Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

Feynman's last mistake

Giorgio Matteucci

Published Feb 1, 1996• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Readers looking for inaccuracies in the Feynman Lectures might be interested in the misrepresentation of the quantum phase shift in the so-called magnetic Aharonov-Bohm effect in chapter 15.5 of volume two. Feynman describes the importance of the vector potential in quantum mechanics, presenting the electron interference experiment suggested by Aharonov and Bohm in his own usual fascinating way. However, the phase shift, revealed by the detector, is misrepresented in figure 15–7.

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/9/2/17

Related papers

Magnetic Aharonov-Bohm effects and the quantum phase shift: A heuristic interpretation

Keith J. Kasunic

In the well-known Aharonov-Bohm and Ehrenberg-Siday effects, the diffraction envelope of an electron is not affected by Lorentz forces in a region of zero magnetic field; instead, a phase difference—created by the magnetic vector potential—shifts the constructive- and destructive-interference fringe positions when electron wavefunctions are overlapped. This shift in fringe positions has been previously derived as resulting from potential-induced phase differences, without being clear on the physical mechanism behind it. In this paper, we show that the de Broglie wavelength of the electron is changed locally by its interaction with the vector potential. The vector potential thus acts as a quantum “phase plate,” changing the phase difference between interfering electron wavefunctions in a non-dispersive, gauge-invariant manner.

arXiv:1812.01724•American Journal of Physics•Aug 19, 2019•18 citations

The Aharonov-Bohm Effect: An Exploration of Quantum Interference and Electromagnetic Potentials

Bahman Zohuri

The AB (Aharonov-Bohm) effect is a pivotal quantum mechanical phenomenon that illustrates the fundamental role of the electromagnetic vector potential A in determining the phase of a charged particle's wave function, even in regions where the magnetic field B is zero.This effect demonstrates that quantum particles are influenced not only by the fields directly present but also by the potentials associated with those fields.In the AB effect, an electron beam is split into two paths, with one path encircling a solenoid and the other bypassing it.Despite the absence of a magnetic field in the regions traversed by the beams, the vector potential A associated with the magnetic flux  through the solenoid induces a phase shift in the electron's wave function.This phase shift, quantified by qc     , manifests as a change in the interference pattern observed in the detection screen.The phenomenon underscores the principle of gauge invariance in QED (quantum electrodynamics), where physical observables remain invariant under local gauge transformations of the vector and scalar potentials.This reinforces the notion that the vector potential A has a profound impact on quantum systems, beyond its classical role.This article outlines the AB effect, including its theoretical framework, experimental observations, and implications.The focus on the role of the vector potential in quantum mechanics provides a comprehensive understanding of this important phenomenon.

Journal of Energy and Power Engineering•Jun 28, 2024•1 citation

The magnetic Aharonov-Bohm effect: forces and phase shifts for quantum sensor design

Keith J. Kasunic

Recent experiments with the Aharonov-Bohm geometry have shown that in addition to an electron-interference fringe shift, there is also a lateral displacement of the electron diffraction envelope. In this paper, we derive an electron displacement force based on a second-order expansion of the magnetic vector potential. The analysis illustrates the conservation of canonical angular momentum, where the mechanical angular momentum and field angular momentum sum to a constant of the motion; the azimuthal force required to change the mechanical momentum is thus supplied by changes in field momentum associated with the second-order vector potential term. Our results are consistent with all known Aharonov-Bohm experiments, including interference fringe shifts, lateral displacements, and the absence of longitudinal time delays.

arXiv:1912.02169•Quantum Nanophotonic Materials, Devices, and Systems•Aug 20, 2020•0 citations

Quantized vector potential and alternative views of the magnetic Aharonov-Bohm phase shift

Philip Pearle, Anthony Rizzi

We give a complete quantum analysis of the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) magnetic phase shift involving three entities: the electron, the charges constituting the solenoid current, and the vector potential. The usual calculation supposes that the solenoid's vector potential may be well approximated as classical. The AB shift is then acquired by the quantized electron moving in this vector potential. Recently, Vaidman presented a semiclassical calculation [L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. A 86, 040101 (2012)], later confirmed by a fully quantum calculation of Pearle and Rizzi [preceding paper, Phys. Rev. A 95, 052123 (2017)], where it is supposed that the electron's vector potential may be well approximated as classical. The AB shift is then acquired by the quantized solenoid charges moving in this vector potential. Here we present a third calculation, which supposes that the electron and solenoid currents may be well approximated as classical sources. The AB phase shift is then shown to be acquired by the quantized vector potential. We next show these are three equivalent alternative ways of calculating the AB shift. We consider the exact problem where all three entities are quantized. We approximate the wave function as the product of three wave functions: a vector potential wave function, an electron wave function, and a solenoid wave function. We apply the variational principle for the exact Schr\"odinger equation to this approximate form of solution. This leads to three Schr\"odinger equations, one each for vector potential, electron, and solenoid, each with classical sources for the other two entities. However, each Schr\"odinger equation contains an additional real $c$-number term, the time derivative of an extra phase. We show that these extra phases are such that the phase of the total wave function produces the AB shift. Since none of the three entities requires different treatment from any of the others, this leads to three alternative views of the physical cause of the AB magnetic effect.

arXiv:1605.04324•Physical Review A•May 25, 2017•29 citations

Generalized Aharonov-Bohm Effect: Its Derivation, Theoretical Implications and Experimental Tests

Gao, Shan

The Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect highlights the fundamental role of electromagnetic potentials in quantum mechanics. While extensively studied in the static case, the impact of a time-varying magnetic flux on the electron's phase shift remains an open and debated question. In this paper, we derive the AB phase shift for a time-dependent magnetic vector potential and show that it is proportional to the time average of enclosed magnetic flux. Our analysis reveals that the AB phase is continuously accumulated as the electron traverses its path, challenging the conventional view that it emerges instantaneously at the point of interference. This generalized AB effect may provide deeper insight into the role of gauge-dependent potentials in quantum mechanics and also suggest novel experimental tests using alternating or pulsed magnetic flux.

