Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Advanced series in applied physics

Delayed-Choice Experiments with the Neutron Interferometer

Daniel M. Greenberger, Michael Horne, C. G. Shull, Anton Zeilinger

Published Jan 1, 1997• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In the neutron interferometer, the neutron wave packet is initially split into two sub-packets and then coherently recombined. The amplitudes and phases of the fringe pattern upon recombination can be changed by altering the experiments performed on the packets in midflight. Quantum mechanically, this is a straight-forward procedure. However in a realistic theory this pattern is present by hidden variables. Several types of delayed-choice experiments are described, and they are related to a one-particle version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox, and to limits on the locality of realistic theories.

DOI
10.1142/9789812819895_0015

Related papers

The neutron interferometer as a device for illustrating the strange behavior of quantum systems

Daniel M. Greenberger

The neutron interferometer is a unique instrument that allows one to construct a neutron wave packet of macroscopic size, divide it into two components separated by centimeters, and then coherently recombine them. A number of experiments clearly showing the difference between quantum and classical theory have been performed with it, which are suitable for presentation in elementary quantum courses. This article presents a simple mathematical model of the interferometer, which can be used to illustrate clearly many of the surprising features of quantum systems. For example, one can describe an experiment to determine which component beam the neutron takes (an analog of the two-slit electron experiment). One can then trace in detail the loss of coherence of the wave function, rather than merely invoke the usual "handwaving" uncertainty arguments. The author discusses the effect of gravity on the neutron beam [the classic COW (Colella, Overhauser, and Werner) experiment], including a simple analysis in an accelerated reference frame, and its relation to the equivalence principle, the red shift, and the twin paradox. Also described are the effect of rotation of the neutron by 360\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{} to change its phase, the effect on the wave function of measuring the absence of the particle from a beam ("Dicke's paradox"), and a realizable version of Wheeler's "delayed-choice" experiments, as well as their relation to the problem of "Schr\"odinger's cat." The treatment is suitable for bright undergraduates and first-year graduate students.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Oct 1, 1983•147 citations

Coherence and spectral filtering in neutron interferometry

Helmut Kaiser, R. Clothier, S. A. Werner +2 more

The coherence length of a neutron wave packet depends on the spectral width of the distribution of wave vectors that make up the packet. The coherent overlap of the wave packets traversing the two beam paths in a perfect-silicon-crystal neutron interferometer (NI) is altered by placing a material with a neutron-nuclear optical potential in one of the beam paths in the NI. If the optical potential is positive, it causes a delay of the wave packet and a loss of fringe visibility. By use of an analyzer crystal, we narrow the spectral distribution after the mixing and interference has occurred in the last crystal slab of the NI. This increases the coherence length and restores some of the fringe visibility.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1992•66 citations

Quantum causality emerging in a delayed-choice quantum Cheshire Cat experiment with neutrons

Richard Wagner, Wenzel Kersten, Hartmut Lemmel +2 more

We report an experiment with neutrons in a silicon perfect crystal interferometer, that realizes a quantum Cheshire Cat in a delayed choice setting. In our setup the quantum Cheshire Cat is established by spatially separating the particle and its property (i.e. the neutron and its spin) into the two different paths of the interferometer. The condition for a delayed choice setting is achieved by postponing the choice of path assignment for the quantum Cheshire Cat, i.e. which path is taken by the particle and which by its property, until the point in time when the neutron wave function has already split and entered the interferometer. The results of the experiment suggest not only the fact that the neutrons and its spin are separated and take different paths in the interferometer, but also quantum-mechanical causality is implied, insomuch that the behavior of a quantum system is affected by the choice of the selection at a later point in time.

Scientific Reports•Mar 8, 2023•7 citations

Aspects of wave-particle complementarity in quantum delayed-choice experiments

Pedro R. Dieguez, H S Karthik

Abstract Quantum delayed-choice experiments are designed to probe the robustness of the complementarity principle. In this proceeding, we revisit the main ideas reported recently in Ref. [Commun. Phys. 5, 82 (2022)] concerning a setup (quantum-controlled reality experiment) that has the same final visibility as the quantum version of Wheeler’s delayed-choice arrangement. Besides the same final statistics, upon an operational criterion of physical realism, the authors claimed a different state of affairs for the wave-and-particle behavior in delayed-choice experiments. To this end, we put forward an analysis by employing the relative entropy of coherence to study how the local wave and particle coherences when the system is traveling inside the interferometer change accordingly to the final observed visibility.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2023•1 citation

A Quantum Delayed-Choice Experiment

Alberto Peruzzo, Peter Shadbolt, Nicolas Brunner +2 more

Delaying Quantum Choice Photons can display wavelike or particle-like behavior, depending on the experimental technique used to measure them. Understanding this duality lies at the heart of quantum mechanics. In two reports, Peruzzo et al. (p. 634 ) and Kaiser et al. (p. 637 ; see the Perspective on both papers by Lloyd ) perform an entangled version of John Wheeler's delayed-choice gedanken experiment, in which the choice of detection can be changed after a photon passes through a double-slit to avoid the measurement process affecting the state of the photon. The original proposal allowed the wave and particle nature of light to be interchanged after the light had entered the interferometer. By contrast in this study, entanglement allowed the wave and particle nature to be interchanged after the light was detected and revealed the quantum nature of the photon, for example, it displays wave- and particle-like behavior simultaneously.

