The main purpose of this paper is to provide a new proof of the impossibility of local theories of hidden variables based on simpler and more general assumptions than those used by Bell (1964, 1966), Wigner (1970), and Suppes and Zanotti (1976). In particular, no assumptions requiring specific quantum mechanical calculations are required. They are replaced by the principle of exchangeability and the principle of identical conditional distributions given the hidden variable. The results may be most easily discussed in terms of a system of two spin-½ particles initially in the singlet state, but generalizations to other quantum mechanical systems of a similar nature are apparent. In essential terms, the analysis of Bell, stated in a particularly clear form by Wigner, depends upon the following assumptions, which we state in intuitive form. (Mathematically explicit axioms are formulated in Appendix A.) 1. Axial symmetry . For any direction of the measuring apparatus the expected spin is 0, where spin is measured by +1 and -1 for spin +½ and spin -½, respectively. Further, the expected product of the spin measurements is the same for different orientations of the measuring apparatuses, as long as the angle between the measuring apparatuses remains the same. 2. Opposite measurement for same orientation . The correlation between the spin measurements is – 1 if the two measuring apparatuses have the same orientation. 3. Independence of λ . The expectation of any function of λ is independent of the orientation of the measuring apparatus.
The main purpose of this paper is to provide a new proof of the impossibility of local theories of hidden variables based on simpler and more general assumptions than those used by Bell (1964, 1966), Wigner (1970), and Suppes and Zanotti (1976). In particular, no assumptions requiring specific quantum mechanical calculations are required. They are replaced by the principle of exchangeability and the principle of identical conditional distributions given the hidden variable. The results may be most easily discussed in terms of a system of two spin-½ particles initially in the singlet state, but generalizations to other quantum mechanical systems of a similar nature are apparent. In essential terms, the analysis of Bell, stated in a particularly clear form by Wigner, depends upon the following assumptions, which we state in intuitive form. (Mathematically explicit axioms are formulated in Appendix A.) 1. Axial symmetry . For any direction of the measuring apparatus the expected spin is 0, where spin is measured by +1 and -1 for spin +½ and spin -½, respectively. Further, the expected product of the spin measurements is the same for different orientations of the measuring apparatuses, as long as the angle between the measuring apparatuses remains the same. 2. Opposite measurement for same orientation . The correlation between the spin measurements is – 1 if the two measuring apparatuses have the same orientation. 3. Independence of λ . The expectation of any function of λ is independent of the orientation of the measuring apparatus.
INTRODUCTION The main purpose of this chapter is to prove a lemma about random variables, and then to apply this lemma to the characterization of local theories of hidden variables by Bell (1964, 1966) and Wigner (1970), which are focused around Bell's inequality. We use the results of the lemma in two different ways. The first is to show that the assumptions of Bell and Wigner can be weakened to conditional statistical independence rather than conditional determinism because determinism follows from conditional independence and the other assumptions that are made about systems of two spin-½ particles. The second direction is to question the attempt of Clauser and Home (1974) to derive a Bell-type inequality for local stochastic theories of hidden variables which use an assumption of conditional statistical independence for observables. The main thrust of our analysis obviously arises from the probabilistic lemma we prove. Roughly speaking, this lemma asserts that if two random variables have strict correlation, that is, the absolute value of the correlation is one, and it is in addition assumed that their expectations are conditionally independent when a third random variable λ is given, then the conditional variance of X and Y given λ is zero. In other words, given the hidden variable λ the observables X and Y are strictly determined. The lemma itself, of course, depends on no assumptions about quantum mechanics. It may be regarded as a limitation on any theories that assume both strict correlation between observables and their conditional independence on the basis of some prior or hidden variable.
Bell's theorem rests on the following fundamental condition for a local system: P(a,b|alpha, beta, lambda)= P(a|alpha, lambda)P(b|beta, lambda). Here a and b are the outcomes respectively for measurements alpha on one side, and beta on the other, of an experiment involving two entangled particles traveling in opposite directions from a source. The parameter lambda (the set of "hidden variables") represents a more complete description of the joint state of the two particles. Because of lambda, the joint probability of detection is now dependent only on lambda and the local measurement setting of alpha; similarly for the other side and the setting beta. From this equation John Bell derived a simple inequality that is violated by the predictions of quantum mechanics, which is generally taken to imply that quantum mechanics is a nonlocal theory. But, by combining Richard Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics with a model of particle interaction described by David Deutsch, we develop a system (the "space of all paths," SP) that (1) is immediately seen to replicate the predictions of quantum mechanics, (2) has a single outcome for each quantum event (unlike MWI on which it is partly based), and (3) contains the set lambda of hidden variables consisting of all possible paths from the source to the detectors on each side of the two-particle experiment. However, the set lambda is nonmeasurable, and therefore the above equation is meaningless in SP.
