Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Tbe Tbird Storm of the Twentietb Century

O. Costa de Beauregard

Published Jan 1, 1978• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A paradox, according to dictionaries, is a surprising but perhaps true statement. Copernicus's heliocentrism was once a paradox. The problem with a true paradox is not in reducing it but in expressing it--as Einstein did with his relativity theory expressing the physical content of the Lorentz-Poincare' formulas of electrodynamics. Today again we have good formulas, those of quantum mechanics, but have not yet understood all their meaning. It is the paradox uncovered by Einstein at the 1927 Solvay Conference (and better known as the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen [E.P.R.) paradox) which forces us to a dramatic revision of traditional ways of thinking about time. The paradox emerges with special clarity from a conceptual experiment in which two spatially separated systems on the quantum scale are made to interact, but the only causal link between them is by way of an event in their common past. The paradox can be expressed in terms of the formal (de jure) symmetry between retarded and advanced interactions in physical theory, interactions which affect the future and the past respectively, independently of the de facta preponderance in nature of retarded interactions. The possibility that advanced interactions may occur de facta in large-scale systems is briefly discussed. * Lecture delivered at the Third Conference of the International Society for the Study of Time, Alpbach, July 1-10 (1976).

Related papers

The Bell inequalities: Commentary on the Nobel Prize in Physics 2022

Hong-Yi Su, Jing‐Ling Chen

The Nobel Prize in Physics 2022 was awarded to three experiment physicists: Alain Aspect, John F. Clauser and Anton Zeilinger, for their contributions to “experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell inequalities and pioneering quantum information science”. In this paper, the history, basics, and applications related with the Bell inequalities are reviewed. The discussion of fundamental issues on quantum mechanics dated back to the year 1927 when the fifth Solvay conference was held, highlighting intense arguments between Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr. At the time, Einstein expressed, publicly for the first time, his critical attitude towards quantum mechanics. While the arguments did not reach a decisive conclusion, Bohr’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation, had since been well circulated among the community. Einstein’s arguments with Bohr lasted many years after the conference. The arguably most famous one was the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, proposed in a 1935 paper written by the three authors. They stated, by flawless reasoning, that quantum mechanics is ‘incomplete’. Bohr replied immediately. So did Erwin Schrödinger, who, in particular, coined the term ‘entangled’ for the first time to describe the bizarre quantum mechanical property. Nevertheless, the EPR paper received few citations at its publication, until 1990’s when quantum information science started blossoming. From today’s perspective, the paper resembles the ‘sleeping beauty’ who slumbered for decades before fully awakening. It has been widely accepted that it was John S. Bell who eventually resolved the EPR paradox. But many important figures before him should not go unnoticed, including John A. Wheeler, Chien-Shiung Wu, David Bohm, to name a few. In 1964, Bell wrote down a mathematical inequality which satisfies local hidden variable theory but which can be violated in quantum mechanics. The significance is that Bell’s inequality brings the rather philosophic debates on the EPR paradox down to be experimentally testable. Hence, an experiment is here appealing, as is the case in all fields of physics. To the end, John F. Clauser, alongside Stuart J. Freedman, conducted an experiment in 1972 to test a Bell inequality, the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality, proposed by him and his collaborators in 1969. The results, however, leaves loopholes open. One of the loopholes was closed in a later experiment led by Alain Aspect in 1982. The Bell-CHSH inequality was later tested under a much stricter condition by Anton Zeilinger’s team. Two most important loopholes were both closed by three teams in 2015 independently. Zeilinger’s team was among them. Almost all experiments to date have confirmed quantum mechanical predictions. Zeilinger’s team also performed the first teleportation of unknown quantum states, the first entanglement swapping, along with other contributions pioneering the quantum information science. In retrospect, the foundational study of quantum theory has been developed over a century. It once drew much of quantum physics founders’ attention, went virtually unnoticed while other physical fields advanced, had for quite a while been considered to have very weak relationship with major physics, and finally revived in recent decades leading to rapid progress in quantum information science and quantum technology. We believe that the Nobel Prize in Physics this year is not only an award and recognition to past achievements, but also heralds a new era of science in future.

Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)•Oct 26, 2022•2 citations

The Bohr—Einstein confrontation: phenomena and physical reality

Sandro Petruccioli

As Quine wrote in 1961, what strikes us in a paradox is its initial air of absurdity, which develops into a sort of psychological discomfort when we compare the conclusions of the reasoning with the apparently irrefutable arguments on which it is based. However, as he went on to observe, ‘More than once in history the discovery of paradox has been the occasion for major reconstruction at the foundations of thought’. Catastrophe may therefore lurk even in the most innocent-seeming of paradoxes and force us to recognize the arbitrary nature ‘of a buried premise or of some preconception previously reckoned as central to physical theory, to mathematics or to the thinking process’. More recently, ideas of this kind have been used to assert in general that the role of paradox in the growth of knowledge is to generate category switches and to construct new universes of discourse. It could also be argued that paradoxes constitute elements of the logic of discovery capable of amplifying and thus making intelligible the still obscure phases accompanying paradigm shifts. Paradoxes would thus represent points of accumulation for the tension created between a given system of conceptual representation and a theory or empirical discovery that violates it. Historians of science have tried different interpretative approaches in their attempts to unravel the thought process that was to lead Einstein in 1905 to the formulation of special relativity and the simultaneous demolition of the classical conception of space and time.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 18, 1993•0 citations

Resolving a paradox

P. J. Bussey

There are few topics in physics that have excited so many different contrary opinions as Einstein’s so-called ‘Twin Paradox’, otherwise known as the ‘Clock Paradox’. It arises as an apparent conseq...

Contemporary Physics•Oct 2, 2021•0 citations

Negative Time Reconnaissance - Observing and Preventing Aggressive Acts Before they Occur

Allan Goff, Dale Lehmann, Joel Siegel

In previous work, the authors have shown that collapse in quantum mechanics can be made consistent with relativity and that at least abstract quantum systems can support paradox-free backwards-in-time causality. This paper considers the challenges in implementing Negative Time Reconnaissance (NTR). The holy grail of reconnaissance has been real time reconnaissance, reducing the time between an event and our acquisition of it to zero. NTR is the technical capability to witness an adversary’s actions literally before they do them. The conceptual design of a machine with the capability to send short digital messages backwards in time by perhaps as much as six hours is presented and analyzed. In classical physics, the paradigm is that the present is an infinitely thin interface between the past and the future. In the quantum systems studied that can support backwards-in-time causality, this paradigm is modified. The present has a temporal “thickness”, the future transitions into the past in a malleable way. While not time travel in the science fiction sense, it does appear that a window can be set up in the immediate future in which the present consists of unresolved pasts and futures. The width of the window is a function of technical maturity, not of physics. Put colloquially, in a classical reality the future hasn’t happened yet while in a quantum reality neither has the present. The bottom line is that if this property of abstract quantum systems is also true of quantum mechanics, then it should be possible to construct a device that could be used to observe and possibly prevent acts of aggression before they occur.

AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit (JPC)•Jul 9, 2006•6 citations

La théorie de la relativité cognitive et systémique

Richard Vitrac

La relativité d'Einstein est née en 1905 pour répondre aux paradoxes posés par l'invariance de la vitesse c de la lumière. Ces paradoxes concernent la dilatation des durées et la contraction des temps observés pour des événements ayant lieu dans un référentiel en mouvement par rapport à un Observateur. La relativité postule que c'est l’interaction entre l'Observateur et l'objet observé qui est la cause des paradoxes. Mais elle ne fait aucune hypothèse concernant la nature de l'Observateur. Or celui qui observe un phénomène n'est jamais un point mais c'est un système ayant une frontière et qui est piloté comme la conscience humaine pilote le corps humain. L'interprétation cognitive et systémique de l'invariance de la vitesse de la lumière permet de prouver l'existence d'un Observateur Universel présent en un point intérieur à tous les systèmes physiques et analogue à la conscience humaine. Contrairement aux systèmes physiques, l'Observateur ne serait pas soumis à la causalité temporelle. Par sa présence inspatiotemporelle à l'intérieur de tous les systèmes, cet Observateur imposerait la valeur des constantes de l'univers, vitesse de la lumière et constante de Planck en particulier. Cette hypothèse raisonnable permet de donner une représentation nouvelle de l'Univers qui serait un multivers composé de tous les univers qui correspondent à tous les systèmes de l'Univers. Elle permettrait aussi de donner une représentation nouvelle de la lumière qui serait constituée de photons qui naîtraient du néant pour y retourner selon un rythme donné. Il y aurait un photon primordial analogue au bit de l'informatique. Il serait le constituant unique de tous les systèmes de l'univers. Cette approche cognitive et systémique de la relativité devrait permet de rapprocher les deux théories de la relativité et de la mécanique quantique. A terme, elle devrait même rapprocher les sciences physiques et les sciences humaines.

