Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fundamental theories of physics

The Discretized Hamiltonian Formalism in PQ $\mathit{PQ}$ Theory

Gerard ’t Hooft

Published Jan 1, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In standard quantum mechanics, the construction of the Schrödinger equation requires a Hamiltonian operator, which must obey some important restrictions. Most of our deterministic models are, to some extent, discrete. How do we carry over the standard Hamiltonian formalism to a discretized world? As in the continuum case, we may assume that conjugate pairs ( $P_{i}; Q_{i}$ ) can be defined, but now $P_{i}$ and $Q_{i}$ are integers. How can a Hamiltonian function $H(\vec{Q}; \vec{P})$ be used to define an evolution law?

DOI
10.1007/978-3-319-41285-6_19

Related papers

PQ PQ\mathit{PQ}PQ Theory

Gerard ’t Hooft

What is badly needed is an elegant mathematical scheme that replaces position and momentum operators $q$ and $p$ by discrete, commuting counterparts, $Q$ and $P$ , in such a way that mappings can be defined between conventional, quantum mechanical systems and deterministic, discrete systems. Here the foundations for such a scheme is suggested. An essential role is played by the Jacobi theta functions.

Fundamental theories of physics•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Hamiltonian formalism for integer-valued variables and integer time steps and a possible application in quantum physics

Gerard ’t Hooft

Most classical mechanical systems are based on dynamical variables whose values are real numbers. Energy conservation is then guaranteed if the dynamical equations are phrased in terms of a Hamiltonian function, which then leads to differential equations in the time variable. If these real dynamical variables are instead replaced by integers, and also the time variable is restricted to integers, it appears to be hard to enforce energy conservation unless one can also derive a Hamiltonian formalism for that case. We here show how the Hamiltonian formalism works here, and how it may yield the usual Hamilton equations in the continuum limit. The question was motivated by the author's investigations of special quantum systems that allow for a deterministic interpretation. The 'discrete Hamiltonian formalism' appears to shed new light on these approaches.

arXiv:1312.1229•Dec 4, 2013•4 citations

Deterministic Quantum Mechanics: The Mathematical Equations

Gerard ’t Hooft

Without wasting time and effort on philosophical justifications and implications, we write down the conditions for the Hamiltonian of a quantum system for rendering it mathematically equivalent to a deterministic system. These are the equations to be considered. Special attention is given to the notion of `locality'. Various examples are worked out, followed by a systematic procedure to generate classical evolution laws and quantum Hamiltonians that are exactly equivalent. What is new here is that we consider interactions, keeping them as general as we can. The quantum systems found, form a dense set if we limit ourselves to sufficiently low energy states. The class is discrete, just because the set of deterministic models containing a finite number of classical states, is discrete. In contrast with earlier suspicions, the gravitational force turns out not to be needed for this; it suffices that the classical system act at a time scale much smaller than the inverse of the maximum scattering energies considered.

arXiv:2005.06374•Frontiers in Physics•Jul 29, 2020•45 citations

Quantum models as classical cellular automata

Hans-Thomas Elze

A synopsis is offered of the properties of discrete and integer-valued, hence "natural", cellular automata (CA). A particular class comprises the "Hamiltonian CA" with discrete updating rules that resemble Hamilton's equations. The resulting dynamics is linear like the unitary evolution described by the Schrödinger equation. Employing Shannon's Sampling Theorem, we construct an invertible map between such CA and continuous quantum mechanical models which incorporate a fundamental discreteness scale l . Consequently, there is a one-to-one correspondence of quantum mechanical and CA conservation laws. We discuss the important issue of linearity, recalling that nonlinearities imply nonlocal effects in the continuous quantum mechanical description of intrinsically local discrete CA - requiring locality entails linearity. The admissible CA observables and the existence of solutions of the l -dependent dispersion relation for stationary states are mentioned, besides the construction of multipartite CA obeying the Superposition Principle. We point out problems when trying to match the deterministic CA here to those envisioned in 't Hooft's CA Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics.

arXiv:1701.02252•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2017•10 citations

Quantum features of natural cellular automata

Hans-Thomas Elze

Cellular automata can show well known features of quantum mechanics, such as a linear rule according to which they evolve and which resembles a discretized version of the Schrödinger equation. This includes corresponding conservation laws. The class of "natural" Hamiltonian cellular automata is based exclusively on integer-valued variables and couplings and their dynamics derives from an Action Principle. They can be mapped reversibly to continuum models by applying Sampling Theory. Thus, "deformed" quantum mechanical models with a finite discreteness scale l are obtained, which for l → 0 reproduce familiar continuum results. We have recently demonstrated that such automata can form "multipartite" systems consistently with the tensor product structures of nonrelativistic many-body quantum mechanics, while interacting and maintaining the linear evolution. Consequently, the Superposition Principle fully applies for such primitive discrete deterministic automata and their composites and can produce the essential quantum effects of interference and entanglement.

arXiv:1604.06652•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2016•7 citations

