Conceptual difficulties still remain in quantum mechanics, even if they had already been identified by its inventors. This does not mean that the theory is not successful! The reality is quite the opposite: in fact, independently of these difficulties, quantum mechanics is certainly one of the most successful theories of all science. One can even consider that its ability to adapt to new situations is one of its most remarkable features. It continues to give efficient and accurate predictions while new experiments are performed, even in situations that the founding fathers had no way to imagine. Actually, there are very few theories that have been verified with the same accuracy in so many situations. Nevertheless, it remains true that conceptual difficulties subsist, and their discussion is the object of this chapter. As we will see, most of them relate to the process of quantum measurement, in particular to the very nature of the random process that takes place on this occasion.
Conceptual difficulties still remain in quantum mechanics, even if they had already been identified by its inventors. This does not mean that the theory is not successful! The reality is quite the opposite: in fact, independently of these difficulties, quantum mechanics is certainly one of the most successful theories of all science. One can even consider that its ability to adapt to new situations is one of its most remarkable features. It continues to give efficient and accurate predictions while new experiments are performed, even in situations that the founding fathers had no way to imagine. Actually, there are very few theories that have been verified with the same accuracy in so many situations. Nevertheless, it remains true that conceptual difficulties subsist, and their discussion is the object of this chapter. As we will see, most of them relate to the process of quantum measurement, in particular to the very nature of the random process that takes place on this occasion.
Current situation of quantum mechanics: some conceptual problems remainQuantum mechanics is one of the most successful theories of all physics.Its predictions have been verified in a huge number of situations, sometimes with a fantastic accuracy of 10 -12 .Historically, it was developed in several stages, each of them implying a different interpretation, sometimes opposite of the others.A "standard" version then emerged, in the line of the contributions of von Neumann and Dirac, which is the version generally found in textbooks.Nevertheless, real conceptual difficulties remain: we are far from a universal consensus concerning the best way to interpret the nature of the wave function, the measurement process, etc. and their possible relation with "physical reality".This is the reason why many interpretations of quantum mechanics have been proposed.A few will be described during the talk: the Copenhagen interpretation (Bohr), the statistical interpretation (Einstein, Ballentine, etc.) as well as the three most famous nonstandard interpretations: dBB (de Broglie Bohm), GRW/CSL (Stochastic Schrödinger dynamics) and Everett (sometimes described as "many worlds").Un certain nombre des difficultés conceptuelles de la mécanique quantique, déjà identifiées par ses inventeurs, subsistent à l'heure actuelle.Que le lecteur n'en retire pas l'impression qu'il s'agit d'une théorie peu solide !L'arbre ne doit pas cacher la forêt : indépendamment de ces difficultés très réelles, la mécanique quantique est assurément l'une des théories les plus couronnées de succès de toute la science.On peut même considérer que sa faculté d'adaptation aux situations les plus variées est sa caractéristique la plus extraordinaire ; elle continue à être toujours aussi efficace dans ses prédictions en accompagnant les progrès expérimentaux qui permettent constamment d'avoir accès à de nouvelles situations physiques que les pères fondateurs de la théorie n'avaient aucun moyen de prévoir.De fait, il existe très peu de théories dont la vérification ait été faite avec la même précision, et ceci dans des domaines d'application variés.Il subsiste cependant que, sur le plan conceptuel, des difficultés subsistent, et ce sont elles qui font l'objet du présent chapitre.Comme nous le verrons, la plupart mettent en jeu le processus de mesure quantique et la nature du phénomène aléatoire qui se produit à cette occasion.Dans le point de vue de Von Neumann ce n'est que lorsqu'une mesure est effectuée que des sauts aléatoires se produisent, selon le postulat de réduction du vecteur d'état.Sinon, en général la fonction d'onde évolue progressivement, d'une façon parfaitement prévisible et continue, selon l'équation de Schrödinger.Bien évidemment, utiliser deux postulats aussi différents pour l'évolution du même objet mathématique 1 est une situation tout à fait (1) Au lieu du « point de vue de Schrödinger », il est équivalent d'utiliser « point de vue de Heisenberg » ; l'évolution continue du vecteur d'état est alors transférée vers les observables du système (opérateurs agissant sur son espace des états), tandis que le vecteur d'état reste indépendant du temps en l'absence de mesure.Les observables évoluent de façon continue, que des mesures soient effectuées ou pas.Mais le vecteur d'état doit encore obéir à des règles différentes suivant la situation : la plupart du temps il reste parfaitement constant, mais lors d'une mesure il saute brusquement vers une nouvelle valeur prenant en compte l'information nouvelle.L'acquisition d'information est donc toujours considérée comme un processus physique totalement différent de l'évolution « normale », ce qui introduit la nécessité de bien définir la frontière entre les deux processus.
