Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Quantum-Classical Correspondence and Quantum Chaos

Wei-Min Zhang, D.H. Feng, Jian‐Min Yuan

Published Sep 1, 1992• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In this article, a theory which we have recently developed is reviewed. This theory addresses the long standing problem of quantum-classical correspondence. It begins with the axiomatic structure of quantum mechanics, from which the basic concept of dynamical degrees of freedom emerges and the associated physical geometry of an arbitrary quantum system is constructed. Such a geometrical space possesses both complex and symplectic structures, the two basic ingredients to guarantee the rigorous correspondence between quantum and classical kinematics. Also, it is remarkable that the quantum-classical correspondence of dynamics can be mediated by a quenched index obtained from the geometry. The intermediate stage from quantum to classical dynamics is described by the semiquantal dynamics. The main property of the semiquantal dynamics is that it manifests the effect of quantum fluctuation on classical trajectories, and quantum fluctuation depends explicitly on the quenched index. This offers a way to study “chaos in quantum systems”. We also prove a theorem which links dynamical symmetry and quantum integrability, and conclude that “quantum chaos” is related to dynamical symmetry breaking. The generic rule of quantum chaos is explored. Throughout the article, many basic quantum systems are used to illustrate these important points.

DOI
10.1142/9789812833167_0002

Related papers

Integrability and chaos in quantum systems (as viewed from geometry and dynamical symmetry)

Wei-Min Zhang, D.H. Feng

It is known that the development and deep understanding of modern interaction theory and classical mechanics are made through geometry and symmetry. Yet, quantum mechanics which was regarded to be the microscopic theory of classical mechanics and achieved the crowning success in interpreting the entire microscopic world was developed purely from algebraic methods. In this thesis, we will study the geometry and dynamical symmetry in quantum systems, from which the question of integrability and chaos are explicitly addressed. First of all, the quantum dynamical degrees of freedom and quantum integrability are precisely defined and the inherent geometrical structure of quantum systems is explored from the fundamental structure of quantum theory. Such a geometrical structure can provide a framework to simultaneously build quantum and classical mechanics. The quantum-classical correspondence is then explicitly deduced. The dynamics of quantum system before it reaches the classical limit is formulated. Thus, the classical chaos is proven to be a special limiting phenomena of quantum systems and the dynamics before the system reaches its classical chaos is explored. The latter is the first step to seek the quantum manifestation of chaos. The relationship between integrability and dynamical symmetry are studied and some universal properties are discovered: a dynamical system (both quantum and classical) is integrable if it possesses a dynamical symmetry. Chaos will occur if the system undergoes a dynamical symmetry breaking and is accompanied by a structural phase transition. Thus, the concept of dynamical symmetry can be used to predict the general behaviors of a system. The theoretical underpinnings developed in this thesis are verified by many basic quantum mechanical examples. In the second part, we have applied the theory to construct the geometrical description for fermionic systems and then use this general formulation to study the geometrical properties, integrability and chaos in nuclear collective motions. The study of geometry for the fermion systems clearly show how the pure quantum properties (e.g. Pauli principle) are exhibited in geometry and how these geometrical manifestations can interpret experimental facts in nuclear collective motion (e.g. the satiation of nuclear deformation and narrow oblate window). The dynamical symmetry and dynamical symmetry breaking in nuclear collective motion are extensively studied.

•Nov 1, 1989•2 citations

Hamiltonian Chaos

Steven Tomsovic

Through semiclassical methods the subject of quantum chaos motivates and depends on Hamiltonian chaos research. Presented here is a selection of some of the most important Hamiltonian chaos topics that in this way get directly related to any of a variety of quantum chaos research problems. The overall emphasis is on intuitive explanations and illustrations of various ideas with the references containing more mathematically rigorous expositions. The chapter begins with a description of various useful theoretical and computational tools of chaos research, e.g.~surfaces of section, paradigms of chaos, stability analysis, and symbolic dynamics... This is followed by discussions regarding the geometry of chaos, how chaotic systems respond to perturbations, and the complexification of Hamiltonian dynamics. Most of the contents concern topics that are long established and well known by now. The exceptions involve complications that arise from the complexification of phase space variables and time. There are relatively recent results summarized regarding the appropriate branches of determinant phases and how to distinguish complex trajectories that are associated with classically allowed processes versus those associated with non-allowed ones.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12976•Apr 15, 2026

Quantum fluctuations in classical chaos

Wei-Min Zhang, Jian‐Min Yuan, D.H. Feng +2 more

The effects of quantum fluctuation on the classical dynamical structure are investigated by using the semiquantal dynamics derived from the effective action. A pulsed-spin system is studied as an example, which shows that global chaos is suppressed by quantum fluctuation. The quantum-classical correspondence is explicitly examined for low-spin cases.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1990•11 citations

