Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Theories with Local Discriminability

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Giulio Chiribella, Paolo Perinotti

Published Nov 2, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this chapter we introduce the principle of local discriminability, which stipulates the possibility of discriminating states of composite systems via local measurements on the component systems. The phenomenon of entanglement has relevant consequences on the accessibility of information in composite systems and on the complexity of characterization of transformations: local discriminability brings dramatic simplifications to the structure of the sets of states and transformations, reconciling the holism of entangled states with the reductionist scientific approach. In order to illustrate the structural relevance of the principle, we will briefly review some OPTs that do not satisfy it, contrasting the features of such theories with those of quantum and classical probabilistic theories, where the principle holds. Entanglement and Holism Holism is a widely known feature of quantum theory, related to the existence of entangled states. In quantum theory one has pure entangled states, whose marginal states are completely mixed. This situation corresponds to having maximal knowledge of the whole with minimal knowledge of the parts. The main manifestation of the holism of entanglement is the impossibility of reconciling the statistics of joint measurements on entangled states with local realism . Local realism is the assumption that any measurement on a system is just the reading of a pre-existing quantity encoded on the system. In other words, we cannot explain the statistics of measurements on the parts of a composite system as a manifestation of our ignorance of locally pre-existing values, as in classical OPT. Does entanglement make information about composite systems locally unaccessible? This would pose severe practical issues on the possibility of acquiring information about physical systems. For example, suppose that two distant telescopes observe a source of entangled photons from a stellar emission. Holism would imply that some features of the emission process could never be detected, unless we are able to make the entangled photons interact in a joint measurement. On the other hand, if a reductionist approach is possible, local observations of the two photons at the sites of the two telescopes would be enough to characterize the emitting source. Thanks to the local discriminability principle, this is actually the case with entangled quantum sources. Another consequence of holism is the fact that transformations generally cannot be characterized by local experiments, namely by applying the unknown transformation only to its input system.

DOI
10.1017/9781107338340.007

Related papers

Classicality without local discriminability: Decoupling entanglement and complementarity

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Marco Erba, Paolo Perinotti

An operational probabilistic theory where all systems are classical, and all pure states of composite systems are entangled, is constructed. The theory is endowed with a rule for composing an arbitrary number of systems, and with a nontrivial set of transformations. Hence, we demonstrate that the presence of entanglement is independent of the existence of incompatible measurements. We then study a variety of phenomena occurring in the theory, some of them contradicting both classical and quantum theories, including cloning, entanglement swapping, dense coding, additivity of classical capacities, nonmonogamous entanglement, hypersignaling. We also prove the existence, in the theory, of a universal processor. The theory is causal and satisfies the no-restriction hypothesis. At the same time, it violates a number of information-theoretic principles enjoyed by quantum theory, most notably, local discriminability, purity of parallel composition of states, and purification. Moreover, we introduce an exhaustive procedure to construct generic operational probabilistic theories, and a sufficient set of conditions to verify their consistency. In addition, we prove a characterization theorem for the parallel composition rules of arbitrary theories, and specialize it to the case of bilocal-tomographic theories. We conclude pointing out some open problems. In particular, on the basis of the fact that every separable state of the theory is a statistical mixture of entangled states, we formulate a no-go conjecture for the existence of a local-realistic ontological model.

arXiv:2008.04011•Physical Review A•Nov 11, 2020•21 citations

Quantum Theory and Beyond: Is Entanglement Special?

Borivoje Dakić, Časlav Brukner

Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.

arXiv:0911.0695•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 18, 2011•281 citations

Genuine activation of nonlocality: From locally available to locally hidden information

Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Saronath Halder

Quantum nonlocality has different manifestations that, in general, are revealed by local measurements of the parts of a composite system. In this paper, we study nonlocality arising from a set of orthogonal states that cannot be perfectly distinguished by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). Such a set is deemed nonlocal, for a joint measurement on the whole system is necessary for perfect discrimination of the states with certainty. On the other hand, a set of orthogonal states that can be perfectly distinguished by LOCC is believed to be devoid of nonlocal properties. Here, we show that there exist orthogonal sets that are locally distinguishable but without local redundancy (i.e., they become nonorthogonal on discarding one or more subsystems) whose nonlocality can be activated by local measurements. In particular, a state chosen from such a set can be locally converted, with certainty, into another state, the identity of which can now only be ascertained by global measurement and no longer by LOCC. In other words, a locally distinguishable set without local redundancy may be locally converted into a locally indistinguishable set with certainty. We also suggest an application, namely, local hiding of information, that allows us to locally hide locally available information without losing any part. Once hidden, the information in its entirety can only be retrieved using entanglement.