The Bell's theorem stands as an insuperable roadblock in the path to a very desired intuitive solution of the EPR paradox and, hence, it lies at the core of the current lack of a clear interpretation of the quantum formalism. The theorem states through an experimentally testable inequality that the predictions of quantum mechanics for the Bell's polarization states of two entangled particles cannot be reproduced by any statistical model of hidden variables that shares certain intuitive features. In this paper, we show, however, that the proof of the Bell's theorem involves a subtle, though crucial, assumption that is not required by fundamental physical principles and, hence, it is not necessarily fulfilled in the experimental setup that tests the inequality. Indeed, this assumption can neither be properly implemented within the standard framework of quantum mechanics. Namely, the proof of the theorem assumes that there exists a preferred absolute frame of reference, supposedly provided by the lab, which enables to compare the orientation of the polarization measurement devices for successive realizations of the experiment and, hence, to define jointly their response functions over the space of hypothetical hidden configurations for all their possible alternative settings. We notice, however, that only the relative orientation between the two measurement devices in every single realization of the experiment is a properly defined physical degree of freedom, while their global rigid orientation is a spurious gauge degree of freedom. Hence, the preferred frame of reference required by the proof of the Bell's theorem does not necessarily exist. In fact, it cannot exist in models in which the gauge symmetry of the experimental setup under global rigid rotations of the two detectors is spontaneously broken by the hidden configurations of the pair of entangled particles and a non-zero geometric phase appears under some cyclic gauge symmetry transformations. Following this observation, we build an explicitly local model of hidden variables that reproduces the predictions of quantum mechanics for the Bell's states.
An argument, due originally to J. S. Bell, is somewhat simplified and made more specific. It deals primarily with a quantum mechanical system consisting of the spins of two spin-12 particles. It shows that a description of the quantum mechanical measurement of the spin components of these two particles by means of hidden parameters is impossible if we assume that the parameters determining the outcome of the measurement of the spin of each particle are independent of the direction in which we decide to measure the spin of the other particle. The mathematical reason for the impossibility is analyzed.
The Bell inequality is thought to be a common constraint shared by all models of local hidden variables that aim to describe the entangled states of two qubits. Since the inequality is violated by the quantum mechanical description of these states, it purportedly allows distinguishing in an experimentally testable way the predictions of quantum mechanics from those of models of local hidden variables and, ultimately, ruling the latter out. In this paper, we show, however, that the models of local hidden variables constrained by the Bell inequality all share a subtle, though crucial, feature that is not required by fundamental physical principles and, hence, it might not be fulfilled in the actual experimental setup that tests the inequality. Indeed, the disputed feature neither can be properly implemented within the standard framework of quantum mechanics and it is even at odds with the fundamental principle of relativity. Namely, the proof of the inequality requires the existence of a preferred absolute frame of reference (supposedly provided by the lab) with respect to which the hidden properties of the entangled particles and the orientations of each one of the measurement devices that test them can be independently defined through a long sequence of realizations of the experiment. We notice, however, that while the relative orientation between the two measurement devices is a properly defined physical magnitude in every single realization of the experiment, their global rigid orientation with respect to a lab frame is a spurious gauge degree of freedom. Following this observation, we were able to explicitly build a model of local hidden variables that does not share the disputed feature and, hence, it is able to reproduce the predictions of quantum mechanics for the entangled states of two qubits.
Abstract. For unit vectors a, b, entanglement requires that spin measurements satisfy those just given for a≠b. Bell’s hidden variable quantum mechanical local particle with a=b cannot provide the values for a≠b and, hence, the values for an entangled particle system. The perception that any hidden variable quantum mechanical description of an entangled system of particles is non-local depends on Bell’s inappropriate definition of locality, which excludes entanglement for a distant particle, and the condition that a=b, which does not give the values for a≠b as required to give the quantum mechanical expectation values, when entanglement occurs for systems that are close, not distant, and ignores that entanglement is a local phenomenon. Expecting the condition a=b and a local particle analysis with no distant entangled particle to give the quantum mechanical result is absurd. Any disentanglement of once entangled particles moving apart sets the spin measurements at those given for a≠b if a≠b and those given for a=b if a=b. Any subsequent measurement of the set values agrees with those for a≠b if a≠b and those given for a=b if a=b just as if the particles are entangled still. In examples where Bell’s inequality is supposedly violated, the conditions for which the inequality is true are not met. There is no contradiction.