Quantization and the Classical Hamilton-Jacobi Equation

Lloyd Motz

In this paper, a formalism for quantization is developed which starts out from the Hamilton-Jacobi expression, $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}S}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}+H(\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}S}{\ensuremath{\partial}q}, q)$, and which leads to its usual quantum-mechanical operator equivalent by means of straightforward algebra. The quantum-mechanical operator equivalents of $H$ and $p$ are then seen to be the consequence of assigning a number of equally probable classical paths to a dynamical system.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1962•20 citations
The Discretized Hamiltonian Formalism in PQ PQ\mathit{PQ}PQ Theory
In standard quantum mechanics, the construction of the Schrödinger equation requires a Hamiltonian operator, which must obey some important restrictions. Most of our deterministic models are, to some extent, discrete. How do we carry over the standard Hamiltonian formalism to a discretized world? As in the continuum case, we may assume that conjugate pairs ( Pi;QiP_{i}; Q_{i}Pi​;Qi​ ) can be defined, but now PiP_{i}Pi​ and QiQ_{i}Qi​ are integers. How can a Hamiltonian function H(Q⃗;P⃗)H(\vec{Q}; \vec{P})H(Q​;P) be used to define an evolution law?
What is badly needed is an elegant mathematical scheme that replaces position and momentum operators qqq and ppp by discrete, commuting counterparts, QQQ and PPP , in such a way that mappings can be defined between conventional, quantum mechanical systems and deterministic, discrete systems. Here the foundations for such a scheme is suggested. An essential role is played by the Jacobi theta functions.
Most classical mechanical systems are based on dynamical variables whose values are real numbers. Energy conservation is then guaranteed if the dynamical equations are phrased in terms of a Hamiltonian function, which then leads to differential equations in the time variable. If these real dynamical variables are instead replaced by integers, and also the time variable is restricted to integers, it appears to be hard to enforce energy conservation unless one can also derive a Hamiltonian formalism for that case. We here show how the Hamiltonian formalism works here, and how it may yield the usual Hamilton equations in the continuum limit. The question was motivated by the author's investigations of special quantum systems that allow for a deterministic interpretation. The 'discrete Hamiltonian formalism' appears to shed new light on these approaches.
Without wasting time and effort on philosophical justifications and implications, we write down the conditions for the Hamiltonian of a quantum system for rendering it mathematically equivalent to a deterministic system. These are the equations to be considered. Special attention is given to the notion of `locality'. Various examples are worked out, followed by a systematic procedure to generate classical evolution laws and quantum Hamiltonians that are exactly equivalent. What is new here is that we consider interactions, keeping them as general as we can. The quantum systems found, form a dense set if we limit ourselves to sufficiently low energy states. The class is discrete, just because the set of deterministic models containing a finite number of classical states, is discrete. In contrast with earlier suspicions, the gravitational force turns out not to be needed for this; it suffices that the classical system act at a time scale much smaller than the inverse of the maximum scattering energies considered.
A synopsis is offered of the properties of discrete and integer-valued, hence "natural", cellular automata (CA). A particular class comprises the "Hamiltonian CA" with discrete updating rules that resemble Hamilton's equations. The resulting dynamics is linear like the unitary evolution described by the Schrödinger equation. Employing Shannon's Sampling Theorem, we construct an invertible map between such CA and continuous quantum mechanical models which incorporate a fundamental discreteness scale l . Consequently, there is a one-to-one correspondence of quantum mechanical and CA conservation laws. We discuss the important issue of linearity, recalling that nonlinearities imply nonlocal effects in the continuous quantum mechanical description of intrinsically local discrete CA - requiring locality entails linearity. The admissible CA observables and the existence of solutions of the l -dependent dispersion relation for stationary states are mentioned, besides the construction of multipartite CA obeying the Superposition Principle. We point out problems when trying to match the deterministic CA here to those envisioned in 't Hooft's CA Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics.
Cellular automata can show well known features of quantum mechanics, such as a linear rule according to which they evolve and which resembles a discretized version of the Schrödinger equation. This includes corresponding conservation laws. The class of "natural" Hamiltonian cellular automata is based exclusively on integer-valued variables and couplings and their dynamics derives from an Action Principle. They can be mapped reversibly to continuum models by applying Sampling Theory. Thus, "deformed" quantum mechanical models with a finite discreteness scale l are obtained, which for l → 0 reproduce familiar continuum results. We have recently demonstrated that such automata can form "multipartite" systems consistently with the tensor product structures of nonrelativistic many-body quantum mechanics, while interacting and maintaining the linear evolution. Consequently, the Superposition Principle fully applies for such primitive discrete deterministic automata and their composites and can produce the essential quantum effects of interference and entanglement.
In this paper, a formalism for quantization is developed which starts out from the Hamilton-Jacobi expression, $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}S}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}+H(\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}S}{\ensuremath{\partial}q}, q)$, and which leads to its usual quantum-mechanical operator equivalent by means of straightforward algebra. The quantum-mechanical operator equivalents of HHH and ppp are then seen to be the consequence of assigning a number of equally probable classical paths to a dynamical system.