Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Measurement Theory Based on the Truth Values Violates Local Realism

Koji Nagata

Published Nov 7, 2016• 1 citation
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/s10773-016-3176-7

Related papers

Towards a Realist Theory of Measurement

Trevor W. Marshall

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1988•2 citations

Analysis of tests of local realism

Yanbao Zhang

Reliable and loophole-free demonstrations of the violation of local realism (LR) are highly desirable not only for understanding the foundation of quantum mechanics but also for facilitating quantum information processing, such as quantum key distribution and randomness expansion. To date, LR has been experimentally violated, but with loopholes, by testing predetermined Bell inequalities. This thesis presents a framework for verifying and quantifying the violation of LR without relying on a particular Bell inequality.\nFirst, the experimental resources, such as the quantum state, measurement settings, detection effciency, and visibility required for a violation of LR, are studied via a measure called the statistical strength. The higher the statistical strength, the more confidence in a violation of LR one has after a suffciently large number of experimental data. Particularly, we study the minimum detection effciency required to achieve any given statistical strength level in tests of LR with entangled states created from two independent polarized photons passing through a polarizing beam splitter. It is shown that, compared with photon detectors, photon counters make violations of LR easier to detect for any nonzero probability of multiple photons in an output beam of the polarizing beam splitter.\nSecond, to quantify the statistical evidence against LR obtained from a finite number of experimental data, one can choose a test statistic, such as a Bell-inequality violation, to measure the amount of violation of LR. It is desirable to bound the probability, according to LR, of obtaining a test statistic at least as extreme as that observed. This probability is known as a p-value for the hypothesis test of LR. We propose a protocol to bound such a p-value. The bound provided is asymptotically tight, if the prepared quantum state and measurement settings are stable during an experiment. Therefore, the proposed protocol is asymptotically optimal, and the bound provided is a standardized measure of success for experimental tests of LR. One can quantitatively compare different experimental tests based on this bound. Moreover, the bound provided is valid even if the quantum state varies arbitrarily and local realistic models depend on previous measurement settings and outcomes. Hence, this bound facilitates device-independent and nonlocality-based quantum information processing. For comparison, bounds of p-values derived from Bell-inequality violations using the number of standard deviations of violation of a Bell inequality or using martingale theory are studied. It is found that putative bounds derived from the number of standard deviations of violation are not valid and bounds from martingale theory are not tight.\nFinally, a simplified and effcient data analysis protocol using a set of Bell inequalities is proposed and compared with the above optimal and martingale-based protocols. The simplified protocol provides as good as and typically tighter p-value bounds than the martingale-based protocol, and the bounds provided can even be asymptotically tight. Moreover, the simplified protocol can be applied to any test with linear witnesses, such as tests for verifying entanglement, system dimensionality, or steering.

•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

The Measurement Problem and Wave Function Realism

Bloomsbury Publishing Plc eBooks•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Asymptotically optimal data analysis for rejecting local realism

Yanbao Zhang, Scott Glancy, Emanuel H. Knill

Reliable experimental demonstrations of violations of local realism are highly desirable for fundamental tests of quantum mechanics. One can quantify the violation witnessed by an experiment in terms of a statistical $p$ value, which can be defined as the maximum probability according to local realism of a violation at least as high as that witnessed. Thus, high violation corresponds to small $p$ value. We propose a prediction-based-ratio (PBR) analysis protocol whose $p$ values are valid even if the prepared quantum state varies arbitrarily and local realistic models can depend on previous measurement settings and outcomes. It is therefore not subject to the memory loophole [J. Barrett et al., Phys. Rev. A 66, 042111 (2002)]. If the prepared state does not vary in time, the $p$ values are asymptotically optimal. For comparison, we consider protocols derived from the number of standard deviations of violation of a Bell inequality and from martingale theory [R. Gill, e-print arXiv:quant-ph/0110137]. We find that the $p$ values of the former can be too small and are therefore not statistically valid, while those derived from the latter are suboptimal. PBR $p$ values do not require a predetermined Bell inequality and can be used to compare results from different tests of local realism independent of experimental details.

arXiv:1108.2468•Physical Review A•Dec 22, 2011•85 citations

A classical probability space exists for the measurement theory based on the truth values

