Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Toward a Loophole-Free Bell Inequality Violation with Barium Ions

Carolyn Auchter

Published Feb 14, 2017• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The successful generation of ion-photon entanglement with a singly-trapped Barium ion and the photon it spontaneously emits is reported along with the current progress and technical details for extending this work to a loophole-free test of Bell's Inequality. The achieved ion-photon entanglement fidelity is .84(1) and a violation of the CHSH Bell Signal is shown to be greater than $8\sigma$. The utilization of a novel trap type and a pulsed laser for excitation is discussed for improvement of the rate of heralded ion-ion entanglement. A side project measuring the branching fraction of the 5D$_{5/2}$ level in $^{138}$Ba$^{+}$ is also discussed.

Related papers

Ion–photon entanglement and Bell inequality violation with ^138Ba^+

Carolyn Auchter, Chen-Kuan Chou, Thomas W. Noel +1 more

We report on the demonstration of ion–photon entanglement and Bell inequality violation in a system of trapped Ba138+ ions. Entanglement between the Zeeman sublevels of the ground state of a single Ba138+ ion and the polarization state of a single 493 nm photon emitted by the ion with a fidelity of 0.84±0.01 was achieved, along with a Bell signal of 2.3, exceeding the classical limit of 2 by more than eight standard deviations. This system is a promising candidate for a loophole-free Bell inequality violation test using long-range ion–ion entanglement as the wavelengths of the transitions of Ba138+ are in the visible region and thus suitable for long-range transmission over fiber optic cable.

arXiv:1310.0028•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jun 12, 2014•17 citations

Toward remote ion-ion entanglement with barium

Thomas W. Noel, Carolyn Auchter, Chen-Kuan Chou +1 more

We present work toward remote entanglement of barium ions in traps separated by a few meters. A new version of an ion trap specialized for remote entanglement is introduced. The new trap allows for highly efficient collection of ion fluorescence while simultaneously minimizing ion micromotion and aligning the trap position precisely to the focus of an in-vacuum parabolic mirror by using a set of bias electrodes and a piezoelectric micro-positioning system. The success rate of the remote entanglement procedure depends strongly on the efficiency with which ion fluorescence can be coupled into an optical fiber. Characterization of our system in terms of ion fluorescence collection and fiber coupling efficiency is presented. Results demonstrating entanglement between a single barium ion and single spontaneously emitted photons are shown. The entanglement fidelity of the ion-photon state is measured to be 0.84(1) and a CHSH Bell signal of 2.303(36) finds violation of the CHSH version of the Bell inequality by over eight standard deviations. Barium’s relatively long wavelength transitions make it an ideal candidate for our longer term goal of remote entanglement of ions separated by a kilometer or more. Such long distance remote entanglement should allow for a loophole-free verification of the violation of the Bell inequality.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Mar 4, 2015•0 citations

Ion Photon Entanglement with Barium

Thomas Noël

Entanglement between a single trapped 138 Ba + and a single spontaneously emitted photon is demonstrated.The system is used to measure a CHSH Bell signal of 2.303(36), verifying the violation of the CHSH inequality by over eight standard deviations.The feasibility of using the system to perform a loophole free measurement of the violation of the Bell inequality is considered.A pair of side projects are discussed.First, the robustness of ARP in the presence of noise in the driving field is investigated.And second, a ppm measurement of the Landé g factor of the 5D 5/2 level of 138 Ba + is reported.The new ion trap that made all this work possible is introduced. LIST OF TABLESTable Number Page 7.1 A summary of systematic error estimates for our experimental apparatuses. .69 8.1 Correlation function measurements and calculated Bell signals . . . . . . . . .86 8.2 Experimental imperfections reducing the ion-photon entangled state fidelity .90 v ABBREVIATIONS AOM Acousto-Optic Modulator.A device that uses Bragg scattering of light off of sound waves in a crystal to redirect and frequency shift laser beams.APD Avalanche Photodiode.A photodiode in which a single photon causes avalanche breakdown of the diode resulting in a large current.APDs can achieve higher quantum efficiency than photon counting PMTs, but often suffer from higher dark count rates.ARP Adiabatic Rapid Passage.A process wherein population is transferred between states of a system by introducing and adiabatically varying a Hamiltonian that couples the states.CCD Charge Coupled Device.Type of camera that uses an array of photosensitive pixels and shift register pixel readout to capture images.DDS Direct Digital Synthesizer.Sythesizer for creating arbitrary programmed waveforms using a single fixed frequency clock input and a digital to analog converter. ECDL External Cavity Diode Laser. Adding an additional cavity external to the barediode laser cavity will greatly reduce the laser linewidth.Often the cavity is formed from a diffraction order of a diffraction grating in order to provide coarse frequency tunability.EMCCD Electron Multiplying CCD.CCD in which charges produced by light are amplified before being read out.PDH Pound-Drever-Hall.Technique for locking a laser to a cavity, in which the laser is phase modulated and the signal reflected off of the cavity is monitored.vi

