Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Experiments Towards Mitigation of Motional Heating in Trapped Ion Quantum Information Processing

Amy Greene

Published Feb 27, 2016• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Trapped ions are a promising candidate for the implementation of quantum information processing. Techniques have already been developed for working with small systems of trapped-ion qubits; scalability is the biggest remaining challenge. One of the major scalability obstacles faced by trapped ions is an anomalous motional heating which limits the fidelity of two-qubit gates. It has been demonstrated that cleaning a gold trap chip via ion milling reduces the heating rate by two orders of magnitude [1]. However, it remains unclear why ion milling causes a much more dramatic improvement than similar cleaning techniques such as plasma cleaning, which only reduces the heating rate by a factor of 4 [2]. Understanding this difference will provide insight into the source of the anomalous heating noise. In this work, we investigate the mechanism by which ion milling reduces the heating rate by cleaning niobium traps with a ex-situ ion milling followed by plasma cleaning. We find that the resulting reduction in the heating rate is consistent with that obtained from plasma cleaning alone. This, combined with a recent result from the ex-situ milling of gold traps [3], suggests that some component of the improvement mechanism is material-based. Additionally, we present our work on the design and testing of a small resonator board used to deliver a high RF voltage to the trap chip. This board, made with off-the-shelf components, represents a more scalable alternative to the helical resonators which are commonly used for this purpose.

Related papers

Reduction of trapped-ion anomalous heating byin situsurface plasma cleaning

Robert McConnell, Colin Bruzewicz, John Chiaverini +1 more

Anomalous motional heating is a major obstacle to scalable quantum information processing with trapped ions. Although the source of this heating is not yet understood, several previous studies suggest that noise due to surface contaminants is the limiting heating mechanism in some instances. We demonstrate an improvement by a factor of 4 in the room-temperature heating rate of a niobium surface electrode trap by in situ plasma cleaning of the trap surface. This surface treatment was performed with a simple homebuilt coil assembly and commercially available matching network and is considerably gentler than other treatments, such as ion milling or laser cleaning, that have previously been shown to improve ion heating rates. We do not see an improvement in the heating rate when the trap is operated at cryogenic temperatures, pointing to a role of thermally activated surface contaminants in motional heating whose activity may freeze out at low temperatures.

arXiv:1505.03844•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2015•36 citations

100-Fold Reduction of Electric-Field Noise in an Ion Trap Cleaned with In Situ Argon-Ion-Beam Bombardment

Dustin A. Hite, Yves Colombe, A. C. Wilson +8 more

Motional heating of trapped atomic ions is a major obstacle to their use as quantum bits in a scalable quantum computer. The detailed physical origin of this heating is not well understood, but experimental evidence suggests that it is caused by electric-field noise emanating from the surface of the trap electrodes. In this study, we have investigated the role of adsorbates on the electrodes by identifying contaminant overlayers, implementing an in situ argon-ion-beam cleaning treatment, and measuring ion heating rates before and after treating the trap electrodes' surfaces. We find a 100-fold reduction in heating rate after treatment. The experiments described here are sensitive to low levels of electric-field noise in the MHz frequency range. Therefore, this approach could become a useful tool in surface science that complements established techniques.

arXiv:1112.5419•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2012•187 citations

Method for determination of technical noise contributions to ion motional heating

Jonathon A. Sedlacek, Jules Stuart, William Loh +4 more

Microfabricated Paul ion traps show tremendous promise for large-scale quantum information processing. However, motional heating of ions can have a detrimental effect on the fidelity of quantum logic operations in miniaturized, scalable designs. In many experiments, motional heating rates are ascribed solely to anomalous heating, which arises at least in part from electric field noise from the trap surface not attributable to any known mechanisms. Contributions to measured ion heating rates due to technical voltage noise present on the static (DC) and radio frequency (RF) electrodes—i.e., due to voltage sources, amplifiers, and other electrical components—can often be overlooked. We present a reliable method for determining the extent to which motional heating is dominated by technical voltage noise on the DC or RF electrodes. Also, we demonstrate that stray DC electric fields can shift the ion position such that technical noise on the RF electrode can significantly contribute to the motional heating rate. After minimizing the pseudopotential gradient experienced by the ion induced by stray DC electric fields, the motional heating due to RF technical noise can be significantly reduced.