The previous chapters contain many examples of the successful application of quantum mechanics to the solution of real physical problems. These represent only a small sample of the wide range of experimental results, spanning just about all areas of physics and chemistry and beyond, that have been successfully explained by quantum theory. So far at least, no quantum-mechanical prediction has been experimentally falsified. Despite these successes, however, many scientists have considered the basic conceptual framework of the subject to be unsatisfactory, and repeated attempts have been made to reinterpret quantum mechanics, or even replace it with a different theory whose philosophical and conceptual basis could be considered more acceptable. In the present chapter we shall explain the reasons for this dissatisfaction and outline some of the reinterpretations and alternative approaches that have been devised. Inevitably many of the questions that arise in this area are matters of opinion rather than fact and, for this reason, some physicists consider that they belong more properly to the realm of philosophy than of physics. However, the conceptual basis of quantum mechanics is so fundamental to our whole understanding of the nature of the physical universe that it should surely be important for physicists to understand the nature of the problems involved, if nothing else.1,2 16.1 THE CONCEPTUAL PROBLEMS In this section we outline some of the main areas of difficulty with a view to more detailed discussion later in the chapter.
Amid the wide variety of interpretations of quantum mechanics, the notion of a fully coherent ontological interpretation has seen a promising evolution over the last few decades. Despite this progress, however, the old dualistic categorical constraints of subjectivity and objectivity, correlate with the metrically restricted definition of local and global, have remained largely in place – a reflection of the broader, persistent inheritance of these comfortable strictures throughout the evolution of modern science. If one traces this inheritance back to its ancient roots in Plato and Aristotle, it is clear that the coherence, scientific utility, and historical durability of the various natural philosophies that followed have been directly proportional to their commitment, tacit or explicit, to object-oriented realism. As Simondon might put it, it is a commitment to the primacy of individuated substance over the process of individuation. For Whitehead, it is the misplaced assimilation of becoming to being, of potentiality to actuality. Quantum mechanics has challenged this commitment with a combined breadth and depth of force that far exceeds any other theory in the history of science. The theory’s objectively demonstrable empirical application is manifest only by way of a fundamentally subjective, context-dependent mechanism of measurement. More compelling still, actual system states are always actualizations of locally contextualized yet globally conditioned potential system states, such that “globally objective” reality is no longer merely the object of local measurement, but also its product. Thus, any coherent, ontological interpretation of quantum theory must include a conceptual framework by which objectivity and subjectivity, actuality and potentiality, global and local, being and becoming, individuated fact and process of individuation, are no longer understood as merely epistemic, mutually exclusive category pairs descriptive of an already extant, closed reality – but rather as mutually implicative ontological categories explicative of an ontogenetic, open reality-in-process.
Despite its enormous practical success, quantum theory is so contrary to intuition that, even after 45 years, the experts themselves still do not all agree what to make of it. The area of disagreement centers primarily around the problem of describing observations. Formally, the result of a measurement is a superposition of vectors, each representing the quantity being observed as having one of its possible values. The question that has to be answered is how this superposition can be reconciled with the fact that in practice we only observe one value. How is the measuring instrument prodded into making up its mind which value it has observed?
Applications of quantum mechanics have led to many successful predictions and explanations of puzzling phenomena, and we now apply quantum mechanics to gain, process, and communicate information in novel ways. We can understand quantum mechanics by understanding how we have applied it. We should not seek agreement on the nature of the world it represents, because this theory does not itself represent the physical world (though its applications do help us to represent it better). When applied to a quantum state, quantum mechanics yields probabilities for physical events: both state and probability are objective—not because they represent elements of physical reality, but because each exerts normative authority over the beliefs of anyone who accepts quantum mechanics and applies it relative to a physical situation they may (but need not) occupy. These events may be described by statements (about values of magnitudes) that are meaningful in an appropriate environmental context, and quantum mechanics can help one to say when that is. Measurement creates an appropriate context, so here the Born rule indirectly yields probabilities of measurement outcomes. The quantum state of a system does not “collapse” on measurement: a new state must be assigned relative to a physical situation in which information about the outcome is accessible. Understood this way, there is no measurement problem, and violation of Bell inequalities does not demonstrate “spooky” non-local action. Quantum field theories have no physical ontology of their own: a quantum field is a mathematical object in a model whose application helps to improve and extend our descriptions of the world in other terms. We cannot realise the scenario of Wigner’s friend and its recent extensions: but the data that provide overwhelming evidence for quantum mechanics are objective in the same sense as the relative measurement outcomes described in those scenarios.
Despite the extraordinary successes the two great bastions of 20th century science (Quantum Theory and General Relativity) are troubled with serious conceptual and mathematical difficulties. As a result, further growth of fundamental science is at stake. Is this the end of science? Optimistic answer is ``NOT''! In this work, it is argued that science must continue its cruise, but with anew strategy -- a thorough recourse into the grass-root level working of science is inevitable. In fact, our conventional scientific methods are based upon ordinary sense perception, which keeps the outer physical universe as a separate entity, that is something quite independent of the observer. Basically, it is the observer -- the knower (human mind) -- which makes perception possible. It makes a person or scientist to recognize or refute the existence of an object or a phenomenon. It is also tempted to evince that working of human mind is epistemically scientific and can, in principle, be completely deciphered. It's inclusion in scientific theories, although tedious, can certainly spark a revolution in our understanding of nature and reality.