Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Incomplete Theories and Other Intellectual Dishonesties

Daniel Joseph Dady, Nikola Tesla, Mahátma Gándhí

Published Jan 1, 2014• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

There has been, for nearly a century, an intellectually dishonest academical argument perpetuating in the annals of universities worldwide that we must accept, as fact, that there are two incomplete and incompat- ible theories that govern the physical laws of nature and that we must accept both theories as indisputable facts. The two theories are Albert Einstein's Theories of Relativity and the collective theories of Quantum Mechanics which relies heavily on statistical deter- mination as its formal basis. Both of these theories provide accurate predictions for their respective do- mains, relativistic theories bode well with very large scales, at the stellar level, while quantum theories are favored for the very small, at the atomic level.

Related papers

Simplifying the equations of relativistic quantum mechanics

Luis Grave de Peralta

I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic

Research Features•Jan 1, 2023•0 citations

Theory of Relativity or Quantum Mechanics

Valentin Malinov

Why scientists stating that the Theory of Relativity and Quantum Mechanics they are not compatible, and one of them probably is wrong?

•Dec 1, 2020•0 citations

Could we now convince Einstein?

Luigi Accardi

The present conference takes place in the same year that celebrates the centenary of Albert Einstein. Hence it is a good occasion to reflect on those problems which have been at the core of Einstein’s intellectual activity. Undoubtedly the foundation of quantum mechanics (QM) is one of these problems. It is known that Einstein was never convinced by the interpretation of quantum mechanics accepted, in his times and still now, by the majority of physicists. The fact that he was sharing this skepticism with people like Schrödinger and, most of all, the fact that no convincing answer, to the doubts of these people, had emerged in a more than half a century old debate, helped in keeping alive the attention of a growing number of people on this problem.The crucial issue is that the standard interpretation of QM has some physical implications which are experimentally verifiable and which, for several years, have been thought to be incompatible with relativity theory (the so‐called “quantum nonlocality”). On the other hand alternative, more intuitive, interpretations (such as the ensemble interpretation) seemed to be ruled out from very well confirmed experimental data.The way out from this impasse has required a deep analysis of the connections between mathematics and physics as well as the emergence of new ideas both in mathematics (non‐Kolmogorovian probabilities) and in physics (the theory of adaptive systems).The Einstein centenary is a good occasion for a short survey of these developments with the goal of answering the intriguing question posed in the title of the present paper.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•12 citations

Are Quantum Mechanics and Relativity Theory Consistent?

Eugene Paul Wigner

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1997•2 citations

The Legacy of Einstein and Bohr

Mendel Sachs

th century ‐ the theory of relativity and the quantum theory. Based on these developments, it is interesting for the future of physics that when examined in terms of their conceptual and mathematical bases, these theories are incompatible. On the other hand, each of these theories requires an incorporation of the other to proceed toward its completion. This is the dilemma we face in these early decades of the 21 st century: Which of the two theories should be abandoned and which should be maintained?[1] Albert Einstein was the leading proponent of the theory of relativity and its philosophy, Niels Bohr was the leading proponent of the quantum theory and its philosophy ‐ as fundamental theories of matter.[2] Because of the incompatibility of the mathematical and conceptual bases of these theories, in fundamental terms, as will be discussed in detail later on, they cannot peacefully coexist. But because aspects of each of these theories are necessary to complete the other, the form of the accepted theory must be generalized in such a way that it yields, as a mathematical approximation, the form of the theory whose concepts are abandoned. This is an appeal to the wellknown principle of correspondence. Bohr appealed to this principle in showing how the formal expression of quantum mechanics goes smoothly into the structure of classical mechanics as the fundamental unit of action ‐ Planck’s constant h ‐ approaches zero, compared with the values of classical action. Similarly, the principle of correspondence reveals how Einstein’s relativistic mechanics goes smoothly

Annales de la fondation Louis de Broglie/Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie•Jan 1, 2006•1 citation

The breakdown of a theory and the efforts to describe nature

George Kuttiparichel Varghese

Quantum theory and the general theory of relativity are the two celebrated discoveries of the twentieth century. The theory of gravity breaks down at Big Bang-the possible starting phase of the universe. Quantum theory is able to work in lower regimes of dimensions. If the predictions of quantum theory are correct, then it could provide a complete description of nature. Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox implies that if local realism is accepted quantum theory is incomplete. The article is organized around the following questions: are the laws of Physics eternal truths? Is it possible to quantize gravity using a theory, which has inherent problems in its basic postulates? How could we speak of the properties of the universe while being part of it? Does nature want to hide her truths from us?.

