Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

The Problem of Time

Andrea Rau

Published Sep 25, 2014• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Time – what it is and its nature – has from the beginning held mysteries for layman, philosopher, and physicist alike. Periodic phenomena from motions of heavenly bodies and pendulums to quantal atomic clocks provide the means to measure time intervals, and Newton’s absolute time is a background flow against which classical and non-relativistic quantum physics is played out. While internally consistent, these two fields of physics are incompatible with the requirement of treating space and time on an equal footing. Quantum field theories provide the answer, as both treated as parameters, physics residing instead in the states and operators. But even in classical physics and quantum mechanics, time-independent descriptions provide an alternative to an explicitly time-dependent one. These, including a general method of approach called invariant imbedding, are discussed as alternative representations of an underlying reality that is the concern of physics.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198709916.003.0007

Related papers

Wave with Self-Spacetime Creating Notion of Average Particle in Wave-Particle Duality?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

A quantum particle is often described as exhibiting dual particle-wave nature. A particle seems to be an object which obeys Newton’s laws/special relativity with a wave also being a phenomenon existing in Newtonian mechanics (special relativity). In other words the particle and wave are governed by x-t external variables which have infinite resolution. It was originally thought that x and t in addition to being external were absolute, but special relativity changed this idea. We have suggested in previous notes that a free quantum particle with energy E and momentum p creates its own space time i.e time intervals are proportional to 1/E and space to 1/p. This means no external clock is needed and different internal rulers and clocks exist for different E,p. It also suggests finite time and space intervals. In fact, an absolute is introduced namely A=0 = -Et+px with t and x being independent. This suggests that t→b/E and x→b/p. A is the free particle Lagrangian (both relativistic and nonrelativistic) with x and t being considered independent. Thus we suggest that the external x ruler and t clock of Newtonian mechanics represent an average of the internal picture and are also described by A, but with x/t=v and not x and t being treated as independent. In (1) we showed that having discrete x spacing with a running time (i.e. Netwon’s time variable) and insisting on spatial invariance leads to dA/dx partial = p. Thus instead of considering particle wave duality we suggest an underlying wave structure which creates its own spacetime intervals (1/E, 1/p), but may be mapped in certain situations to the external running x and t of Newton’s theory. For example, consider an electron (a quantum particle) with a fixed p moving over a distance much greater than its wavelength. It may be mapped to Newton’s external running x,t values with x=vt, but this is an average mapping into continuous x and t. In reality the situation is more complicated because there may be a Bohm-Aharonov effect occurring. Thus the underlying wave picture is in fact physically important and linked to interactions. Thus a self-ruler is not simply a measuring device - interactions may occur unlike in the case of the external ruler. Given that p defines a kind of spatial invariance approximated by a periodic function exp(ipx) (eigenfunction of -id/dx) and that Newton’s running time is not needed in a quantum bound state equilibrium, one may wonder what one should do in the case of a particle bound in a V(x) potential. In Newtonian mechanics V(x) suggests non-spatial invariance and v(x) velocity changes with x as well in contrast with exp(ipx) which is periodically invariant. In fact Newtonian mechanics (and Lagrangian/Hamiltonian as well) focus on d/dt i.e x(t). We have argued above that time intervals 1/E are independent of 1/p spatial ones. It may be noticed, however, that different p values lead to different wavelengths and so even though there is a kind of spatial invariance for each, when compared to each other this invariance is broken and superpositions of exp(ipx) may create local x probability densities. At the same they create spatial momentum densities because -d/dx (d/dx) 1/2m yields a kind of average kinetic energy when normalized. This seems to describe the x-p uncertainty relationship. In order to create spatial resolution (other than the built-in one in the wavelength) one needs to superpose different momenta, each of which are spatially invariant according to their periodic scheme exp(ipx). Thus one may create an average 1/2m <pp> and obtain a vrms. This may be described in terms of Newtonian external running x and t variables which have infinite resolution, but this vrms does not map to a physical state i.e to exp(i (mvrms) x) localized at x. Rather the various exp(ipx)’s which create vrms are the physical entities as may be seen by knocking a particle out of a bound state. The physical exp(ipx) momenta states have spatial invariance and so cannot be associated with a specific position in space. Only their superposition creates the notion of specific position in space, but then there is a distribution of p. This seems to be the basis for the x-p uncertainty principle. Thus we suggest that the particle of particle-wave duality is created through a mapping of a physical wave scenario to a continuous (infinite resolution) x-t scheme which in reality is an abstraction because each p,E free particle state has it sown internal clock-ruler i.e. 1/E and 1/p time and space units. Given that 1/E and 1/p have finite values the idea of dt and dx tending to 0 only makes sense as an abstraction which only holds in certain situations.

