Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum dynamics of small numbers of ions in a penning trap

G. Stutter

Published Nov 1, 2015• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Laser-cooled trapped ions are one of the main systems used in experiments in the fields of quantum optics and quantum information. There are two commonly-used types of ion trap, the radiofrequency trap and the Penning trap. In general, the RF trap has been more widely used in quantum information experiments, meaning that the set of experimental tools for conducting these types of experiments in a Penning trap is currently less complete. The aim of the work presented in this thesis is to increase this array of tools. Our experiment uses 40Ca+ ions in a Penning trap alongside lasers. Spectroscopy has been performed on single Doppler cooled ions, and on ions that have been prepared close to their ground state of motion using a multiple-stage sideband cooling technique resulting in an average phonon occupation number of $\nzbar = 0.029\pm 0.011$ from an initial $\nzbar \approx 24$. This corresponds to a quantum ground state population of $97\%$, which is close to the sideband cooling limit in our system. An axial heating rate measurement of $\dot{\bar{n}}_z=\SI{0.56\pm0.52}{\per\second}$ has also been obtained, which is the lowest recorded to date, due in part to the large dimensions of our trap. Additionally improved control of the Penning trap radial motion has been demonstrated and the average phonon occupation number of the modified cyclotron motion has been reduced from $\ncbar\approx150$ after Doppler cooling to $\ncbar=0.6$ after sideband cooling. Some preliminary single-ion coherent operations have also been performed. In the future we hope that this system of ground state cooled ions in a Penning trap can be used to generate highly-entangled states in two or more ions, with a view to performing simple quantum error-correcting codes and eventually an analogue quantum simulation of spin systems.

DOI
10.25560/31473

Related papers

Sideband cooling to the quantum ground state in a penning trap

Joseph F. Goodwin

For 35 years, laser-cooled trapped ions have been at the frontier of progress in quantum computing, quantum simulation and precision measurement, and remain one of the most valuable tools in these fields to this day. Most of these experiments are predicated upon or benefit from the ability to place ions in the motional quantum ground state, a technique that was first demonstrated in radiofrequency ion traps 25 years ago. For a range of crucial experiments that are impossible to conduct in radiofrequency traps or are not well suited to this architecture, Penning traps provide an important alternative. However, the performance of Penning traps had been limited by the fact that ground-state cooling was yet to be achieved in such a system. This thesis reports the first demonstration of resolved-sideband cooling in a Penning trap, for 40Ca+ions cooled with light at 729-nm, achieving a ground state occupation of 99% in one dimension. Demonstrations of the coherent manipulations possible at this level of confinement are presented. The ion heating rate is measured and although higher than might be expected given the unusually large ion-electrode distance remains amongst the lowest reported in any trap to date. Achieving this result required the development of a number of new experimental systems and major upgrades to the stability and reliability of the experiment, the details of which are also given. The thesis also presents theoretical work into the use of two-dimensional Coulomb crystals in a Penning trap as a resource for quantum information. Using the symmetries of the crystal, we find that it is possible to engineer complex entangled states, specifically two small quantum error correcting codes, using a very small number of global entangling pulses. Efficient entanglement protocols such as these are vital for the implementation of useful quantum error correction.

•Nov 1, 2014•1 citation

Coherent dynamics of trapped ions within and outside the Lamb-Dicke regime

Manoj K. Joshi

From subatomic particles to macromolecules, quantum mechanics has a deep impact in understanding the interactions and nature of such constituents of matter. The paradoxical observations of entanglement in quantum systems is used in quantum computations. Ion traps are among the leading platforms which provide clean and highly controllable quantum systems. This thesis presents the study of quantum coherence aiming to devise and test coherent control with trapped ions in a Penning trap. Our apparatus contains one or more calcium ions that are confined in space using DC electric and magnetic fields. Doppler cooling and resolved sideband cooling of trapped ions are carried out to perform high fidelity quantum control. The ions are prepared in their motional ground state via a multi-stage resolved sideband cooling technique. The cooling methods are first verified through simulations. The axial mean phonon numbers for a single ion are measured to be 0.03 ± 0.01 and 0.012 ± 0.009 at 187 kHz and 420 kHz axial frequencies, respectively. The heating rate is measured to be 2.5 ± 0.5 phonons/s, which is consistent with the previous measurements in our system. Similarly, the radial motional modes of a single ion are cooled to 〈n_+ 〉<0.4 and 〈n_- 〉<0.6 from mean phonon numbers corresponding to each mode of around 100. Preliminary studies are carried out of the axial motional modes of a 1D chain and 2D planar crystals, extending sideband cooling to small ICC's in a Penning trap. Coherent control is examined in our system and the optical coherence time and motional coherence time are estimated to be approximately 1 ms and 0.5 s, respectively. Furthermore, a single ion is prepared outside the Lamb-Dicke regime via a sideband heating technique and coherent studies are performed in such a regime via a laser beam.

