Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Theory of Computing

On beating the hybrid argument.

Bill Fefferman, Ronen Shaltiel, Christopher Umans, Emanuele Viola

Published Jan 1, 2013• 28 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The hybrid argument allows one to relate the distinguishability of a distribution (from uniform) to the predictability of individual bits given a prefix. The argument incurs a loss of a factor $k$ equal to the bit-length of the distributions: $\epsilon$-distinguishability implies $\epsilon/k$-predictability. This paper studies the consequences of avoiding this loss -- what we call “beating the hybrid argument” -- and develops new proof techniques that circumvent the loss in certain natural settings. Our main results are: We give an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson generator (JCSS '94) that can be broken by quantum computers, and that is $o(1)$-unpredictable against $AC^0$. We conjecture that this generator indeed fools $AC^0$. Our conjecture implies the existence of an oracle relative to which BQP is not in the PH, a longstanding open problem. We show that the “INW generator” by Impagliazzo, Nisan, and Wigderson (STOC '94) with seed length $O(\log n \log \log n)$ produces a distribution that is $1/\log n$-unpredictable against poly-logarithmic width (general) read-once oblivious branching programs. (This was also observed by other researchers.) Obtaining such generators where the output is indistinguishable from uniform is a longstanding open problem. We identify a property of functions $f$, “resamplability,” that allows us to beat the hybrid argument when arguing indistinguishability of \[G^{\otimes k}_f(x_1,\ldots,x_k) = (x_1,f(x_1),x_2,f(x_2),\ldots,x_k,f(x_k))\] from uniform. This gives new pseudorandom generators for classes such as $AC^0[p]$ with a stretch that, despite being sub-linear, is the largest known. We view this as a first step towards beating the hybrid argument in the analysis of the Nisan-Wigderson generator (which applies $G^{\otimes k}_f$ on correlated $x_1,\ldots,x_k$) and proving the conjecture in the first item. An extended abstract of this paper appeared in the Proceedings of the 3rd Innovations in Theoretical Computer Science (ITCS) 2012.

DOI
10.4086/toc.2013.v009a026

Related papers

Pseudorandom generators and the BQP vs. PH problem

Bill Fefferman, Christopher Umans

It is a longstanding open problem to devise an oracle relative to which BQP does not lie in the Polynomial-Time Hierarchy (PH). We advance a natural conjecture about the capacity of the Nisan-Wigderson pseudorandom generator [NW94] to fool AC_0, with MAJORITY as its hard function. Our conjecture is essentially that the loss due to the hybrid argument (which is a component of the standard proof from [NW94]) can be avoided in this setting. This is a question that has been asked previously in the pseudorandomness literature [BSW03]. We then make three main contributions: (1) We show that our conjecture implies the existence of an oracle relative to which BQP is not in the PH. This entails giving an explicit construction of unitary matrices, realizable by small quantum circuits, whose row-supports are "nearly-disjoint." (2) We give a simple framework (generalizing the setting of Aaronson [A10]) in which any efficiently quantumly computable unitary gives rise to a distribution that can be distinguished from the uniform distribution by an efficient quantum algorithm. When applied to the unitaries we construct, this framework yields a problem that can be solved quantumly, and which forms the basis for the desired oracle. (3) We prove that Aaronson's "GLN conjecture" [A10] implies our conjecture; our conjecture is thus formally easier to prove. The GLN conjecture was recently proved false for depth greater than 2 [A10a], but it remains open for depth 2. If true, the depth-2 version of either conjecture would imply an oracle relative to which BQP is not in AM, which is itself an outstanding open problem. Taken together, our results have the following interesting interpretation: they give an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson generator that can be broken by quantum computers, but not by the relevant modes of classical computation, if our conjecture is true.

arXiv:1007.0305•Jul 2, 2010•16 citations

On Quantum Computing and Pseudorandomness

William Jason Fefferman

The relationship between efficient verification and quantum computing is one of the most important and least well-understood questions in the theory of computation. In particular, is there a problem that can be solved efficiently on a quantum computer that cannot be verified? In this thesis we give evidence that BQP ⊄ PH, relating the classes of languages decidable with a quantum computer to a generalization of NP. In so doing we connect a question in pseudorandomness, first studied [BSW03] to the problem of finding an oracle relative to which BQP ⊄ PH. The primary technical challenge is to construct a unitary matrix, realized by an efficient quantum circuit and whose rows are supported on nearly disjoint subsets. Using this matrix and assuming the validity of the aforementioned question in pseudorandomness, we show an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson pseudorandom generator that can be broken with quantum computers, but not with the relevant mode of classical computation.