•Nov 2, 2022•0 citations

Time?

Richard L. Amoroso

The concept of time in the ‘clockwork’ Newtonian world was irrelevant; and has generally been ignored until recently by several generations of physicists since the implementation of quantum mechanics. We will set aside the utility of time as a property relating to physical calculations of events relating to a metrics line element or as an aspect of the transformation of a particles motion/interaction in a coordinate system or in relation to thermodynamics etc., i.e. we will discard all the usual uses of time as a concept used to circularly define physical parameters in terms of other physical parameters; concentrating instead on time as an aspect of the fundamental cosmic topology of our virtual reality especially as it inseparably relates to the nature and role of the observer in natural science.

International Symposium Honoring Mathematical Physicist Jean-Pierre Vigier•Oct 16, 2013•0 citations

BECOMING AS A BRIDGE BETWEEN QUANTUM MECHANICS AND RELATIVITY

Avshalom C. Elitzur, Shahar Dolev

Time’s apparent “flow” is often dismissed in physical theory. We propose to take it as a real property of reality and show how the addition of this assumption to physics’ prevailing postulate yields a new framework within which relativity and quantum theories are in harmony with one another.

Endophysics, Time, Quantum and the Subjective•Oct 1, 2005•24 citations

The Holomorphic Quantum: A Systems Approach to Understanding the Nature of Reality

Theodore J. St. John

Quantum Mechanics is appropriately named because it is mostly about the mechanics of working out probability problems as they apply to the mysterious effect of measurement that makes energy present as quantum particle-waves. It is easy to visualize a quantum particle but there seems to be no way to visualize a “probability wave” so there has never been a clear interpretation of what quantum physics tells us – or should tell us – about the underlying essence of reality. Fortunately, a new approach was discovered and proven to work in biology that treats the mystery of life like a locking system and provides not only the key, but also the keyhole and the direction in which to turn it. In this paper the systems approach is introduced, including some background information on the history of how the systems approach has integrated elements of substance philosophy with process philosophy and has become a powerful tool for use in science. Here, it is applied to physics and used to represent the transformation of implicit energy into an explicit space-time quantum domain superimposed on a relativistic time-space background. These two “products” are then correlated with two of four blocks in a basic control-system diagram (input and output) commonly used in control-systems engineering. (The four blocks are input, transfer function, output and feedback function) Because they are explicit, they can be drawn explicitly on the space versus time plot as a map of motion. We emphasize that this is a map – an explicit projection of an implicit function (in this case, a plot of space versus time is a projection of the variance we call motion) represented as an implicit domain (a perpendicular dimension). We recognizing that a feedback function is equivalent to and therefore implies a back-projection or reflection back “up” into that “implicate order.” These two implicit functions (projection and reflection) are then correlated with the transfer function and feedback function in the control system. The motion function is related to the probability wave by the name used in statistics – the “variance” of a statistical distribution – and we point out that each axis of the space-time domain is scaled by standard “deviations,” which define the explicit scales. Because a standard deviation is the square root of a variance, the square space that maps as a relativistic scalar plot (a standard Cartesian coordinate system) of space versus time or “space-time” actually represents one of two square roots of the implicit variance we call motion. In essence, our measurements of this domain keep us rooted in physical reality. However, this coordinate system is shown to be just the root – one part of a “whole system” that includes a non-physical implicit feedback function. The feedback function is correlated with the “reflection” of the explicit domain, i.e. inverse-space and inverse-time, presented as a phase space called time-space and represented as a unit of spatial frequency versus temporal frequency. These frequency representations are shown to be the two well-known equations for quantum energy from quantum mechanics and they are used to identify energy-space as “the quantum domain” inside of, or superimposed on the background “relativistic domain,” which is a scalar space. These two domains are then shown to be coupled at the point where both scales are equal to “1”. As a whole, and in the language of quantum field theory, this model is a graphical representation of an energy-momentum tensor and as a visual model, it provides a clear conceptual interpretation of complexity theory, in which reality is expressed as the superposition of a self-organizing control system that convolves with a dissipative open system or “sea of disorder” and transforms it into physical units of order. This “holomorphic systems approach” is similar to, but much simpler and visually illustrative than the mathematically rigorous discussion On Symmetry and the Reality of Holomorphic Hartree–Fock Wavefunctions [1] or the Kohn-Sham Density Functional Theory [2]. Furthermore, it reveals that the question about the beginning of time is a question fallacy, by representing the equivalence of space and time as S=Tc2, and presents it geometrically to be the exact same relation as the mass-energy equivalence equation E=mc2. The model also reveals that quantized energy (which Huynh and Thom refer to as self-consistent fields or SCF) projects as a characteristic and allows one to visualize the solution to the particle-wave duality “problem” as being a change in perspective. It’s the change in perspective that makes the particle-like property and wave-like property appear as “emergent” – analogous to what would appear when one visualizes an object from two different perspectives – at rest with respect to one’s own body yet in motion relative to some other “moving” body. The approach also reveals how the transfer function and feedback function act to transform matter, adding the fourth component (the Controller) and making it a complete control system: a self-organizing, self-sensing system that can see itself explicitly and reflect upon itself implicitly. How that correlates with living systems becomes obvious.

