Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

OLD QUANTUM THEORY—COMPARISON WITH EXPERIMENT

George William Series

Published Jun 1, 1988• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

PASCHEN’S study [102] of the lines of ionized helium, and, in particular, of the line 4686 Å ( n = 4→ n = 3) was claimed to provide striking experimental support for Sommerfeld’s theory. The fine structure of the Balmer series, as far as it was resolved at that time, also supported the theory, and further weighty evidence came from measurements of X-ray fine structure. In the following sections we shall briefly review these lines of argument.

DOI
10.1142/9789814415637_0005

Related papers

THE FINE STRUCTURE—OLD QUANTUM THEORY

George William Series

IT had been known for over twenty-five years before Bohr’s theory that the Balmer lines were not single, but appeared to be close doublets under instruments of high resolving power There was, however, considerable disagreement as to the separation between the doublet peaks. It was particularly important to the early spectroscopists to know whether the doublet separation remained constant throughout the Balmer series, or whether it gradually decreased, since this is an important distinction in alkali spectra between the sharp and diffuse series on the one hand, and the principal series on the other. In fact, each Balmer line is a blend of sharp, principal and diffuse doublets. Complete resolution even in the most favourable case of H α has not yet been achieved.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 1, 1988•0 citations

Conclusions

Jonathan Allday

Now that we have reached the end of our brief tour through the early history of quantum theory, we need to stop and consider some important themes. From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork cobbled together from classical physics with a few quantum ideas thrown in. e works of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be classed as old quantum theory. is is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievements that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which slowly emerged from the works of Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Born, and Dirac.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 3, 2009•0 citations

Shift and broadening of resolved hydrogen Balmer- α fine-structure lines in helium

E. W. Weber

Accurate values for the density shift and broadening of five isolated ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ fine-structure transitions have been measured. Doppler-free polarization and double-quantum saturation spectroscopy with a cw dye laser are used in a He dc discharge with 1% ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}$. The negative shifts and the huge broadening values are correctly predicted by an impact-approximation theory taking into account the large cross sections for fine-structure transfer (quenching) collisions and only Van der Waals interaction between ${\mathrm{H}}^{*}$ and He. Consequences of a comparison with the positive shift of the unresolved ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ line and of the alkali-metal $D$ lines in He buffer gas are discussed. For pressures below 0.1 Torr hfs decoupling collisions give rise to a positive shift of single ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ fine-structure lines and to a collisional narrowing effect analogous to that observed in nuclear magnetic resonance.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1979•29 citations

Time Series, Stochastic Processes and Completeness of Quantum Theory

Marian Kupczyński

Most of physical experiments are usually described as repeated measurements of some random variables. The experimental data registered by on-line computers form time series of outcomes. The frequencies of different outcomes are compared with the probabilities provided by the algorithms of quantum theory (QT). In spite of statistical predictions of QT a claim was made that the theory provided the most complete description of the data and of the underlying physical phenomena. This claim could be easily rejected if some fine structures, averaged out in standard statistical descriptive analysis, were found in the time series of experimental data. To search for these structures one has to use more subtle statistical tools which were developed to study time series produced by various stochastic processes. In this talk we review some of these tools. As an example we show how the standard descriptive statistical analysis of the data is unable to reveal a fine structure in a simulated sample of AR(2) stochastic process. We emphasize once again that the violation of Bell inequalities gives no information on the completeness or the non locality of QT. The appropriate way to test the completeness of quantum theory is to search for fine structures in time series of experimental data by means of the purity tests or by studying the autocorrelation and partial autocorrelation functions.

arXiv:1009.3002•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•17 citations

Conclusions

Jonathan Allday

From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork, cobbled together by incorporating some quantum ideas into essentially classical physics. The work of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be bracketed as old quantum theory. This classification is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievement that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which emerged from the work of Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, and Dirac. The development of the photon concept is a key example of a radically new idea gradually gaining acceptance. The process works via a growing realization that more and more things can be explained in the context of the photon model.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