•Apr 1, 2018•0 citations

High-fidelity quantum control using ion crystals in a Penning trap

Michael J. Biercuk, Hermann Uys, Aaron P. VanDevender +3 more

We provide an introduction to the use of ion crystals in a Penning trap for experiments in quantum information. Macroscopic Penning traps allow for the containment of a few to a few million atomic ions whose internal states may be used in quantum information experiments. Ions are laser Doppler cooled, and the mutual Coulomb repulsion of the ions leads to the formation of crystalline arrays. The structure and dimensionality of the resulting ion crystals may be tuned using a combination of control laser beams and external potentials. We discuss the use of two-dimensional $^{9}$Be$^{+}$ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations ($\tau_{\pi}\sim$200 $\mu$s). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized $\pi/2$ and $\pi$ pulse pair) of $8\pm1\times10^{-4}$. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of $T_{2}\sim$2 ms, and a limiting $T_{1\rho}\sim$688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.

arXiv:0906.0398•Quantum Information and Computation•Nov 1, 2009•55 citations

Ground state cooling of the radial motion of a single ion in a penning trap and coherent manipulation of small numbers of ions

Pavel Hrmo

This thesis extends the recently reported ground state sideband cooling of the axial motion of a single ion to a broader frequency range of the axial motion, the radial motion and ion crystals. Once cold, coherent control of these different configurations is demonstrated. The experimental work in this thesis uses 40Ca+ ions that can be coherently addressed on a narrow linewidth optical transition at 729 nm. The technique of axialization that resonantly couples the two radial modes of motion is used to enhance laser Doppler cooling leading to mean phonon occupation numbers in the low hundreds for both modes. The sideband cooling technique is then used to simultaneously cool both the motional modes to within one phonon of the ground state for the first time evers. Sideband cooling is then also employed to cool the axial modes of many ion Coulomb crystals in two different configurations. For two ions in a 1D chain, motional occupation numbers of nbar_COM=0.30(4) and nbar_B=0.07(3) are achieved. For two ions in a planar 2D configuration the result for the two modes are nbar_T=nbar_COM<0.1. This technique is scaled up to demonstrate ground state occupation of up to 10 ions in the planar configuration. The axial mode of motion of a single motion is used to characterise the coherent addressing capabilities in our system through optical and motional Ramsey spectroscopy. We observe optical coherence times of 1.78(4) ms and motional coherence times of 590(12) ms. Dynamical decoupling techniques are shown to extend these coherence times. Furthermore, basic decoherence models are validated in high-lying non-thermal motional states that are prepared by a sideband heating technique. Progress towards entangling gates is demonstrated using a bichromatic laser beam to prepare non-classical states of motion.

•May 1, 2018•2 citations

Towards Sideband Cooling of a Single 40Ca+ Ion in a Penning Trap

S. Donnellan

This thesis presents work aimed towards achieving sideband cooling of 40Ca+ ions in a Penning trap. The observation of an increase in the number of quantum jumps as a function of the trapping magnetic field is first presented. This observation is explained by the ion falling into a long-lived D5/2 state, out of which the ion is not being re-pumped. The ion can fall into this state due to mixing of the fine structure components with the same mJ quantum number induced by the applied magnetic field. A calculation of the mixing and shelving rate as a function of magnetic field strength is presented. This theory matches well with the experimental results observed. This work has been presented in a publication in which a perturbative analysis was used. An alternative analysis is presented here in which the full Hamiltonian is diagonalised. The essential conclusions however remain unchanged. This ‘J-state mixing’ effect means re-pumping from each of the six D5/2 state sub-levels of our ion is required for efficient laser cooling. This is achieved by the addition of a system comprising an 854 nm laser and a fibre EOM to provide the radiation required to re-pump these levels. The same EOM is then used to re-pump out of the four sub-levels of the D3/2 state using a single 866 nm laser. This is a great simplification of the experimental setup required to cool a 40Ca+ ion in a Penning trap which would otherwise require ten separate lasers to independently address each of the D sub-states. Achieving efficient repumping leads to the ability to perform pulsed spectroscopy on the quadrupole S1/2 → D5/2 transition in 40Ca+ . Preliminary results of this spectroscopy in a radio-frequency trap are presented.

