Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics

The PBR theorem: Whose side is it on?

Yemima Ben‐Menahem

Published Dec 24, 2016• 22 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1016/j.shpsb.2016.11.004

Related papers

On the Nonreality of the PBR Theorem

Marcoen J. T. F. Cabbolet

arXiv:2211.15469•Foundations of Physics•Jun 1, 2023•5 citations

A Discussion on the Validity of the PBR Theorem

İnanç Şahin, Gazi Alumur

Foundations of Physics•Aug 1, 2025•0 citations

Alternative Experimental Protocol for a PBR-Like Theorem

Damien Miller

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Addendum to ‘On the Nonreality of the PBR Theorem’: Disproof by Generic Counterexample

Marcoen J. T. F. Cabbolet

arXiv:2402.15742•Foundations of Physics•Jul 6, 2024•2 citations

A no-go theorem for $Ψ-$anomic models under the restricted ontic indifference assumption

Aurélien Drezet

We address the question of whether a non-nomological (i.e., anomic) interpretation of the wavefunction is compatible with the quantum formalism. After clarifying the distinction between ontic, epistemic, nomic and anomic models we focus our attention on two famous no-go theorems due to Pusey, Barrett, and Rudolph (PBR) on the one side and Hardy on the other side which forbid the existence of anomic-epistemic models. Moreover, we demonstrate that the so called restricted ontic indifference introduced by Hardy induces new constraints. We show that after modifications the Hardy theorem actually rules out all anomic models of the wavefunction assuming only restricted ontic indifference and preparation independence.

arXiv:2105.06445•May 13, 2021•0 citations

Does the PBR theorem refute Bohmian mechanics

Shan Gao

The nature of the wave function has been a hot topic of debate since the early days of quantum mechanics. The recent PBR theorem proves that the wave function is ontic, representing the ontic state of a physical system or a concrete physical entity. On the other hand, Bohmian mechanics regards the wave function as not ontic but nomological, like a law of nature. This raises an interesting question: does the PBR theorem refute Bohmian mechanics? It seems widely thought that the ontic view and the nomological view are compatible, and thus the PBR theorem has no implications for Bohmian mechanics. In this paper, I argue that this is not the case. First, I point out that the nomological view and the ontic view are two different views of the wave function. This means that the result of the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are incompatible. Next, I argue that the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are nevertheless compatible, and the former does not refute the latter. The reason is that the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are based on different fundamental assumptions, and in particular, Bohmian mechanics rejects one key assumption of the ontological models framework on which the PBR theorem is based. Finally, I argue that the rejection of this assumption will bring to our attention a potential important issue of Bohmian mechanics.

•Nov 20, 2019•2 citations
A no-go theorem for Ψ−Ψ-Ψ−anomic models under the restricted ontic indifference assumption
We address the question of whether a non-nomological (i.e., anomic) interpretation of the wavefunction is compatible with the quantum formalism. After clarifying the distinction between ontic, epistemic, nomic and anomic models we focus our attention on two famous no-go theorems due to Pusey, Barrett, and Rudolph (PBR) on the one side and Hardy on the other side which forbid the existence of anomic-epistemic models. Moreover, we demonstrate that the so called restricted ontic indifference introduced by Hardy induces new constraints. We show that after modifications the Hardy theorem actually rules out all anomic models of the wavefunction assuming only restricted ontic indifference and preparation independence.
The nature of the wave function has been a hot topic of debate since the early days of quantum mechanics. The recent PBR theorem proves that the wave function is ontic, representing the ontic state of a physical system or a concrete physical entity. On the other hand, Bohmian mechanics regards the wave function as not ontic but nomological, like a law of nature. This raises an interesting question: does the PBR theorem refute Bohmian mechanics? It seems widely thought that the ontic view and the nomological view are compatible, and thus the PBR theorem has no implications for Bohmian mechanics. In this paper, I argue that this is not the case. First, I point out that the nomological view and the ontic view are two different views of the wave function. This means that the result of the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are incompatible. Next, I argue that the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are nevertheless compatible, and the former does not refute the latter. The reason is that the PBR theorem and Bohmian mechanics are based on different fundamental assumptions, and in particular, Bohmian mechanics rejects one key assumption of the ontological models framework on which the PBR theorem is based. Finally, I argue that the rejection of this assumption will bring to our attention a potential important issue of Bohmian mechanics.