Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Is Time Quantized

Nathalie Olivi‐Tran, Eugene Bataillon

Published Jan 1, 2012• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

We analyze the nature of the Schrödinger equation and of the Dirac equation. Due to the theoretical reversibility of time (see Olivi-Tran [1, 2, 3, 4]), a simple transformation of Scḧrödinger equation leads to that conclusion. In the case of Dirac equation the nature itself of the Dirac matrices leads to a quantization of time when solving this equation with the associated matrices.

Related papers

The Dirac Equation and Time Flux

Francesco R. Ruggeri

It was argued in a number of previous notes that for the nonrelativistic case, W(x,t) transforms under x->x+a, t-> t+b (with a and b infinitesimal) as exp(ipx - iEt), except with p replaced with = - i d/dx W(x,t) and E replaced with i d/dt W(x,t). It was suggested this was a driving condition of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, and if this is the case, one might expect these ideas to carry over into relativistic quantum mechanics. For relativistic quantum mechanics, however, one has the Einstein energy-momentum relationship E*E= p*p + mo*mo (c=1) which leads to -d/dt d/dt W(x,t) and -d/dx d/dx W(x,t) being used. The momentum term is fine because it is related to < p*p conditional >, but the second derivative of time seems to be a little confusing as it represents < E*E conditional > and not <E conditional >. If <E conditional> has physical significance, as it seems to be the case in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, one might expect an equation with this time flux i.e. i d/dt W(x,t) / W(x,t) = < E conditional > and not < E*E conditional >. Dirac wrote such an equation, but obtaining a single time derivative comes at a price. The Dirac equation, in one dimension, contains matrices, d/dx and d/dt in addition to a two vector wavefunction (U(x,t), V(x,t)) instead of W(x,t). Thus, the Dirac equation in one dimension leads to coupled equations with U(x,t) and V(x,t). The single derivative d/dx is deceptive because U(x,t) can be written in terms of d/dx V(x,t) and vice versa, so ultimately the Dirac equations contain d/dx d/dx which is needed to obtain < p*p conditional >. The question is: How can one obtain < E conditional >? This may be done by using a (d/dt + constant ) -1 operator i,e. almost an inverse time operator, in other words either (E+m)-1 or (E-m) -1 where E can be thought of as id/dt. Thus, the RHS of the Dirac equations is i d/dt U(x,t) or i d/dt V(x,t) which suggests an infinitesimal step forward in time, while the LHS side contains (id/dt +m)-1 or (-id/dt-m) -1 which seems to be representative of undoing such a step. It should be noted that one may take Einstein’s energy-momentum equation E*E = p*p + mo*mo, without any knowledge of quantum mechanics, and cast it as 2x2 matrix equation, linear in E, namely H (U,V) = E (U,V). The matrix H serves as an evolution operator and another matrix serves as a velocity operator. One may derive the Schrodinger zitterbewegung equation for the velocity matrix without any use of wavefunctions and derivatives which are key to quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, the idea of noncommuting matrices, vectors and zitterbewegung is present. There are several choices for the matrix H, but one leads to the one dimensional Dirac coupled equations Thus, the “spin” features may be obtained directly from E*E= p*p+mo*mo without any quantum mechanics. (1), (2). The purpose of this note is to examine some of these ideas.

•Jul 24, 2019•0 citations

The Dirac-Schrödinger Equation

Antoine Balan

We take a time in a spinorial manifold so that we can define a Dirac-Schrodinger equation when we remplace the derivative with respect to the time by the Dirac operator.

