World Scientific series in 20th century physics
Paper 6.5: "Complementarity with Neutron Two-Path Interferences and Separated-Oscillatory-Field Resonances," N. F. Ramsey, Phys. Rev. A48, 80–82 (1993)
Abstract
At a conference honoring Y. Aharonov, I was urged to present a paper on my work with Wendell Furry (Paper 6.2) that had played such a major role in convincing the skeptical physics community of the validity of the original Aharonov–Bohm theory. However, I was reluctant to do so, since the field was far from my usual research. I then realized I might be able to develop analogous theorems for electrically neutral particles and for the sharp interference pattern with the separated oscillatory fields method. In Paper 6.5, I showed that in a neutron beam magnetic resonance experiment one can design an apparatus to determine the orientation state of the neutron in the intermediate region between the two oscillatory fields. However, if one does such an experiment, just as the sensitivity is good enough to determine the orientation state, the neutron resonance becomes sufficiently blurred by the Aharonov–Casher effect that a sharp interference pattern is no longer observable. This loss of the sharp resonance is analogous to the loss of the two-slit interference pattern in the AB effect. Although the two cases are analogous, there is an important difference. In the separated oscillatory fields method with a neutron spin there is a clear physical meaning to the linear superposition of states with spin up and spin down; it corresponds to a state with angular momentum orthogonal to the original orientations. As a result, the separated oscillatory fields method can be described classically by saying that in the first oscillatory field the spin vector is flipped π/2 radians, and if it precesses in the intermediate region by the same amount as the oscillator oscillates, the second oscillatory field will induce a similar π/2 rotation, giving rise to a sharp narrow resonance. Such an explanation is not possible with an electron two-slit experiment, since there is no classical analog of an electron being a superposition of two position states. The difference arises from the angular momentum being a three-dimensional vector so that a linear superposition of a spin up and a spin down state is a state of orthogonal angular momentum.