Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

The measurement problem in quantum mechanics

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

Published Apr 16, 2009• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In most textbooks, measurement does not receive the full attention it deserves and sometimes is even not treated at all, apart a brief and cryptic mention of the “reduction of the wave packet.” However, in the last decades, the situation has profoundly changed and it is time to consider measurement a fundamental part of quantum mechanics, even, to a certain extent, an important generalization of the traditional theory (see also Chs. 14–15). This chapter consists of three major parts. In the first block (Secs. 9.1–9.4) we develop the main physical features of the measurement process: the heart of the argument is here represented by the aspects related to the interpretation. In the second part (Secs. 9.5–9.8) we discuss several special (and partly interdependent) topics of measurement: the heart here is represented by experimental aspects. In the third part (Secs. 9.9–9.12) we deal with the measurement process on a more formal plane, making use, in particular, of the generalization represented by the concepts of effect and positive operator valued measure (POVM). As we have said, the measurement problem is one of the most fundamental issues in the conceptual structure of quantum mechanics (as described in Sec. 9.1) and has a long history that will be examined in Sec. 9.2. In this context, the existence of apparently paradoxical quantum states comes about: the so-called Schrödinger cat states (see Sec. 9.3).

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511813955.010

Related papers

MEASUREMENT PROBLEM

The fourth part handles the first thematic area of the book and probably the most important part of the theory: the measurement problem. • First we examine some basic concepts [ chapter 13 ]. • Then we reconstruct von Neumann's original proposal and its refinements [ chapter 14 ]. Von Neumann was the first to assume a dichotomy between two different types of evolutions: the unitary one and the measurement process. On this matter, different positions have been developed: • there are those who have accepted such a dichotomy and tried to assign a fundamental function to the consciousness (after von Neumann: London, Bauer, Wigner): this is the content of chapter 14 ; • some have tried to eliminate the jump-like features of the measurement by rejecting the projection postulate (Margenau, Ballentine, Everett, deWitt); this is the content of chapter 15 ; • others have tried to explain measurement in terms of intervention of macrosystems: either as a limiting case of a thermodynamical evolution (Green, van Hove and others) or using SSRs for obtaining the required classical behaviour of the pointer: this is the issue in chapter 16 ; • there are those who have tried to find some ad hoc parameters in order to explain the reduction (Ghirardi/Rimini/Weber): this will be treated later in chapter 23 , because the proposal will account more generally for spontaneous transitions to localisation, and hence it is more like a theory of the relation between microphysics and macrophysics; • others have developed a form of non-unitary evolution by using the specific nature of open systems: this is the theory of decoherence (Zurek, Cini, Machida/Namiki, among others), which is treated in chapter 17 . It is quit astonishing that measurement theory has led to so many different positions and that, consequently, for fifty years has been a problematic area of QM. The reasons will be briefly discussed in subsection 14.1.1. The last three chapters of this part are devoted to new developments which partly extend and integrate the theory of decoherence. • The operational approach [ chapter 18 ] represents a formal generalization of the quantum theory of open systems. • Chapter 19 is dedicated to the Quantum Non-demolition Measurement. The last two chapters contain results which are generally valid and neutral with respect to a particular interpretation. Anyway, their importance for QM (and partly also for some interpretational problems) justifies the place they occupy here. • Finally we investigate a new field of research which has very interesting interpretational implications and a lot of technological consequences: the so-called interaction-free measurements [ chapter 20 ]. In the following we shall use the word ‘Measurement’ to mean the measurement process in general, while the word ‘measurement’ always indicates a particular measurement process.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 2000•0 citations

The measurement problem in quantum mechanics

Alessio Giuseppe Ferraioli, Canio Noce

In this paper, we discuss the importance of measurement in quantum mechanics and the so-called measurement problem. Any quantum system can be described as a linear combination of eigenstates of an operator representing a physical quantity; this means that the system can be in a superposition of states that corresponds to different eigenvalues, i.e., different physical outcomes, each one incompatible with the others. The measurement process converts a state of superposition (not macroscopically defined) in a well-defined state. We show that, if we describe the measurement by the standard laws of quantum mechanics, the system would preserve its state of superposition even on a macroscopic scale. Since this is not the case, we assume that a measurement does not obey to standard quantum mechanics, but to a new set of laws that form a “quantum measurement theory”.