•Sep 1, 2017•0 citations

Hydrogen Atom and Equivalent Form of the Lévy-Leblond Equation

Muhammad Adeel Ajaib

We discuss the equivalent form of the Lévy-Leblond equation such that the nilpotent matrices are two-dimensional. We show that this equation can be obtained in the non-relativistic limit of the (2+1)-dimensional Dirac equation. Furthermore, we analyze the case with four-dimensional matrices, propose a Hamiltonian for the equation in (3+1) dimensions, and solve it for a Coulomb potential. The quantized energy levels for the hydrogen atom are obtained, and the result is consistent with the non-relativistic quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1607.06729•Chinese Physics Letters•May 1, 2017•2 citations

All you need to know about the Dirac equation

P. Weinberger

A very brief introduction is given to all that is needed to appreciate the formal structure of the Dirac equation and why–without destroying this structure–it cannot be reduced to a Pauli-Schrödinger type equation.

The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Jun 21, 2008•8 citations

Dirac's equation and the nature of quantum field theory

Arkady Plotnitsky

This paper re-examines the key aspects of Dirac's derivation of his relativistic equation for the electron in order advance our understanding of the nature of quantum field theory. Dirac's derivation, the paper argues, follows the key principles behind Heisenberg's discovery of quantum mechanics, which, the paper also argues, transformed the nature of both theoretical and experimental physics vis-a-vis classical physics and relativity. However, the limit theory (a crucial consideration for both Dirac and Heisenberg) in the case of Dirac's theory was quantum mechanics, specifically, Schrodinger's equation, while in the case of quantum mechanics, in Heisenberg's version, the limit theory was classical mechanics. Dirac had to find a new equation, Dirac's equation, along with a new type of quantum variables, while Heisenberg, to find new theory, was able to use the equations of classical physics, applied to different, quantum-mechanical variables. In this respect, Dirac's task was more similar to that of Schrodinger in his work on his version of quantum mechanics. Dirac's equation reflects a more complex character of quantum electrodynamics or quantum field theory in general and of the corresponding (high-energy) experimental quantum physics vis-a-vis that of quantum mechanics and the (low-energy) experimental quantum physics. The final section examines this greater complexity and its implications for fundamental physics.

Physica Scripta•Nov 1, 2012•1 citation

Paul A. M. Dirac. Matchmaker: Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Helge Kastrup, Jeffry V. Mallow A

Paul Dirac made contributions to theoretical physics that spanned quantum mechanics, relativity, gravity, and magnetism. Among these, the most important was arguably his connecting relativity and quantum mechanics. The Schrödinger equation is only correct for speeds much less than the speed of light. An equation correct for all speeds must include the energy associated with mass: E = mc2. The Dirac equation did just that. It also turned out to naturally include spin, which was an ad hoc addition to the wave functions obtained by the Schrödinger equation. He and Schrödinger shared the 1933 Nobel Prize.