Acta Europeana Systemica•Jul 11, 2020•1 citation

EPR Paradox and the Physical Meaning of an Experiment in Quantum Mechanics

Vesselin Noninski

It is shown that there is one purely deterministic outcome when measurement is made on the state function chosen by EPR to describe the combined two-particle system – the distance between the two particles is preserved the same. Further, it is shown that, surprisingly, the Ψ-function designed according to QM leads to the following paradox – despite the fact that the two particles move in opposite directions, in time the distance between them becomes shorter and shorter. As is known, Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) [1] observe two particles which have interacted in the past (for 0 Tt< <) but the interaction between them has ceased for times Tt>. Nevertheless, both particles, even at times Tt> EPR consider to be described by one common state-function, namely 1 2 ( ,)x xΨ. The authors have chosen to explore one particular form of that state-function, namely ( ) 1 2 01 2 (), i x x x pdpex x − −Ψ = ∫ =. (1) This function may be rewritten as ( ) 2 0 11 2 (), i ix x p x pdpe ex x − +Ψ = ∫ = = (2) and then 1 i x p e = can be considered as the orthonormal basis of an observable A pertaining to particle 1 (position of particle 1) while the exponents

•Feb 1, 2003•0 citations
A paradox, according to dictionaries, is a surprising but perhaps true statement. Copernicus's heliocentrism was once a paradox. The problem with a true paradox is not in reducing it but in expressing it--as Einstein did with his relativity theory expressing the physical content of the Lorentz-Poincare' formulas of electrodynamics. Today again we have good formulas, those of quantum mechanics, but have not yet understood all their meaning. It is the paradox uncovered by Einstein at the 1927 Solvay Conference (and better known as the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen [E.P.R.) paradox) which forces us to a dramatic revision of traditional ways of thinking about time. The paradox emerges with special clarity from a conceptual experiment in which two spatially separated systems on the quantum scale are made to interact, but the only causal link between them is by way of an event in their common past. The paradox can be expressed in terms of the formal (de jure) symmetry between retarded and advanced interactions in physical theory, interactions which affect the future and the past respectively, independently of the de facta preponderance in nature of retarded interactions. The possibility that advanced interactions may occur de facta in large-scale systems is briefly discussed. * Lecture delivered at the Third Conference of the International Society for the Study of Time, Alpbach, July 1-10 (1976).
The Nobel Prize in Physics 2022 was awarded to three experiment physicists: Alain Aspect, John F. Clauser and Anton Zeilinger, for their contributions to “experiments with entangled photons, establishing the violation of Bell inequalities and pioneering quantum information science”. In this paper, the history, basics, and applications related with the Bell inequalities are reviewed. The discussion of fundamental issues on quantum mechanics dated back to the year 1927 when the fifth Solvay conference was held, highlighting intense arguments between Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr. At the time, Einstein expressed, publicly for the first time, his critical attitude towards quantum mechanics. While the arguments did not reach a decisive conclusion, Bohr’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation, had since been well circulated among the community. Einstein’s arguments with Bohr lasted many years after the conference. The arguably most famous one was the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox, proposed in a 1935 paper written by the three authors. They stated, by flawless reasoning, that quantum mechanics is ‘incomplete’. Bohr replied immediately. So did Erwin Schrödinger, who, in particular, coined the term ‘entangled’ for the first time to describe the bizarre quantum mechanical property. Nevertheless, the EPR paper received few citations at its publication, until 1990’s when quantum information science started blossoming. From today’s perspective, the paper resembles the ‘sleeping beauty’ who slumbered for decades before fully awakening. It has been widely accepted that it was John S. Bell who eventually resolved the EPR paradox. But many important figures before him should not go unnoticed, including John A. Wheeler, Chien-Shiung Wu, David Bohm, to name a few. In 1964, Bell wrote down a mathematical inequality which satisfies local hidden variable theory but which can be violated in quantum mechanics. The significance is that Bell’s inequality brings the rather philosophic debates on the EPR paradox down to be experimentally testable. Hence, an experiment is here appealing, as is the case in all fields of physics. To the end, John F. Clauser, alongside Stuart J. Freedman, conducted an experiment in 1972 to test a Bell inequality, the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality, proposed by him and his collaborators in 1969. The results, however, leaves loopholes open. One of the loopholes was closed in a later experiment led by Alain Aspect in 1982. The Bell-CHSH inequality was later tested under a much stricter condition by Anton Zeilinger’s team. Two most important loopholes were both closed by three teams in 2015 independently. Zeilinger’s team was among them. Almost all experiments to date have confirmed quantum mechanical predictions. Zeilinger’s team also performed the first teleportation of unknown quantum states, the first entanglement swapping, along with other contributions pioneering the quantum information science. In retrospect, the foundational study of quantum theory has been developed over a century. It once drew much of quantum physics founders’ attention, went virtually unnoticed while other physical fields advanced, had for quite a while been considered to have very weak relationship with major physics, and finally revived in recent decades leading to rapid progress in quantum information science and quantum technology. We believe that the Nobel Prize in Physics this year is not only an award and recognition to past achievements, but also heralds a new era of science in future.