Book Publisher International (a part of SCIENCEDOMAIN International)•Aug 24, 2021•0 citations

Revisiting the Nature of Time: A Unified Perspective Across Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Waheed Sabry

Journal of Engineering Advances and Technologies for Sustainable Applications•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

NOTES ON THE THEORY OF QUANTUM CLOCK

Igor E. Tralle, Juha-Pekka Pellonpää

In this paper we argue that the notion of time, whatever complicated and difficult to define as the philosophical cat-egory, from physicist’s point of view is nothing else but the sum of ’lapses of time ’ measured by a proper clock. As far as Quantum Mechanics is concerned, we distinguish a special class of clocks, the ’atomic clocks’. It is because at atomic and subatomic level there is no other possibility to construct a ’unit of time ’ or ’instant of time ’ as to use the quantum transitions between chosen quantum states of a quantum ob-ject such as atoms, atomic nuclei and so on, to imitate the periodic circular motion of a clock hand over the dial. The clock synchronization problem is also discussed in the paper. We study the problem of defining a time difference observable for two-mode oscillator system. We assume that the time dif-ference obsevable is the difference of two single-mode covariant Concepts of Physics, Vol. II (2005) 113 time observables which are represented as a time shift covari-ant normalized positive operator measures. The difficulty of finding the correct value space and normalization for time dif-ference is discussed. 114 Concepts of Physics, Vol. II (2005) Notes on the Theory of Quantum Clock And the heaven departed as a scroll when it is rolled together;... And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and earth and the things that therein, and the sea, and the things which are therein, that THERE SHOULD