Science & philosophy•Jun 1, 2019•4 citations

Change without time. Relationalism and field quantization

Johannes Simon

The nature of time has long been debated in human history and nowadays is considered of central importance for understanding quantum gravity. We focus on and advocate the relational concept of time, which was put forward in the 17th century in opposition to Newton's absolute time, and only in 1990 explored in a quantum mechanical framework by Carlo Rovelli. After a historical introduction the mathematical models of time are carefully analyzed in chapter 1, followed by a discussion of the role of time played in fundamental theories. Using as an example nonrelativistic mechanics, the process of parametrization is explained, leading to a separation of a 'canonical time coordinate' from an arbitrary evolution parameter. The discussion of the role of time in special and general relativity as well as in quantum mechanics shows that more fundamental theories use less structure of time. This is followed by an exposition of the history of the relational concept of time, which negates the existence of an absolute duration and therefore often is called "timeless". Next it is shown how fundamental theories can be formulated and re-interpreted using this concept. We put emphasis on the hitherto neglected connection between relationalism and non-extensibility, while absolute time is shown to be unproblematic in classical mechanics just because of the possibility to extend the system without changing its nature. We conclude chapter 1 with a new axiomatic basis for the construction of time observables based on a simultaneity relation between 'observations', which are treated as a primitive concept and intuitively correspond to measurement events, but without knowing 'when' these events occur. There is no fundamental time observable; any observable qualifies as a time observable, if it allows to separate all instants. Chapter 2 gives a brief account of three main problems connected with time: a) The problem of the arrow of time. This has to be disentangled from the problem of irreversibility: a solution of the latter essentially excludes cyclic motions and is required for a solution of the former, which consists in showing that a fundamental direction between any two non-identical instants is physically meaningful. We give a formal definition of the arrow of time. This classical analysis is followed by a review of the problem of the arrow of time in quantum theory, where the situation becomes more complicated because of indeterminism. The discussion shows that there is no experimental evidence for a fundamental arrow of time, so that no contradiction with the relational concept of time arises. b) The problem of time measurement, which is of particular importance for the relational approach, in which time has no reality except if measured by a clock. In quantum theory useful time operators seem to be possible only within the more general formalism of positive operator valued measures (POVM). Clocks based on an oscillation mechanism do however require phase measurements; quantum phase operators can be defined as certain POVMs. Phase difference operators do also exist in the traditional Hilbert space formalism, if another quantization is used, as is done with relational quantization. c) The problem of quantum gravity is sketched only briefly. Chapter 3 introduces and discusses a model of Rovelli consisting of two oscillators with no external time. In this model one oscillator is considered as a clock and defines a relational time for the other one. In the first section we introduce this model and generalize it to a free massless scalar field in one dimension. We establish the relation between a single field mode and the infrared behaviour of the field through constants of motion. In the second section after a short review of canonical quantization we review Rovelli's quantization and generalize it to the free field. We could not prove the existence of the quantization map, but calculations using computer algebra indicate that the quantization does exist. For an enlarged algebra we are able to prove the nonexistence of a quantization map similar to a proof by Groenewold and van Hove. In chapter 4 we observe that a clock time always requires infinitely many degrees of freedom, and we make the hypothesis that a time observable is given by the infrared behaviour of quantum fields, leading to a classical notion of time when using algebraic quantum mechanics. This does however not solve the main problem of quantum relationalism: Which conditions determine a particular evolution?