•Feb 2, 2011•0 citations

BosonSampling is far from uniform

Scott Aaronson, Alex Arkhipov

BosonSampling, which we proposed three years ago, is a scheme for using linear-optical networks to solve sampling problems that appear to be intractable for a classical computer. \ In a recent manuscript, Gogolin et al.\ claimed that even an ideal BosonSampling device's output would be operationally indistinguishable\textquotedblright\ from a uniform random outcome, at least \textquotedblleft without detailed a priori knowledge; or at any rate, that telling the two apart might itself be a hard problem. We first answer these claims---explaining why the first is based on a definition of a priori knowledge such that, were it adopted, almost no quantum algorithm could be distinguished from a pure random-number source; while the second is neither new nor a practical obstacle to interesting BosonSampling experiments.However, we then go further, and address some interesting research questions inspired by Gogolin et al.'s arguments. We prove that, with high probability over a Haar-random matrix $A$, the BosonSampling distribution induced by $A$ is far from the uniform distribution in total variation distance. More surprisingly, and counter to Gogolin et al., we give an efficient algorithm that distinguishes these two distributions with constant bias. Finally, we offer three bonus results about BosonSampling. First, we report an observation of Fernando Brandao: that one can efficiently sample a distribution that has large entropy and that's indistinguishable from a BosonSampling distribution by any circuit of fixed polynomial size. Second, we show that BosonSampling distributions can be efficiently distinguished from uniform even with photon losses and for general initial states. Third, we offer the simplest known proof that Fermion Sampling is solvable in classical polynomial time, and we reuse techniques from our Boson Sampling analysis to characterize random FermionSampling distributions.

arXiv:1309.7460•Quantum Information and Computation•Nov 1, 2014•175 citations

Parallel Quantum Advantage with Limited Adaptivity Requires Structure

Qipeng Liu, Saachi Mutreja

Aaronson and Ambainis (Theory of Computing, 2014) conjectured that quantum query algorithms admit efficient almost-everywhere classical simulation: for any $T$-query quantum algorithm, its acceptance probability can be approximated on a $(1-δ)$ fraction of inputs, up to $ε$ additive error, using $\mathrm{poly}(T, 1/ε, 1/δ)$ classical queries. At a high level, the conjecture suggests that exponential quantum speedups are possible only on sufficiently structured inputs. In this work, we make progress on this conjecture by proving it for quantum algorithms that make massively parallel quantum queries. In contrast, Yamakawa and Zhandry (Journal of the ACM, 2024) showed that quantum algorithms restricted to parallel queries can still achieve exponential speedups over classical algorithms for sampling problems. We establish our simulation theorem by proving the stronger statement that parallel-query quantum algorithms cannot distinguish the uniform distribution over oracles from oracles drawn from so-called "dense distributions". Our main technical contribution is a coupling theorem that relates the uniform distribution over oracles to oracles drawn from dense distributions. We further extend this approach beyond the purely parallel setting. We prove simulation theorems for quantum algorithms with constant rounds of adaptivity, and for quantum algorithms with a bounded quantum-query prefix followed by a massively parallel quantum-query stage.

