Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

No bridge across the quantum rift

Tony Leggett

Published Jul 1, 1993• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The last decade has seen a proliferation of books which attempt to explain the conceptual paradoxes of quantum mechanics in a non-technical way. This latest contribution, by David Albert, professor of philosophy at Columbia University, is brash, readable, provocative and at times breathtakingly naive and ill-informed. It will probably cause mild apoplexy, for both good reasons and bad, in a sizeable fraction of the professional quantum measurement community.

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/6/7/41

Related papers

Conclusions

George Jaroszkiewicz

In the Preface to this book, we started with Alice and Bob having very different views of their observations. Alice used an optical telescope and reported nothing unusual about a distant galaxy that she could see. Bob, on the other hand, detected intense radio activity in that galaxy. Our question was: who has the true view of that galaxy? We advised the reader that the answer is not Alice . Neither is it Bob . The answer is not both of them , nor is it neither of them . It is not a trick question either. So what is the answer that this book would supply? Our answer will come presently. While this book has set forth a definite mathematical perspective on empirical physics, it has contained quite a lot of commentary that might be disparaged as metaphysics or philosophy. Such commentary is generally frowned on in science, because it has no empirical content. It is vacuous. In our defense, we point out the obvious: science is not a robotic activity; it is carried out by humans and these are driven by their metaphysical, philosophical, and emotional imperatives. For instance, the hard-core scientific view that quantum theory needs no interpretation but only application is itself a philosophy. It is no more than a conditioned response, based on opinion and subscription to current scientific norms. It is, indeed, a philosophy of how to do quantum mechanics. So we all do it, in one way or another. Our concern in this book is that the way that we do it should be based soundly on scientific principles. The quantized detector approach that we describe and use in this book is our attempt to do just that. There is an excellent paper on all of this that has the provocative title “Quantum Theory Needs No Interpretation,” by Fuchs and Peres (2000). It seems on the face of it to dismiss any sort of “interpretation” of quantum mechanics. In fact, close reading of it confirms (to us at least) the agenda that we have set out in this book. Yes, quantum mechanics needs no interpretation, when it is being applied to processes that take place in the information void .

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2017•0 citations

Against “Paradoxes”: A New Quantum Philosophy for Quantum Mechanics

Claudio Garola

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1999•8 citations

The Probability Map of the Universe

Barry Loewer, Brad Weslake, Eric Winsberg

David Albert’s 2000 book Time and Chance attempts to account for some of the most intractable problems in theoretical physics, in particular those arising from the direction of time. This collection assembles essays exploring and debating Albert’s ideas, now recognized as among the most important recent contributions to the philosophy of science.

Harvard University Press eBooks•Nov 9, 2022•15 citations

Collapse, Selection, and the Geometry of Information A Variational and Schrödinger Bridge Foundation for Quantum Measurement

Giro-Kai Hong

Collapse, Selection, and the Geometry of Information A Variational and Schrödinger Bridge Foundation for Quantum Measurement Quantum theory explains the evolution of possibilities with extraordinary precision, yet the emergence of definite outcomes remains conceptually unresolved. Why does one outcome appear rather than another? Decoherence explains the suppression of interference and the emergence of preferred bases, but not the mechanism by which multiplicity gives way to singularity. Collapse models introduce stochastic modifications of dynamics, yet the structural principle governing outcome selection remains obscure. Collapse, Selection, and the Geometry of Information proposes a new framework for approaching this longstanding problem. Drawing upon Schrödinger bridge theory, entropy-regularized optimal transport, concentration inequalities, and threshold phenomena in high-dimensional probability, the book develops a variational account of measurement in which selection emerges through constrained probabilistic evolution rather than through ad hoc dynamical interruption. At the center of the argument lies a simple but far-reaching shift in perspective: the measurement problem is reframed not primarily as a problem of collapse, but as a problem of selection. Within this framework, admissible measurement outcomes are represented as endpoint distributions connected by entropy-minimizing stochastic bridges. In the small-noise regime, concentration phenomena and large-deviation structure produce exponential stabilization of particular channels, yielding effective outcome definiteness without modification of unitary quantum evolution. The book integrates ideas from quantum foundations, stochastic processes, optimal transport, and information geometry into a unified conceptual architecture. Along the way, it explores the relation between decoherence and variational structure, the geometry of path space, threshold mechanisms in probabilistic systems, and the emergence of macroscopic stability from high-dimensional stochastic dynamics. Neither purely technical textbook nor purely philosophical meditation, this work occupies a rare middle ground: mathematically informed, conceptually ambitious, and written in continuous narrative prose accessible to advanced readers in physics, mathematics, and philosophy of science. Ultimately, the book argues that the transition from possibility to actuality may be inseparable from the geometry of probability itself.