arXiv:2104.11933•Physical Review A•Nov 8, 2021•20 citations

On the conflict between local realism and classical physics

Salvatore Savasta, Omar Di Stefano, R. Girlanda

In contrast to the intuitively plausible assumption of local realism, entangled particles, even when isolated, are not allowed to possess definite properties in their own right, as quantitatively expressed by violations of Bell's inequalities [1]. Even as entanglement is now a key feature of quantum information and communication technology [2,3], it remains the most puzzling feature of quantum mechanics [4] and its conceptual foundation is still widely debated. Here we demonstrate that physical systems providing dicotomic outcomes are not able to guarantee both the rotation properties of physical quantities and local realism. This result opens the way to a new formulation of quantum mechanics based on only two elementary physical principles replacing the abstract mathematical axiomes of the present theory. According to this formulation, the coexistence of discrete outcomes with the classical continuous transformation properties of physical quantities under coordinate transformation inevitably implies quantum probabilities. These results, provide a simple physical explanation to the most debated quantum features and put into question the existence of physical quantities displaying continuous outcomes in agreement with approaches that attempt to integrate quantum theory with general relativity [5-8].

arXiv:quant-ph/0507102•Jul 11, 2005•0 citations

Classical theories with entanglement

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Marco Erba, Paolo Perinotti

We investigate operational probabilistic theories where the pure states of every system are the vertices of a simplex. A special case of such theories is that of classical theories, i.e., simplicial theories whose pure states are jointly perfectly discriminable. The usual classical theory satisfies also local discriminability. However, simplicial theories---including the classical ones---can violate local discriminability, thus admitting entangled states. First, we prove sufficient conditions for the presence of entangled states in arbitrary probabilistic theories. Then we prove that simplicial theories are necessarily causal, and this represents a no-go theorem for conceiving noncausal classical theories. We then provide necessary and sufficient conditions for simplicial theories to exhibit entanglement and classify their system-composition rules. We conclude by proving that, in simplicial theories, an operational formulation of the superposition principle cannot be satisfied, and that---under the hypothesis of $n$-local discriminability---no mixed state admits a purification. Our results hold also in the general case where the sets of states fail to be convex.

arXiv:1909.07134•Physical Review A•Apr 20, 2020•24 citations

Local measurement in entangled systems: Conditional states, quantum instruments, and the no-signalling theorem

Sachin .