Time Series, Stochastic Processes and Completeness of Quantum Theory

Marian Kupczyński, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

Most of physical experiments are usually described as repeated measurements of some random variables. Experimental data registered by on‐line computers form time series of outcomes. The frequencies of different outcomes are compared with the probabilities provided by the algorithms of quantum theory (QT). In spite of statistical predictions of QT a claim was made that it provided the most complete description of the data and of the underlying physical phenomena. This claim could be easily rejected if some fine structures, averaged out in the standard descriptive statistical analysis, were found in time series of experimental data. To search for these structures one has to use more subtle statistical tools which were developed to study time series produced by various stochastic processes. In this talk we review some of these tools. As an example we show how the standard descriptive statistical analysis of the data is unable to reveal a fine structure in a simulated sample of AR (2) stochastic process. We emphasize once again that the violation of Bell inequalities gives no information on the completeness or the non locality of QT. The appropriate way to test the completeness of quantum theory is to search for fine structures in time series of the experimental data by means of the purity tests or by studying the autocorrelation and partial autocorrelation functions.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•7 citations
PASCHEN’S study [102] of the lines of ionized helium, and, in particular, of the line 4686 Å ( n = 4→ n = 3) was claimed to provide striking experimental support for Sommerfeld’s theory. The fine structure of the Balmer series, as far as it was resolved at that time, also supported the theory, and further weighty evidence came from measurements of X-ray fine structure. In the following sections we shall briefly review these lines of argument.
IT had been known for over twenty-five years before Bohr’s theory that the Balmer lines were not single, but appeared to be close doublets under instruments of high resolving power There was, however, considerable disagreement as to the separation between the doublet peaks. It was particularly important to the early spectroscopists to know whether the doublet separation remained constant throughout the Balmer series, or whether it gradually decreased, since this is an important distinction in alkali spectra between the sharp and diffuse series on the one hand, and the principal series on the other. In fact, each Balmer line is a blend of sharp, principal and diffuse doublets. Complete resolution even in the most favourable case of H α has not yet been achieved.
Now that we have reached the end of our brief tour through the early history of quantum theory, we need to stop and consider some important themes. From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork cobbled together from classical physics with a few quantum ideas thrown in. e works of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be classed as old quantum theory. is is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievements that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which slowly emerged from the works of Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Born, and Dirac.
Accurate values for the density shift and broadening of five isolated ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ fine-structure transitions have been measured. Doppler-free polarization and double-quantum saturation spectroscopy with a cw dye laser are used in a He dc discharge with 1% H2{\mathrm{H}}_{2}H2​. The negative shifts and the huge broadening values are correctly predicted by an impact-approximation theory taking into account the large cross sections for fine-structure transfer (quenching) collisions and only Van der Waals interaction between H∗{\mathrm{H}}^{*}H∗ and He. Consequences of a comparison with the positive shift of the unresolved ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ line and of the alkali-metal DDD lines in He buffer gas are discussed. For pressures below 0.1 Torr hfs decoupling collisions give rise to a positive shift of single ${\mathrm{H}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ fine-structure lines and to a collisional narrowing effect analogous to that observed in nuclear magnetic resonance.
Most of physical experiments are usually described as repeated measurements of some random variables. The experimental data registered by on-line computers form time series of outcomes. The frequencies of different outcomes are compared with the probabilities provided by the algorithms of quantum theory (QT). In spite of statistical predictions of QT a claim was made that the theory provided the most complete description of the data and of the underlying physical phenomena. This claim could be easily rejected if some fine structures, averaged out in standard statistical descriptive analysis, were found in the time series of experimental data. To search for these structures one has to use more subtle statistical tools which were developed to study time series produced by various stochastic processes. In this talk we review some of these tools. As an example we show how the standard descriptive statistical analysis of the data is unable to reveal a fine structure in a simulated sample of AR(2) stochastic process. We emphasize once again that the violation of Bell inequalities gives no information on the completeness or the non locality of QT. The appropriate way to test the completeness of quantum theory is to search for fine structures in time series of experimental data by means of the purity tests or by studying the autocorrelation and partial autocorrelation functions.
From a historical point of view, a distinction can be drawn between ‘old quantum theory’ and the full quantum theory that we now use. Old quantum theory was in essence a patchwork, cobbled together by incorporating some quantum ideas into essentially classical physics. The work of Planck, Einstein, Bohr, and Sommerfeld can be bracketed as old quantum theory. This classification is not meant to undermine the tremendous achievement that old quantum theory represents, but simply to underline its standing as a stage on the way to a fully formed quantum theory, which emerged from the work of Heisenberg, Schrodinger, Born, and Dirac. The development of the photon concept is a key example of a radically new idea gradually gaining acceptance. The process works via a growing realization that more and more things can be explained in the context of the photon model.
Most of physical experiments are usually described as repeated measurements of some random variables. Experimental data registered by on‐line computers form time series of outcomes. The frequencies of different outcomes are compared with the probabilities provided by the algorithms of quantum theory (QT). In spite of statistical predictions of QT a claim was made that it provided the most complete description of the data and of the underlying physical phenomena. This claim could be easily rejected if some fine structures, averaged out in the standard descriptive statistical analysis, were found in time series of experimental data. To search for these structures one has to use more subtle statistical tools which were developed to study time series produced by various stochastic processes. In this talk we review some of these tools. As an example we show how the standard descriptive statistical analysis of the data is unable to reveal a fine structure in a simulated sample of AR (2) stochastic process. We emphasize once again that the violation of Bell inequalities gives no information on the completeness or the non locality of QT. The appropriate way to test the completeness of quantum theory is to search for fine structures in time series of the experimental data by means of the purity tests or by studying the autocorrelation and partial autocorrelation functions.