•May 19, 2026•0 citations

Review of David Albert, Quantum Mechanics and Experience

Mauricio Suárez

Erkenntnis•Jan 1, 1994•1 citation

Strange world at a simple level

Colin Jack

David Lindley's book on interpretations of quantum theory won wide acclaim when it was first published in the US last year. Infuriatingly, the original Basic Books hardback remained almost unobtainable in Europe. I know of at least one major UK bookshop that has been trying to reorder it since last May, so this paperback edition is most welcome. Lindley does an excellent job of describing the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics in a way that is accessible to the layperson. He sets out to tell the tale in a logical rather than a historical order, yet we get a good flavour of the way in which the scientific consensus has progressed. We are also reminded how the prejudices of some of the main contributors, notably Einstein, Bohr and David Bohm, may have been just as influential as their scientific contributions.

Physics World•Apr 1, 1997•0 citations
The last decade has seen a proliferation of books which attempt to explain the conceptual paradoxes of quantum mechanics in a non-technical way. This latest contribution, by David Albert, professor of philosophy at Columbia University, is brash, readable, provocative and at times breathtakingly naive and ill-informed. It will probably cause mild apoplexy, for both good reasons and bad, in a sizeable fraction of the professional quantum measurement community.
In the Preface to this book, we started with Alice and Bob having very different views of their observations. Alice used an optical telescope and reported nothing unusual about a distant galaxy that she could see. Bob, on the other hand, detected intense radio activity in that galaxy. Our question was: who has the true view of that galaxy? We advised the reader that the answer is not Alice . Neither is it Bob . The answer is not both of them , nor is it neither of them . It is not a trick question either. So what is the answer that this book would supply? Our answer will come presently. While this book has set forth a definite mathematical perspective on empirical physics, it has contained quite a lot of commentary that might be disparaged as metaphysics or philosophy. Such commentary is generally frowned on in science, because it has no empirical content. It is vacuous. In our defense, we point out the obvious: science is not a robotic activity; it is carried out by humans and these are driven by their metaphysical, philosophical, and emotional imperatives. For instance, the hard-core scientific view that quantum theory needs no interpretation but only application is itself a philosophy. It is no more than a conditioned response, based on opinion and subscription to current scientific norms. It is, indeed, a philosophy of how to do quantum mechanics. So we all do it, in one way or another. Our concern in this book is that the way that we do it should be based soundly on scientific principles. The quantized detector approach that we describe and use in this book is our attempt to do just that. There is an excellent paper on all of this that has the provocative title “Quantum Theory Needs No Interpretation,” by Fuchs and Peres (2000). It seems on the face of it to dismiss any sort of “interpretation” of quantum mechanics. In fact, close reading of it confirms (to us at least) the agenda that we have set out in this book. Yes, quantum mechanics needs no interpretation, when it is being applied to processes that take place in the information void .
Collapse, Selection, and the Geometry of Information A Variational and Schrödinger Bridge Foundation for Quantum Measurement Quantum theory explains the evolution of possibilities with extraordinary precision, yet the emergence of definite outcomes remains conceptually unresolved. Why does one outcome appear rather than another? Decoherence explains the suppression of interference and the emergence of preferred bases, but not the mechanism by which multiplicity gives way to singularity. Collapse models introduce stochastic modifications of dynamics, yet the structural principle governing outcome selection remains obscure. Collapse, Selection, and the Geometry of Information proposes a new framework for approaching this longstanding problem. Drawing upon Schrödinger bridge theory, entropy-regularized optimal transport, concentration inequalities, and threshold phenomena in high-dimensional probability, the book develops a variational account of measurement in which selection emerges through constrained probabilistic evolution rather than through ad hoc dynamical interruption. At the center of the argument lies a simple but far-reaching shift in perspective: the measurement problem is reframed not primarily as a problem of collapse, but as a problem of selection. Within this framework, admissible measurement outcomes are represented as endpoint distributions connected by entropy-minimizing stochastic bridges. In the small-noise regime, concentration phenomena and large-deviation structure produce exponential stabilization of particular channels, yielding effective outcome definiteness without modification of unitary quantum evolution. The book integrates ideas from quantum foundations, stochastic processes, optimal transport, and information geometry into a unified conceptual architecture. Along the way, it explores the relation between decoherence and variational structure, the geometry of path space, threshold mechanisms in probabilistic systems, and the emergence of macroscopic stability from high-dimensional stochastic dynamics. Neither purely technical textbook nor purely philosophical meditation, this work occupies a rare middle ground: mathematically informed, conceptually ambitious, and written in continuous narrative prose accessible to advanced readers in physics, mathematics, and philosophy of science. Ultimately, the book argues that the transition from possibility to actuality may be inseparable from the geometry of probability itself.
David Lindley's book on interpretations of quantum theory won wide acclaim when it was first published in the US last year. Infuriatingly, the original Basic Books hardback remained almost unobtainable in Europe. I know of at least one major UK bookshop that has been trying to reorder it since last May, so this paperback edition is most welcome. Lindley does an excellent job of describing the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics in a way that is accessible to the layperson. He sets out to tell the tale in a logical rather than a historical order, yet we get a good flavour of the way in which the scientific consensus has progressed. We are also reminded how the prejudices of some of the main contributors, notably Einstein, Bohr and David Bohm, may have been just as influential as their scientific contributions.