Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fundamental theories of physics

The measurement problem

Klaas Landsman

Published Jan 1, 2017• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The measurement problem of quantum mechanics was probably born in 1926: ‘Thus Schrödinger’s quantum mechanics gives a very definite answer to the question of the outcome of a collision; however, this does not involve any causal relationship. One obtains no answer to the question “what is the state after the collision,” but only to the question “how probable is a specific outcome of the collision” (in which the quantum-mechanical law of [conservation of] energy must of course be satisfied). This raises the entire problem of determinism. From the standpoint of our quantum mechanics, there is no quantity that could causally establish the outcome of a collision in each individual case; however, so far we are not aware of any experimental clue to the effect that there are internal properties of atoms that enforce some particular outcome. Should we hope to discover such properties that determine individual outcomes later (perhaps phases of the internal atomic motions)? Or should we believe that the agreement between theory and experiment concerning our inability to give conditions for a causal course of events is some pre-established harmony that is based on the non-existence of such conditions? I myself tend to relinquish determinism in the atomic world. But this is [also] a philosophical question, for which physical arguments alone are not decisive.’ (Born, 1926a, p. 866; translation by the author) These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

DOI
10.1007/978-3-319-51777-3_11

Related papers

The Quantum Measurement Problem

E. Karlsson

Measurements play a specific role in quantum mechanics; only measurements allow us to catch a glimpse of the eluding physical reality. However, there is something deeply unsatisfactory with this specificity—a measurement is itself a physical process! Several varying modes of coping with this dilemma have been proposed and this article tries to describe how a now-century-long discussion has led to new insights about the transition from the quantum to the classical world. Starting from the pioneer’s view of the quantum measurement problem, it follows the development of formalisms, the interest from philosophers for its new aspects on reality and how different interpretations of quantum mechanics have tried to support our classically working brains in understanding quantum phenomena. Decoherence is a main topic and its role in measurement processes exemplified. The question of whether the quantum measurement problem is now solved is left open for the readers’ own judgment.

Quantum Reports•Jun 13, 2025•2 citations

An Algebraic Approach for Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in Quantum Statistical Mechanics

Gérard G. Emch

The language of this first section is quite heuristic, as it only aims at a broad presentation of the problems we want to turn our attention to. A rigorous formulation of some of these questions, and of their answers, is reviewed in section 2. A few illustrative models are mentioned briefly in Section 3. Section 4 is entirely devoted to the question raised by the very existence of crystals in a world where the fundamental interactions are believed to be covariant at least under the group of rigid motions in IR 3 . These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Vieweg+Teubner eBooks•Jan 1, 1980•7 citations

Conclusions of Part II

Gerard ’t Hooft

We wrap up the main outcomes of our investigations. Even if not all questions and issues could be addressed as precisely and persuasively as one would wish, we do find that the assumption of an underlying theory describing a single, definite world with completely deterministic evolution laws, can be maintained and pursued further. In the more distant future, it is hoped that the Cellular Automaton Theory will enable us to select credible models for grand unification an quantized gravity; in the mean while, the Cellular Automaton Interpretation will be helpful in visualizing what we are actually doing when we are involved with quantum mechanical calculations. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Fundamental theories of physics•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

The Nonexisting ‘Measurement Problem’

F. J. Duarte

The indeterminacy and stochasticity of quantum mechanics have nurtured an illustrious gathering of critics including Einstein, Schrödinger, Bell, and Penrose. This has been good for quantum mechanics since it has become the most ruggedized and most battle hardened branch of physics. The one criticism that is often alluded to, now days, is ‘the measurement problem.’ First of all, from a pragmatic perspective it can be categorically stated that there is no measurement problem. Quantum mechanics exquisitely agrees with experimental measurements. Secondly, the so called ‘measurement problem’ is often related, by supporters of this concept, to the alleged ‘collapse of the wave function’ which is an unobserved phenomenon. In this chapter, several aspects of this experimentally nonexisting problem are discussed in order to inform the reader on the measurement reality of quantum mechanics.