Hamiltonian Chaos III

Niraj Srivastava, Charles Kaufman, Gerhard H. Muller

Does quantum chaos exist?If it exists, what is it?If it does not, what was it supposed to have been?Why should we associate chaos with a "third revolution in physics" if it fails to be expressible in terms of quantum mechanics, our most fundamental theory of physical reality?Is there something wrong with quantum mechanics?Or is chaos merely a mathematical construct relevant only for models in classical mechanics?Is the human mind doomed to interpret and understand quantum mechanics in classical terms?The list of unanswered questions in quantum chaos research itself shows symptoms of the phenomenon it attempts to grasp. 1 How do we recognize classical Hamiltonian chaos?We have dealt with this question in our two previous columns.2,3 In Part I we discussed the implications of integrability and non-integrability for the phase-space trajectories of classical Hamiltonian systems with two degrees of freedom.We described the method of Poincaré surfaces of section as a convenient and striking discriminant between the two possibilities.In Part II we searched for an alternate mode of representation for classical Hamiltonian systems, a mode that is an equally powerful indicator of chaos, but one that can be more directly translated into quantum mechanics than the Poincaré map.We proposed a representation based on the construction of classical invariants via time averages of dynamical variables, a representation that can be employed under very general circumstances including integrable and nonintegrable models.In this column we shall construct quantum invariants, demonstrate the impact of non-integrability on these quantities, and discuss their properties in relation to their classical counterparts.In a future column we intend to introduce quantum Poincaré surfaces of section for stationary states and bring full circle our survey of quantum and classical Hamiltonian chaos.Consider a quantized integrable model.Its eigenstates are labeled by quantum numbers.There are as many quantum numbers as there are degrees of freedom.Each quantum number represents a quantized action.In the still evolving language of quantum chaos, quantum numbers are said to have been "lost" in the transition from a quantum system whose classical counterpart is integrable to one whose counterpart is chaotic.The broken, or lost, tori of classical chaos become lost quantum numbers of quantum chaos.As we shall see, the loss of quantum numbers is vividly mirrored in the behavior of the quantum invariants.We begin by describing the construction of the quantum invariants for a

Computers in Physics•Jan 1, 1992•3 citations

Quantum-classical Correspondence of Regular Motion of Integrable Systems and Related Problems

Gong-ou Xu

Based on the dynamical symmetry group characterizing the integrability of classical as well as quantum mechanics, quantum dynamics with proper initial conditions was genuinely formulated, and analytical solutions in the form of soliton-like state evolving around a certain invariant torus were obtained. It has been shown that, in case the intrinsic size of the evolving quantum state is significantly smaller than the extent of its evolving orbit, the motion can be satisfactorily treated with classical approximation. Having demonstrated the quantum-classical correspondence of regular motion, the possibility to study quantum chaos on the basis dynamical symmetry breaking was briefly discussed.

Yuanzihe wuli pinglun•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

Dynamical Symmetry Breaking and Quantum Nonintegrability

Wei-Min Zhang, Craig C. Martens, D.H. Feng +1 more

In this Letter, we describe the connection between the classical concepts of nonintegrability and chaos and the quantum concept of dynamical symmetry breaking. The existence of unbroken dynamical symmetry implies integrability of the mean-field motion in a quantum phase space, defined as a symplectic coherent-state parametrization of the coset space of the overall dynamical group. Broken dynamical symmetry leads to nonintegrability, and thus chaotic solutions to Hamilton's equations in the quantum phase space. We illustrate the general ideas with results obtained for a model of two coupled spins.