•Jan 1, 2014•2 citations

Novel Ion Traps for Enhanced Fluorescence Collections and Single Photon Sources Based on Barium Ions

Gang Shu

Efficient ion-photon interface is critical for ion-photon and ion-ion entanglement generation, which are the fundamental building blocks for loophole-free Bell inequality violation tests based on ion qubits, and for the quantum computer architecture based on ion-photon networks. As one approach to address the problem, the feasibility of integrating reflective optics into ion trap to increase free-space photon interception is studied. The development and operation of two novel ion traps are demonstrated: one integrates a spherical mirror with a linear quadrapole trap, and the other combines the optical surface with the RF electrode. The possibility of using aspherical optics to improve ion images is studied and partially implemented. A continuously excited single photon source based on 138Ba+ ion is demonstrated and calibrated. Methods of scaling up current design are also discussed.

•Nov 1, 2010•1 citation

Ion Photon Entanglement in a Parabolic Mirror Trap

Chen-Kuan Chou

Single trapped ion qubits are excellent candidates for quantum computation and information, and they also possess the ability to coherently couple to single photons. Efficient fluorescence collection is the most challenging part in remotely entangled ion qubit state generation. To address this issue, I developed an ion trap combining a reflective parabolic surface with trap electrodes. This parabolic trap design covers a solid angle of 2π steradians, and allows precise ion placement at the focus of parabola. I measured 39% fluorescence collection efficiency from a single ion with this mirror trap, and 10% single-mode optical fiber coupling efficiency out of the total reflected fluorescence. A deformable mirror was used to reduce aberration to less than 2.8 times over the diffraction limit. By analyzing the ion behavior in this RF quadrupole trap, I determined that the optical resolution is limited by ion micro-motion. When trapping singly ionized barium, entanglement can be established between its energy level and the polarization of fluorescence. This setup generates an entangled ion-photon pair at 1 Hz with a mode-locked pulsed laser as the excitation source. Quantum correlation was measured between the ion spin state and the photon polarization state, and found to be above the 50% classical limit and the 71% threshold required for a Bell’s inequality violation test.

•May 16, 2017•0 citations

Robust Long-Distance Entanglement and a Loophole-Free Bell Test with Ions and Photons

Christoph Simon, William T. M. Irvine

Two trapped ions that are kilometers apart can be entangled by the joint detection of two photons, each coming from one of the ions, in a basis of entangled states. Such a detection is possible with linear optical elements. The use of two-photon interference allows entanglement distribution free of interferometric sensitivity to the path length of the photons. The present method of creating entangled ions also opens up the possibility of a loophole-free test of Bell's inequalities.