CRC Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2026•0 citations

A Complete Operator-Theoretic Resolution of the Quantum Measurement Problem

Rodgers, Jeremy

This preprint presents a complete and fully operator-theoretic resolution of the quantum measurement problem. Including collapse, the Born rule, the uniqueness of outcomes, and the irrelevance of observersm derived entirely from a universal structural principle called the lawhood identity.Rather than adding new physics, modifying the Schrödinger equation, introducing hidden variables, invoking many-worlds branching, or appealing to consciousness, this work shows that quantum measurement is a direct, unavoidable consequence of a general fixed-point law that applies to all stable physical systems. When instantiated for quantum mechanics, this law forces every genuine superposition to fail the criteria for being a physically lawful state. Collapse is not an extra postulate: it is structurally mandatory.Key results include:• The No-Superposition Theorem: All superpositions are proven to be structurally unlawful; they cannot survive the measurement map. • Mandatory Collapse: Collapse emerges automatically from the composition of three physical operators (boundary, decoherence, and closure), without modifying quantum dynamics. • Derivation of the Born Rule: The familiar probabilities arise uniquely from the internal consistency of the measurement operators. No additional assumptions, decision theory, or symmetry arguments are required. • Observer Independence: Awareness and measurement are formally separated. Collapse is a physical, observer-independent process; knowledge acquisition is epistemic, not causal. • Uniqueness of Outcomes: The framework proves that there is only one stable classical outcome for any initial quantum state, directly resolving the many-worlds branching issue. • Experimental Signatures: The formulation predicts measurable relationships involving entropy, decoherence rates, and effective dimensionality.This paper shows that the puzzles of quantum collapse, superposition, outcome selection, probability, and the apparent role of observers, are not mysteries requiring new interpretations. They are the natural consequences of a deeper structural principle that governs all lawful physical systems. Quantum mechanics, under this lens, becomes a specific case of a universal operator identity that determines which states can persist as stable reality.Readers will find a complete, logically self-contained argument, with theorems and proofs written in a way that does not rely on philosophical interpretation or speculative assumptions. The result is a clear and testable framework that resolves a problem that has persisted since the birth of quantum theory.This work is part of a broader research program developing the universal Tier-0 lawhood framework and the “Everything Equation,” which unifies stability, collapse, and fixed-point structure across physics, computation, thermodynamics, and information. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17823241

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

The quantum measurement problem: a review of recent trends

A. A. Tomaz, Rafael Souza Mattos, Mario Barbatti

Left on its own, a quantum state evolves deterministically under the Schrödinger equation, forming superpositions. Upon measurement, however, a stochastic process governed by the Born rule collapses it to a single outcome. This dual evolution of quantum states – the core of the Measurement Problem – has puzzled physicists and philosophers for nearly a century. Yet, amid the cacophony of competing interpretations, the problem today is not as impenetrable as it once seemed. This paper reviews the current status of the Measurement Problem, distinguishing between what is well understood and what remains unresolved. We examine key theoretical approaches, including decoherence, many-worlds interpretation, objective collapse theories, hidden-variable theories, dualistic approaches, deterministic models, and epistemic interpretations. To make these discussions accessible to a broader audience, we also reference curated online resources that provide high-quality introductions to central concepts.

