Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Einstein's Law of the Photoelectric Effect is Quite Wrong

Ahmad Reza Estakhr

Published Nov 21, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

The Laws of Photoelectric Action and the Unitary Theory of Light (Licht-Quanten Theorie)

Owen Willans Richardson

Science•Jul 12, 1912•4 citations

A relativistic explanation of the photoelectric effect

J. Perdijon

Annales de la fondation Louis de Broglie/Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations

On the Correct Formulation of the Law of the External Photoelectric Effect

Temur Z. Kalanov

The critical and correct scientific analysis of the generally accepted theory of the external photoelectric effect is proposed. The methodological basis for the analysis is the unity of formal logic and of rational dialectics. It is shown that Einstein’s formulation of the law of the photoelectric effect is not free from the following objection. The terms of Einstein’s formula characterize the quantitative determinacy (i.e., energy) which belongs and is related to the different material objects: “photon”, “electron in metal”, and “electron not in metal”. This signifies that Einstein’s formula represents violation of the formal-logical laws of identity and absence (lack) of contradiction. The correct mathematical formulation of the law of the external photoelectric effect within the framework of the system approach is proposed. The correct formulation represents the proportion by relative increments of the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron. The proportion describes the linear relationship between the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Sep 14, 2016•10 citations

Albert Einstein. Myth Buster Again: Quantum Mechanics

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

This chapter comprises Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, his analysis of the transition of electrons in atoms, his study of the behavior of bosons (named after their discoverer, Satyendra Bose), and his opposition to the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics. For the photoelectric effect, Einstein showed that light could behave as a particle, not only as a wave. Using this “photon” model, he explained how atoms absorbed and emitted light. He also predicted that a photon could stimulate the emission of many more, through (decades later) light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. He studied bosons, particles that, unlike fermions (named after Enrico Fermi), such as electrons in atoms, had no “Exclusion Principle”: any number of them could “condense” into a single state. Finally, he opposed Bohr's “Copenhagen interpretation,” that a system such as an electron has a range of values for its properties such as spin, until a measurement is made, forcing it to choose one. Einstein argued for a “hidden variable theory” in which there was something deeper than quantum mechanics: that a system was in a specific state before a measurement. (He was wrong.)

•Sep 27, 2022•0 citations

Analysis of the Photoelectric Effect

Philip R. Wallace

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•3 citations

An Alternative to Quantum Theory, Photon Radiation, Entanglement,Photon Structure, the Wave-Particle Paradox, and Einstein’s Photoelectric Effect

Donald C. Aucamp

In the prior work on this topic orbiting electrons in steady state are viewed as doublets which are laid out in strings in such a way that they do not radiate, even though they would if they existed alone.In this second paper a detailed description of the radiation process is given, as well as an analysis of the properties of the emitted photons.These are shown to be single electric field corpuscles which therefore have no frequency.The theory leads to an equation for the photoelectric effect which is a modification of the Einstein/Planck law.Though the modification can and does happen, it is conjectured this is generally not the case.The theory also leads to a resolution of the wave-particle paradox and a proof of the law of radii.A byproduct of the study is that quantum theory and entanglement are shown to be invalid, as well as Einstein's view that his law also applies to Maxwell radiation.

Open Access Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 2023•2 citations
The critical and correct scientific analysis of the generally accepted theory of the external photoelectric effect is proposed. The methodological basis for the analysis is the unity of formal logic and of rational dialectics. It is shown that Einstein’s formulation of the law of the photoelectric effect is not free from the following objection. The terms of Einstein’s formula characterize the quantitative determinacy (i.e., energy) which belongs and is related to the different material objects: “photon”, “electron in metal”, and “electron not in metal”. This signifies that Einstein’s formula represents violation of the formal-logical laws of identity and absence (lack) of contradiction. The correct mathematical formulation of the law of the external photoelectric effect within the framework of the system approach is proposed. The correct formulation represents the proportion by relative increments of the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron. The proportion describes the linear relationship between the energy of the incident photon and the energy of the emitted electron.
This chapter comprises Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, his analysis of the transition of electrons in atoms, his study of the behavior of bosons (named after their discoverer, Satyendra Bose), and his opposition to the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics. For the photoelectric effect, Einstein showed that light could behave as a particle, not only as a wave. Using this “photon” model, he explained how atoms absorbed and emitted light. He also predicted that a photon could stimulate the emission of many more, through (decades later) light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation. He studied bosons, particles that, unlike fermions (named after Enrico Fermi), such as electrons in atoms, had no “Exclusion Principle”: any number of them could “condense” into a single state. Finally, he opposed Bohr's “Copenhagen interpretation,” that a system such as an electron has a range of values for its properties such as spin, until a measurement is made, forcing it to choose one. Einstein argued for a “hidden variable theory” in which there was something deeper than quantum mechanics: that a system was in a specific state before a measurement. (He was wrong.)
In the prior work on this topic orbiting electrons in steady state are viewed as doublets which are laid out in strings in such a way that they do not radiate, even though they would if they existed alone.In this second paper a detailed description of the radiation process is given, as well as an analysis of the properties of the emitted photons.These are shown to be single electric field corpuscles which therefore have no frequency.The theory leads to an equation for the photoelectric effect which is a modification of the Einstein/Planck law.Though the modification can and does happen, it is conjectured this is generally not the case.The theory also leads to a resolution of the wave-particle paradox and a proof of the law of radii.A byproduct of the study is that quantum theory and entanglement are shown to be invalid, as well as Einstein's view that his law also applies to Maxwell radiation.