•Nov 1, 2011•1 citation

Optical Sideband Cooling of Ions in a Penning Trap

Richard Claude Thompson, Joseph F. Goodwin, G. Stutter +1 more

Optical sideband cooling is a well-established technique for preparing trapped ions in the ground state of one or more of their motional degrees of freedom. Up to now, this technique has mainly been applied in various types of radiofrequency trap. We show in this paper that the technique is also very effective in a Penning trap, and demonstrate that our trap has an exceptionally low heating rate, due to the large size of the Penning trap electrodes and the absence of large-amplitude radiofrequency fields in the trap.

Laser Spectroscopy•Oct 5, 2016•0 citations
Laser-cooled trapped ions are one of the main systems used in experiments in the fields of quantum optics and quantum information. There are two commonly-used types of ion trap, the radiofrequency trap and the Penning trap. In general, the RF trap has been more widely used in quantum information experiments, meaning that the set of experimental tools for conducting these types of experiments in a Penning trap is currently less complete. The aim of the work presented in this thesis is to increase this array of tools. Our experiment uses 40Ca+ ions in a Penning trap alongside lasers. Spectroscopy has been performed on single Doppler cooled ions, and on ions that have been prepared close to their ground state of motion using a multiple-stage sideband cooling technique resulting in an average phonon occupation number of \nzbar=0.029±0.011\nzbar = 0.029\pm 0.011\nzbar=0.029±0.011 from an initial \nzbar≈24\nzbar \approx 24\nzbar≈24. This corresponds to a quantum ground state population of 97%97\%97%, which is close to the sideband cooling limit in our system. An axial heating rate measurement of nˉ˙z=\SI0.56±0.52\per\second\dot{\bar{n}}_z=\SI{0.56\pm0.52}{\per\second}nˉ˙z​=\SI0.56±0.52\per\second has also been obtained, which is the lowest recorded to date, due in part to the large dimensions of our trap. Additionally improved control of the Penning trap radial motion has been demonstrated and the average phonon occupation number of the modified cyclotron motion has been reduced from \ncbar≈150\ncbar\approx150\ncbar≈150 after Doppler cooling to \ncbar=0.6\ncbar=0.6\ncbar=0.6 after sideband cooling. Some preliminary single-ion coherent operations have also been performed. In the future we hope that this system of ground state cooled ions in a Penning trap can be used to generate highly-entangled states in two or more ions, with a view to performing simple quantum error-correcting codes and eventually an analogue quantum simulation of spin systems.
For 35 years, laser-cooled trapped ions have been at the frontier of progress in quantum computing, quantum simulation and precision measurement, and remain one of the most valuable tools in these fields to this day. Most of these experiments are predicated upon or benefit from the ability to place ions in the motional quantum ground state, a technique that was first demonstrated in radiofrequency ion traps 25 years ago. For a range of crucial experiments that are impossible to conduct in radiofrequency traps or are not well suited to this architecture, Penning traps provide an important alternative. However, the performance of Penning traps had been limited by the fact that ground-state cooling was yet to be achieved in such a system. This thesis reports the first demonstration of resolved-sideband cooling in a Penning trap, for 40Ca+ions cooled with light at 729-nm, achieving a ground state occupation of 99% in one dimension. Demonstrations of the coherent manipulations possible at this level of confinement are presented. The ion heating rate is measured and although higher than might be expected given the unusually large ion-electrode distance remains amongst the lowest reported in any trap to date. Achieving this result required the development of a number of new experimental systems and major upgrades to the stability and reliability of the experiment, the details of which are also given. The thesis also presents theoretical work into the use of two-dimensional Coulomb crystals in a Penning trap as a resource for quantum information. Using the symmetries of the crystal, we find that it is possible to engineer complex entangled states, specifically two small quantum error correcting codes, using a very small number of global entangling pulses. Efficient entanglement protocols such as these are vital for the implementation of useful quantum error correction.
From subatomic particles to macromolecules, quantum mechanics has a deep impact in understanding the interactions and nature of such constituents of matter. The paradoxical observations of entanglement in quantum systems is used in quantum computations. Ion traps are among the leading platforms which provide clean and highly controllable quantum systems. This thesis presents the study of quantum coherence aiming to devise and test coherent control with trapped ions in a Penning trap. Our apparatus contains one or more calcium ions that are confined in space using DC electric and magnetic fields. Doppler cooling and resolved sideband cooling of trapped ions are carried out to perform high fidelity quantum control. The ions are prepared in their motional ground state via a multi-stage resolved sideband cooling technique. The cooling methods are first verified through simulations. The axial mean phonon numbers for a single ion are measured to be 0.03 ± 0.01 and 0.012 ± 0.009 at 187 kHz and 420 kHz axial frequencies, respectively. The heating rate is measured to be 2.5 ± 0.5 phonons/s, which is consistent with the previous measurements in our system. Similarly, the radial motional modes of a single ion are cooled to 〈n_+ 〉<0.4 and 〈n_- 〉<0.6 from mean phonon numbers corresponding to each mode of around 100. Preliminary studies are carried out of the axial motional modes of a 1D chain and 2D planar crystals, extending sideband cooling to small ICC's in a Penning trap. Coherent control is examined in our system and the optical coherence time and motional coherence time are estimated to be approximately 1 ms and 0.5 s, respectively. Furthermore, a single ion is prepared outside the Lamb-Dicke regime via a sideband heating technique and coherent studies are performed in such a regime via a laser beam.