arXiv:2502.19278•The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Dec 26, 2025•26 citations
The measurement problem of quantum mechanics was probably born in 1926: ‘Thus Schrödinger’s quantum mechanics gives a very definite answer to the question of the outcome of a collision; however, this does not involve any causal relationship. One obtains no answer to the question “what is the state after the collision,” but only to the question “how probable is a specific outcome of the collision” (in which the quantum-mechanical law of [conservation of] energy must of course be satisfied). This raises the entire problem of determinism. From the standpoint of our quantum mechanics, there is no quantity that could causally establish the outcome of a collision in each individual case; however, so far we are not aware of any experimental clue to the effect that there are internal properties of atoms that enforce some particular outcome. Should we hope to discover such properties that determine individual outcomes later (perhaps phases of the internal atomic motions)? Or should we believe that the agreement between theory and experiment concerning our inability to give conditions for a causal course of events is some pre-established harmony that is based on the non-existence of such conditions? I myself tend to relinquish determinism in the atomic world. But this is [also] a philosophical question, for which physical arguments alone are not decisive.’ (Born, 1926a, p. 866; translation by the author) These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Measurements play a specific role in quantum mechanics; only measurements allow us to catch a glimpse of the eluding physical reality. However, there is something deeply unsatisfactory with this specificity—a measurement is itself a physical process! Several varying modes of coping with this dilemma have been proposed and this article tries to describe how a now-century-long discussion has led to new insights about the transition from the quantum to the classical world. Starting from the pioneer’s view of the quantum measurement problem, it follows the development of formalisms, the interest from philosophers for its new aspects on reality and how different interpretations of quantum mechanics have tried to support our classically working brains in understanding quantum phenomena. Decoherence is a main topic and its role in measurement processes exemplified. The question of whether the quantum measurement problem is now solved is left open for the readers’ own judgment.
The language of this first section is quite heuristic, as it only aims at a broad presentation of the problems we want to turn our attention to. A rigorous formulation of some of these questions, and of their answers, is reviewed in section 2. A few illustrative models are mentioned briefly in Section 3. Section 4 is entirely devoted to the question raised by the very existence of crystals in a world where the fundamental interactions are believed to be covariant at least under the group of rigid motions in IR 3 . These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
We wrap up the main outcomes of our investigations. Even if not all questions and issues could be addressed as precisely and persuasively as one would wish, we do find that the assumption of an underlying theory describing a single, definite world with completely deterministic evolution laws, can be maintained and pursued further. In the more distant future, it is hoped that the Cellular Automaton Theory will enable us to select credible models for grand unification an quantized gravity; in the mean while, the Cellular Automaton Interpretation will be helpful in visualizing what we are actually doing when we are involved with quantum mechanical calculations. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
The indeterminacy and stochasticity of quantum mechanics have nurtured an illustrious gathering of critics including Einstein, Schrödinger, Bell, and Penrose. This has been good for quantum mechanics since it has become the most ruggedized and most battle hardened branch of physics. The one criticism that is often alluded to, now days, is ‘the measurement problem.’ First of all, from a pragmatic perspective it can be categorically stated that there is no measurement problem. Quantum mechanics exquisitely agrees with experimental measurements. Secondly, the so called ‘measurement problem’ is often related, by supporters of this concept, to the alleged ‘collapse of the wave function’ which is an unobserved phenomenon. In this chapter, several aspects of this experimentally nonexisting problem are discussed in order to inform the reader on the measurement reality of quantum mechanics.
This preprint presents a complete and fully operator-theoretic resolution of the quantum measurement problem. Including collapse, the Born rule, the uniqueness of outcomes, and the irrelevance of observersm derived entirely from a universal structural principle called the lawhood identity.Rather than adding new physics, modifying the Schrödinger equation, introducing hidden variables, invoking many-worlds branching, or appealing to consciousness, this work shows that quantum measurement is a direct, unavoidable consequence of a general fixed-point law that applies to all stable physical systems. When instantiated for quantum mechanics, this law forces every genuine superposition to fail the criteria for being a physically lawful state. Collapse is not an extra postulate: it is structurally mandatory.Key results include:• The No-Superposition Theorem: All superpositions are proven to be structurally unlawful; they cannot survive the measurement map. • Mandatory Collapse: Collapse emerges automatically from the composition of three physical operators (boundary, decoherence, and closure), without modifying quantum dynamics. • Derivation of the Born Rule: The familiar probabilities arise uniquely from the internal consistency of the measurement operators. No additional assumptions, decision theory, or symmetry arguments are required. • Observer Independence: Awareness and measurement are formally separated. Collapse is a physical, observer-independent process; knowledge acquisition is epistemic, not causal. • Uniqueness of Outcomes: The framework proves that there is only one stable classical outcome for any initial quantum state, directly resolving the many-worlds branching issue. • Experimental Signatures: The formulation predicts measurable relationships involving entropy, decoherence rates, and effective dimensionality.This paper shows that the puzzles of quantum collapse, superposition, outcome selection, probability, and the apparent role of observers, are not mysteries requiring new interpretations. They are the natural consequences of a deeper structural principle that governs all lawful physical systems. Quantum mechanics, under this lens, becomes a specific case of a universal operator identity that determines which states can persist as stable reality.Readers will find a complete, logically self-contained argument, with theorems and proofs written in a way that does not rely on philosophical interpretation or speculative assumptions. The result is a clear and testable framework that resolves a problem that has persisted since the birth of quantum theory.This work is part of a broader research program developing the universal Tier-0 lawhood framework and the “Everything Equation,” which unifies stability, collapse, and fixed-point structure across physics, computation, thermodynamics, and information. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17823241
Left on its own, a quantum state evolves deterministically under the Schrödinger equation, forming superpositions. Upon measurement, however, a stochastic process governed by the Born rule collapses it to a single outcome. This dual evolution of quantum states – the core of the Measurement Problem – has puzzled physicists and philosophers for nearly a century. Yet, amid the cacophony of competing interpretations, the problem today is not as impenetrable as it once seemed. This paper reviews the current status of the Measurement Problem, distinguishing between what is well understood and what remains unresolved. We examine key theoretical approaches, including decoherence, many-worlds interpretation, objective collapse theories, hidden-variable theories, dualistic approaches, deterministic models, and epistemic interpretations. To make these discussions accessible to a broader audience, we also reference curated online resources that provide high-quality introductions to central concepts.