•Jan 1, 2005•1 citation
Time – what it is and its nature – has from the beginning held mysteries for layman, philosopher, and physicist alike. Periodic phenomena from motions of heavenly bodies and pendulums to quantal atomic clocks provide the means to measure time intervals, and Newton’s absolute time is a background flow against which classical and non-relativistic quantum physics is played out. While internally consistent, these two fields of physics are incompatible with the requirement of treating space and time on an equal footing. Quantum field theories provide the answer, as both treated as parameters, physics residing instead in the states and operators. But even in classical physics and quantum mechanics, time-independent descriptions provide an alternative to an explicitly time-dependent one. These, including a general method of approach called invariant imbedding, are discussed as alternative representations of an underlying reality that is the concern of physics.
A quantum particle is often described as exhibiting dual particle-wave nature. A particle seems to be an object which obeys Newton’s laws/special relativity with a wave also being a phenomenon existing in Newtonian mechanics (special relativity). In other words the particle and wave are governed by x-t external variables which have infinite resolution. It was originally thought that x and t in addition to being external were absolute, but special relativity changed this idea. We have suggested in previous notes that a free quantum particle with energy E and momentum p creates its own space time i.e time intervals are proportional to 1/E and space to 1/p. This means no external clock is needed and different internal rulers and clocks exist for different E,p. It also suggests finite time and space intervals. In fact, an absolute is introduced namely A=0 = -Et+px with t and x being independent. This suggests that t→b/E and x→b/p. A is the free particle Lagrangian (both relativistic and nonrelativistic) with x and t being considered independent. Thus we suggest that the external x ruler and t clock of Newtonian mechanics represent an average of the internal picture and are also described by A, but with x/t=v and not x and t being treated as independent. In (1) we showed that having discrete x spacing with a running time (i.e. Netwon’s time variable) and insisting on spatial invariance leads to dA/dx partial = p. Thus instead of considering particle wave duality we suggest an underlying wave structure which creates its own spacetime intervals (1/E, 1/p), but may be mapped in certain situations to the external running x and t of Newton’s theory. For example, consider an electron (a quantum particle) with a fixed p moving over a distance much greater than its wavelength. It may be mapped to Newton’s external running x,t values with x=vt, but this is an average mapping into continuous x and t. In reality the situation is more complicated because there may be a Bohm-Aharonov effect occurring. Thus the underlying wave picture is in fact physically important and linked to interactions. Thus a self-ruler is not simply a measuring device - interactions may occur unlike in the case of the external ruler. Given that p defines a kind of spatial invariance approximated by a periodic function exp(ipx) (eigenfunction of -id/dx) and that Newton’s running time is not needed in a quantum bound state equilibrium, one may wonder what one should do in the case of a particle bound in a V(x) potential. In Newtonian mechanics V(x) suggests non-spatial invariance and v(x) velocity changes with x as well in contrast with exp(ipx) which is periodically invariant. In fact Newtonian mechanics (and Lagrangian/Hamiltonian as well) focus on d/dt i.e x(t). We have argued above that time intervals 1/E are independent of 1/p spatial ones. It may be noticed, however, that different p values lead to different wavelengths and so even though there is a kind of spatial invariance for each, when compared to each other this invariance is broken and superpositions of exp(ipx) may create local x probability densities. At the same they create spatial momentum densities because -d/dx (d/dx) 1/2m yields a kind of average kinetic energy when normalized. This seems to describe the x-p uncertainty relationship. In order to create spatial resolution (other than the built-in one in the wavelength) one needs to superpose different momenta, each of which are spatially invariant according to their periodic scheme exp(ipx). Thus one may create an average 1/2m <pp> and obtain a vrms. This may be described in terms of Newtonian external running x and t variables which have infinite resolution, but this vrms does not map to a physical state i.e to exp(i (mvrms) x) localized at x. Rather the various exp(ipx)’s which create vrms are the physical entities as may be seen by knocking a particle out of a bound state. The physical exp(ipx) momenta states have spatial invariance and so cannot be associated with a specific position in space. Only their superposition creates the notion of specific position in space, but then there is a distribution of p. This seems to be the basis for the x-p uncertainty principle. Thus we suggest that the particle of particle-wave duality is created through a mapping of a physical wave scenario to a continuous (infinite resolution) x-t scheme which in reality is an abstraction because each p,E free particle state has it sown internal clock-ruler i.e. 1/E and 1/p time and space units. Given that 1/E and 1/p have finite values the idea of dt and dx tending to 0 only makes sense as an abstraction which only holds in certain situations.
The concept of time in the ‘clockwork’ Newtonian world was irrelevant; and has generally been ignored until recently by several generations of physicists since the implementation of quantum mechanics. We will set aside the utility of time as a property relating to physical calculations of events relating to a metrics line element or as an aspect of the transformation of a particles motion/interaction in a coordinate system or in relation to thermodynamics etc., i.e. we will discard all the usual uses of time as a concept used to circularly define physical parameters in terms of other physical parameters; concentrating instead on time as an aspect of the fundamental cosmic topology of our virtual reality especially as it inseparably relates to the nature and role of the observer in natural science.