As Quine wrote in 1961, what strikes us in a paradox is its initial air of absurdity, which develops into a sort of psychological discomfort when we compare the conclusions of the reasoning with the apparently irrefutable arguments on which it is based. However, as he went on to observe, ‘More than once in history the discovery of paradox has been the occasion for major reconstruction at the foundations of thought’. Catastrophe may therefore lurk even in the most innocent-seeming of paradoxes and force us to recognize the arbitrary nature ‘of a buried premise or of some preconception previously reckoned as central to physical theory, to mathematics or to the thinking process’. More recently, ideas of this kind have been used to assert in general that the role of paradox in the growth of knowledge is to generate category switches and to construct new universes of discourse. It could also be argued that paradoxes constitute elements of the logic of discovery capable of amplifying and thus making intelligible the still obscure phases accompanying paradigm shifts. Paradoxes would thus represent points of accumulation for the tension created between a given system of conceptual representation and a theory or empirical discovery that violates it. Historians of science have tried different interpretative approaches in their attempts to unravel the thought process that was to lead Einstein in 1905 to the formulation of special relativity and the simultaneous demolition of the classical conception of space and time.
In previous work, the authors have shown that collapse in quantum mechanics can be made consistent with relativity and that at least abstract quantum systems can support paradox-free backwards-in-time causality. This paper considers the challenges in implementing Negative Time Reconnaissance (NTR). The holy grail of reconnaissance has been real time reconnaissance, reducing the time between an event and our acquisition of it to zero. NTR is the technical capability to witness an adversary’s actions literally before they do them. The conceptual design of a machine with the capability to send short digital messages backwards in time by perhaps as much as six hours is presented and analyzed. In classical physics, the paradigm is that the present is an infinitely thin interface between the past and the future. In the quantum systems studied that can support backwards-in-time causality, this paradigm is modified. The present has a temporal “thickness”, the future transitions into the past in a malleable way. While not time travel in the science fiction sense, it does appear that a window can be set up in the immediate future in which the present consists of unresolved pasts and futures. The width of the window is a function of technical maturity, not of physics. Put colloquially, in a classical reality the future hasn’t happened yet while in a quantum reality neither has the present. The bottom line is that if this property of abstract quantum systems is also true of quantum mechanics, then it should be possible to construct a device that could be used to observe and possibly prevent acts of aggression before they occur.
La relativité d'Einstein est née en 1905 pour répondre aux paradoxes posés par l'invariance de la vitesse c de la lumière. Ces paradoxes concernent la dilatation des durées et la contraction des temps observés pour des événements ayant lieu dans un référentiel en mouvement par rapport à un Observateur. La relativité postule que c'est l’interaction entre l'Observateur et l'objet observé qui est la cause des paradoxes. Mais elle ne fait aucune hypothèse concernant la nature de l'Observateur. Or celui qui observe un phénomène n'est jamais un point mais c'est un système ayant une frontière et qui est piloté comme la conscience humaine pilote le corps humain. L'interprétation cognitive et systémique de l'invariance de la vitesse de la lumière permet de prouver l'existence d'un Observateur Universel présent en un point intérieur à tous les systèmes physiques et analogue à la conscience humaine. Contrairement aux systèmes physiques, l'Observateur ne serait pas soumis à la causalité temporelle. Par sa présence inspatiotemporelle à l'intérieur de tous les systèmes, cet Observateur imposerait la valeur des constantes de l'univers, vitesse de la lumière et constante de Planck en particulier. Cette hypothèse raisonnable permet de donner une représentation nouvelle de l'Univers qui serait un multivers composé de tous les univers qui correspondent à tous les systèmes de l'Univers. Elle permettrait aussi de donner une représentation nouvelle de la lumière qui serait constituée de photons qui naîtraient du néant pour y retourner selon un rythme donné. Il y aurait un photon primordial analogue au bit de l'informatique. Il serait le constituant unique de tous les systèmes de l'univers. Cette approche cognitive et systémique de la relativité devrait permet de rapprocher les deux théories de la relativité et de la mécanique quantique. A terme, elle devrait même rapprocher les sciences physiques et les sciences humaines.
It is shown that there is one purely deterministic outcome when measurement is made on the state function chosen by EPR to describe the combined two-particle system – the distance between the two particles is preserved the same. Further, it is shown that, surprisingly, the Ψ-function designed according to QM leads to the following paradox – despite the fact that the two particles move in opposite directions, in time the distance between them becomes shorter and shorter. As is known, Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) [1] observe two particles which have interacted in the past (for 0 Tt< <) but the interaction between them has ceased for times Tt>. Nevertheless, both particles, even at times Tt> EPR consider to be described by one common state-function, namely 1 2 ( ,)x xΨ. The authors have chosen to explore one particular form of that state-function, namely ( ) 1 2 01 2 (), i x x x pdpex x − −Ψ = ∫ =. (1) This function may be rewritten as ( ) 2 0 11 2 (), i ix x p x pdpe ex x − +Ψ = ∫ = = (2) and then 1 i x p e = can be considered as the orthonormal basis of an observable A pertaining to particle 1 (position of particle 1) while the exponents