Ever since the introduction of the Anderson model in 1958, physicists and mathematicians alike have been interested in the effects of disorder on quantum mechanical systems. For example, it is known that transport is suppressed for an electron moving about in a random environment, which follows from localization results proven for the Anderson model. Quantum spin systems provide a relatively simple starting point when one is interested in studying many-body systems. Here we investigate a random block operator arising from the anisotropic xy-spin chain model. Allowing for arbitrary nontrivial single-site distributions, we prove a zero-velocity Lieb-Robinson bound under the assumption of dynamical localization at all energies. After a preliminary study of basic properties and location of the almost-sure spectrum of this random block operator, we apply a transfer matrix formalism and prove contractivity and irreducibility properties of the Furstenberg group and, in particular, positivity of Lyapunov exponents at all nonzero energies. Then in the general setting of random block Jacobi matrices, we establish a Thouless formula, and under contractivity and irreducibility assumptions, we conclude dynamical localization via multiscale analysis by proving a Wegner estimate and an initial length scale estimate. Finally we apply our general results to prove localization for the special case of the Ising model, and we discuss a critical energy that arises.
Ever since the introduction of the Anderson model in 1958, physicists and mathematicians alike have been interested in the effects of disorder on quantum mechanical systems. For example, it is known that transport is suppressed for an electron moving about in a random environment, which follows from localization results proven for the Anderson model. Quantum spin systems provide a relatively simple starting point when one is interested in studying many-body systems. Here we investigate a random block operator arising from the anisotropic xy-spin chain model. Allowing for arbitrary nontrivial single-site distributions, we prove a zero-velocity Lieb-Robinson bound under the assumption of dynamical localization at all energies. After a preliminary study of basic properties and location of the almost-sure spectrum of this random block operator, we apply a transfer matrix formalism and prove contractivity and irreducibility properties of the Furstenberg group and, in particular, positivity of Lyapunov exponents at all nonzero energies. Then in the general setting of random block Jacobi matrices, we establish a Thouless formula, and under contractivity and irreducibility assumptions, we conclude dynamical localization via multiscale analysis by proving a Wegner estimate and an initial length scale estimate. Finally we apply our general results to prove localization for the special case of the Ising model, and we discuss a critical energy that arises.
We review several aspects of Many‐Body Localization‐like properties exhibited by the disordered XY chains: localization properties of the energy eigenstates and thermal states, propagation bounds of Lieb‐Robinson type, decay of correlation functions, absence of particle transport, bounds on the bipartite entanglement, and bounded entanglement growth under the dynamics. We also prove new results on the absence of energy transport and Fock space localization. All these properties are made accessible to mathematical analysis due to the exact mapping of the XY chain to a system of quasi‐free fermions given by the Jordan‐Wigner transformation. Motivated by these results we discuss conjectured properties of more general disordered quantum spin and other systems as possible directions for future mathematical research.
We give an introduction into some aspects of the emerging mathematical theory of many-body localization (MBL) for disordered quantum spin chains. In particular, we discuss manifestations of MBL such as zero-velocity Lieb-Robinson bounds, quasi-locality of the time evolution of local observables, as well as exponential clustering and low entanglement of eigenstates. Explicit models where such properties have recently been verified are the XY and XXZ spin chain, in each case with disorder introduced in the form of a random exterior field. We introduce these models, state many of the available results and try to provide some general context. We discuss methods and ideas which enter the proofs and, in a few illustrative examples, include more detailed arguments. Finally, we also mention some directions for future mathematical work on MBL.
A real-space renormalization-group treatment of random transverse-field Ising spin chains that was introduced previously is developed and extensively analyzed. It yields results that are asymptotically exact in the critical region near the zero-temperature para-to-ferromagnetic quantum phase transition. In particular, the exact scaling function is obtained for the magnetization as a function of a uniform applied magnetic field and the distance to the critical point, and up to the solution of a linear ordinary differential equation whose solution can be exhaustively analyzed, the scaling function of the average spin-spin correlation function is also obtained. Thus more exact information is obtainable about the critical behavior for this random model than is known for the pure version which is equivalent to the two-dimensional Ising model. The basic reason for this is the extremely broad distribution of energy scales that occurs at low energies near the critical point of the random system. For the random chain the distribution of the magnetization of the first spin in a semi-infinite system is also studied and the results found to agree in the scaling limit with results of McCoy obtained from the exact solution of the closely related McCoy-Wu Ising model; this provides strong justification for the validity of the present approach. The singular properties of the weakly ordered and weakly disordered ``Griffiths' phases'' that occur at zero temperature near the critical point are also studied, as well as the behavior at low but nonzero temperature. Possible extensions of the results and general lessons drawn from them for other random systems are briefly discussed.