•Feb 11, 2025•0 citations

Aptly named Aharonov-Bohm effect has classical analogue, long history

Michael Berry

Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jul 30, 2010•13 citations
Readers looking for inaccuracies in the Feynman Lectures might be interested in the misrepresentation of the quantum phase shift in the so-called magnetic Aharonov-Bohm effect in chapter 15.5 of volume two. Feynman describes the importance of the vector potential in quantum mechanics, presenting the electron interference experiment suggested by Aharonov and Bohm in his own usual fascinating way. However, the phase shift, revealed by the detector, is misrepresented in figure 15–7.
In the well-known Aharonov-Bohm and Ehrenberg-Siday effects, the diffraction envelope of an electron is not affected by Lorentz forces in a region of zero magnetic field; instead, a phase difference—created by the magnetic vector potential—shifts the constructive- and destructive-interference fringe positions when electron wavefunctions are overlapped. This shift in fringe positions has been previously derived as resulting from potential-induced phase differences, without being clear on the physical mechanism behind it. In this paper, we show that the de Broglie wavelength of the electron is changed locally by its interaction with the vector potential. The vector potential thus acts as a quantum “phase plate,” changing the phase difference between interfering electron wavefunctions in a non-dispersive, gauge-invariant manner.
The AB (Aharonov-Bohm) effect is a pivotal quantum mechanical phenomenon that illustrates the fundamental role of the electromagnetic vector potential A in determining the phase of a charged particle's wave function, even in regions where the magnetic field B is zero.This effect demonstrates that quantum particles are influenced not only by the fields directly present but also by the potentials associated with those fields.In the AB effect, an electron beam is split into two paths, with one path encircling a solenoid and the other bypassing it.Despite the absence of a magnetic field in the regions traversed by the beams, the vector potential A associated with the magnetic flux  through the solenoid induces a phase shift in the electron's wave function.This phase shift, quantified by qc     , manifests as a change in the interference pattern observed in the detection screen.The phenomenon underscores the principle of gauge invariance in QED (quantum electrodynamics), where physical observables remain invariant under local gauge transformations of the vector and scalar potentials.This reinforces the notion that the vector potential A has a profound impact on quantum systems, beyond its classical role.This article outlines the AB effect, including its theoretical framework, experimental observations, and implications.The focus on the role of the vector potential in quantum mechanics provides a comprehensive understanding of this important phenomenon.
Recent experiments with the Aharonov-Bohm geometry have shown that in addition to an electron-interference fringe shift, there is also a lateral displacement of the electron diffraction envelope. In this paper, we derive an electron displacement force based on a second-order expansion of the magnetic vector potential. The analysis illustrates the conservation of canonical angular momentum, where the mechanical angular momentum and field angular momentum sum to a constant of the motion; the azimuthal force required to change the mechanical momentum is thus supplied by changes in field momentum associated with the second-order vector potential term. Our results are consistent with all known Aharonov-Bohm experiments, including interference fringe shifts, lateral displacements, and the absence of longitudinal time delays.
We give a complete quantum analysis of the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) magnetic phase shift involving three entities: the electron, the charges constituting the solenoid current, and the vector potential. The usual calculation supposes that the solenoid's vector potential may be well approximated as classical. The AB shift is then acquired by the quantized electron moving in this vector potential. Recently, Vaidman presented a semiclassical calculation [L. Vaidman, Phys. Rev. A 86, 040101 (2012)], later confirmed by a fully quantum calculation of Pearle and Rizzi [preceding paper, Phys. Rev. A 95, 052123 (2017)], where it is supposed that the electron's vector potential may be well approximated as classical. The AB shift is then acquired by the quantized solenoid charges moving in this vector potential. Here we present a third calculation, which supposes that the electron and solenoid currents may be well approximated as classical sources. The AB phase shift is then shown to be acquired by the quantized vector potential. We next show these are three equivalent alternative ways of calculating the AB shift. We consider the exact problem where all three entities are quantized. We approximate the wave function as the product of three wave functions: a vector potential wave function, an electron wave function, and a solenoid wave function. We apply the variational principle for the exact Schr\"odinger equation to this approximate form of solution. This leads to three Schr\"odinger equations, one each for vector potential, electron, and solenoid, each with classical sources for the other two entities. However, each Schr\"odinger equation contains an additional real ccc-number term, the time derivative of an extra phase. We show that these extra phases are such that the phase of the total wave function produces the AB shift. Since none of the three entities requires different treatment from any of the others, this leads to three alternative views of the physical cause of the AB magnetic effect.
The Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect highlights the fundamental role of electromagnetic potentials in quantum mechanics. While extensively studied in the static case, the impact of a time-varying magnetic flux on the electron's phase shift remains an open and debated question. In this paper, we derive the AB phase shift for a time-dependent magnetic vector potential and show that it is proportional to the time average of enclosed magnetic flux. Our analysis reveals that the AB phase is continuously accumulated as the electron traverses its path, challenging the conventional view that it emerges instantaneously at the point of interference. This generalized AB effect may provide deeper insight into the role of gauge-dependent potentials in quantum mechanics and also suggest novel experimental tests using alternating or pulsed magnetic flux.
Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.