arXiv:1805.09491•Journal of Applied Physics•Dec 6, 2018•16 citations

Reduction of heating rate in a microfabricated ion trap by pulsed-laser cleaning

D T C Allcock, Luca Guidoni, T P Harty +4 more

Laser cleaning of the electrodes in a planar micro-fabricated ion trap has been attempted using ns pulses from a tripled Nd:YAG laser at 355 nm.The effect of the laser pulses at several energy density levels has been tested by measuring the heating rate of a single 40 Ca + trapped ion as a function of its secular frequency ω z .A reduction of the electric-field noise spectral density by ∼50% has been observed and a change in the frequency dependence also noticed.This is the first reported experiment where the 'anomalous heating' phenomenon has been reduced by removing the source as opposed to reducing its thermal driving by cryogenic cooling.This technique may open up the way to better control of the electrode surface quality in ion microtraps.The recent success of quantum information experiments based on trapped ions [1] triggered research on micro-fabricated radio-frequency (Paul) traps, which are in principle able to fulfill the scalability requirement of a quantum computer [2,3].In such traps, a set of micro-fabricated conducting electrodes generates oscillating and static electric fields that trap laser-cooled ions in a harmonic potential well at a sub-millimeter distance d from the substrate [4,5].However, the presence of uncontrolled fluctuating electric fields affects the ions' external motion and induces an 'anomalous heating' that limits the achievable fidelity of multi-ion quantum gates that rely on the coherent control of this motion [6].Experimental observations concerning this phenomenon 4

arXiv:1110.1486•New Journal of Physics•Dec 16, 2011•72 citations

Simplified motional heating rate measurements of trapped ions

R. J. Epstein, Signe Louise Seidelin, Dietrich G. Leibfried +13 more

We have measured motional heating rates of trapped atomic ions, a factor that can influence multi-ion quantum logic gate fidelities. Two simplified techniques were developed for this purpose: one relies on Raman sideband detection implemented with a single laser source, while the second is even simpler and is based on time-resolved fluorescence detection during Doppler recooling. We applied these methods to determine heating rates in a microfrabricated surface-electrode trap made of gold on fused quartz, which traps ions $40\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\mu}}\mathrm{m}$ above its surface. Heating rates obtained from the two techniques were found to be in reasonable agreement. In addition, the trap gives rise to a heating rate of $300\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}30\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ for a motional frequency of $5.25\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{MHz}$, substantially below the trend observed in other traps.

arXiv:0707.1528•Physical Review A•Sep 19, 2007•122 citations

A High Motional Frequency Ion Trapping Regime for Quantum Information Science

A. J. Rasmusson

We investigate high frequency motional states of trapped atomic ions. Trapped ions in rf traps are confined by an approximate harmonic potential and exhibit quantum motional states that mediate essential techniques in quantum computing, simulation, networking, and precision measurement. However, motional state decoherence mechanisms, heating and dephasing, are broadly limiting: reduced two-qubit gate fidelities; lower fidelity and lifetime of highly nonclassical bosonic states; long laser cooling times; and large recoil heating rates. These also challenge the scalability of increasingly sophisticated protocols. We propose high motional frequency ion trapping as an operating regime that addresses these challenges and reshapes the design landscape for quantum information experiments and quantum control techniques. We report an experimentally motivated investigation of realizing this high-frequency regime and discuss the consequences for laser cooling, motional state coherence, fidelity and lifetime of nonclassical bosonic states, and scalability of experimental runtimes. We report clear design trajectories for ion traps to reach high motional frequency, a new limiting mechanism for laser cooling at these high frequencies, and more than an order-of-magnitude speedup in experimental duty cycles with larger speed ups possible for quantum error correction protocols. Taken together, high motional frequency ion trapping has broad implications for the future of quantum information experiments.

