The previous chapter is devoted to the formulation of DMFT and applications that are exact in the limit of infinite dimensions; however, in finite dimensions this is only a single-site approximation. The present chapter is devoted to clusters and other methods to treat correlation between sites. The equations are derived in a unified way, applicable to a single site or a cluster. For a cluster with more than one site there are various ways to choose the boundary conditions and the embedding procedure, and special care must be taken to satisfy causality and translation invariance. A few selected applications illustrate different techniques and results for Hubbard-type models. The essential features of DMFT are brought out in the previous chapter in the simplest form: the single-site approximation in which correlation between sites can be neglected. In this case the self-energy due to interactions can be calculated using an auxiliary system of a single site embedded in an effective medium that represents the surrounding crystal. The resulting many-body problem is equivalent to an Anderson impurity model that must be solved self-consistently. The results are exact for infinite dimensions d → ∞; however, in any finite dimension, i.e., real systems, this is just a mean-field approximation analogous to the Weiss mean field in magnetic systems or the CPA for disordered alloys. There are, however, many important properties and phenomena that require us to go beyond mean-field approximations. For example, basic questions concerning the nature of a metal–insulator transition can be established only by quantitative assessment of the correlations between different sites. Is a single site sufficient (the central idea in the arguments by Mott discussed in Sec. 3.2) or is correlation between sites (for example, an ordered antiferromagnetic state) essential for interactions to lead to an insulating state? A complete theory must establish the range of correlation needed to understand the mechanisms and to make quantitative calculations. A striking example that requires a k -dependent self-energy is the opening of a “pseudogap” in only part of the Brillouin zone in a high-temperature superconductor, as illustrated in Fig. 2.16. This chapter is devoted to methods that go beyond the single-site approximation to take into account interactions and correlations between electrons on sites.
The previous chapter is devoted to the formulation of DMFT and applications that are exact in the limit of infinite dimensions; however, in finite dimensions this is only a single-site approximation. The present chapter is devoted to clusters and other methods to treat correlation between sites. The equations are derived in a unified way, applicable to a single site or a cluster. For a cluster with more than one site there are various ways to choose the boundary conditions and the embedding procedure, and special care must be taken to satisfy causality and translation invariance. A few selected applications illustrate different techniques and results for Hubbard-type models. The essential features of DMFT are brought out in the previous chapter in the simplest form: the single-site approximation in which correlation between sites can be neglected. In this case the self-energy due to interactions can be calculated using an auxiliary system of a single site embedded in an effective medium that represents the surrounding crystal. The resulting many-body problem is equivalent to an Anderson impurity model that must be solved self-consistently. The results are exact for infinite dimensions d → ∞; however, in any finite dimension, i.e., real systems, this is just a mean-field approximation analogous to the Weiss mean field in magnetic systems or the CPA for disordered alloys. There are, however, many important properties and phenomena that require us to go beyond mean-field approximations. For example, basic questions concerning the nature of a metal–insulator transition can be established only by quantitative assessment of the correlations between different sites. Is a single site sufficient (the central idea in the arguments by Mott discussed in Sec. 3.2) or is correlation between sites (for example, an ordered antiferromagnetic state) essential for interactions to lead to an insulating state? A complete theory must establish the range of correlation needed to understand the mechanisms and to make quantitative calculations. A striking example that requires a k -dependent self-energy is the opening of a “pseudogap” in only part of the Brillouin zone in a high-temperature superconductor, as illustrated in Fig. 2.16. This chapter is devoted to methods that go beyond the single-site approximation to take into account interactions and correlations between electrons on sites.