IEEE International Symposium on Technology and Society (ISTAS)•Nov 11, 2002•0 citations
There has been, for nearly a century, an intellectually dishonest academical argument perpetuating in the annals of universities worldwide that we must accept, as fact, that there are two incomplete and incompat- ible theories that govern the physical laws of nature and that we must accept both theories as indisputable facts. The two theories are Albert Einstein's Theories of Relativity and the collective theories of Quantum Mechanics which relies heavily on statistical deter- mination as its formal basis. Both of these theories provide accurate predictions for their respective do- mains, relativistic theories bode well with very large scales, at the stellar level, while quantum theories are favored for the very small, at the atomic level.
I n the early 20th century, the groundbreaking theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity emerged at roughly the same time.At first, both theories appeared to be entirely incompatible with each other.While the quantum equations written out by Erwin Schrödinger and Wolfgang Pauli dealt with the behaviours of electrons, atoms, and molecules moving at speeds encountered in classical physics, the rules of special relativity first imagined by Albert Einstein described the behaviour of matter moving at close to the speed of light.Initially, this apparent clash of theories presented a crisis in physics.However, in the late 1920s, further theoretical work carried out by physicists including Paul Dirac, Oskar Klein, and Walter Gordon culminated in a new set of equations, which proved definitively that quantum mechanics and special relativity are compatible with each other after all. An educational challengeYet with this groundbreaking discovery came an entirely new problem.In adding a new layer of complexity to the equations of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the more complete theories of relativistic
The present conference takes place in the same year that celebrates the centenary of Albert Einstein. Hence it is a good occasion to reflect on those problems which have been at the core of Einstein’s intellectual activity. Undoubtedly the foundation of quantum mechanics (QM) is one of these problems. It is known that Einstein was never convinced by the interpretation of quantum mechanics accepted, in his times and still now, by the majority of physicists. The fact that he was sharing this skepticism with people like Schrödinger and, most of all, the fact that no convincing answer, to the doubts of these people, had emerged in a more than half a century old debate, helped in keeping alive the attention of a growing number of people on this problem.The crucial issue is that the standard interpretation of QM has some physical implications which are experimentally verifiable and which, for several years, have been thought to be incompatible with relativity theory (the so‐called “quantum nonlocality”). On the other hand alternative, more intuitive, interpretations (such as the ensemble interpretation) seemed to be ruled out from very well confirmed experimental data.The way out from this impasse has required a deep analysis of the connections between mathematics and physics as well as the emergence of new ideas both in mathematics (non‐Kolmogorovian probabilities) and in physics (the theory of adaptive systems).The Einstein centenary is a good occasion for a short survey of these developments with the goal of answering the intriguing question posed in the title of the present paper.
th century ‐ the theory of relativity and the quantum theory. Based on these developments, it is interesting for the future of physics that when examined in terms of their conceptual and mathematical bases, these theories are incompatible. On the other hand, each of these theories requires an incorporation of the other to proceed toward its completion. This is the dilemma we face in these early decades of the 21 st century: Which of the two theories should be abandoned and which should be maintained?[1] Albert Einstein was the leading proponent of the theory of relativity and its philosophy, Niels Bohr was the leading proponent of the quantum theory and its philosophy ‐ as fundamental theories of matter.[2] Because of the incompatibility of the mathematical and conceptual bases of these theories, in fundamental terms, as will be discussed in detail later on, they cannot peacefully coexist. But because aspects of each of these theories are necessary to complete the other, the form of the accepted theory must be generalized in such a way that it yields, as a mathematical approximation, the form of the theory whose concepts are abandoned. This is an appeal to the wellknown principle of correspondence. Bohr appealed to this principle in showing how the formal expression of quantum mechanics goes smoothly into the structure of classical mechanics as the fundamental unit of action ‐ Planck’s constant h ‐ approaches zero, compared with the values of classical action. Similarly, the principle of correspondence reveals how Einstein’s relativistic mechanics goes smoothly
Quantum theory and the general theory of relativity are the two celebrated discoveries of the twentieth century. The theory of gravity breaks down at Big Bang-the possible starting phase of the universe. Quantum theory is able to work in lower regimes of dimensions. If the predictions of quantum theory are correct, then it could provide a complete description of nature. Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox implies that if local realism is accepted quantum theory is incomplete. The article is organized around the following questions: are the laws of Physics eternal truths? Is it possible to quantize gravity using a theory, which has inherent problems in its basic postulates? How could we speak of the properties of the universe while being part of it? Does nature want to hide her truths from us?.