Chapter 7 discusses the Bell theorem and its demonstration using Mermin’s machine. The Bell theorem proves that a theory based on local realism (one with hidden variables) must satisfy certain inequalities; quantum mechanics predicts these are violated. Mermin designed a gedanken experiment having a double-particle source and two detectors each having three settings, which can correspond to measurements along three spin orientations. A simple hidden-variable assumption is shown to violate quantum predictions. The CHSH inequality, a form of the general Bell inequality, is proved. This relation has been shown to be violated experimentally in quantum experiments, implying that quantum mechanics indeed has “spooky action at a distance.” Many experiments over the years had loopholes, ways used to explain away the data in order to preserve local reality, but recent experiments have been able to eliminate most of these.
Chapter 7 discusses the Bell theorem and its demonstration using Mermin’s machine. The Bell theorem proves that a theory based on local realism (one with hidden variables) must satisfy certain inequalities; quantum mechanics predicts these are violated. Mermin designed a gedanken experiment having a double-particle source and two detectors each having three settings, which can correspond to measurements along three spin orientations. A simple hidden-variable assumption is shown to violate quantum predictions. The CHSH inequality, a form of the general Bell inequality, is proved. This relation has been shown to be violated experimentally in quantum experiments, implying that quantum mechanics indeed has “spooky action at a distance.” Many experiments over the years had loopholes, ways used to explain away the data in order to preserve local reality, but recent experiments have been able to eliminate most of these.
Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) have designed a gedanken experiment that suggested a theory that was more complete than quantum mechanics. The EPR design was later realized in various forms, with experimental results close to the quantum mechanical prediction. The experimental results by themselves have no bearing on the EPR claim that quantum mechanics must be incomplete nor on the existence of hidden parameters. However, the well known inequalities of Bell are based on the assumption that local hidden parameters exist and, when combined with conflicting experimental results, do appear to prove that local hidden parameters cannot exist. This fact leaves only instantaneous actions at a distance (called "spooky" by Einstein) to explain the experiments. The Bell inequalities are based on a mathematical model of the EPR experiments. They have no experimental confirmation, because they contradict the results of all EPR experiments. In addition to the assumption that hidden parameters exist, Bell tacitly makes a variety of other assumptions; for instance, he assumes that the hidden parameters are governed by a single probability measure independent of the analyzer settings. We argue that the mathematical model of Bell excludes a large set of local hidden variables and a large variety of probability densities. Our set of local hidden variables includes time-like correlated parameters and a generalized probability density. We prove that our extended space of local hidden variables does permit derivation of the quantum result and is consistent with all known experiments.
Bell's theorem is an important milestone in the development of quantum mechanics. It draws a line between concepts such as realism and locality on the one hand and quantum mechanics on the other. Experimentally veried violations of Bell inequalities can yield important information about what assumptions can be made about physical reality. Experiments have been conducted for over 40 years, but have left loopholes open in their executions. It is of great interest to close these loopholes, and in order to do so, further experiments are needed. The objective of this project is to investigate the underlying, previous work in the eld and to formulate a proposal for a new experiment. To do this, the derivations of the original Bell inequality and the CHSH inequality are presented along with previously conducted experiments. Also presented is the EPR paradox from which sprung the original Bell inequality.
Bell's theorem states that no description of a Bell experiment can be simultaneously local, realistic in the sense of counterfactual definiteness, and free of conspiracy between settings and hidden state. The recent generation of experiments has confirmed the predicted violation of the CHSH inequality, so one of the assumptions must be abandoned. Which one, and how one reconstructs a coherent worldview after doing so, is a question on which many authors disagree. This paper is written by three such authors. All three reject both counterfactual definiteness and conspiratorial violation of statistical independence of setting choices and state. After a joint exposition of the classical half of Bell's theorem in the language of Pearl-style causal graphs, a joint summary of the loophole-free experiments, and a joint survey of the recent literature, each author states where they have presently arrived. Gill accepts irreducible and non-local quantum randomness and finds the choice between locality and realism a false dichotomy. In his later works, Bell derives counterfactual definiteness from classical local causality, and that is what has to go. The metaphysical concepts "realism", "locality", "causality" need to be reconsidered. Helland reconstructs the Hilbert-space formalism from a theory of accessible variables, and from this theory he concludes that every observer must be limited in a specific sense. Jongejan proposes a geometric hidden-variable construction in which the degree of violation of the CHSH inequality depends on the number of dimensions of space, Tsirelson's bound corresponding to three dimensions. The authors conclude with a discussion.
Abstract The experimentally verified violation of Bell’s inequalities apparently implies that at least one of two beliefs, which are accepted as true in almost all scientific practice, must be false. These beliefs are: that effects propagating at infinite velocity do not exist, and that natural phenomena occur independently of being observed. Giving up any one of these two beliefs (usually known together as Local Realism) is controversial. For many years, many theories have been proposed to reconcile the violation of Bell’s inequalities with Local Realism, but none has been fully successful. In this paper, it is recalled that Bell’s inequalities are equivalent to the conditions to decide the completeness of a theory according to Boolean logic. Therefore, any theory aimed to violate Bell’s inequalities must start by giving up Boolean logic. Two problems are therefore defined: the “soft” one is to explain the violation of Bell’s inequalities without violating (non-Boolean) Local Realism; the “hard” one is to predict the time values when single particles are detected, in such a way that the resulting number of coincidences violates Bell’s inequalities. A simple hidden variables model is introduced, which solves the “soft” problem even in an ideal setup. This is possible thanks to the use of vectors in real space as the hidden variables and the corresponding operation (projection), which do not hold to Boolean logic. This model reconciles the violation of Bell’s inequalities with Local Realism and should end a controversy that has lasted for decades. Regarding the “hard” problem, the introduced model is as incomplete as Quantum Mechanics is. It is claimed that solving the “hard” problem requires devising a new kind of quantum computer, which should be able to accept (non-Boolean) hidden variable values as input data and to replace the statistical Born’s rule of Quantum Mechanics with a deterministic threshold condition.
Bell's theorem can be proved through simple geometrical reasoning, without the need for the Psi function, probability distributions, or calculus. The proof is based on N. David Mermin's explication of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-Bohm experiment, which involves Stern-Gerlach detectors which flash red or green lights when detecting spin-up or spin-down. The statistics of local hidden variable theories for this experiment can be arranged in colored strips from which simple inequalities can be deduced. These inequalities lead to a demonstration of Bell's theorem. Moreover, all local hidden variable theories can be graphed in such a way as to enclose their statistics in a pyramid, with the quantum-mechanical result lying a finite distance beneath the base of the pyramid.
Quantum computers have tremendous potential of simulating large quantum systems that classical computers can’t. In the theoretical verification of quantum non-locality principle, Bell’s and Mermin’s inequalities stood out, which proved to be valid in multiple empirical experiments. In this paper we report the tests of Bell and Mermin’s inequalities carried out on the 2- qubit and 3-qubit IBM quantum computer respectively. By comparing the result we obtained and the pattern predicted by the inequalities, our experimental results indicate clear violations of the two inequalities; thereby, we validate postulates in quantum mechanics and disprove the local realism argument in classical hidden variable theories proposed by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen on quantum circuits.