In the previous chapters DMFT has been developed as a methodology for calculation of dynamical and thermodynamic properties of many-body systems, with applications to model systems. In order for DMFT to be a general method for quantitative calculations, there must be systematic procedures to derive all the ingredients from first principles. In this chapter we consider the most prominent examples, materials with partially filled 3 d , 4 f , or 5 f localized, atomic-like states, and set up the characteristic form of the hamiltonian. This is the basis for DFT+DMFT methods discussed here and used in the examples in Ch. 20, and for the combination of DMFT with many-body perturbation theory in Ch. 21. Simpler techniques, including self-interaction correction, DFT+U, and DFT+Gutzwiller, are also useful and are summarized in the last sections of this chapter. Up to this point, dynamical mean-field theory has been developed for model systems with Hubbard-type hamiltonians, where the hopping matrix elements and interactions are considered as parameters. For problems with strong interactions, DMFT leads to renormalized bands, satellites in the one-particle spectra, magnetic phase transitions and local moments, metal–insulator transitions, and many other phenomena observed in real materials, as brought out in Ch. 2. The purpose of this chapter is to provide the framework for a quantitative theory of these materials. These are difficult problems, experimentally, theoretically, and computationally, and the first step is to identify the aspects of the materials that must be treated explicitly as the local strongly interacting system, and the “rest” that are treated by a different method. This division of the problem is useful because a real material involves many degrees of freedom, i.e., the electronic states must be described in a basis sufficiently large to describe all the relevant states. However, the part that can be treated by non-perturbative solvers (Ch. 18) is limited by the computational cost that scales rapidly with the number of states included in the embedded site or cluster. Thus one must choose a small number of localized orbitals that inevitably are non-unique. This may seem like a step backward for quantitative methods; however, it opens a window for methods to treat these interesting problems and it presents a challenge to overcome the limitations.
SummaryDynamical mean-field theory is designed to treat systems with local effective interactions that are strong compared with the independent-particle terms that lead to delocalized band-like states. Interactions are taken into account by a many-body calculation for an auxiliary system, a site embedded in a dynamical mean field, that is chosen to best represent the coupling to the rest of the crystal. The methods are constructed to be exact in three limits: interacting electrons on isolated sites, a lattice with no interactions, and the limit of infinite dimensions d → ∞ where mean-field theory is exact. This chapter is devoted to the general formulation, the single-site approximation where the calculation of the self-energy is mapped onto a self-consistent quantum impurity problem, and instructive examples for the Hubbard model on a d → ∞ Bethe lattice. Further developments and applications are the topics of Chs. 17–21.
Almost 50 years after the invention of the Hubbard model [1–3] and despite modern petaflop supercomputers, a precise analysis of the criticality of this most basic model for electronic correlations has not been achieved so far, at least not in three dimensions. Dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) [4–6] was a big step forward to quantitatively calculate the three dimensional Hubbard model since the major contribution of electronic correlations, i.e., the local ones, are well captured within this theory. Local correlations give rise to quasiparticle renormalization, the Mott-Hubbard transition, magnetism, and even more subtle issues such as kinks in a purely electronic models [7]. However, non-local spatial correlations are also naturally generated by a purely local Hubbard interaction, and, as it is well known, they become of essential importance in the vicinity of secondorder phase transitions. As these correlations are neglected in DMFT, this scheme can provide only for a conventional mean-field (MF) description of the critical properties. To overcome this shortcoming cluster extensions to DMFT such as the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) and cluster-DMFT have been proposed, see Ref. 8 for a review. In these approaches non-local correlations beyond DMFT are taken into account, however only within the range of the cluster size; and due to computational limitations the actual size of the cluster is severely restricted to about 3-5 sites for each direction. Hence, short-range correlations are included by these approaches, whereas long-range ones are not. Nonetheless, Kent et al. [9] were able to extrapolate the cluster size of so-called Betts clusters to infinity, albeit assuming from the very beginning the critical exponents to be those of the Heisenberg model. This way they extrapolated the critical temperature of the paramagnetic-toantiferromagnetic phase transition which was found to be in agreement with earlier quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations of Staudt et al. [10] on finite lattices.
It is shown that a minimum realization of the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) can be achieved by mapping a correlated lattice model onto an impurity model in which the impurity is coupled to an uncorrelated bath that consists of a single site only. The two-site impurity model can be solved exactly. The mapping is approximate. The self-consistency conditions are constructed in a way that the resulting ``two-site DMFT'' reduces to the previously discussed linearized DMFT for the Mott transition. It is demonstrated that a reasonable description of the mean-field physics is possible with a minimum computational effort. This qualifies the simple two-site DMFT for a systematic study of more complex lattice models which cannot be treated by the full DMFT in a feasible way. To show the strengths and limitations of the new approach, the single-band Hubbard model is investigated in detail. The predictions of the two-site DMFT are compared with results of the full DMFT. Internal consistency checks are performed which concern the Luttinger sum rule, other Fermi-liquid relations and thermodynamic consistency.