Koji Nagata, Tadao Nakamura

Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Aug 4, 2016•0 citations

AN EXPERIMENTAL TEST OF NON-LOCAL REALISM AND THE THEORY OF OBJECTIVITY

Vidamor Cabannas

This article develops an expanded critical–propositional analysis of Simon Gröblacher et al.’s 2007 experiment, “An Experimental Test of Non-Local Realism”, published in Nature, in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Gröblacher et al. investigated whether abandoning locality is sufficient to preserve a particular form of physical realism in the face of quantum-mechanical correlations. Building upon A. J. Leggett’s class of crypto-nonlocal hidden-variable models, the experiment tested theories in which individual measurement outcomes arise from pre-existing properties, physical states consist of statistical mixtures of subensembles carrying definite polarizations, and the local averages of those subensembles obey Malus’ law. Using high-visibility polarization-entangled photon pairs generated through sponta- neous parametric down-conversion, Gröblacher et al. measured correlations in different planes of the Poincaré sphere and reported a violation of a generalized Leggett-type inequality. At a difference angle of 20◦ , the experiment yielded SNLHV = 3.8521 ± 0.0227, corresponding to a violation of approximately 3.2 standard deviations. The same data also gave SCHSH = 2.178 ± 0.0199, violating the local-realistic CHSH bound by approximately nine standard deviations (Gröblacher et al. 2007a). A subsequent corrigendum clarified the relevant experimental angle and other technical details while leaving the final inequality and scientific conclusions unchanged (Gröblacher et al. 2007b). The present analysis argues that these results must not be interpreted as an experimental refutation of objectivity, external reality, or realism in every conceivable sense. Instead, they constrain a particular class of realist ontologies in which maximally entangled systems can be decomposed into subensembles endowed with definite individual polarizations satisfying Malus’ law. This distinction is decisive for comparison with TO. Within TO, objectivity is grounded not in human observation but in modal conditions concerning elements, individual fields, boundaries, relations among elements, composition, and an informational or transcendent dimension. The Fifth Absolute Truth, in particular, defines observation non-anthropocentrically: an element acquires logical existence through relational inclusion within the observation or frequency of at least two other elements. The Seventh Absolute Truth identifies the transcendent element with knowledge or information generated in atomic relations and considers such information equivalent, within TO, to atomic radiation. The analysis identifies substantial conceptual compatibility between Gröblacher et al. and relational readings of the Second, Fourth, Fifth, and Seventh Absolute Truths. Quantum entanglement preserves operational distinguishability between subsystems while invalidating simple classical separability; experimental observation is physically imple- mented without requiring human consciousness; and experimentally relevant information resides crucially in correlations rather than solely in independently assigned classical properties. At the same time, the experiment imposes an important restriction upon any future operationalization of TO: an individual field, physical boundary, or objective existence cannot simply be identified with a catalogue of predetermined local polarization values of the Leggett type. If TO is to establish strong empirical contact with quantum physics, it must derive quantitative correlation functions that either reproduce existing quantum results or predict measurable deviations from them. The First Absolute Truth—the logically, mathematically, and eternally structured Nothingness preceding the universe—remains outside the empirical domain of Gröblacher’s laboratory test. The Third Absolute Truth, the TO cosmogonic theorem, the Inductive Effects, and the cosmological Eras are likewise not directly tested. Consequently, the experiment is classified here not as a proof of TO but as a case of indirect empirical corroboration of selected relational and non-anthropocentric features combined with a significant negative constraint on overly classical interpretations of objectivity. The article concludes that Gröblacher et al. merits a dialogue score of 8.3/10 in relation to TO and proposes a program for transforming the present interpretive convergence into genuine differential empirical tests. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; non-local realism; Leggett inequality; Bell theo- rem; quantum entanglement; objectivity; modal ontology; quantum information; non- anthropocentric observation; relationality; Gröblacher; quantum foundations.

