin acted upon by a torque, the Thomas precession, the equations of evolution for spin, the concept of quantization, the anomalous Zeeman effect and the energy of the spin-orbit interaction. The obtained results coincide for already-known concepts as well as those found within quantum theories. For example, when considering the evolution of particles with spin within magnetic fields, classical equations of motion present equivalent results as those derived using equations of evolution for expected quantum values. This means that there are similarities supporting and justifying the point of view adopted in this book. The author hopes that the reader may benefit from and enjoy reading this text. For all whom read and enjoy reading this publication, he pass on the words Virgil used when talking about Lucretius, the author of De Rerum Natura, “Fortunate is he who is able to know the causes of things.”

DOI
10.4236/9781618962459

Related papers

Bras and kets, and canonical quantization

Jeff Greensite

Written in a lucid and engaging style, the author takes readers from an overview of classical mechanics and the historical development of quantum theory through to advanced topics. The mathematical aspects of quantum theory necessary for a firm grasp of the subject are developed in the early chapters, but an effort is made to motivate that formalism on physical grounds. Including animated figures and their respective Mathematica® codes, this book provides a complete and comprehensive text for students in physics, maths, chemistry and engineering needing an accessible introduction to quantum mechanics. Supplementary Mathematica codes available within Book Information

Institute of Physics eBooks•Feb 1, 2017•1 citation

Quantum Relativity: A Synthesis of the Ideas of Einstein and Heisenberg

Marek Czachor

Standard Boolean logic is based on ideas taken from classical, first-order set theory. The first-order logic of quantum mechanics introduced by von Neumann is not a classical one. It is therefore natural to ask whether it is possible to formulate the corresponding theory of quantum sets, their (quantum) topology and higher-order structures. Once we have quantum sets and quantum topologies we can try to quantize essentially anything: phase space, groups, spacetime, etc. In his book Finkelstein reports results of some 40 years of studies in this direction. The book is not addressed to specialists, but to `thoughtful students of physics, mathematics and philosophy', which may justify the fact that this review is written by a person who is not actively working in the field of quantum logic. From this layman's position I must say that the book does not read very well. First of all, the standard language of physics is not naturally suited for speaking about such problems, so Finkelstein invents a new one. Obviously, it is not easy to read a difficult text which, in addition, is written in a language we do not know. It seems that the author should have tried to depart as little as possible from the standard terminology, but he could not resist coining new terms even for things we already know under different names. When I first looked into the table of contents I felt both curiosity and some intimidation since I did not understand the words. To give an example, we find there spinors, cospinors, anti-spinors, anti-cospinors, ambi-spinors, ambi-cospinors, etc. It turned out that they are simply upper- and lower-index, primed or unprimed ordinary spinors, or their second-rank tensor products. Fortunately higher-rank spinors were not needed. The notation also does not help to understand the text. For example, on p 148 the symbol denotes a spacetime index, but three lines later, in equation (11), it is a gauge group parameter, and no comment is made on this. On the other hand, the same object is often denoted in different ways (see, for instance, equation (1) on p 44 and (7) on p 47) and if we add a number of typographical errors the first reading of the book is really tiring. A general philosophy advocated in the book is to use a kind of two-time description which replaces continuous dynamics with discrete algebraic `activity'. The construction begins with a bi-modal logic of initial and final actions and the preclusion (or `occlusion' ) relation ` ' (essentially iff a transition between and is forbidden). A Hilbert space and a field of coefficients are derived from . Discretization of time goes hand-in-hand with the idea that spacetime should be quantized and, finally, an outline of its construction is given. An intriguing consequence of the Finkelstein formalism is the appearance of internal local gauge groups of the standard model just from the spacetime structure. It seems that some results presented in the book are subject to limitations which are not mentioned by the author. For example, the construction based on will not work correctly if the dynamics between the initial and final acts is nonlinear. This is so because mutually precluding acts do not have to correspond to orthogonal vectors if we use nonlinear eigenvalue problems. So details of evolution between initial and final acts may be more important than one would expect naively. The same concerns the proof that transition probabilities must be of the form . Such subtleties can be ignored in standard quantum mechanics but here we aim at generalization. I find some parts of the text misleading. A canonical example illustrating mathematical and physical meanings of the Finkelstein formalism is a Malusian experiment (i.e. the one involving photons and polarizers), but the Bell theorem given on p 251 cannot distinguish between its single-photon and two-photon versions. Physically the two systems are essentially different and a purely classical Aerts model that gives the Malus law for a single particle is known, even though the theorems and discussion on pp 251 - 3 suggest that this is impossible. Perhaps the original work the theorems were taken from clarifies this point but a reader will not find it for two reasons. First, the name of its author is misprinted. Second, there is no reference to the paper. This is quite typical of the book; the results which are regarded as inessential from the viewpoint of the main argument are oversimplified and quoted without references to original works. The clarity of the presentation would be improved if the author did not try to briefly summarize what he knows about physics (and certainly he knows a lot) but, instead, were more detailed about the material that is really new. In spite of all these minor critical remarks I think the book may be inspiring and opens an entirely new perspective on physics. Many of the problems discussed by Finkelstein remain unsolved but the strategy he proposes looks at least promising and, hopefully, some readers will join the author in his brave attack on the most difficult questions of modern science.