quant-pharXiv:2604.03435•Apr 7, 2026•1 citation
Trapped ions are a promising candidate for the implementation of quantum information processing. Techniques have already been developed for working with small systems of trapped-ion qubits; scalability is the biggest remaining challenge. One of the major scalability obstacles faced by trapped ions is an anomalous motional heating which limits the fidelity of two-qubit gates. It has been demonstrated that cleaning a gold trap chip via ion milling reduces the heating rate by two orders of magnitude [1]. However, it remains unclear why ion milling causes a much more dramatic improvement than similar cleaning techniques such as plasma cleaning, which only reduces the heating rate by a factor of 4 [2]. Understanding this difference will provide insight into the source of the anomalous heating noise. In this work, we investigate the mechanism by which ion milling reduces the heating rate by cleaning niobium traps with a ex-situ ion milling followed by plasma cleaning. We find that the resulting reduction in the heating rate is consistent with that obtained from plasma cleaning alone. This, combined with a recent result from the ex-situ milling of gold traps [3], suggests that some component of the improvement mechanism is material-based. Additionally, we present our work on the design and testing of a small resonator board used to deliver a high RF voltage to the trap chip. This board, made with off-the-shelf components, represents a more scalable alternative to the helical resonators which are commonly used for this purpose.
Anomalous motional heating is a major obstacle to scalable quantum information processing with trapped ions. Although the source of this heating is not yet understood, several previous studies suggest that noise due to surface contaminants is the limiting heating mechanism in some instances. We demonstrate an improvement by a factor of 4 in the room-temperature heating rate of a niobium surface electrode trap by in situ plasma cleaning of the trap surface. This surface treatment was performed with a simple homebuilt coil assembly and commercially available matching network and is considerably gentler than other treatments, such as ion milling or laser cleaning, that have previously been shown to improve ion heating rates. We do not see an improvement in the heating rate when the trap is operated at cryogenic temperatures, pointing to a role of thermally activated surface contaminants in motional heating whose activity may freeze out at low temperatures.
Motional heating of trapped atomic ions is a major obstacle to their use as quantum bits in a scalable quantum computer. The detailed physical origin of this heating is not well understood, but experimental evidence suggests that it is caused by electric-field noise emanating from the surface of the trap electrodes. In this study, we have investigated the role of adsorbates on the electrodes by identifying contaminant overlayers, implementing an in situ argon-ion-beam cleaning treatment, and measuring ion heating rates before and after treating the trap electrodes' surfaces. We find a 100-fold reduction in heating rate after treatment. The experiments described here are sensitive to low levels of electric-field noise in the MHz frequency range. Therefore, this approach could become a useful tool in surface science that complements established techniques.
Microfabricated Paul ion traps show tremendous promise for large-scale quantum information processing. However, motional heating of ions can have a detrimental effect on the fidelity of quantum logic operations in miniaturized, scalable designs. In many experiments, motional heating rates are ascribed solely to anomalous heating, which arises at least in part from electric field noise from the trap surface not attributable to any known mechanisms. Contributions to measured ion heating rates due to technical voltage noise present on the static (DC) and radio frequency (RF) electrodes—i.e., due to voltage sources, amplifiers, and other electrical components—can often be overlooked. We present a reliable method for determining the extent to which motional heating is dominated by technical voltage noise on the DC or RF electrodes. Also, we demonstrate that stray DC electric fields can shift the ion position such that technical noise on the RF electrode can significantly contribute to the motional heating rate. After minimizing the pseudopotential gradient experienced by the ion induced by stray DC electric fields, the motional heating due to RF technical noise can be significantly reduced.
Laser cleaning of the electrodes in a planar micro-fabricated ion trap has been attempted using ns pulses from a tripled Nd:YAG laser at 355 nm.The effect of the laser pulses at several energy density levels has been tested by measuring the heating rate of a single 40 Ca + trapped ion as a function of its secular frequency ω z .A reduction of the electric-field noise spectral density by ∼50% has been observed and a change in the frequency dependence also noticed.This is the first reported experiment where the 'anomalous heating' phenomenon has been reduced by removing the source as opposed to reducing its thermal driving by cryogenic cooling.This technique may open up the way to better control of the electrode surface quality in ion microtraps.The recent success of quantum information experiments based on trapped ions [1] triggered research on micro-fabricated radio-frequency (Paul) traps, which are in principle able to fulfill the scalability requirement of a quantum computer [2,3].In such traps, a set of micro-fabricated conducting electrodes generates oscillating and static electric fields that trap laser-cooled ions in a harmonic potential well at a sub-millimeter distance d from the substrate [4,5].However, the presence of uncontrolled fluctuating electric fields affects the ions' external motion and induces an 'anomalous heating' that limits the achievable fidelity of multi-ion quantum gates that rely on the coherent control of this motion [6].Experimental observations concerning this phenomenon 4
We have measured motional heating rates of trapped atomic ions, a factor that can influence multi-ion quantum logic gate fidelities. Two simplified techniques were developed for this purpose: one relies on Raman sideband detection implemented with a single laser source, while the second is even simpler and is based on time-resolved fluorescence detection during Doppler recooling. We applied these methods to determine heating rates in a microfrabricated surface-electrode trap made of gold on fused quartz, which traps ions $40\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\mu}}\mathrm{m}$ above its surface. Heating rates obtained from the two techniques were found to be in reasonable agreement. In addition, the trap gives rise to a heating rate of $300\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}30\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}{\mathrm{s}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ for a motional frequency of 5.25MHz5.25\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\mathrm{MHz}5.25MHz, substantially below the trend observed in other traps.
We investigate high frequency motional states of trapped atomic ions. Trapped ions in rf traps are confined by an approximate harmonic potential and exhibit quantum motional states that mediate essential techniques in quantum computing, simulation, networking, and precision measurement. However, motional state decoherence mechanisms, heating and dephasing, are broadly limiting: reduced two-qubit gate fidelities; lower fidelity and lifetime of highly nonclassical bosonic states; long laser cooling times; and large recoil heating rates. These also challenge the scalability of increasingly sophisticated protocols. We propose high motional frequency ion trapping as an operating regime that addresses these challenges and reshapes the design landscape for quantum information experiments and quantum control techniques. We report an experimentally motivated investigation of realizing this high-frequency regime and discuss the consequences for laser cooling, motional state coherence, fidelity and lifetime of nonclassical bosonic states, and scalability of experimental runtimes. We report clear design trajectories for ion traps to reach high motional frequency, a new limiting mechanism for laser cooling at these high frequencies, and more than an order-of-magnitude speedup in experimental duty cycles with larger speed ups possible for quantum error correction protocols. Taken together, high motional frequency ion trapping has broad implications for the future of quantum information experiments.