Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Relativistic approach to the tunneling-time problem

Igor A. Ivanov, Kyung Taec Kim

Published Nov 12, 2015• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We report a study of the effect of relativity on the tunneling time for the process of the tunneling ionization. Our results indicate that the relativistic effects make the tunneling time nonzero. A time interval of a few attoseconds is required for the electron to traverse the barrier. This finding agrees with the basic postulate of the special relativity that two events which are in causal relationship cannot occur simultaneously.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.053418

Related papers

Tunneling Flight Time, Chemistry, and Special Relativity

Jakob Petersen, Eli Pollak

Attosecond ionization experiments have not resolved the question "What is the tunneling time?". Different definitions of tunneling time lead to different results. Second, a zero tunneling time for a material particle suggests that the nonrelativistic theory includes speeds greater than the speed of light. Chemical reactions, occurring via tunneling, should then not be considered in terms of a nonrelativistic quantum theory calling into question quantum dynamics computations on tunneling reactions. To answer these questions, we define a new experimentally measurable paradigm, the tunneling flight time, and show that it vanishes for scattering through an Eckart or a square barrier, irrespective of barrier length or height, generalizing the Hartman effect. We explain why this result does not lead to experimental measurement of speeds greater than the speed of light. We show that this tunneling is an incoherent process by comparing a classical Wigner theory with exact quantum mechanical computations.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Aug 9, 2017•26 citations

Universal Time Tunneling

Guenter Nimtz

How much time does a tunneling wave packet spent in traversing a barrier? Quantum mechanical calculations result in zero time inside a barrier . In the nineties analogous tunneling experiments with microwaves were carried out. The results agreed with quantum mechanical calculations. Electron tunneling time is hard to measure being extremely short and parasitic effects due to the electric charge of electrons may be dominant. However, quite recently the atomic ionization tunneling time has been measured. Experimental data of photonic, phononic, and electronic tunneling time is available now and will be presented. It appears that the tunneling time is a universal property independent of the field in question.

arXiv:0901.3968•Jan 26, 2009•1 citation

Tunneling in attosecond optical ionization and a dynamical time operator

M. Bauer

The conundrum parameter-operator of time in quantum mechanics, as well as the time-energy uncertainty relation and the tunneling delay time, have recently been addressed in attosecond optical ionization experiments. Dirac's formulation of the electron's relativistic quantum mechanics (RQM) allows the introduction of a dynamical self-adjoint time operator, representing an internal time of the system. Its relation to the parametric (laboratory) time is derived. Its relevance to the tunneling measurements in these experiments is exhibited, namely, as the time it takes the wave packet to cross the exit point of the barrier, thus justifying considering this time operator an additional observable in RQM.

arXiv:1608.03492•Physical Review A•Aug 29, 2017•17 citations

Tunneling Time, Exit Time and Exit Momentum in Strong Field Tunnel Ionization

Nicolas Teeny

Tunnel ionization belongs to the fundamental processes of atomic physics. It is still an open question when does the electron tunnel ionize and how long is the duration of tunneling. In this work we solve the time-dependent Schr{\\"o}dinger equation in one and two dimensions and use \\textit{ab initio} quantum calculations in order to answer these questions. Additionally, we determine the exit momentum of the tunnel ionized electron from first principles. We find out results that are different from the assumptions of the commonly employed two-step model, which assumes that the electron ionizes at the instant of electric field maximum with a zero momentum. After determining the quantum final momentum distribution of tunnel ionized electrons we show that the two-step model fails to predict the correct final momentum. Accordingly we suggest how to correct the two-step model. Furthermore, we determine the instant at which tunnel ionization starts, which turns out to be different from the instant usually assumed. From determining the instant at which it is most probable for the electron to enter the tunneling barrier and the instant at which it exits we determine the most probable time spent under the barrier. Moreover, we apply a quantum clock approach in order to determine the duration of tunnel ionization. From the quantum clock we determine an average tunneling time which is different in magnitude and origin with respect to the most probable tunneling time. By defining a probability distribution of tunneling times using virtual detectors we relate both methods and explain the apparent discrepancy. The results found have in general an effect on the interpretation of experiments that measure the spectra of tunnel ionized electrons, and specifically on the calibration of the so called attoclock experiments, because models with imprecise assumptions are usually employed in order to interpret experimental results.

•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation

Relativistic tunnelling time for electronic wave packets

Óscar del Barco, V. Gasparian

We have analyzed the influence of the wave packet size in the relativistic tunnelling time τ and its uncertainty �τ when it traverses a given potential barrier. The analytical expressions obtained for both magnitudes confirm that the size of the incident pulse has a significant effect on the tunnelling process. This effect is greater for short pulses, compared with the length of the barrier. For the evanescent zone, we have derived an analytical expression for τ with a good limit of validity. This expression constitutes a value tool to calculate the relativistic tunnelling time as a function of the incident wave packet with a good limit of validity. Superluminal propagation is found in this region but with a large value of the uncertainty �τ compared with the tunnelling time itself. We can conclude that the probability of superluminal propagation is practically negligible in the evanescent region. In respect to the Klein zone, we have derived an analytical expression for τ that depends on the size of the incident

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 30, 2010•6 citations

Relativistic quantum field theory approach to electron wave-packet tunneling: A fully causal process