•Jan 1, 2005•1 citation

Operational Quantum Physics

John L. Safko

This tome is a formal presentation of the unsharp observable approach to quantum mechanics using the positive operator valued (POV) concept of an observable. It is intended for philosophers and mathematicians as well as physicists. This is a very formalistic book. There are, however, portions that should be read by all experimentalists performing quantum mechanical studies as well as graduate students completing their first graduate year quantum mechanics course. If we interpret quantum mechanics as making statistical predictions on the results of states prepared in identical fashions, we will often find that the observed probabilities are nearly, but not exactly, the expected 1 or 0 for measurements that are expected to always give the same result. Hence, rather than demanding sharp measures with probabilities of exactly 1 or 0, quantum mechanics allows a reasonable interpretation of unsharp results of nearly 1 or nearly 0. As the authors point out in chapter II, POV measures and the associated unsharp measures are not essential for an interpretation of quantum mechanical results. However, more sharp variables, and hence a larger Hilbert space, will be needed than are required by the unsharp approach. Also, the theoretical interpretation will often not be as straightforward with only sharp observables. As I have previously stated, all graduate students, both those of a theoretical and those of an experimental bent, should read parts of this book (after they have completed a normal introduction using sharp variables). They should at least read the first chapter which explains the unsharp variable measure concept as well as giving some examples, one of which is the Stern - Gerlach experiment. In chapter VII, the last chapter, the Stern - Gerlach experiment photon polarization and other quantum optical experiments and wave-particle duality experiments for photons are examined in detail using the POV formalism. This would also be an excellent chapter for all graduate students to read. Some sections may send them back to some of the intermediate chapters, hopefully to peruse in greater detail. The intermediate chapters contain the formal development of the POV formalism and compare it to the normal method. There is also a brief introduction to measurement theory using unsharp observables. As the authors state, this is not intended to be a complete solution to the problem of measurement theory. The next two chapters deal with uncertainty and phase space formalism as considered by the unsharp observables. Philosophers of physics and mathematicians will find this an excellent introduction to the POV formalism and the distinction between sharp and unsharp measurements. Many texts will gloss over both the philosophical and mathematical consequences inherent in the full statistical formalism of quantum mechanics. This monograph is not, by the authors' admission, a full treatment of quantum measurement theory. Also, although in the introduction the authors discuss the importance of applying quantum mechanics to individual objects, this book mainly considers the interpretations as statistical measures. There is little attempt to deal with the quantum mechanical interpretations of the behaviour of a single particle. That is, questions about measurements on a single particle or the interpretation of the wavefunction for a single particle are not fully covered. The authors claim that the POV approach is also the best for individual systems, but do little in applications. The major example given is in the last chapter where they consider interference measurements for single photons. They might have referenced more of the current alternative approaches to measurement theory of single particle wavefunctions. The readers of this journal will be disappointed, but not surprised, that the covariant nature of observables is restricted almost entirely to the Galilei group. The only Poincare group material is the example of photon localization in the last chapter. This is a reflection of the great difficulty of applying the special or the general theories of relativity to the Hilbert space formalism.

Classical and Quantum Gravity•Mar 1, 1996•74 citations

The Quantum Measurement Problem

E. Karlsson

Measurements play a specific role in quantum mechanics; only measurements allow us to catch a glimpse of the eluding physical reality. However, there is something deeply unsatisfactory with this specificity—a measurement is itself a physical process! Several varying modes of coping with this dilemma have been proposed and this article tries to describe how a now-century-long discussion has led to new insights about the transition from the quantum to the classical world. Starting from the pioneer’s view of the quantum measurement problem, it follows the development of formalisms, the interest from philosophers for its new aspects on reality and how different interpretations of quantum mechanics have tried to support our classically working brains in understanding quantum phenomena. Decoherence is a main topic and its role in measurement processes exemplified. The question of whether the quantum measurement problem is now solved is left open for the readers’ own judgment.