Classical and Quantum Gravity•Apr 1, 1997•24 citations

Hilbert Space and Quantum Mechanics

Franco Gallone

The topics of this book are the mathematical foundations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics and the mathematical theory they require. The main characteristic of the book is that the mathematics is developed assuming familiarity with elementary analysis only. Moreover, all the proofs are carried out in detail. These features make the book easily accessible to readers with only the mathematical training offered by undergraduate education in mathematics or in physics, and also ideal for individual study. The principles of quantum mechanics are discussed with complete mathematical accuracy and an effort is made to always trace them back to the experimental reality that lies at their root. The treatment of quantum mechanics is axiomatic, with definitions followed by propositions proved in a mathematical fashion. No previous knowledge of quantum mechanics is required. This book is designed so that parts of it can be easily used for various courses in mathematics and mathematical physics, as suggested in the Preface. The book is of interest to researchers and graduate students in functional analysis, who can see how closely an important part of their chosen field is linked with quantum mechanics, and also to physicists, who can see how the abstract language of functional analysis brings unity to the apparently distinct approaches employed in quantum theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 30, 2014•5 citations

Introduction to spin

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, Gennaro Miele +1 more

First, the experimental foundations for the existence of a new dynamical variable, the spin of particles, are presented. The Pauli equation is then derived in detail, two applications are given and the energy levels of a particle with spin in a constant magnetic field are studied. This is the analysis of Landau levels, which can be performed by using the known results on the spectrum of harmonic oscillators. In this chapter we also study in detail the addition of orbital angular momentum and spin, as well as the spin–orbit interaction with the resulting Thomas precession. Stern-Gerlach experiment and electron spin The hypothesis that the electron has an intrinsic magnetic moment and an angular momentum, in short a spin , was first suggested in Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit (1926). They noticed, even before the discovery of quantum mechanics, that a complete description of spectra was not possible unless a magnetic moment and a mechanical moment were ascribed to the electron, and hence the concept of an electron as a point charge was insufficient. First, let us therefore try to understand how a magnetic moment can be associated to an atomic system. For this purpose, consider for simplicity the Bohr model of an hydrogen atom, where the electron moves along a circular orbit and rotates with orbital angular momentum L .