A local measurement on one member of an entangled composite system is said to change the distant member's state instantaneously. Taken without qualification, this is misleading. A selective measurement changes the conditional state assigned to the remote subsystem once a local outcome is specified; a non-selective measurement, where that outcome is ignored, leaves the remote reduced density operator unchanged. This distinction reconciles quantum state update with operational no-signalling and provides the setting for Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen steering. This review develops measurement using density operators, completely positive instruments, Kraus representations, partial traces, conditional states, and steering assemblages. It derives the invariance of remote marginal statistics under local trace-preserving operations and contrasts this with Bell-local factorization. It examines the hierarchy among entanglement, steering, and Bell nonlocality, joint measurability, remote state preparation, and one-sided device-independent protocols. The article considers spacelike-separated measurements, microcausality in relativistic quantum theory, and ontological readings of selective state update offered by Everettian, Bohmian, collapse, and relational approaches. Decoherence is treated as the process through which local outcomes become records, while quantum Darwinism accounts for their redundant local accessibility. It highlights gaps in literature, and concludes that entanglement permits nonclassical conditional correlations, but local measurement supplies no controllable superluminal signal.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations
In this chapter we introduce the principle of local discriminability, which stipulates the possibility of discriminating states of composite systems via local measurements on the component systems. The phenomenon of entanglement has relevant consequences on the accessibility of information in composite systems and on the complexity of characterization of transformations: local discriminability brings dramatic simplifications to the structure of the sets of states and transformations, reconciling the holism of entangled states with the reductionist scientific approach. In order to illustrate the structural relevance of the principle, we will briefly review some OPTs that do not satisfy it, contrasting the features of such theories with those of quantum and classical probabilistic theories, where the principle holds. Entanglement and Holism Holism is a widely known feature of quantum theory, related to the existence of entangled states. In quantum theory one has pure entangled states, whose marginal states are completely mixed. This situation corresponds to having maximal knowledge of the whole with minimal knowledge of the parts. The main manifestation of the holism of entanglement is the impossibility of reconciling the statistics of joint measurements on entangled states with local realism . Local realism is the assumption that any measurement on a system is just the reading of a pre-existing quantity encoded on the system. In other words, we cannot explain the statistics of measurements on the parts of a composite system as a manifestation of our ignorance of locally pre-existing values, as in classical OPT. Does entanglement make information about composite systems locally unaccessible? This would pose severe practical issues on the possibility of acquiring information about physical systems. For example, suppose that two distant telescopes observe a source of entangled photons from a stellar emission. Holism would imply that some features of the emission process could never be detected, unless we are able to make the entangled photons interact in a joint measurement. On the other hand, if a reductionist approach is possible, local observations of the two photons at the sites of the two telescopes would be enough to characterize the emitting source. Thanks to the local discriminability principle, this is actually the case with entangled quantum sources. Another consequence of holism is the fact that transformations generally cannot be characterized by local experiments, namely by applying the unknown transformation only to its input system.
An operational probabilistic theory where all systems are classical, and all pure states of composite systems are entangled, is constructed. The theory is endowed with a rule for composing an arbitrary number of systems, and with a nontrivial set of transformations. Hence, we demonstrate that the presence of entanglement is independent of the existence of incompatible measurements. We then study a variety of phenomena occurring in the theory, some of them contradicting both classical and quantum theories, including cloning, entanglement swapping, dense coding, additivity of classical capacities, nonmonogamous entanglement, hypersignaling. We also prove the existence, in the theory, of a universal processor. The theory is causal and satisfies the no-restriction hypothesis. At the same time, it violates a number of information-theoretic principles enjoyed by quantum theory, most notably, local discriminability, purity of parallel composition of states, and purification. Moreover, we introduce an exhaustive procedure to construct generic operational probabilistic theories, and a sufficient set of conditions to verify their consistency. In addition, we prove a characterization theorem for the parallel composition rules of arbitrary theories, and specialize it to the case of bilocal-tomographic theories. We conclude pointing out some open problems. In particular, on the basis of the fact that every separable state of the theory is a statistical mixture of entangled states, we formulate a no-go conjecture for the existence of a local-realistic ontological model.
Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.
Quantum nonlocality has different manifestations that, in general, are revealed by local measurements of the parts of a composite system. In this paper, we study nonlocality arising from a set of orthogonal states that cannot be perfectly distinguished by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). Such a set is deemed nonlocal, for a joint measurement on the whole system is necessary for perfect discrimination of the states with certainty. On the other hand, a set of orthogonal states that can be perfectly distinguished by LOCC is believed to be devoid of nonlocal properties. Here, we show that there exist orthogonal sets that are locally distinguishable but without local redundancy (i.e., they become nonorthogonal on discarding one or more subsystems) whose nonlocality can be activated by local measurements. In particular, a state chosen from such a set can be locally converted, with certainty, into another state, the identity of which can now only be ascertained by global measurement and no longer by LOCC. In other words, a locally distinguishable set without local redundancy may be locally converted into a locally indistinguishable set with certainty. We also suggest an application, namely, local hiding of information, that allows us to locally hide locally available information without losing any part. Once hidden, the information in its entirety can only be retrieved using entanglement.
In contrast to the intuitively plausible assumption of local realism, entangled particles, even when isolated, are not allowed to possess definite properties in their own right, as quantitatively expressed by violations of Bell's inequalities [1]. Even as entanglement is now a key feature of quantum information and communication technology [2,3], it remains the most puzzling feature of quantum mechanics [4] and its conceptual foundation is still widely debated. Here we demonstrate that physical systems providing dicotomic outcomes are not able to guarantee both the rotation properties of physical quantities and local realism. This result opens the way to a new formulation of quantum mechanics based on only two elementary physical principles replacing the abstract mathematical axiomes of the present theory. According to this formulation, the coexistence of discrete outcomes with the classical continuous transformation properties of physical quantities under coordinate transformation inevitably implies quantum probabilities. These results, provide a simple physical explanation to the most debated quantum features and put into question the existence of physical quantities displaying continuous outcomes in agreement with approaches that attempt to integrate quantum theory with general relativity [5-8].
We investigate operational probabilistic theories where the pure states of every system are the vertices of a simplex. A special case of such theories is that of classical theories, i.e., simplicial theories whose pure states are jointly perfectly discriminable. The usual classical theory satisfies also local discriminability. However, simplicial theories---including the classical ones---can violate local discriminability, thus admitting entangled states. First, we prove sufficient conditions for the presence of entangled states in arbitrary probabilistic theories. Then we prove that simplicial theories are necessarily causal, and this represents a no-go theorem for conceiving noncausal classical theories. We then provide necessary and sufficient conditions for simplicial theories to exhibit entanglement and classify their system-composition rules. We conclude by proving that, in simplicial theories, an operational formulation of the superposition principle cannot be satisfied, and that---under the hypothesis of nnn-local discriminability---no mixed state admits a purification. Our results hold also in the general case where the sets of states fail to be convex.
A local measurement on one member of an entangled composite system is said to change the distant member's state instantaneously. Taken without qualification, this is misleading. A selective measurement changes the conditional state assigned to the remote subsystem once a local outcome is specified; a non-selective measurement, where that outcome is ignored, leaves the remote reduced density operator unchanged. This distinction reconciles quantum state update with operational no-signalling and provides the setting for Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen steering. This review develops measurement using density operators, completely positive instruments, Kraus representations, partial traces, conditional states, and steering assemblages. It derives the invariance of remote marginal statistics under local trace-preserving operations and contrasts this with Bell-local factorization. It examines the hierarchy among entanglement, steering, and Bell nonlocality, joint measurability, remote state preparation, and one-sided device-independent protocols. The article considers spacelike-separated measurements, microcausality in relativistic quantum theory, and ontological readings of selective state update offered by Everettian, Bohmian, collapse, and relational approaches. Decoherence is treated as the process through which local outcomes become records, while quantum Darwinism accounts for their redundant local accessibility. It highlights gaps in literature, and concludes that entanglement permits nonclassical conditional correlations, but local measurement supplies no controllable superluminal signal.