Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Reviving Complementarity: John Wheeler's efforts to apply complementarity toward a quantum description of gravitation

Paul Halpern

Published Jan 30, 2017• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

Complementarity, Quantum Mechanics, and Quantum Field Theory

Arkady Plotnitsky

Springer eBooks•Nov 14, 2006•0 citations

JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER

Freeman J. Dyson

9 JULY 1911 * 13 APRIL 2008JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER (1911-2008) was a great physicist and also a great teacher. He famously said, We all know that the real reason universities have students is in order to educate the professors. During his tenure (1938-76) in the Princeton University physics department, he broke all the records by supervising forty-six graduate students and forty-six undergraduate seniors. Besides that, he supervised several more at the University of North Carolina (1935-38) and the University of Texas (1976-86). He was a central figure in the international community of physicists for seventy years. He was a fiercely patriotic American who took pride in his contributions to nuclear weaponry, and he was a warm personal friend of physicists all over the world.Complementarity is the philosophical principle that Niels Bohr invented to make sense of quantum mechanics. Complementarity says that nature is too rich to be described by a single picture. To describe a quantum process, we need two complementary pictures that cannot be seen simultaneously. classic example of complementarity is the behavior of light, which can be seen in one experiment as a wave and in another experiment as a collection of particles. wave and the particles cannot be seen together in one experiment, but they are both essential for defining the nature of light. Complementarity is firmly established by a wealth of experiments in the domain of atomic physics. But Bohr extended complementarity to a wider domain where its validity is still controversial. He wrote of complementarity between molecular and organic descriptions in biology, between practical usage and strict definition in linguistics, between justice and mercy in ethics, and between quantum and classical physics in descriptions of the world at large.Complementarity played two separate roles in Wheeler's life. In his technical activity as a theoretical physicist, complementarity was a working tool on which he could rely to get the right answers to practical questions. In his broader activities as a philosophical thinker, complementarity enabled him to combine opposites, to be a conservative revolutionary, a prosaic poet, a calculating dreamer. Wheeler's technical mastery of physics is best seen in the classic paper of Bohr and Wheeler, The Mechanism of Nuclear Fission (1939), published on the day when Hitler's armies marched into Poland and World War II began. Bohr and Wheeler wrote the paper in Princeton, where Bohr was visiting in the spring of 1939, a few months after the discovery of fission. paper is a masterpiece of clear thinking and lucid writing. It reveals, at the center of the mystery of fission, a tiny world where everything can be calculated and everything understood. tiny world is a nucleus of uranium 236, formed when a neutron is freshly captured by a nucleus of uranium 235.The uranium 236 nucleus sits precisely on the border between classical and quantum physics. Seen from the classical point of view, it is a liquid drop composed of a positively charged fluid. electrostatic force that is trying to split it apart is balanced by the nuclear surface tension that is holding it together. energy supplied by the captured neutron causes the drop to oscillate in various normal modes that can be calculated classically. Seen from the quantum point of view, the nucleus is a superposition of a variety of quantum states leading to different final outcomes. final outcome may be a uranium 235 nucleus with a re-emitted neutron, or a uranium 236 nucleus with an emitted gamma-ray, or a pair of fission-fragment nuclei with one or more free neutrons. Bohr and Wheeler calculate the cross-section for fission of uranium 235 by a slow neutron and get the right answer within a factor of two. Their calculation is a marvelous demonstration of the power of classical mechanics and quantum mechanics working together. By studying this process in detail, they show how the complementary views provided by classical and quantum pictures are both essential to the understanding of nature. …

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 2015•0 citations

Foundations of Quantum Theory and Complementarity

L. Rosenfeld

Nature•Apr 1, 1961•43 citations

Bryce DeWitt letter to John Wheeler 20-April-1967

Bryce Seligman DeWitt

In 1967, Bryce DeWitt published a three part essay, called Quantum Theory of Gravitation. He sent a preprint of the first part to Wheeler for his comments. This is DeWitt's reply to Wheeler's comments. It is notable because DeWitt mentions Everett, Bohr, Rosenfeld, and Wheeler's companion to Everett's paper.

•May 19, 2011•0 citations

What Can Wheeler Tell Us About the Bohr–Høffding Relationship?

Jan Faye, Stefano Furlan, Rasmus Jaksland

John Wheeler tells us that Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg met with the Danish philosopher Harald Høffding in the summer of 1927 to discuss the philosophy of quantum mechanics—following the disagreement between Bohr and Heisenberg about the uncertainty relations and right before Bohr’s introduction of his complementarity interpretation of quantum mechanics in Como, Italy, in September 1927. Is this evidence that Høffding had an even greater influence on the early development and interpretation of quantum mechanics than hitherto believed? We trace the historical sources of the story, which Wheeler first heard from Casimir, who apparently was present when the episode took place. We argue that the episode cannot have taken place earlier than 1929 and propose an event in November 1929 as its likely origin. What remains true is that Bohr, Casimir, and Høffding did meet, but the meeting is less remarkable than in Wheeler’s retelling. Nonetheless, Casimir’s role in the story adds new evidence for Høffding’s influence on Bohr. Heisenberg presence, though, is entirely of Wheeler’s invention. We use this rendering to illustrate how Wheeler operated as a storyteller of quantum mechanics from the 1980s to his death.