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 31, 2014•0 citations

Operational Quantum Physics

John L. Safko

This tome is a formal presentation of the unsharp observable approach to quantum mechanics using the positive operator valued (POV) concept of an observable. It is intended for philosophers and mathematicians as well as physicists. This is a very formalistic book. There are, however, portions that should be read by all experimentalists performing quantum mechanical studies as well as graduate students completing their first graduate year quantum mechanics course. If we interpret quantum mechanics as making statistical predictions on the results of states prepared in identical fashions, we will often find that the observed probabilities are nearly, but not exactly, the expected 1 or 0 for measurements that are expected to always give the same result. Hence, rather than demanding sharp measures with probabilities of exactly 1 or 0, quantum mechanics allows a reasonable interpretation of unsharp results of nearly 1 or nearly 0. As the authors point out in chapter II, POV measures and the associated unsharp measures are not essential for an interpretation of quantum mechanical results. However, more sharp variables, and hence a larger Hilbert space, will be needed than are required by the unsharp approach. Also, the theoretical interpretation will often not be as straightforward with only sharp observables. As I have previously stated, all graduate students, both those of a theoretical and those of an experimental bent, should read parts of this book (after they have completed a normal introduction using sharp variables). They should at least read the first chapter which explains the unsharp variable measure concept as well as giving some examples, one of which is the Stern - Gerlach experiment. In chapter VII, the last chapter, the Stern - Gerlach experiment photon polarization and other quantum optical experiments and wave-particle duality experiments for photons are examined in detail using the POV formalism. This would also be an excellent chapter for all graduate students to read. Some sections may send them back to some of the intermediate chapters, hopefully to peruse in greater detail. The intermediate chapters contain the formal development of the POV formalism and compare it to the normal method. There is also a brief introduction to measurement theory using unsharp observables. As the authors state, this is not intended to be a complete solution to the problem of measurement theory. The next two chapters deal with uncertainty and phase space formalism as considered by the unsharp observables. Philosophers of physics and mathematicians will find this an excellent introduction to the POV formalism and the distinction between sharp and unsharp measurements. Many texts will gloss over both the philosophical and mathematical consequences inherent in the full statistical formalism of quantum mechanics. This monograph is not, by the authors' admission, a full treatment of quantum measurement theory. Also, although in the introduction the authors discuss the importance of applying quantum mechanics to individual objects, this book mainly considers the interpretations as statistical measures. There is little attempt to deal with the quantum mechanical interpretations of the behaviour of a single particle. That is, questions about measurements on a single particle or the interpretation of the wavefunction for a single particle are not fully covered. The authors claim that the POV approach is also the best for individual systems, but do little in applications. The major example given is in the last chapter where they consider interference measurements for single photons. They might have referenced more of the current alternative approaches to measurement theory of single particle wavefunctions. The readers of this journal will be disappointed, but not surprised, that the covariant nature of observables is restricted almost entirely to the Galilei group. The only Poincare group material is the example of photon localization in the last chapter. This is a reflection of the great difficulty of applying the special or the general theories of relativity to the Hilbert space formalism.