We provide an introduction to the use of ion crystals in a Penning trap for experiments in quantum information. Macroscopic Penning traps allow for the containment of a few to a few million atomic ions whose internal states may be used in quantum information experiments. Ions are laser Doppler cooled, and the mutual Coulomb repulsion of the ions leads to the formation of crystalline arrays. The structure and dimensionality of the resulting ion crystals may be tuned using a combination of control laser beams and external potentials. We discuss the use of two-dimensional 9^{9}9Be+^{+}+ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations ($\tau_{\pi}\sim$200 μ\muμs). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized π/2\pi/2π/2 and π\piπ pulse pair) of 8±1×10−48\pm1\times10^{-4}8±1×10−4. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of $T_{2}\sim$2 ms, and a limiting $T_{1\rho}\sim$688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.
This thesis extends the recently reported ground state sideband cooling of the axial motion of a single ion to a broader frequency range of the axial motion, the radial motion and ion crystals. Once cold, coherent control of these different configurations is demonstrated. The experimental work in this thesis uses 40Ca+ ions that can be coherently addressed on a narrow linewidth optical transition at 729 nm. The technique of axialization that resonantly couples the two radial modes of motion is used to enhance laser Doppler cooling leading to mean phonon occupation numbers in the low hundreds for both modes. The sideband cooling technique is then used to simultaneously cool both the motional modes to within one phonon of the ground state for the first time evers. Sideband cooling is then also employed to cool the axial modes of many ion Coulomb crystals in two different configurations. For two ions in a 1D chain, motional occupation numbers of nbar_COM=0.30(4) and nbar_B=0.07(3) are achieved. For two ions in a planar 2D configuration the result for the two modes are nbar_T=nbar_COM<0.1. This technique is scaled up to demonstrate ground state occupation of up to 10 ions in the planar configuration. The axial mode of motion of a single motion is used to characterise the coherent addressing capabilities in our system through optical and motional Ramsey spectroscopy. We observe optical coherence times of 1.78(4) ms and motional coherence times of 590(12) ms. Dynamical decoupling techniques are shown to extend these coherence times. Furthermore, basic decoherence models are validated in high-lying non-thermal motional states that are prepared by a sideband heating technique. Progress towards entangling gates is demonstrated using a bichromatic laser beam to prepare non-classical states of motion.
This thesis presents work aimed towards achieving sideband cooling of 40Ca+ ions in a Penning trap. The observation of an increase in the number of quantum jumps as a function of the trapping magnetic field is first presented. This observation is explained by the ion falling into a long-lived D5/2 state, out of which the ion is not being re-pumped. The ion can fall into this state due to mixing of the fine structure components with the same mJ quantum number induced by the applied magnetic field. A calculation of the mixing and shelving rate as a function of magnetic field strength is presented. This theory matches well with the experimental results observed. This work has been presented in a publication in which a perturbative analysis was used. An alternative analysis is presented here in which the full Hamiltonian is diagonalised. The essential conclusions however remain unchanged. This ‘J-state mixing’ effect means re-pumping from each of the six D5/2 state sub-levels of our ion is required for efficient laser cooling. This is achieved by the addition of a system comprising an 854 nm laser and a fibre EOM to provide the radiation required to re-pump these levels. The same EOM is then used to re-pump out of the four sub-levels of the D3/2 state using a single 866 nm laser. This is a great simplification of the experimental setup required to cool a 40Ca+ ion in a Penning trap which would otherwise require ten separate lasers to independently address each of the D sub-states. Achieving efficient repumping leads to the ability to perform pulsed spectroscopy on the quadrupole S1/2 → D5/2 transition in 40Ca+ . Preliminary results of this spectroscopy in a radio-frequency trap are presented.
Optical sideband cooling is a well-established technique for preparing trapped ions in the ground state of one or more of their motional degrees of freedom. Up to now, this technique has mainly been applied in various types of radiofrequency trap. We show in this paper that the technique is also very effective in a Penning trap, and demonstrate that our trap has an exceptionally low heating rate, due to the large size of the Penning trap electrodes and the absence of large-amplitude radiofrequency fields in the trap.