Quantum Mechanics is appropriately named because it is mostly about the mechanics of working out probability problems as they apply to the mysterious effect of measurement that makes energy present as quantum particle-waves. It is easy to visualize a quantum particle but there seems to be no way to visualize a “probability wave” so there has never been a clear interpretation of what quantum physics tells us – or should tell us – about the underlying essence of reality. Fortunately, a new approach was discovered and proven to work in biology that treats the mystery of life like a locking system and provides not only the key, but also the keyhole and the direction in which to turn it. In this paper the systems approach is introduced, including some background information on the history of how the systems approach has integrated elements of substance philosophy with process philosophy and has become a powerful tool for use in science. Here, it is applied to physics and used to represent the transformation of implicit energy into an explicit space-time quantum domain superimposed on a relativistic time-space background. These two “products” are then correlated with two of four blocks in a basic control-system diagram (input and output) commonly used in control-systems engineering. (The four blocks are input, transfer function, output and feedback function) Because they are explicit, they can be drawn explicitly on the space versus time plot as a map of motion. We emphasize that this is a map – an explicit projection of an implicit function (in this case, a plot of space versus time is a projection of the variance we call motion) represented as an implicit domain (a perpendicular dimension). We recognizing that a feedback function is equivalent to and therefore implies a back-projection or reflection back “up” into that “implicate order.” These two implicit functions (projection and reflection) are then correlated with the transfer function and feedback function in the control system. The motion function is related to the probability wave by the name used in statistics – the “variance” of a statistical distribution – and we point out that each axis of the space-time domain is scaled by standard “deviations,” which define the explicit scales. Because a standard deviation is the square root of a variance, the square space that maps as a relativistic scalar plot (a standard Cartesian coordinate system) of space versus time or “space-time” actually represents one of two square roots of the implicit variance we call motion. In essence, our measurements of this domain keep us rooted in physical reality. However, this coordinate system is shown to be just the root – one part of a “whole system” that includes a non-physical implicit feedback function. The feedback function is correlated with the “reflection” of the explicit domain, i.e. inverse-space and inverse-time, presented as a phase space called time-space and represented as a unit of spatial frequency versus temporal frequency. These frequency representations are shown to be the two well-known equations for quantum energy from quantum mechanics and they are used to identify energy-space as “the quantum domain” inside of, or superimposed on the background “relativistic domain,” which is a scalar space. These two domains are then shown to be coupled at the point where both scales are equal to “1”. As a whole, and in the language of quantum field theory, this model is a graphical representation of an energy-momentum tensor and as a visual model, it provides a clear conceptual interpretation of complexity theory, in which reality is expressed as the superposition of a self-organizing control system that convolves with a dissipative open system or “sea of disorder” and transforms it into physical units of order. This “holomorphic systems approach” is similar to, but much simpler and visually illustrative than the mathematically rigorous discussion On Symmetry and the Reality of Holomorphic Hartree–Fock Wavefunctions [1] or the Kohn-Sham Density Functional Theory [2]. Furthermore, it reveals that the question about the beginning of time is a question fallacy, by representing the equivalence of space and time as S=Tc2, and presents it geometrically to be the exact same relation as the mass-energy equivalence equation E=mc2. The model also reveals that quantized energy (which Huynh and Thom refer to as self-consistent fields or SCF) projects as a characteristic and allows one to visualize the solution to the particle-wave duality “problem” as being a change in perspective. It’s the change in perspective that makes the particle-like property and wave-like property appear as “emergent” – analogous to what would appear when one visualizes an object from two different perspectives – at rest with respect to one’s own body yet in motion relative to some other “moving” body. The approach also reveals how the transfer function and feedback function act to transform matter, adding the fourth component (the Controller) and making it a complete control system: a self-organizing, self-sensing system that can see itself explicitly and reflect upon itself implicitly. How that correlates with living systems becomes obvious.
In this paper we argue that the notion of time, whatever complicated and difficult to define as the philosophical cat-egory, from physicist’s point of view is nothing else but the sum of ’lapses of time ’ measured by a proper clock. As far as Quantum Mechanics is concerned, we distinguish a special class of clocks, the ’atomic clocks’. It is because at atomic and subatomic level there is no other possibility to construct a ’unit of time ’ or ’instant of time ’ as to use the quantum transitions between chosen quantum states of a quantum ob-ject such as atoms, atomic nuclei and so on, to imitate the periodic circular motion of a clock hand over the dial. The clock synchronization problem is also discussed in the paper. We study the problem of defining a time difference observable for two-mode oscillator system. We assume that the time dif-ference obsevable is the difference of two single-mode covariant Concepts of Physics, Vol. II (2005) 113 time observables which are represented as a time shift covari-ant normalized positive operator measures. The difficulty of finding the correct value space and normalization for time dif-ference is discussed. 114 Concepts of Physics, Vol. II (2005) Notes on the Theory of Quantum Clock And the heaven departed as a scroll when it is rolled together;... And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and earth and the things that therein, and the sea, and the things which are therein, that THERE SHOULD