Classical and Quantum Gravity•Mar 1, 1996•74 citations

Particles in a Magnetic Field

David Tong

The universe we live in is both strange and interesting. This strangeness comes about because, at the most fundamental level, the universe is governed by the laws of quantum mechanics. This is the most spectacularly accurate and powerful theory ever devised, one that has given us insights into many aspects of the world, from the structure of matter to the meaning of information. This textbook provides a comprehensive account of all things quantum. It starts by introducing the wavefunction and its interpretation as an ephemeral wave of complex probability, before delving into the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics and exploring its diverse applications, from atomic physics and scattering, to quantum computing. Designed to be accessible, this volume is suitable for both students and researchers, beginning with the basics before progressing to more advanced topics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jun 19, 2025•0 citations
The incorporation of spin within classical mechanics suggests the following revision: the Euler equations, or the concept of a time-derivative operator relative to different reference frames, should be our new theoretical paradigm. From here, the existence of formal developments valid both in classical and in quantum mechanics are explored through the analysis of topics such as: the dynamics of a particle with spin acted upon by a torque, the Thomas precession, the equations of evolution for spin, the concept of quantization, the anomalous Zeeman effect and the energy of the spin-orbit interaction. The obtained results coincide for already-known concepts as well as those found within quantum theories. For example, when considering the evolution of particles with spin within magnetic fields, classical equations of motion present equivalent results as those derived using equations of evolution for expected quantum values. This means that there are similarities supporting and justifying the point of view adopted in this book. The author hopes that the reader may benefit from and enjoy reading this text. For all whom read and enjoy reading this publication, he pass on the words Virgil used when talking about Lucretius, the author of De Rerum Natura, “Fortunate is he who is able to know the causes of things.”
Written in a lucid and engaging style, the author takes readers from an overview of classical mechanics and the historical development of quantum theory through to advanced topics. The mathematical aspects of quantum theory necessary for a firm grasp of the subject are developed in the early chapters, but an effort is made to motivate that formalism on physical grounds. Including animated figures and their respective Mathematica® codes, this book provides a complete and comprehensive text for students in physics, maths, chemistry and engineering needing an accessible introduction to quantum mechanics. Supplementary Mathematica codes available within Book Information
Standard Boolean logic is based on ideas taken from classical, first-order set theory. The first-order logic of quantum mechanics introduced by von Neumann is not a classical one. It is therefore natural to ask whether it is possible to formulate the corresponding theory of quantum sets, their (quantum) topology and higher-order structures. Once we have quantum sets and quantum topologies we can try to quantize essentially anything: phase space, groups, spacetime, etc. In his book Finkelstein reports results of some 40 years of studies in this direction. The book is not addressed to specialists, but to `thoughtful students of physics, mathematics and philosophy', which may justify the fact that this review is written by a person who is not actively working in the field of quantum logic. From this layman's position I must say that the book does not read very well. First of all, the standard language of physics is not naturally suited for speaking about such problems, so Finkelstein invents a new one. Obviously, it is not easy to read a difficult text which, in addition, is written in a language we do not know. It seems that the author should have tried to depart as little as possible from the standard terminology, but he could not resist coining new terms even for things we already know under different names. When I first looked into the table of contents I felt both curiosity and some intimidation since I did not understand the words. To give an example, we find there spinors, cospinors, anti-spinors, anti-cospinors, ambi-spinors, ambi-cospinors, etc. It turned out that they are simply upper- and lower-index, primed or unprimed ordinary spinors, or their second-rank tensor products. Fortunately higher-rank spinors were not needed. The notation also does not help to understand the text. For example, on p 148 the symbol denotes a spacetime index, but three lines later, in equation (11), it is a gauge group parameter, and no comment is made on this. On the other hand, the same object is often denoted in different ways (see, for instance, equation (1) on p 44 and (7) on p 47) and if we add a number of typographical errors the first reading of the book is really tiring. A general philosophy advocated in the book is to use a kind of two-time description which replaces continuous dynamics with discrete algebraic `activity'. The construction begins with a bi-modal logic of initial and final actions and the preclusion (or `occlusion' ) relation ` ' (essentially iff a transition between and is forbidden). A Hilbert space and a field of coefficients are derived from . Discretization of time goes hand-in-hand with the idea that spacetime should be quantized and, finally, an outline of its construction is given. An intriguing consequence of the Finkelstein formalism is the appearance of internal local gauge groups of the standard model just from the spacetime structure. It seems that some results presented in the book are subject to limitations which are not mentioned by the author. For example, the construction based on will not work correctly if the dynamics between the initial and final acts is nonlinear. This is so because mutually precluding acts do not have to correspond to orthogonal vectors if we use nonlinear eigenvalue problems. So details of evolution between initial and final acts may be more important than one would expect naively. The same concerns the proof that transition probabilities must be of the form . Such subtleties can be ignored in standard quantum mechanics but here we aim at generalization. I find some parts of the text misleading. A canonical example illustrating mathematical and physical meanings of the Finkelstein formalism is a Malusian experiment (i.e. the one involving photons and polarizers), but the Bell theorem given on p 251 cannot distinguish between its single-photon and two-photon versions. Physically the two systems are essentially different and a purely classical Aerts model that gives the Malus law for a single particle is known, even though the theorems and discussion on pp 251 - 3 suggest that this is impossible. Perhaps the original work the theorems were taken from clarifies this point but a reader will not find it for two reasons. First, the name of its author is misprinted. Second, there is no reference to the paper. This is quite typical of the book; the results which are regarded as inessential from the viewpoint of the main argument are oversimplified and quoted without references to original works. The clarity of the presentation would be improved if the author did not try to briefly summarize what he knows about physics (and certainly he knows a lot) but, instead, were more detailed about the material that is really new. In spite of all these minor critical remarks I think the book may be inspiring and opens an entirely new perspective on physics. Many of the problems discussed by Finkelstein remain unsolved but the strategy he proposes looks at least promising and, hopefully, some readers will join the author in his brave attack on the most difficult questions of modern science.