Quantum Reports•Jun 13, 2025•2 citations

The Measurement Problem Is the "Measurement" Problem

Arne Hansen, Stefan Wolf

The term "measurement" in quantum theory (as well as in other physical theories) is ambiguous: It is used to describe both an experience - e.g., an observation in an experiment - and an interaction with the system under scrutiny. If doing physics is regarded as a creative activity to develop a meaningful description of the world, then one has to carefully discriminate between the two notions: An observer's account of experience - consitutive to meaning - is hardly expressed exhaustively by the formal framework of an interaction within one particular theory. We develop a corresponding perspective onto central terms in quantum mechanics in general, and onto the measurement problem in particular.

arXiv:1810.04573•Oct 10, 2018•4 citations
In most textbooks, measurement does not receive the full attention it deserves and sometimes is even not treated at all, apart a brief and cryptic mention of the “reduction of the wave packet.” However, in the last decades, the situation has profoundly changed and it is time to consider measurement a fundamental part of quantum mechanics, even, to a certain extent, an important generalization of the traditional theory (see also Chs. 14–15). This chapter consists of three major parts. In the first block (Secs. 9.1–9.4) we develop the main physical features of the measurement process: the heart of the argument is here represented by the aspects related to the interpretation. In the second part (Secs. 9.5–9.8) we discuss several special (and partly interdependent) topics of measurement: the heart here is represented by experimental aspects. In the third part (Secs. 9.9–9.12) we deal with the measurement process on a more formal plane, making use, in particular, of the generalization represented by the concepts of effect and positive operator valued measure (POVM). As we have said, the measurement problem is one of the most fundamental issues in the conceptual structure of quantum mechanics (as described in Sec. 9.1) and has a long history that will be examined in Sec. 9.2. In this context, the existence of apparently paradoxical quantum states comes about: the so-called Schrödinger cat states (see Sec. 9.3).
The fourth part handles the first thematic area of the book and probably the most important part of the theory: the measurement problem. • First we examine some basic concepts [ chapter 13 ]. • Then we reconstruct von Neumann's original proposal and its refinements [ chapter 14 ]. Von Neumann was the first to assume a dichotomy between two different types of evolutions: the unitary one and the measurement process. On this matter, different positions have been developed: • there are those who have accepted such a dichotomy and tried to assign a fundamental function to the consciousness (after von Neumann: London, Bauer, Wigner): this is the content of chapter 14 ; • some have tried to eliminate the jump-like features of the measurement by rejecting the projection postulate (Margenau, Ballentine, Everett, deWitt); this is the content of chapter 15 ; • others have tried to explain measurement in terms of intervention of macrosystems: either as a limiting case of a thermodynamical evolution (Green, van Hove and others) or using SSRs for obtaining the required classical behaviour of the pointer: this is the issue in chapter 16 ; • there are those who have tried to find some ad hoc parameters in order to explain the reduction (Ghirardi/Rimini/Weber): this will be treated later in chapter 23 , because the proposal will account more generally for spontaneous transitions to localisation, and hence it is more like a theory of the relation between microphysics and macrophysics; • others have developed a form of non-unitary evolution by using the specific nature of open systems: this is the theory of decoherence (Zurek, Cini, Machida/Namiki, among others), which is treated in chapter 17 . It is quit astonishing that measurement theory has led to so many different positions and that, consequently, for fifty years has been a problematic area of QM. The reasons will be briefly discussed in subsection 14.1.1. The last three chapters of this part are devoted to new developments which partly extend and integrate the theory of decoherence. • The operational approach [ chapter 18 ] represents a formal generalization of the quantum theory of open systems. • Chapter 19 is dedicated to the Quantum Non-demolition Measurement. The last two chapters contain results which are generally valid and neutral with respect to a particular interpretation. Anyway, their importance for QM (and partly also for some interpretational problems) justifies the place they occupy here. • Finally we investigate a new field of research which has very interesting interpretational implications and a lot of technological consequences: the so-called interaction-free measurements [ chapter 20 ]. In the following we shall use the word ‘Measurement’ to mean the measurement process in general, while the word ‘measurement’ always indicates a particular measurement process.