•Sep 27, 2022•0 citations
We analyze the nature of the Schrödinger equation and of the Dirac equation. Due to the theoretical reversibility of time (see Olivi-Tran [1, 2, 3, 4]), a simple transformation of Scḧrödinger equation leads to that conclusion. In the case of Dirac equation the nature itself of the Dirac matrices leads to a quantization of time when solving this equation with the associated matrices.
It was argued in a number of previous notes that for the nonrelativistic case, W(x,t) transforms under x->x+a, t-> t+b (with a and b infinitesimal) as exp(ipx - iEt), except with p replaced with = - i d/dx W(x,t) and E replaced with i d/dt W(x,t). It was suggested this was a driving condition of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, and if this is the case, one might expect these ideas to carry over into relativistic quantum mechanics. For relativistic quantum mechanics, however, one has the Einstein energy-momentum relationship E*E= p*p + mo*mo (c=1) which leads to -d/dt d/dt W(x,t) and -d/dx d/dx W(x,t) being used. The momentum term is fine because it is related to < p*p conditional >, but the second derivative of time seems to be a little confusing as it represents < E*E conditional > and not <E conditional >. If <E conditional> has physical significance, as it seems to be the case in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, one might expect an equation with this time flux i.e. i d/dt W(x,t) / W(x,t) = < E conditional > and not < E*E conditional >. Dirac wrote such an equation, but obtaining a single time derivative comes at a price. The Dirac equation, in one dimension, contains matrices, d/dx and d/dt in addition to a two vector wavefunction (U(x,t), V(x,t)) instead of W(x,t). Thus, the Dirac equation in one dimension leads to coupled equations with U(x,t) and V(x,t). The single derivative d/dx is deceptive because U(x,t) can be written in terms of d/dx V(x,t) and vice versa, so ultimately the Dirac equations contain d/dx d/dx which is needed to obtain < p*p conditional >. The question is: How can one obtain < E conditional >? This may be done by using a (d/dt + constant ) -1 operator i,e. almost an inverse time operator, in other words either (E+m)-1 or (E-m) -1 where E can be thought of as id/dt. Thus, the RHS of the Dirac equations is i d/dt U(x,t) or i d/dt V(x,t) which suggests an infinitesimal step forward in time, while the LHS side contains (id/dt +m)-1 or (-id/dt-m) -1 which seems to be representative of undoing such a step. It should be noted that one may take Einstein’s energy-momentum equation E*E = p*p + mo*mo, without any knowledge of quantum mechanics, and cast it as 2x2 matrix equation, linear in E, namely H (U,V) = E (U,V). The matrix H serves as an evolution operator and another matrix serves as a velocity operator. One may derive the Schrodinger zitterbewegung equation for the velocity matrix without any use of wavefunctions and derivatives which are key to quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, the idea of noncommuting matrices, vectors and zitterbewegung is present. There are several choices for the matrix H, but one leads to the one dimensional Dirac coupled equations Thus, the “spin” features may be obtained directly from E*E= p*p+mo*mo without any quantum mechanics. (1), (2). The purpose of this note is to examine some of these ideas.
We discuss the equivalent form of the Lévy-Leblond equation such that the nilpotent matrices are two-dimensional. We show that this equation can be obtained in the non-relativistic limit of the (2+1)-dimensional Dirac equation. Furthermore, we analyze the case with four-dimensional matrices, propose a Hamiltonian for the equation in (3+1) dimensions, and solve it for a Coulomb potential. The quantized energy levels for the hydrogen atom are obtained, and the result is consistent with the non-relativistic quantum mechanics.
This paper re-examines the key aspects of Dirac's derivation of his relativistic equation for the electron in order advance our understanding of the nature of quantum field theory. Dirac's derivation, the paper argues, follows the key principles behind Heisenberg's discovery of quantum mechanics, which, the paper also argues, transformed the nature of both theoretical and experimental physics vis-a-vis classical physics and relativity. However, the limit theory (a crucial consideration for both Dirac and Heisenberg) in the case of Dirac's theory was quantum mechanics, specifically, Schrodinger's equation, while in the case of quantum mechanics, in Heisenberg's version, the limit theory was classical mechanics. Dirac had to find a new equation, Dirac's equation, along with a new type of quantum variables, while Heisenberg, to find new theory, was able to use the equations of classical physics, applied to different, quantum-mechanical variables. In this respect, Dirac's task was more similar to that of Schrodinger in his work on his version of quantum mechanics. Dirac's equation reflects a more complex character of quantum electrodynamics or quantum field theory in general and of the corresponding (high-energy) experimental quantum physics vis-a-vis that of quantum mechanics and the (low-energy) experimental quantum physics. The final section examines this greater complexity and its implications for fundamental physics.
Paul Dirac made contributions to theoretical physics that spanned quantum mechanics, relativity, gravity, and magnetism. Among these, the most important was arguably his connecting relativity and quantum mechanics. The Schrödinger equation is only correct for speeds much less than the speed of light. An equation correct for all speeds must include the energy associated with mass: E = mc2. The Dirac equation did just that. It also turned out to naturally include spin, which was an ad hoc addition to the wave functions obtained by the Schrödinger equation. He and Schrödinger shared the 1933 Nobel Prize.