The topics of this book are the mathematical foundations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics and the mathematical theory they require. The main characteristic of the book is that the mathematics is developed assuming familiarity with elementary analysis only. Moreover, all the proofs are carried out in detail. These features make the book easily accessible to readers with only the mathematical training offered by undergraduate education in mathematics or in physics, and also ideal for individual study. The principles of quantum mechanics are discussed with complete mathematical accuracy and an effort is made to always trace them back to the experimental reality that lies at their root. The treatment of quantum mechanics is axiomatic, with definitions followed by propositions proved in a mathematical fashion. No previous knowledge of quantum mechanics is required. This book is designed so that parts of it can be easily used for various courses in mathematics and mathematical physics, as suggested in the Preface. The book is of interest to researchers and graduate students in functional analysis, who can see how closely an important part of their chosen field is linked with quantum mechanics, and also to physicists, who can see how the abstract language of functional analysis brings unity to the apparently distinct approaches employed in quantum theory.
First, the experimental foundations for the existence of a new dynamical variable, the spin of particles, are presented. The Pauli equation is then derived in detail, two applications are given and the energy levels of a particle with spin in a constant magnetic field are studied. This is the analysis of Landau levels, which can be performed by using the known results on the spectrum of harmonic oscillators. In this chapter we also study in detail the addition of orbital angular momentum and spin, as well as the spin–orbit interaction with the resulting Thomas precession. Stern-Gerlach experiment and electron spin The hypothesis that the electron has an intrinsic magnetic moment and an angular momentum, in short a spin , was first suggested in Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit (1926). They noticed, even before the discovery of quantum mechanics, that a complete description of spectra was not possible unless a magnetic moment and a mechanical moment were ascribed to the electron, and hence the concept of an electron as a point charge was insufficient. First, let us therefore try to understand how a magnetic moment can be associated to an atomic system. For this purpose, consider for simplicity the Bohr model of an hydrogen atom, where the electron moves along a circular orbit and rotates with orbital angular momentum L .
This tome is a formal presentation of the unsharp observable approach to quantum mechanics using the positive operator valued (POV) concept of an observable. It is intended for philosophers and mathematicians as well as physicists. This is a very formalistic book. There are, however, portions that should be read by all experimentalists performing quantum mechanical studies as well as graduate students completing their first graduate year quantum mechanics course. If we interpret quantum mechanics as making statistical predictions on the results of states prepared in identical fashions, we will often find that the observed probabilities are nearly, but not exactly, the expected 1 or 0 for measurements that are expected to always give the same result. Hence, rather than demanding sharp measures with probabilities of exactly 1 or 0, quantum mechanics allows a reasonable interpretation of unsharp results of nearly 1 or nearly 0. As the authors point out in chapter II, POV measures and the associated unsharp measures are not essential for an interpretation of quantum mechanical results. However, more sharp variables, and hence a larger Hilbert space, will be needed than are required by the unsharp approach. Also, the theoretical interpretation will often not be as straightforward with only sharp observables. As I have previously stated, all graduate students, both those of a theoretical and those of an experimental bent, should read parts of this book (after they have completed a normal introduction using sharp variables). They should at least read the first chapter which explains the unsharp variable measure concept as well as giving some examples, one of which is the Stern - Gerlach experiment. In chapter VII, the last chapter, the Stern - Gerlach experiment photon polarization and other quantum optical experiments and wave-particle duality experiments for photons are examined in detail using the POV formalism. This would also be an excellent chapter for all graduate students to read. Some sections may send them back to some of the intermediate chapters, hopefully to peruse in greater detail. The intermediate chapters contain the formal development of the POV formalism and compare it to the normal method. There is also a brief introduction to measurement theory using unsharp observables. As the authors state, this is not intended to be a complete solution to the problem of measurement theory. The next two chapters deal with uncertainty and phase space formalism as considered by the unsharp observables. Philosophers of physics and mathematicians will find this an excellent introduction to the POV formalism and the distinction between sharp and unsharp measurements. Many texts will gloss over both the philosophical and mathematical consequences inherent in the full statistical formalism of quantum mechanics. This monograph is not, by the authors' admission, a full treatment of quantum measurement theory. Also, although in the introduction the authors discuss the importance of applying quantum mechanics to individual objects, this book mainly considers the interpretations as statistical measures. There is little attempt to deal with the quantum mechanical interpretations of the behaviour of a single particle. That is, questions about measurements on a single particle or the interpretation of the wavefunction for a single particle are not fully covered. The authors claim that the POV approach is also the best for individual systems, but do little in applications. The major example given is in the last chapter where they consider interference measurements for single photons. They might have referenced more of the current alternative approaches to measurement theory of single particle wavefunctions. The readers of this journal will be disappointed, but not surprised, that the covariant nature of observables is restricted almost entirely to the Galilei group. The only Poincare group material is the example of photon localization in the last chapter. This is a reflection of the great difficulty of applying the special or the general theories of relativity to the Hilbert space formalism.
The universe we live in is both strange and interesting. This strangeness comes about because, at the most fundamental level, the universe is governed by the laws of quantum mechanics. This is the most spectacularly accurate and powerful theory ever devised, one that has given us insights into many aspects of the world, from the structure of matter to the meaning of information. This textbook provides a comprehensive account of all things quantum. It starts by introducing the wavefunction and its interpretation as an ephemeral wave of complex probability, before delving into the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics and exploring its diverse applications, from atomic physics and scattering, to quantum computing. Designed to be accessible, this volume is suitable for both students and researchers, beginning with the basics before progressing to more advanced topics.