quant-pharXiv:2608.20297•Aug 21, 2026•3 citations

Oracle separations of hybrid quantum-classical circuits

Atul Singh Arora, Alexandru Gheorghiu, Singh, Uttam

An important theoretical problem in the study of quantum computation, that is also practically relevant in the context of near-term quantum devices, is to understand the computational power of hybrid models, that combine poly-time classical computation with short-depth quantum computation. Here, we consider two such models: CQ_d which captures the scenario of a polynomial-time classical algorithm that queries a d-depth quantum computer many times; and QC_d which is more analogous to measurement-based quantum computation and captures the scenario of a d-depth quantum computer with the ability to change the sequence of gates being applied depending on measurement outcomes processed by a classical computation. Chia, Chung & Lai (STOC 2020) and Coudron & Menda (STOC 2020) showed that these models (with d=log^O(1) (n)) are strictly weaker than BQP (the class of problems solvable by poly-time quantum computation), relative to an oracle, disproving a conjecture of Jozsa in the relativised world. We show that, despite the similarities between CQ_d and QC_d, the two models are incomparable, i.e. CQ_d $\nsubseteq$ QC_d and QC_d $\nsubseteq$ CQ_d relative to an oracle. In other words, there exist problems that one model can solve but not the other and vice versa. We do this by considering new oracle problems that capture the distinctions between the two models and by introducing the notion of an intrinsically stochastic oracle, an oracle whose responses are inherently randomised, which is used for our second result. While we leave showing the second separation relative to a standard oracle as an open problem, we believe the notion of stochastic oracles could be of independent interest for studying complexity classes which have resisted separation in the standard oracle model. Our constructions also yield simpler oracle separations between the hybrid models and BQP, compared to earlier works.

arXiv:2201.01904•Jan 6, 2022•13 citations

A Counterexample to the Generalized Linial-Nisan Conjecture

Scott Aaronson

In earlier work, we gave an oracle separating the relational versions of BQP and the polynomial hierarchy, and showed that an oracle separating the decision versions would follow from what we called the Generalized Linial-Nisan (GLN) Conjecture: that "almost k-wise independent" distributions are indistinguishable from the uniform distribution by constant-depth circuits. The original Linial-Nisan Conjecture was recently proved by Braverman; we offered a $200 prize for the generalized version. In this paper, we save ourselves $200 by showing that the GLN Conjecture is false, at least for circuits of depth 3 and higher. As a byproduct, our counterexample also implies that Pi2P is not contained in P^NP relative to a random oracle with probability 1. It has been conjectured since the 1980s that PH is infinite relative to a random oracle, but the highest levels of PH previously proved separate were NP and coNP. Finally, our counterexample implies that the famous results of Linial, Mansour, and Nisan, on the structure of AC0 functions, cannot be improved in several interesting respects.