In this paper, we discuss the importance of measurement in quantum mechanics and the so-called measurement problem. Any quantum system can be described as a linear combination of eigenstates of an operator representing a physical quantity; this means that the system can be in a superposition of states that corresponds to different eigenvalues, i.e., different physical outcomes, each one incompatible with the others. The measurement process converts a state of superposition (not macroscopically defined) in a well-defined state. We show that, if we describe the measurement by the standard laws of quantum mechanics, the system would preserve its state of superposition even on a macroscopic scale. Since this is not the case, we assume that a measurement does not obey to standard quantum mechanics, but to a new set of laws that form a “quantum measurement theory”.
The nature of time has long been debated in human history and nowadays is considered of central importance for understanding quantum gravity. We focus on and advocate the relational concept of time, which was put forward in the 17th century in opposition to Newton's absolute time, and only in 1990 explored in a quantum mechanical framework by Carlo Rovelli. After a historical introduction the mathematical models of time are carefully analyzed in chapter 1, followed by a discussion of the role of time played in fundamental theories. Using as an example nonrelativistic mechanics, the process of parametrization is explained, leading to a separation of a 'canonical time coordinate' from an arbitrary evolution parameter. The discussion of the role of time in special and general relativity as well as in quantum mechanics shows that more fundamental theories use less structure of time. This is followed by an exposition of the history of the relational concept of time, which negates the existence of an absolute duration and therefore often is called "timeless". Next it is shown how fundamental theories can be formulated and re-interpreted using this concept. We put emphasis on the hitherto neglected connection between relationalism and non-extensibility, while absolute time is shown to be unproblematic in classical mechanics just because of the possibility to extend the system without changing its nature. We conclude chapter 1 with a new axiomatic basis for the construction of time observables based on a simultaneity relation between 'observations', which are treated as a primitive concept and intuitively correspond to measurement events, but without knowing 'when' these events occur. There is no fundamental time observable; any observable qualifies as a time observable, if it allows to separate all instants. Chapter 2 gives a brief account of three main problems connected with time: a) The problem of the arrow of time. This has to be disentangled from the problem of irreversibility: a solution of the latter essentially excludes cyclic motions and is required for a solution of the former, which consists in showing that a fundamental direction between any two non-identical instants is physically meaningful. We give a formal definition of the arrow of time. This classical analysis is followed by a review of the problem of the arrow of time in quantum theory, where the situation becomes more complicated because of indeterminism. The discussion shows that there is no experimental evidence for a fundamental arrow of time, so that no contradiction with the relational concept of time arises. b) The problem of time measurement, which is of particular importance for the relational approach, in which time has no reality except if measured by a clock. In quantum theory useful time operators seem to be possible only within the more general formalism of positive operator valued measures (POVM). Clocks based on an oscillation mechanism do however require phase measurements; quantum phase operators can be defined as certain POVMs. Phase difference operators do also exist in the traditional Hilbert space formalism, if another quantization is used, as is done with relational quantization. c) The problem of quantum gravity is sketched only briefly. Chapter 3 introduces and discusses a model of Rovelli consisting of two oscillators with no external time. In this model one oscillator is considered as a clock and defines a relational time for the other one. In the first section we introduce this model and generalize it to a free massless scalar field in one dimension. We establish the relation between a single field mode and the infrared behaviour of the field through constants of motion. In the second section after a short review of canonical quantization we review Rovelli's quantization and generalize it to the free field. We could not prove the existence of the quantization map, but calculations using computer algebra indicate that the quantization does exist. For an enlarged algebra we are able to prove the nonexistence of a quantization map similar to a proof by Groenewold and van Hove. In chapter 4 we observe that a clock time always requires infinitely many degrees of freedom, and we make the hypothesis that a time observable is given by the infrared behaviour of quantum fields, leading to a classical notion of time when using algebraic quantum mechanics. This does however not solve the main problem of quantum relationalism: Which conditions determine a particular evolution?
