In the generalized Russian cards problem, we have a card deck
X of
n cards and three participants, Alice, Bob, and Cathy, dealt
a,
b, and
c cards, respectively. Once the cards are dealt, Alice and Bob wish to privately communicate their hands to each other via public announcements, without the advantage of a shared secret or public key infrastructure. Cathy, for her part, should remain ignorant of all but her own cards after Alice and Bob have made their announcements. Notions for Cathy's ignorance in the literature range from Cathy not learning the fate of any individual card with certainty (weak
1-security) to not gaining any probabilistic advantage in guessing the fate of some set of
δ cards (perfect
δ-security). As we demonstrate in this work, the generalized Russian cards problem has close ties to the field of combinatorial designs, on which we rely heavily, particularly for perfect security notions. Our main result establishes an equivalence between perfectly
δ-secure strategies and
(c+δ)-designs on
n points with block size
a, when announcements are chosen uniformly at random from the set of possible announcements. We also provide construction methods and example solutions, including a construction that yields perfect
1-security against Cathy when
c=2. Drawing on our equivalence results, we are able to use a known combinatorial design to construct a strategy with
a=8,
b=13, and
c=3 that is perfectly
2-secure. Finally, we consider a variant of the problem that yields solutions that are easy to construct and optimal with respect to both the number of announcements and level of security achieved. Moreover, this is the first method obtaining weak
δ-security that allows Alice to hold an arbitrary number of cards and Cathy to hold a set of
c=⌊2a−δ⌋ cards. Alternatively, the construction yields solutions for arbitrary
δ,
c and any
a≥δ+2c.
Security and privacy are of paramount importance in the modern information age. Secure multi-party computation and private information retrieval are canonical and representative problems in cryptography that capture the key challenges in understanding the fundamentals of security and privacy. In this dissertation, we use information theoretic tools to tackle these two classical cryptographic primitives. In the first part, we consider the secure multi-party computation problem, where multiple users, each holding an independent message, wish to compute a function on the messages without revealing any additional information. We present an efficient protocol in terms of randomness cost to securely compute a vector linear function. In the second part, we discuss the symmetric private information retrieval problem, where a user wishes to retrieve one message from a number of replicated databases while keeping the desired message index a secret from each individual database. Further, the user learns nothing about the other messages. We present an optimal protocol that achieves the minimum upload cost for symmetric private information retrieval, i.e., the queries sent from the user to the databases have the minimum number of bits.
The design of secure protocols that implement arbitrarily desired functionalities is a major part of modern cryptography. Taking the opposite perspective, the design of any cryptographic scheme may be viewed as the design of a secure protocol for implementing a suitable functionality. Still, we believe that it makes sense to differentiate between basic cryptographic primitives (which involve little interaction) like encryption and signature schemes, on the one hand, and general cryptographic protocols, on the other hand. In this chapter we consider general results concerning secure multi –party computations, where the two –party case is an important special case. In a nutshell, these results assert that one can construct protocols for securely computing any desirable multi–party functionality (see the following terminology). Indeed, what is striking about these results is their generality, and we believe that the wonder is not diminished by the (various alternative) conditions under which these results hold. Our focus on the general study of secure multi–party computation (rather than on protocols for solving specific problems) is natural in the context of the theoretical treatment of the subject matter. We wish to highlight the importance of this general study to practice. Firstly, this study clarifies fundamental issues regarding security in a multi–party environment. Secondly, it draws the lines between what is possible in principle and what is not. Thirdly, it develops general techniques for designing secure protocols. And last, sometimes it may even yield schemes (or modules) that may be incorporated in practical systems.
Two types of generalizations in secure multi-party computation are described. First, we report on a new general adversary model: while previous protocols were designed to tolerate misbehavior of one of two types (active or passive adversaries) the new protocols tolerate mixed types of adversaries, i.e. an adversary that can corrupt players actively, passively, or can let them crash (i.e. stop execution). We derive the necessary and sufficient conditions under which such a general adversary can be tolerated. Second, we present a generic protocol framework that unifies previous approaches achieving unconditional (or information-theoretic) security and cryptographic security (i.e. security based on a cryptographic intractability assumption). This is achieved by introducing secret sharing schemes with an additional property called the multiplication property and a new type of homomorphic commitment scheme, and by generalizing the concept of commitments.
We show that some problems in information security can be solved without using one-way functions. The latter are usually regarded as a central concept of cryptography, but the very existence of one-way functions depends on difficult conjectures in complexity theory, most notably on the notorious “” conjecture. This is why cryptographic primitives that do not employ one-way functions are often called “unconditionally secure”. In this paper, we suggest protocols for secure computation of the sum, product, and some other functions of two or more elements of an arbitrary constructible ring, without using any one-way functions. A new input that we offer here is that, in contrast with other proposals, we conceal “intermediate results” of a computation. For example, when we compute the sum of k numbers, only the final result is known to the parties; partial sums are not known to anybody. Other applications of our method include voting/rating over insecure channels and a rather elegant and efficient solution of the “two millionaires problem”. Then, while it is fairly obvious that a secure (bit) commitment between two parties is impossible without a one-way function, we show that it is possible if the number of parties is at least 3. We also show how our unconditionally secure (bit) commitment scheme for three parties can be used to arrange an unconditionally secure (bit) commitment between just two parties if they use a “dummy” (e.g., a computer) as the third party. We explain how our concept of a “dummy” is different from the well-known concept of a “trusted third party”. Based on a similar idea, we also offer an unconditionally secure k - n oblivious transfer protocol between two parties who use a “dummy”. We also suggest a protocol, without using a one-way function, for the so-called “mental poker”, i.e., a fair card dealing (and playing) over distance. Finally, we propose a secret sharing scheme where an advantage over Shamir's and other known secret sharing schemes is that nobody, including the dealer, ends up knowing the shares (of the secret) owned by any particular player. It should be mentioned that computational cost of our protocols is negligible to the point that all of them can be executed without a computer.
We outline the need for stricter requirements for unconditionally secure cryptographic protocols inspired by the Russian Cards problem. A new requirement CA4 is proposed that checks for bias in single card occurrence in announcements consisting of alternatives for players' holdings of cards. This requirement CA4 is shown to be equivalent to an alternative requirement CA5. All announcements found to satisfy CA4 are 2-designs. We also show that all binary designs are 3-designs. Instead of avoiding bias in announcements produced by such protocols, one may as well apply unbiased protocols such that patterns in announcements become meaningless. We gave two examples of such protocols for card deal parameters (3,3,1), i.e. two of the players hold three cards, and the remaining player, playing the role of eavesdropper, holds a single card.