We consider the spreading of a local operator A in one-dimensional many-body systems with Hamiltonian H by calculating the k -fold commutator [ H , [ H , [ . . . , [ H , A ] ] ] ] . We derive bounds for the operator norm of this commutator in free and interacting systems with and without disorder thus directly connecting the with questions of localization. We analytically show, in particular, that an almost-factorial growth of the operator norm—as recently proven for the random Ising model and strongly suggested here to also hold for the Heisenberg model with random fields—is inconsistent with an exponential localization of A . Assuming there exists a quasilocal unitary U which maps H onto an effective Hamiltonian H ̃ = U H U † = ∑ n E n τ n z + ∑ i , j J i j τ i z τ j z + ⋯ , we show that A ̃ = U A U † is a quasilocal operator which, in contrast to the Anderson case, indeed in the general many-body case, leading to an almost-factorial growth of the commutator norm. Therefore, either the unitary U in many-body systems with maximal norm growth does not exist, and such systems are always ergodic, or unusual nonergodic phases described by H ̃ exist which violate the operator growth hypothesis and in which local operators spread over the entire lattice, implying that transport will eventually set in. To investigate this issue further, we concentrate on the chain with random magnetic fields. We analytically and symbolically verify our general results for the noninteracting Anderson and Aubry-André models. For the case, the symbolic calculations are consistent with a maximal norm growth. Furthermore, we find no indication of a weakened exponential localization of A , expected for strong disorder and low commutator orders if the unitary U does exist. Finally, we study the differences between the interacting and noninteracting cases when trying to perturbatively construct U by consecutive Schrieffer-Wolff transformations. While it is straightforward to show that this construction converges in the Anderson case, we find no indications for a convergence in the interacting case, suggesting that U does not exist and that many-body localization is absent.
We review recent results on many-body localization for two explicitly analyzable models of many-body quantum systems, the XY spin chain in transversal magnetic field as well as interacting systems of harmonic quantum oscillators. In both models the presence of disorder leads to dynamical localization in the form of zero-velocity Lieb-Robinson bounds and to exponential decay of ground state correlations. Moreover, for oscillator systems one can also show exponential decay of thermal states as well as an area law bound for the entanglement entropy of ground and thermal states. The key fact which allows a rigorous analysis of these models is that they are given by many-body Hamiltonians which can be reduced to effective single particle Hamiltonians.
The dynamic critical behavior of one-dimensional random spin systems in a field at zero temperature is investigated by a generalized transfer-matrix scaling technique. Three spin models are considered: Heisenberg in a longitudinal field, XY in a transverse field, and Ising in a transverse field, with either spin-glass or random-field disorder. Near the transition, i.e., for small values of the reduced field \ensuremath{\Delta}=(H-Hc), where Hc is the critical field, one finds that the dispersion relation for the low-frequency \ensuremath{\omega}, small-wave-vector k spin-wave excitations takes the scaling form \ensuremath{\omega}=kzf(\ensuremath{\Delta}/kcphi), and exact results are given for the dynamic exponent z and crossover exponent cphi. This form contains a crossover of the frequency \ensuremath{\omega} between two different asymptotic behaviors: kz for \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\ll}kcphi and ${h}^{\ensuremath{\delta}}$ for \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\gg}kcphi, where the field exponent is \ensuremath{\delta}=z/cphi. In the case of the Heisenberg systems the spin-glass disorder gives rise to the nontrivial dynamic exponent z=(3/2, whereas in the random-field case it is the exponent associated to the field that becomes nontrivial, taking the value (4/3. For the transverse XY systems the random-field disorder implies nontrivial values for both the dynamic and field exponents, (3/2 and (3/4, respectively, whereas the spin-glass disorder does not affect the dynamics of the system, which behaves like a pure transverse XY ferromagnet. Finally, for the transverse Ising systems neither the random field nor the spin-glass disorder affects the dynamics, which is the same as for a pure transverse Ising ferromagnet.