Physical Review Letters•Nov 7, 1988•39 citations
In this article, a theory which we have recently developed is reviewed. This theory addresses the long standing problem of quantum-classical correspondence. It begins with the axiomatic structure of quantum mechanics, from which the basic concept of dynamical degrees of freedom emerges and the associated physical geometry of an arbitrary quantum system is constructed. Such a geometrical space possesses both complex and symplectic structures, the two basic ingredients to guarantee the rigorous correspondence between quantum and classical kinematics. Also, it is remarkable that the quantum-classical correspondence of dynamics can be mediated by a quenched index obtained from the geometry. The intermediate stage from quantum to classical dynamics is described by the semiquantal dynamics. The main property of the semiquantal dynamics is that it manifests the effect of quantum fluctuation on classical trajectories, and quantum fluctuation depends explicitly on the quenched index. This offers a way to study “chaos in quantum systems”. We also prove a theorem which links dynamical symmetry and quantum integrability, and conclude that “quantum chaos” is related to dynamical symmetry breaking. The generic rule of quantum chaos is explored. Throughout the article, many basic quantum systems are used to illustrate these important points.
It is known that the development and deep understanding of modern interaction theory and classical mechanics are made through geometry and symmetry. Yet, quantum mechanics which was regarded to be the microscopic theory of classical mechanics and achieved the crowning success in interpreting the entire microscopic world was developed purely from algebraic methods. In this thesis, we will study the geometry and dynamical symmetry in quantum systems, from which the question of integrability and chaos are explicitly addressed. First of all, the quantum dynamical degrees of freedom and quantum integrability are precisely defined and the inherent geometrical structure of quantum systems is explored from the fundamental structure of quantum theory. Such a geometrical structure can provide a framework to simultaneously build quantum and classical mechanics. The quantum-classical correspondence is then explicitly deduced. The dynamics of quantum system before it reaches the classical limit is formulated. Thus, the classical chaos is proven to be a special limiting phenomena of quantum systems and the dynamics before the system reaches its classical chaos is explored. The latter is the first step to seek the quantum manifestation of chaos. The relationship between integrability and dynamical symmetry are studied and some universal properties are discovered: a dynamical system (both quantum and classical) is integrable if it possesses a dynamical symmetry. Chaos will occur if the system undergoes a dynamical symmetry breaking and is accompanied by a structural phase transition. Thus, the concept of dynamical symmetry can be used to predict the general behaviors of a system. The theoretical underpinnings developed in this thesis are verified by many basic quantum mechanical examples. In the second part, we have applied the theory to construct the geometrical description for fermionic systems and then use this general formulation to study the geometrical properties, integrability and chaos in nuclear collective motions. The study of geometry for the fermion systems clearly show how the pure quantum properties (e.g. Pauli principle) are exhibited in geometry and how these geometrical manifestations can interpret experimental facts in nuclear collective motion (e.g. the satiation of nuclear deformation and narrow oblate window). The dynamical symmetry and dynamical symmetry breaking in nuclear collective motion are extensively studied.
Through semiclassical methods the subject of quantum chaos motivates and depends on Hamiltonian chaos research. Presented here is a selection of some of the most important Hamiltonian chaos topics that in this way get directly related to any of a variety of quantum chaos research problems. The overall emphasis is on intuitive explanations and illustrations of various ideas with the references containing more mathematically rigorous expositions. The chapter begins with a description of various useful theoretical and computational tools of chaos research, e.g.~surfaces of section, paradigms of chaos, stability analysis, and symbolic dynamics... This is followed by discussions regarding the geometry of chaos, how chaotic systems respond to perturbations, and the complexification of Hamiltonian dynamics. Most of the contents concern topics that are long established and well known by now. The exceptions involve complications that arise from the complexification of phase space variables and time. There are relatively recent results summarized regarding the appropriate branches of determinant phases and how to distinguish complex trajectories that are associated with classically allowed processes versus those associated with non-allowed ones.
Does quantum chaos exist?If it exists, what is it?If it does not, what was it supposed to have been?Why should we associate chaos with a "third revolution in physics" if it fails to be expressible in terms of quantum mechanics, our most fundamental theory of physical reality?Is there something wrong with quantum mechanics?Or is chaos merely a mathematical construct relevant only for models in classical mechanics?Is the human mind doomed to interpret and understand quantum mechanics in classical terms?The list of unanswered questions in quantum chaos research itself shows symptoms of the phenomenon it attempts to grasp. 1 How do we recognize classical Hamiltonian chaos?We have dealt with this question in our two previous columns.2,3 In Part I we discussed the implications of integrability and non-integrability for the phase-space trajectories of classical Hamiltonian systems with two degrees of freedom.We described the method of Poincaré surfaces of section as a convenient and striking discriminant between the two possibilities.In Part II we searched for an alternate mode of representation for classical Hamiltonian systems, a mode that is an equally powerful indicator of chaos, but one that can be more directly translated into quantum mechanics than the Poincaré map.We proposed a representation based on the construction of classical invariants via time averages of dynamical variables, a representation that can be employed under very general circumstances including integrable and nonintegrable models.In this column we shall construct quantum invariants, demonstrate the impact of non-integrability on these quantities, and discuss their properties in relation to their classical counterparts.In a future column we intend to introduce quantum Poincaré surfaces of section for stationary states and bring full circle our survey of quantum and classical Hamiltonian chaos.Consider a quantized integrable model.Its eigenstates are labeled by quantum numbers.There are as many quantum numbers as there are degrees of freedom.Each quantum number represents a quantized action.In the still evolving language of quantum chaos, quantum numbers are said to have been "lost" in the transition from a quantum system whose classical counterpart is integrable to one whose counterpart is chaotic.The broken, or lost, tori of classical chaos become lost quantum numbers of quantum chaos.As we shall see, the loss of quantum numbers is vividly mirrored in the behavior of the quantum invariants.We begin by describing the construction of the quantum invariants for a
Based on the dynamical symmetry group characterizing the integrability of classical as well as quantum mechanics, quantum dynamics with proper initial conditions was genuinely formulated, and analytical solutions in the form of soliton-like state evolving around a certain invariant torus were obtained. It has been shown that, in case the intrinsic size of the evolving quantum state is significantly smaller than the extent of its evolving orbit, the motion can be satisfactorily treated with classical approximation. Having demonstrated the quantum-classical correspondence of regular motion, the possibility to study quantum chaos on the basis dynamical symmetry breaking was briefly discussed.
In this Letter, we describe the connection between the classical concepts of nonintegrability and chaos and the quantum concept of dynamical symmetry breaking. The existence of unbroken dynamical symmetry implies integrability of the mean-field motion in a quantum phase space, defined as a symplectic coherent-state parametrization of the coset space of the overall dynamical group. Broken dynamical symmetry leads to nonintegrability, and thus chaotic solutions to Hamilton's equations in the quantum phase space. We illustrate the general ideas with results obtained for a model of two coupled spins.