arXiv:quant-ph/0303023•Physical Review Letters•Sep 12, 2003•363 citations
The successful generation of ion-photon entanglement with a singly-trapped Barium ion and the photon it spontaneously emits is reported along with the current progress and technical details for extending this work to a loophole-free test of Bell's Inequality. The achieved ion-photon entanglement fidelity is .84(1) and a violation of the CHSH Bell Signal is shown to be greater than 8σ8\sigma8σ. The utilization of a novel trap type and a pulsed laser for excitation is discussed for improvement of the rate of heralded ion-ion entanglement. A side project measuring the branching fraction of the 5D5/2_{5/2}5/2​ level in 138^{138}138Ba+^{+}+ is also discussed.
We report on the demonstration of ion–photon entanglement and Bell inequality violation in a system of trapped Ba138+ ions. Entanglement between the Zeeman sublevels of the ground state of a single Ba138+ ion and the polarization state of a single 493 nm photon emitted by the ion with a fidelity of 0.84±0.01 was achieved, along with a Bell signal of 2.3, exceeding the classical limit of 2 by more than eight standard deviations. This system is a promising candidate for a loophole-free Bell inequality violation test using long-range ion–ion entanglement as the wavelengths of the transitions of Ba138+ are in the visible region and thus suitable for long-range transmission over fiber optic cable.
We present work toward remote entanglement of barium ions in traps separated by a few meters. A new version of an ion trap specialized for remote entanglement is introduced. The new trap allows for highly efficient collection of ion fluorescence while simultaneously minimizing ion micromotion and aligning the trap position precisely to the focus of an in-vacuum parabolic mirror by using a set of bias electrodes and a piezoelectric micro-positioning system. The success rate of the remote entanglement procedure depends strongly on the efficiency with which ion fluorescence can be coupled into an optical fiber. Characterization of our system in terms of ion fluorescence collection and fiber coupling efficiency is presented. Results demonstrating entanglement between a single barium ion and single spontaneously emitted photons are shown. The entanglement fidelity of the ion-photon state is measured to be 0.84(1) and a CHSH Bell signal of 2.303(36) finds violation of the CHSH version of the Bell inequality by over eight standard deviations. Barium’s relatively long wavelength transitions make it an ideal candidate for our longer term goal of remote entanglement of ions separated by a kilometer or more. Such long distance remote entanglement should allow for a loophole-free verification of the violation of the Bell inequality.
Entanglement between a single trapped 138 Ba + and a single spontaneously emitted photon is demonstrated.The system is used to measure a CHSH Bell signal of 2.303(36), verifying the violation of the CHSH inequality by over eight standard deviations.The feasibility of using the system to perform a loophole free measurement of the violation of the Bell inequality is considered.A pair of side projects are discussed.First, the robustness of ARP in the presence of noise in the driving field is investigated.And second, a ppm measurement of the Landé g factor of the 5D 5/2 level of 138 Ba + is reported.The new ion trap that made all this work possible is introduced. LIST OF TABLESTable Number Page 7.1 A summary of systematic error estimates for our experimental apparatuses. .69 8.1 Correlation function measurements and calculated Bell signals . . . . . . . . .86 8.2 Experimental imperfections reducing the ion-photon entangled state fidelity .90 v ABBREVIATIONS AOM Acousto-Optic Modulator.A device that uses Bragg scattering of light off of sound waves in a crystal to redirect and frequency shift laser beams.APD Avalanche Photodiode.A photodiode in which a single photon causes avalanche breakdown of the diode resulting in a large current.APDs can achieve higher quantum efficiency than photon counting PMTs, but often suffer from higher dark count rates.ARP Adiabatic Rapid Passage.A process wherein population is transferred between states of a system by introducing and adiabatically varying a Hamiltonian that couples the states.CCD Charge Coupled Device.Type of camera that uses an array of photosensitive pixels and shift register pixel readout to capture images.DDS Direct Digital Synthesizer.Sythesizer for creating arbitrary programmed waveforms using a single fixed frequency clock input and a digital to analog converter. ECDL External Cavity Diode Laser. Adding an additional cavity external to the barediode laser cavity will greatly reduce the laser linewidth.Often the cavity is formed from a diffraction order of a diffraction grating in order to provide coarse frequency tunability.EMCCD Electron Multiplying CCD.CCD in which charges produced by light are amplified before being read out.PDH Pound-Drever-Hall.Technique for locking a laser to a cavity, in which the laser is phase modulated and the signal reflected off of the cavity is monitored.vi
Efficient ion-photon interface is critical for ion-photon and ion-ion entanglement generation, which are the fundamental building blocks for loophole-free Bell inequality violation tests based on ion qubits, and for the quantum computer architecture based on ion-photon networks. As one approach to address the problem, the feasibility of integrating reflective optics into ion trap to increase free-space photon interception is studied. The development and operation of two novel ion traps are demonstrated: one integrates a spherical mirror with a linear quadrapole trap, and the other combines the optical surface with the RF electrode. The possibility of using aspherical optics to improve ion images is studied and partially implemented. A continuously excited single photon source based on 138Ba+ ion is demonstrated and calibrated. Methods of scaling up current design are also discussed.
Single trapped ion qubits are excellent candidates for quantum computation and information, and they also possess the ability to coherently couple to single photons. Efficient fluorescence collection is the most challenging part in remotely entangled ion qubit state generation. To address this issue, I developed an ion trap combining a reflective parabolic surface with trap electrodes. This parabolic trap design covers a solid angle of 2π steradians, and allows precise ion placement at the focus of parabola. I measured 39% fluorescence collection efficiency from a single ion with this mirror trap, and 10% single-mode optical fiber coupling efficiency out of the total reflected fluorescence. A deformable mirror was used to reduce aberration to less than 2.8 times over the diffraction limit. By analyzing the ion behavior in this RF quadrupole trap, I determined that the optical resolution is limited by ion micro-motion. When trapping singly ionized barium, entanglement can be established between its energy level and the polarization of fluorescence. This setup generates an entangled ion-photon pair at 1 Hz with a mode-locked pulsed laser as the excitation source. Quantum correlation was measured between the ion spin state and the photon polarization state, and found to be above the 50% classical limit and the 71% threshold required for a Bell’s inequality violation test.