This tome is a formal presentation of the unsharp observable approach to quantum mechanics using the positive operator valued (POV) concept of an observable. It is intended for philosophers and mathematicians as well as physicists. This is a very formalistic book. There are, however, portions that should be read by all experimentalists performing quantum mechanical studies as well as graduate students completing their first graduate year quantum mechanics course. If we interpret quantum mechanics as making statistical predictions on the results of states prepared in identical fashions, we will often find that the observed probabilities are nearly, but not exactly, the expected 1 or 0 for measurements that are expected to always give the same result. Hence, rather than demanding sharp measures with probabilities of exactly 1 or 0, quantum mechanics allows a reasonable interpretation of unsharp results of nearly 1 or nearly 0. As the authors point out in chapter II, POV measures and the associated unsharp measures are not essential for an interpretation of quantum mechanical results. However, more sharp variables, and hence a larger Hilbert space, will be needed than are required by the unsharp approach. Also, the theoretical interpretation will often not be as straightforward with only sharp observables. As I have previously stated, all graduate students, both those of a theoretical and those of an experimental bent, should read parts of this book (after they have completed a normal introduction using sharp variables). They should at least read the first chapter which explains the unsharp variable measure concept as well as giving some examples, one of which is the Stern - Gerlach experiment. In chapter VII, the last chapter, the Stern - Gerlach experiment photon polarization and other quantum optical experiments and wave-particle duality experiments for photons are examined in detail using the POV formalism. This would also be an excellent chapter for all graduate students to read. Some sections may send them back to some of the intermediate chapters, hopefully to peruse in greater detail. The intermediate chapters contain the formal development of the POV formalism and compare it to the normal method. There is also a brief introduction to measurement theory using unsharp observables. As the authors state, this is not intended to be a complete solution to the problem of measurement theory. The next two chapters deal with uncertainty and phase space formalism as considered by the unsharp observables. Philosophers of physics and mathematicians will find this an excellent introduction to the POV formalism and the distinction between sharp and unsharp measurements. Many texts will gloss over both the philosophical and mathematical consequences inherent in the full statistical formalism of quantum mechanics. This monograph is not, by the authors' admission, a full treatment of quantum measurement theory. Also, although in the introduction the authors discuss the importance of applying quantum mechanics to individual objects, this book mainly considers the interpretations as statistical measures. There is little attempt to deal with the quantum mechanical interpretations of the behaviour of a single particle. That is, questions about measurements on a single particle or the interpretation of the wavefunction for a single particle are not fully covered. The authors claim that the POV approach is also the best for individual systems, but do little in applications. The major example given is in the last chapter where they consider interference measurements for single photons. They might have referenced more of the current alternative approaches to measurement theory of single particle wavefunctions. The readers of this journal will be disappointed, but not surprised, that the covariant nature of observables is restricted almost entirely to the Galilei group. The only Poincare group material is the example of photon localization in the last chapter. This is a reflection of the great difficulty of applying the special or the general theories of relativity to the Hilbert space formalism.
Measurements play a specific role in quantum mechanics; only measurements allow us to catch a glimpse of the eluding physical reality. However, there is something deeply unsatisfactory with this specificity—a measurement is itself a physical process! Several varying modes of coping with this dilemma have been proposed and this article tries to describe how a now-century-long discussion has led to new insights about the transition from the quantum to the classical world. Starting from the pioneer’s view of the quantum measurement problem, it follows the development of formalisms, the interest from philosophers for its new aspects on reality and how different interpretations of quantum mechanics have tried to support our classically working brains in understanding quantum phenomena. Decoherence is a main topic and its role in measurement processes exemplified. The question of whether the quantum measurement problem is now solved is left open for the readers’ own judgment.
The term "measurement" in quantum theory (as well as in other physical theories) is ambiguous: It is used to describe both an experience - e.g., an observation in an experiment - and an interaction with the system under scrutiny. If doing physics is regarded as a creative activity to develop a meaningful description of the world, then one has to carefully discriminate between the two notions: An observer's account of experience - consitutive to meaning - is hardly expressed exhaustively by the formal framework of an interaction within one particular theory. We develop a corresponding perspective onto central terms in quantum mechanics in general, and onto the measurement problem in particular.