•Sep 7, 2026•0 citations
Reliable and loophole-free demonstrations of the violation of local realism (LR) are highly desirable not only for understanding the foundation of quantum mechanics but also for facilitating quantum information processing, such as quantum key distribution and randomness expansion. To date, LR has been experimentally violated, but with loopholes, by testing predetermined Bell inequalities. This thesis presents a framework for verifying and quantifying the violation of LR without relying on a particular Bell inequality.\nFirst, the experimental resources, such as the quantum state, measurement settings, detection effciency, and visibility required for a violation of LR, are studied via a measure called the statistical strength. The higher the statistical strength, the more confidence in a violation of LR one has after a suffciently large number of experimental data. Particularly, we study the minimum detection effciency required to achieve any given statistical strength level in tests of LR with entangled states created from two independent polarized photons passing through a polarizing beam splitter. It is shown that, compared with photon detectors, photon counters make violations of LR easier to detect for any nonzero probability of multiple photons in an output beam of the polarizing beam splitter.\nSecond, to quantify the statistical evidence against LR obtained from a finite number of experimental data, one can choose a test statistic, such as a Bell-inequality violation, to measure the amount of violation of LR. It is desirable to bound the probability, according to LR, of obtaining a test statistic at least as extreme as that observed. This probability is known as a p-value for the hypothesis test of LR. We propose a protocol to bound such a p-value. The bound provided is asymptotically tight, if the prepared quantum state and measurement settings are stable during an experiment. Therefore, the proposed protocol is asymptotically optimal, and the bound provided is a standardized measure of success for experimental tests of LR. One can quantitatively compare different experimental tests based on this bound. Moreover, the bound provided is valid even if the quantum state varies arbitrarily and local realistic models depend on previous measurement settings and outcomes. Hence, this bound facilitates device-independent and nonlocality-based quantum information processing. For comparison, bounds of p-values derived from Bell-inequality violations using the number of standard deviations of violation of a Bell inequality or using martingale theory are studied. It is found that putative bounds derived from the number of standard deviations of violation are not valid and bounds from martingale theory are not tight.\nFinally, a simplified and effcient data analysis protocol using a set of Bell inequalities is proposed and compared with the above optimal and martingale-based protocols. The simplified protocol provides as good as and typically tighter p-value bounds than the martingale-based protocol, and the bounds provided can even be asymptotically tight. Moreover, the simplified protocol can be applied to any test with linear witnesses, such as tests for verifying entanglement, system dimensionality, or steering.
Reliable experimental demonstrations of violations of local realism are highly desirable for fundamental tests of quantum mechanics. One can quantify the violation witnessed by an experiment in terms of a statistical ppp value, which can be defined as the maximum probability according to local realism of a violation at least as high as that witnessed. Thus, high violation corresponds to small ppp value. We propose a prediction-based-ratio (PBR) analysis protocol whose ppp values are valid even if the prepared quantum state varies arbitrarily and local realistic models can depend on previous measurement settings and outcomes. It is therefore not subject to the memory loophole [J. Barrett et al., Phys. Rev. A 66, 042111 (2002)]. If the prepared state does not vary in time, the ppp values are asymptotically optimal. For comparison, we consider protocols derived from the number of standard deviations of violation of a Bell inequality and from martingale theory [R. Gill, e-print arXiv:quant-ph/0110137]. We find that the ppp values of the former can be too small and are therefore not statistically valid, while those derived from the latter are suboptimal. PBR ppp values do not require a predetermined Bell inequality and can be used to compare results from different tests of local realism independent of experimental details.
This article develops an expanded critical–propositional analysis of Simon Gröblacher et al.’s 2007 experiment, “An Experimental Test of Non-Local Realism”, published in Nature, in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Gröblacher et al. investigated whether abandoning locality is sufficient to preserve a particular form of physical realism in the face of quantum-mechanical correlations. Building upon A. J. Leggett’s class of crypto-nonlocal hidden-variable models, the experiment tested theories in which individual measurement outcomes arise from pre-existing properties, physical states consist of statistical mixtures of subensembles carrying definite polarizations, and the local averages of those subensembles obey Malus’ law. Using high-visibility polarization-entangled photon pairs generated through sponta- neous parametric down-conversion, Gröblacher et al. measured correlations in different planes of the Poincaré sphere and reported a violation of a generalized Leggett-type inequality. At a difference angle of 20◦ , the experiment yielded SNLHV = 3.8521 ± 0.0227, corresponding to a violation of approximately 3.2 standard deviations. The same data also gave SCHSH = 2.178 ± 0.0199, violating the local-realistic CHSH bound by approximately nine standard deviations (Gröblacher et al. 2007a). A subsequent corrigendum clarified the relevant experimental angle and other technical details while leaving the final inequality and scientific conclusions unchanged (Gröblacher et al. 2007b). The present analysis argues that these results must not be interpreted as an experimental refutation of objectivity, external reality, or realism in every conceivable sense. Instead, they constrain a particular class of realist ontologies in which maximally entangled systems can be decomposed into subensembles endowed with definite individual polarizations satisfying Malus’ law. This distinction is decisive for comparison with TO. Within TO, objectivity is grounded not in human observation but in modal conditions concerning elements, individual fields, boundaries, relations among elements, composition, and an informational or transcendent dimension. The Fifth Absolute Truth, in particular, defines observation non-anthropocentrically: an element acquires logical existence through relational inclusion within the observation or frequency of at least two other elements. The Seventh Absolute Truth identifies the transcendent element with knowledge or information generated in atomic relations and considers such information equivalent, within TO, to atomic radiation. The analysis identifies substantial conceptual compatibility between Gröblacher et al. and relational readings of the Second, Fourth, Fifth, and Seventh Absolute Truths. Quantum entanglement preserves operational distinguishability between subsystems while invalidating simple classical separability; experimental observation is physically imple- mented without requiring human consciousness; and experimentally relevant information resides crucially in correlations rather than solely in independently assigned classical properties. At the same time, the experiment imposes an important restriction upon any future operationalization of TO: an individual field, physical boundary, or objective existence cannot simply be identified with a catalogue of predetermined local polarization values of the Leggett type. If TO is to establish strong empirical contact with quantum physics, it must derive quantitative correlation functions that either reproduce existing quantum results or predict measurable deviations from them. The First Absolute Truth—the logically, mathematically, and eternally structured Nothingness preceding the universe—remains outside the empirical domain of Gröblacher’s laboratory test. The Third Absolute Truth, the TO cosmogonic theorem, the Inductive Effects, and the cosmological Eras are likewise not directly tested. Consequently, the experiment is classified here not as a proof of TO but as a case of indirect empirical corroboration of selected relational and non-anthropocentric features combined with a significant negative constraint on overly classical interpretations of objectivity. The article concludes that Gröblacher et al. merits a dialogue score of 8.3/10 in relation to TO and proposes a program for transforming the present interpretive convergence into genuine differential empirical tests. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; non-local realism; Leggett inequality; Bell theo- rem; quantum entanglement; objectivity; modal ontology; quantum information; non- anthropocentric observation; relationality; Gröblacher; quantum foundations.