arXiv:1110.6126•Oct 27, 2011•17 citations
The hybrid argument allows one to relate the distinguishability of a distribution (from uniform) to the predictability of individual bits given a prefix. The argument incurs a loss of a factor kkk equal to the bit-length of the distributions: ϵ\epsilonϵ-distinguishability implies ϵ/k\epsilon/kϵ/k-predictability. This paper studies the consequences of avoiding this loss -- what we call “beating the hybrid argument” -- and develops new proof techniques that circumvent the loss in certain natural settings. Our main results are: We give an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson generator (JCSS '94) that can be broken by quantum computers, and that is o(1)o(1)o(1)-unpredictable against AC0AC^0AC0. We conjecture that this generator indeed fools AC0AC^0AC0. Our conjecture implies the existence of an oracle relative to which BQP is not in the PH, a longstanding open problem. We show that the “INW generator” by Impagliazzo, Nisan, and Wigderson (STOC '94) with seed length O(log⁡nlog⁡log⁡n)O(\log n \log \log n)O(lognloglogn) produces a distribution that is 1/log⁡n1/\log n1/logn-unpredictable against poly-logarithmic width (general) read-once oblivious branching programs. (This was also observed by other researchers.) Obtaining such generators where the output is indistinguishable from uniform is a longstanding open problem. We identify a property of functions fff, “resamplability,” that allows us to beat the hybrid argument when arguing indistinguishability of [G^{\otimes k}_f(x_1,\ldots,x_k) = (x_1,f(x_1),x_2,f(x_2),\ldots,x_k,f(x_k))] from uniform. This gives new pseudorandom generators for classes such as AC0[p]AC^0[p]AC0[p] with a stretch that, despite being sub-linear, is the largest known. We view this as a first step towards beating the hybrid argument in the analysis of the Nisan-Wigderson generator (which applies Gf⊗kG^{\otimes k}_fGf⊗k​ on correlated x1,…,xkx_1,\ldots,x_kx1​,…,xk​) and proving the conjecture in the first item. An extended abstract of this paper appeared in the Proceedings of the 3rd Innovations in Theoretical Computer Science (ITCS) 2012.
It is a longstanding open problem to devise an oracle relative to which BQP does not lie in the Polynomial-Time Hierarchy (PH). We advance a natural conjecture about the capacity of the Nisan-Wigderson pseudorandom generator [NW94] to fool AC_0, with MAJORITY as its hard function. Our conjecture is essentially that the loss due to the hybrid argument (which is a component of the standard proof from [NW94]) can be avoided in this setting. This is a question that has been asked previously in the pseudorandomness literature [BSW03]. We then make three main contributions: (1) We show that our conjecture implies the existence of an oracle relative to which BQP is not in the PH. This entails giving an explicit construction of unitary matrices, realizable by small quantum circuits, whose row-supports are "nearly-disjoint." (2) We give a simple framework (generalizing the setting of Aaronson [A10]) in which any efficiently quantumly computable unitary gives rise to a distribution that can be distinguished from the uniform distribution by an efficient quantum algorithm. When applied to the unitaries we construct, this framework yields a problem that can be solved quantumly, and which forms the basis for the desired oracle. (3) We prove that Aaronson's "GLN conjecture" [A10] implies our conjecture; our conjecture is thus formally easier to prove. The GLN conjecture was recently proved false for depth greater than 2 [A10a], but it remains open for depth 2. If true, the depth-2 version of either conjecture would imply an oracle relative to which BQP is not in AM, which is itself an outstanding open problem. Taken together, our results have the following interesting interpretation: they give an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson generator that can be broken by quantum computers, but not by the relevant modes of classical computation, if our conjecture is true.
The relationship between efficient verification and quantum computing is one of the most important and least well-understood questions in the theory of computation. In particular, is there a problem that can be solved efficiently on a quantum computer that cannot be verified? In this thesis we give evidence that BQP ⊄ PH, relating the classes of languages decidable with a quantum computer to a generalization of NP. In so doing we connect a question in pseudorandomness, first studied [BSW03] to the problem of finding an oracle relative to which BQP ⊄ PH. The primary technical challenge is to construct a unitary matrix, realized by an efficient quantum circuit and whose rows are supported on nearly disjoint subsets. Using this matrix and assuming the validity of the aforementioned question in pseudorandomness, we show an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson pseudorandom generator that can be broken with quantum computers, but not with the relevant mode of classical computation.