We investigate Hubbard-type models by means of the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) combined with the continuous-time quantum Monte Carlo (CTQMC) method. In this thesis, a great deal of effort has been devoted to investigating diverse facets of Mott physics. Interesting phenomena in strongly correlated electron systems emerge mostly when various energy scales compete with each other. We introduce additional degrees of freedom to the standard Hubbard model. The additional degrees of freedom include a staggered lattice potential, two orbitals, bilayer structure, and superconductivity. Depending on the model system, we extend the single-site DMFT to the multi-orbital one or employ cluster extension of the DMFT. In addition, two complementary versions of CTQMC, weak and strong coupling algorithm, are adopted as an impurity solver.\nWe first consider a Mott transition of the Hubbard model in infinite dimensions. The DMFT is employed in combination with the CTQMC method for an accurate description at low temperatures. Through the use of the double occupancy and the energy density, which are directly measured via the CTQMC method, we construct the phase diagram. We pay particular attention to the construction of the first-order phase transition line (PTL) in the coexistence region of metallic and insulating phases. The resulting PTL is found to exhibit reasonable agreement with earlier finite-temperature results. We also show, by including systematically low-temperature data, that the PTL, which is obtained independently of the previous zero-temperature results, approaches monotonically the transition point reported in earlier zero-temperature studies.\nWe next investigate paramagnetic metal-insulator transitions in the infinite-dimensional ionic Hubbard model at finite temperatures. By means of the DMFT with an impurity solver of the CTQMC, we show that an increase in the interaction strength brings about a crossover from a band insulating phase to a metallic one, followed by a first-order transition to the Mott insulating phase. The first-order transition turns into a crossover above a certain critical temperature, which becomes higher as the strength of the staggered lattice potential is increased. Further, analysis of the temperature dependence of the energy density discloses that the intermediate metallic phase is a Fermi liquid. It is also found that the metallic phase is stable against strong staggered potentials even at very low temperatures. \nFinite-temperature phase transitions are also examined in the two-orbital Hubbard model with Ising-type Hunds coupling. We adopt the multi-orbital extension of the DMFT combined with the strong coupling CTQMC. It is found that there emerges a peculiar reverse-sloped first-order Mott transition between the orbital-selective Mott phase and the Mott insulator phase. It turns out that the increase of Hunds coupling lowers the critical temperature of the reverse-sloped Mott transition. Beyond a certain critical value of Hunds coupling the first-order transition becomes a finite-temperature crossover.\nBilayer effects in the Hubbard model are also studied in the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) combined with the weak coupling algorithm of CTQMC. In the magnetic phase diagrams obtained in earlier studies, there still remain several controversial issues, particularly for weak on-site Coulomb interactions. In this study, we adopt eight-site clusters which preserve the underlying lattice symmetry. Magnetic properties and associated metal-insulator transitions are examined at low temperatures, and their implications to the ground-state phase diagram are also discussed.\nFinally, we discuss the BCS+U model which is a natural generalization of Gutzwiller-projected BCS model. For this study, we use the DCA combined with the weak coupling CTQMC and verify the reliability of our calculation by changing the cluster size. Our main focus is on the correlation effects of the phenomenological d-wave superconductor. The transition between the superconductor and the Mott insulator is observed as we change the interaction strength or doping concentration. We discuss the change in the spectral properties of the system during the transition.
This thesis will describe efforts to enhance our ability to simulate the 2D Hubbard model. Chapter 2 provides a background on the main computational techniques used throughout the work, including quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), dynamical mean field theory (DMFT), the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA), the continuous time auxiliary field algorithm (CTAUX), and the Maximum Entropy Method (MEM) for numeric analytic continuation. Chapter 3 presents new work on applying Twisted Boundary Conditions to the DCA framework. This method is applied in a effort to access thermodynamic (i.e. large system) information about the Hubbard model without the immense computational expense required to simulate large lattices directly. Chapter 4 describes efforts to study the extended 2D Hubbard model, which re-introduces non-local interactions between electrons that drive the formation of charge ordered phases. The work includes a thorough analysis of the phase diagram of the model away from half-filling, as well as analysis of the effect of non-local interactions on anti-ferromagnetic fluctuations and competition between the charge order and AFM states. Chapter 5 includes a derivation of the dual fermions diagrammatic expansion and the dual fermions ladder approximation used to compute corrections to single site DMFT calculations. The method is applied to the 2D Hubbard model in order to study the evolution of its spectral function, Fermi surface, and momentum dependent mass renormalization as the temperature, interaction strength, and doping are changed. The great advantage of this method is that we are able to access arbitrary momenta throughout the Brillouin zone, in contrast to the limitation to a few cluster momenta that characterize cluster methods like DCA.