M. Alkhateeb, X. Gutiérrez de la Cal, M. Ll. Pons +2 more

Recent results on electron tunneling across a potential barrier, inferred from observations or obtained from theoretical models, have suggested superluminal or instantaneous barrier traversal times. In this work we investigate relativistic wave-packet dynamics for an electron tunneling through a potential barrier employing space-time resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory (QFT) equations. We prove by linking the QFT property of microcausality to the wave-packet behavior that the tunneling dynamics is fully causal, precluding instantaneous or superluminal effects. We illustrate these results by performing numerical computations for an electron tunneling through a potential barrier for standard tunneling as well for Klein tunneling. In all cases (Klein tunneling or regular tunneling across a standard or a supercritical potential) the transmitted wave packet remains in the causal envelope of the propagator, even when its average position lies ahead of the average position of the corresponding freely propagated wave packet.

arXiv:2407.07160•Physical Review A•Jan 29, 2025•8 citations
We report a study of the effect of relativity on the tunneling time for the process of the tunneling ionization. Our results indicate that the relativistic effects make the tunneling time nonzero. A time interval of a few attoseconds is required for the electron to traverse the barrier. This finding agrees with the basic postulate of the special relativity that two events which are in causal relationship cannot occur simultaneously.
Attosecond ionization experiments have not resolved the question "What is the tunneling time?". Different definitions of tunneling time lead to different results. Second, a zero tunneling time for a material particle suggests that the nonrelativistic theory includes speeds greater than the speed of light. Chemical reactions, occurring via tunneling, should then not be considered in terms of a nonrelativistic quantum theory calling into question quantum dynamics computations on tunneling reactions. To answer these questions, we define a new experimentally measurable paradigm, the tunneling flight time, and show that it vanishes for scattering through an Eckart or a square barrier, irrespective of barrier length or height, generalizing the Hartman effect. We explain why this result does not lead to experimental measurement of speeds greater than the speed of light. We show that this tunneling is an incoherent process by comparing a classical Wigner theory with exact quantum mechanical computations.
How much time does a tunneling wave packet spent in traversing a barrier? Quantum mechanical calculations result in zero time inside a barrier . In the nineties analogous tunneling experiments with microwaves were carried out. The results agreed with quantum mechanical calculations. Electron tunneling time is hard to measure being extremely short and parasitic effects due to the electric charge of electrons may be dominant. However, quite recently the atomic ionization tunneling time has been measured. Experimental data of photonic, phononic, and electronic tunneling time is available now and will be presented. It appears that the tunneling time is a universal property independent of the field in question.
The conundrum parameter-operator of time in quantum mechanics, as well as the time-energy uncertainty relation and the tunneling delay time, have recently been addressed in attosecond optical ionization experiments. Dirac's formulation of the electron's relativistic quantum mechanics (RQM) allows the introduction of a dynamical self-adjoint time operator, representing an internal time of the system. Its relation to the parametric (laboratory) time is derived. Its relevance to the tunneling measurements in these experiments is exhibited, namely, as the time it takes the wave packet to cross the exit point of the barrier, thus justifying considering this time operator an additional observable in RQM.
Tunnel ionization belongs to the fundamental processes of atomic physics. It is still an open question when does the electron tunnel ionize and how long is the duration of tunneling. In this work we solve the time-dependent Schr{\\"o}dinger equation in one and two dimensions and use \\textit{ab initio} quantum calculations in order to answer these questions. Additionally, we determine the exit momentum of the tunnel ionized electron from first principles. We find out results that are different from the assumptions of the commonly employed two-step model, which assumes that the electron ionizes at the instant of electric field maximum with a zero momentum. After determining the quantum final momentum distribution of tunnel ionized electrons we show that the two-step model fails to predict the correct final momentum. Accordingly we suggest how to correct the two-step model. Furthermore, we determine the instant at which tunnel ionization starts, which turns out to be different from the instant usually assumed. From determining the instant at which it is most probable for the electron to enter the tunneling barrier and the instant at which it exits we determine the most probable time spent under the barrier. Moreover, we apply a quantum clock approach in order to determine the duration of tunnel ionization. From the quantum clock we determine an average tunneling time which is different in magnitude and origin with respect to the most probable tunneling time. By defining a probability distribution of tunneling times using virtual detectors we relate both methods and explain the apparent discrepancy. The results found have in general an effect on the interpretation of experiments that measure the spectra of tunnel ionized electrons, and specifically on the calibration of the so called attoclock experiments, because models with imprecise assumptions are usually employed in order to interpret experimental results.
We have analyzed the influence of the wave packet size in the relativistic tunnelling time τ and its uncertainty �τ when it traverses a given potential barrier. The analytical expressions obtained for both magnitudes confirm that the size of the incident pulse has a significant effect on the tunnelling process. This effect is greater for short pulses, compared with the length of the barrier. For the evanescent zone, we have derived an analytical expression for τ with a good limit of validity. This expression constitutes a value tool to calculate the relativistic tunnelling time as a function of the incident wave packet with a good limit of validity. Superluminal propagation is found in this region but with a large value of the uncertainty �τ compared with the tunnelling time itself. We can conclude that the probability of superluminal propagation is practically negligible in the evanescent region. In respect to the Klein zone, we have derived an analytical expression for τ that depends on the size of the incident
Recent results on electron tunneling across a potential barrier, inferred from observations or obtained from theoretical models, have suggested superluminal or instantaneous barrier traversal times. In this work we investigate relativistic wave-packet dynamics for an electron tunneling through a potential barrier employing space-time resolved solutions to relativistic quantum field theory (QFT) equations. We prove by linking the QFT property of microcausality to the wave-packet behavior that the tunneling dynamics is fully causal, precluding instantaneous or superluminal effects. We illustrate these results by performing numerical computations for an electron tunneling through a potential barrier for standard tunneling as well for Klein tunneling. In all cases (Klein tunneling or regular tunneling across a standard or a supercritical potential) the transmitted wave packet remains in the causal envelope of the propagator, even when its average position lies ahead of the average position of the corresponding freely propagated wave packet.