BosonSampling, which we proposed three years ago, is a scheme for using linear-optical networks to solve sampling problems that appear to be intractable for a classical computer. \ In a recent manuscript, Gogolin et al.\ claimed that even an ideal BosonSampling device's output would be operationally indistinguishable\textquotedblright\ from a uniform random outcome, at least \textquotedblleft without detailed a priori knowledge; or at any rate, that telling the two apart might itself be a hard problem. We first answer these claims---explaining why the first is based on a definition of a priori knowledge such that, were it adopted, almost no quantum algorithm could be distinguished from a pure random-number source; while the second is neither new nor a practical obstacle to interesting BosonSampling experiments.However, we then go further, and address some interesting research questions inspired by Gogolin et al.'s arguments. We prove that, with high probability over a Haar-random matrix AAA, the BosonSampling distribution induced by AAA is far from the uniform distribution in total variation distance. More surprisingly, and counter to Gogolin et al., we give an efficient algorithm that distinguishes these two distributions with constant bias. Finally, we offer three bonus results about BosonSampling. First, we report an observation of Fernando Brandao: that one can efficiently sample a distribution that has large entropy and that's indistinguishable from a BosonSampling distribution by any circuit of fixed polynomial size. Second, we show that BosonSampling distributions can be efficiently distinguished from uniform even with photon losses and for general initial states. Third, we offer the simplest known proof that Fermion Sampling is solvable in classical polynomial time, and we reuse techniques from our Boson Sampling analysis to characterize random FermionSampling distributions.
Aaronson and Ambainis (Theory of Computing, 2014) conjectured that quantum query algorithms admit efficient almost-everywhere classical simulation: for any TTT-query quantum algorithm, its acceptance probability can be approximated on a (1−δ)(1-δ)(1−δ) fraction of inputs, up to εεε additive error, using poly(T,1/ε,1/δ)\mathrm{poly}(T, 1/ε, 1/δ)poly(T,1/ε,1/δ) classical queries. At a high level, the conjecture suggests that exponential quantum speedups are possible only on sufficiently structured inputs. In this work, we make progress on this conjecture by proving it for quantum algorithms that make massively parallel quantum queries. In contrast, Yamakawa and Zhandry (Journal of the ACM, 2024) showed that quantum algorithms restricted to parallel queries can still achieve exponential speedups over classical algorithms for sampling problems. We establish our simulation theorem by proving the stronger statement that parallel-query quantum algorithms cannot distinguish the uniform distribution over oracles from oracles drawn from so-called "dense distributions". Our main technical contribution is a coupling theorem that relates the uniform distribution over oracles to oracles drawn from dense distributions. We further extend this approach beyond the purely parallel setting. We prove simulation theorems for quantum algorithms with constant rounds of adaptivity, and for quantum algorithms with a bounded quantum-query prefix followed by a massively parallel quantum-query stage.
An important theoretical problem in the study of quantum computation, that is also practically relevant in the context of near-term quantum devices, is to understand the computational power of hybrid models, that combine poly-time classical computation with short-depth quantum computation. Here, we consider two such models: CQ_d which captures the scenario of a polynomial-time classical algorithm that queries a d-depth quantum computer many times; and QC_d which is more analogous to measurement-based quantum computation and captures the scenario of a d-depth quantum computer with the ability to change the sequence of gates being applied depending on measurement outcomes processed by a classical computation. Chia, Chung & Lai (STOC 2020) and Coudron & Menda (STOC 2020) showed that these models (with d=log^O(1) (n)) are strictly weaker than BQP (the class of problems solvable by poly-time quantum computation), relative to an oracle, disproving a conjecture of Jozsa in the relativised world. We show that, despite the similarities between CQ_d and QC_d, the two models are incomparable, i.e. CQ_d ⊈\nsubseteq⊈ QC_d and QC_d ⊈\nsubseteq⊈ CQ_d relative to an oracle. In other words, there exist problems that one model can solve but not the other and vice versa. We do this by considering new oracle problems that capture the distinctions between the two models and by introducing the notion of an intrinsically stochastic oracle, an oracle whose responses are inherently randomised, which is used for our second result. While we leave showing the second separation relative to a standard oracle as an open problem, we believe the notion of stochastic oracles could be of independent interest for studying complexity classes which have resisted separation in the standard oracle model. Our constructions also yield simpler oracle separations between the hybrid models and BQP, compared to earlier works.
In earlier work, we gave an oracle separating the relational versions of BQP and the polynomial hierarchy, and showed that an oracle separating the decision versions would follow from what we called the Generalized Linial-Nisan (GLN) Conjecture: that "almost k-wise independent" distributions are indistinguishable from the uniform distribution by constant-depth circuits. The original Linial-Nisan Conjecture was recently proved by Braverman; we offered a $200 prize for the generalized version. In this paper, we save ourselves $200 by showing that the GLN Conjecture is false, at least for circuits of depth 3 and higher. As a byproduct, our counterexample also implies that Pi2P is not contained in P^NP relative to a random oracle with probability 1. It has been conjectured since the 1980s that PH is infinite relative to a random oracle, but the highest levels of PH previously proved separate were NP and coNP. Finally, our counterexample implies that the famous results of Linial, Mansour, and Nisan, on the structure of AC0 functions, cannot be improved in several interesting respects.