HOPOS The Journal of the International Society for the History of Philosophy of Science•Aug 25, 2025•1 citation

Quantum Physics and Philosophy–Causality and Complementarity

Raymond Klibansky, Niels Henrik David Bohr

Niels Bohr•Jan 1, 1996•81 citations
9 JULY 1911 * 13 APRIL 2008JOHN ARCHIBALD WHEELER (1911-2008) was a great physicist and also a great teacher. He famously said, We all know that the real reason universities have students is in order to educate the professors. During his tenure (1938-76) in the Princeton University physics department, he broke all the records by supervising forty-six graduate students and forty-six undergraduate seniors. Besides that, he supervised several more at the University of North Carolina (1935-38) and the University of Texas (1976-86). He was a central figure in the international community of physicists for seventy years. He was a fiercely patriotic American who took pride in his contributions to nuclear weaponry, and he was a warm personal friend of physicists all over the world.Complementarity is the philosophical principle that Niels Bohr invented to make sense of quantum mechanics. Complementarity says that nature is too rich to be described by a single picture. To describe a quantum process, we need two complementary pictures that cannot be seen simultaneously. classic example of complementarity is the behavior of light, which can be seen in one experiment as a wave and in another experiment as a collection of particles. wave and the particles cannot be seen together in one experiment, but they are both essential for defining the nature of light. Complementarity is firmly established by a wealth of experiments in the domain of atomic physics. But Bohr extended complementarity to a wider domain where its validity is still controversial. He wrote of complementarity between molecular and organic descriptions in biology, between practical usage and strict definition in linguistics, between justice and mercy in ethics, and between quantum and classical physics in descriptions of the world at large.Complementarity played two separate roles in Wheeler's life. In his technical activity as a theoretical physicist, complementarity was a working tool on which he could rely to get the right answers to practical questions. In his broader activities as a philosophical thinker, complementarity enabled him to combine opposites, to be a conservative revolutionary, a prosaic poet, a calculating dreamer. Wheeler's technical mastery of physics is best seen in the classic paper of Bohr and Wheeler, The Mechanism of Nuclear Fission (1939), published on the day when Hitler's armies marched into Poland and World War II began. Bohr and Wheeler wrote the paper in Princeton, where Bohr was visiting in the spring of 1939, a few months after the discovery of fission. paper is a masterpiece of clear thinking and lucid writing. It reveals, at the center of the mystery of fission, a tiny world where everything can be calculated and everything understood. tiny world is a nucleus of uranium 236, formed when a neutron is freshly captured by a nucleus of uranium 235.The uranium 236 nucleus sits precisely on the border between classical and quantum physics. Seen from the classical point of view, it is a liquid drop composed of a positively charged fluid. electrostatic force that is trying to split it apart is balanced by the nuclear surface tension that is holding it together. energy supplied by the captured neutron causes the drop to oscillate in various normal modes that can be calculated classically. Seen from the quantum point of view, the nucleus is a superposition of a variety of quantum states leading to different final outcomes. final outcome may be a uranium 235 nucleus with a re-emitted neutron, or a uranium 236 nucleus with an emitted gamma-ray, or a pair of fission-fragment nuclei with one or more free neutrons. Bohr and Wheeler calculate the cross-section for fission of uranium 235 by a slow neutron and get the right answer within a factor of two. Their calculation is a marvelous demonstration of the power of classical mechanics and quantum mechanics working together. By studying this process in detail, they show how the complementary views provided by classical and quantum pictures are both essential to the understanding of nature. …
John Wheeler tells us that Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg met with the Danish philosopher Harald Høffding in the summer of 1927 to discuss the philosophy of quantum mechanics—following the disagreement between Bohr and Heisenberg about the uncertainty relations and right before Bohr’s introduction of his complementarity interpretation of quantum mechanics in Como, Italy, in September 1927. Is this evidence that Høffding had an even greater influence on the early development and interpretation of quantum mechanics than hitherto believed? We trace the historical sources of the story, which Wheeler first heard from Casimir, who apparently was present when the episode took place. We argue that the episode cannot have taken place earlier than 1929 and propose an event in November 1929 as its likely origin. What remains true is that Bohr, Casimir, and Høffding did meet, but the meeting is less remarkable than in Wheeler’s retelling. Nonetheless, Casimir’s role in the story adds new evidence for Høffding’s influence on Bohr. Heisenberg presence, though, is entirely of Wheeler’s invention. We use this rendering to illustrate how Wheeler operated as a storyteller of quantum mechanics from the 1980s to his death.