Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

The quantum philosopher

Edwin Cartlidge

Published Aug 1, 2005• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Tony Leggett has two questions that he likes to ask audiences of physicists.The first concerns the double-slit experiment with single electrons: does each electron pass through just one of the slits to make the interference pattern? The second is about Schrödinger's famous thought experiment with a cat in a box: will the cat definitely be either alive or dead before the box is opened?

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/18/8/18

Related papers

Revealing the cat in the box

When Erwin Schrödinger suggested a thought experiment in which a cat inside a box could be both dead and alive at the same time, he conjured up one of the most evocative images in quantum mechanics. However, this paradoxical Picture is only valid when the system is free from external influences. Open the box, and the cat is forced into one or other of its classical states – a phenomenon known as decoherence.

Physics World•Feb 1, 2000•0 citations

Quantum largesse

In 1935 Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment to show the absurd consequences of applying quantum mechanics to everyday objects. Schrödinger imagined placing a cat in a box, along with a vial of deadly poison that is connected to a radioactive atom. If the atom decays, it releases the poison and kills the cat. When the box is closed we do not know if the atom has decayed or not, which means that it can be in a "superposition" of two states (decayed and non-decayed) at the same time. Therefore, protested Schrödinger, the cat can be both dead and alive at the same time – which is clearly absurd. There was obviously, he thought, some boundary between the microscopic world of atoms and quantum mechanics, and the macroscopic world of cats and classical mechanics.

Physics World•Aug 1, 2000•0 citations

Schizophrenic Atom Doubles as Schrödinger's Cat—or Kitten

Gary Taubes

Schrödinger's cat has always been an elusive beast, but physicists may have finally trapped one in the laboratory. In the great Austrian physicist's thought experiment, the fate of a cat was linked to the quantum indeterminacy of a radioactive atom—half decayed, half undecayed. The cat, as a result, was both alive and dead. Now physicists at the National Institute of Standards and Technology in Boulder, Colorado, report in this issue ( p. 1131 ) that they have created what one observer calls a “Schrödinger's kitten,” in which they excite an atom into a superposition of quantum states, then ease those two states apart so that the atom appears to be in two distinct physical locations simultaneously.

Science•May 24, 1996•12 citations

The paradox of Schrodinger's cat

C N Villars

Erwin Schrodinger first described the thought-experiment which has since become known as 'the paradox of Schrodinger's cat' 51 years ago. In recent years, popular accounts of quantum mechanics have tended to adopt one or other of the philosophically most extreme solutions to this paradox, i.e. the consciousness hypothesis or the many worlds interpretation. The author attempts to redress the balance by describing what he takes to be the orthodox solution to the paradox which explains the paradox, without recourse to such counterintuitive notions as a cat simultaneously dead and alive or a universe continually splitting into multiple worlds, as being due to a misapplication of the quantum formalism.

Physics Education•Jul 1, 1986•8 citations

Prequel to the Logical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics: A Classical Logic Edition—How to Check, Via Experiment , Whether Schrödinger's Cat Is in Superposition Before Opening the Box

Chan

Schrödinger’s cat paradox has symbolized the apparent conflict between quantum superposition and classical reality for nearly a century. This note introduces a simple thought experiment—two sealed double-slit apparatuses, one with which-path detectors and one without—that resolves the paradox using only classical logic and the standard quantum formalism. The pattern on each screen is determined by the experimental operational setup—whether which-path detectors are installed or not—not by a later observation. The cat, being macroscopic, itself acts as a detector of the life-death variable. It is therefore not in a quantum superposition. Instead, it resides in a quantum mixed state with classical probability—not a superposition state, which must be pure—even in a closed box. Once the non-literal nature of the shorthand is recognized—the wave function is (in encoded form) a statistical pattern, not a physical field in physical spacetime—quantum mechanics proves fully consistent with classical logic.

•Dec 31, 2025•0 citations

From Particle-in-a-Box Thought Experiment to a Complete Quantum Theory?

Jixin Chen

Einstein: God does not play dice and nothing travels faster than the speed of light. Schrödinger: My cat cannot be both dead and alive. Dirac: The existing quantum theory should not be considered to be the final solution. Feynman: How does it work? de Broglie: My matter wave has an imaginary part. Me: Great! This could be the missing piece the others have been looking for.

•Aug 3, 2023•0 citations
Tony Leggett has two questions that he likes to ask audiences of physicists.The first concerns the double-slit experiment with single electrons: does each electron pass through just one of the slits to make the interference pattern? The second is about Schrödinger's famous thought experiment with a cat in a box: will the cat definitely be either alive or dead before the box is opened?
In 1935 Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment to show the absurd consequences of applying quantum mechanics to everyday objects. Schrödinger imagined placing a cat in a box, along with a vial of deadly poison that is connected to a radioactive atom. If the atom decays, it releases the poison and kills the cat. When the box is closed we do not know if the atom has decayed or not, which means that it can be in a "superposition" of two states (decayed and non-decayed) at the same time. Therefore, protested Schrödinger, the cat can be both dead and alive at the same time – which is clearly absurd. There was obviously, he thought, some boundary between the microscopic world of atoms and quantum mechanics, and the macroscopic world of cats and classical mechanics.
Schrödinger's cat has always been an elusive beast, but physicists may have finally trapped one in the laboratory. In the great Austrian physicist's thought experiment, the fate of a cat was linked to the quantum indeterminacy of a radioactive atom—half decayed, half undecayed. The cat, as a result, was both alive and dead. Now physicists at the National Institute of Standards and Technology in Boulder, Colorado, report in this issue ( p. 1131 ) that they have created what one observer calls a “Schrödinger's kitten,” in which they excite an atom into a superposition of quantum states, then ease those two states apart so that the atom appears to be in two distinct physical locations simultaneously.
Erwin Schrodinger first described the thought-experiment which has since become known as 'the paradox of Schrodinger's cat' 51 years ago. In recent years, popular accounts of quantum mechanics have tended to adopt one or other of the philosophically most extreme solutions to this paradox, i.e. the consciousness hypothesis or the many worlds interpretation. The author attempts to redress the balance by describing what he takes to be the orthodox solution to the paradox which explains the paradox, without recourse to such counterintuitive notions as a cat simultaneously dead and alive or a universe continually splitting into multiple worlds, as being due to a misapplication of the quantum formalism.
Schrödinger’s cat paradox has symbolized the apparent conflict between quantum superposition and classical reality for nearly a century. This note introduces a simple thought experiment—two sealed double-slit apparatuses, one with which-path detectors and one without—that resolves the paradox using only classical logic and the standard quantum formalism. The pattern on each screen is determined by the experimental operational setup—whether which-path detectors are installed or not—not by a later observation. The cat, being macroscopic, itself acts as a detector of the life-death variable. It is therefore not in a quantum superposition. Instead, it resides in a quantum mixed state with classical probability—not a superposition state, which must be pure—even in a closed box. Once the non-literal nature of the shorthand is recognized—the wave function is (in encoded form) a statistical pattern, not a physical field in physical spacetime—quantum mechanics proves fully consistent with classical logic.