arXiv:1205.4926•Science•Nov 1, 2012•275 citations

Time-of-flight neutron interferometry

H. Rauch, H. Wölwitsch, R. Clothier +2 more

In the experiment described in this paper, a chopper serves as a source of neutron intensity pulses which pass through a perfect Si-crystal neutron interferometer (NI), where they are split coherently into two parts that recombine and interfere. As the occupation number of a single pulse is much smaller than unity, the results very clearly demonstrate the single-particle interference phenomena of neutron interferometry experiments. While traveling the pulses spread, with faster (slower) neutrons tending toward the leading (trailing) edge. The coherence length of the neutrons depends on the spectral width of their wavelength distribution. When a material with a neutron-nuclear optical potential is placed in one beam path in the NI, there is a loss of fringe visibility (contrast), which depends on the coherence length. By using time-of-flight techniques, we divide the pulse into time segments. Within a given time slice, the wavelength spectrum is narrower than in the pulse as a whole. As a result, contrast remains in the time slices even when it disappears in the overall pulse. We also observe an additional contrast modulation due to the overlap of neighboring pulses.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1992•21 citations
In the neutron interferometer, the neutron wave packet is initially split into two sub-packets and then coherently recombined. The amplitudes and phases of the fringe pattern upon recombination can be changed by altering the experiments performed on the packets in midflight. Quantum mechanically, this is a straight-forward procedure. However in a realistic theory this pattern is present by hidden variables. Several types of delayed-choice experiments are described, and they are related to a one-particle version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox, and to limits on the locality of realistic theories.
The neutron interferometer is a unique instrument that allows one to construct a neutron wave packet of macroscopic size, divide it into two components separated by centimeters, and then coherently recombine them. A number of experiments clearly showing the difference between quantum and classical theory have been performed with it, which are suitable for presentation in elementary quantum courses. This article presents a simple mathematical model of the interferometer, which can be used to illustrate clearly many of the surprising features of quantum systems. For example, one can describe an experiment to determine which component beam the neutron takes (an analog of the two-slit electron experiment). One can then trace in detail the loss of coherence of the wave function, rather than merely invoke the usual "handwaving" uncertainty arguments. The author discusses the effect of gravity on the neutron beam [the classic COW (Colella, Overhauser, and Werner) experiment], including a simple analysis in an accelerated reference frame, and its relation to the equivalence principle, the red shift, and the twin paradox. Also described are the effect of rotation of the neutron by 360\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{} to change its phase, the effect on the wave function of measuring the absence of the particle from a beam ("Dicke's paradox"), and a realizable version of Wheeler's "delayed-choice" experiments, as well as their relation to the problem of "Schr\"odinger's cat." The treatment is suitable for bright undergraduates and first-year graduate students.
The coherence length of a neutron wave packet depends on the spectral width of the distribution of wave vectors that make up the packet. The coherent overlap of the wave packets traversing the two beam paths in a perfect-silicon-crystal neutron interferometer (NI) is altered by placing a material with a neutron-nuclear optical potential in one of the beam paths in the NI. If the optical potential is positive, it causes a delay of the wave packet and a loss of fringe visibility. By use of an analyzer crystal, we narrow the spectral distribution after the mixing and interference has occurred in the last crystal slab of the NI. This increases the coherence length and restores some of the fringe visibility.
We report an experiment with neutrons in a silicon perfect crystal interferometer, that realizes a quantum Cheshire Cat in a delayed choice setting. In our setup the quantum Cheshire Cat is established by spatially separating the particle and its property (i.e. the neutron and its spin) into the two different paths of the interferometer. The condition for a delayed choice setting is achieved by postponing the choice of path assignment for the quantum Cheshire Cat, i.e. which path is taken by the particle and which by its property, until the point in time when the neutron wave function has already split and entered the interferometer. The results of the experiment suggest not only the fact that the neutrons and its spin are separated and take different paths in the interferometer, but also quantum-mechanical causality is implied, insomuch that the behavior of a quantum system is affected by the choice of the selection at a later point in time.
Abstract Quantum delayed-choice experiments are designed to probe the robustness of the complementarity principle. In this proceeding, we revisit the main ideas reported recently in Ref. [Commun. Phys. 5, 82 (2022)] concerning a setup (quantum-controlled reality experiment) that has the same final visibility as the quantum version of Wheeler’s delayed-choice arrangement. Besides the same final statistics, upon an operational criterion of physical realism, the authors claimed a different state of affairs for the wave-and-particle behavior in delayed-choice experiments. To this end, we put forward an analysis by employing the relative entropy of coherence to study how the local wave and particle coherences when the system is traveling inside the interferometer change accordingly to the final observed visibility.
Delaying Quantum Choice Photons can display wavelike or particle-like behavior, depending on the experimental technique used to measure them. Understanding this duality lies at the heart of quantum mechanics. In two reports, Peruzzo et al. (p. 634 ) and Kaiser et al. (p. 637 ; see the Perspective on both papers by Lloyd ) perform an entangled version of John Wheeler's delayed-choice gedanken experiment, in which the choice of detection can be changed after a photon passes through a double-slit to avoid the measurement process affecting the state of the photon. The original proposal allowed the wave and particle nature of light to be interchanged after the light had entered the interferometer. By contrast in this study, entanglement allowed the wave and particle nature to be interchanged after the light was detected and revealed the quantum nature of the photon, for example, it displays wave- and particle-like behavior simultaneously.
In the experiment described in this paper, a chopper serves as a source of neutron intensity pulses which pass through a perfect Si-crystal neutron interferometer (NI), where they are split coherently into two parts that recombine and interfere. As the occupation number of a single pulse is much smaller than unity, the results very clearly demonstrate the single-particle interference phenomena of neutron interferometry experiments. While traveling the pulses spread, with faster (slower) neutrons tending toward the leading (trailing) edge. The coherence length of the neutrons depends on the spectral width of their wavelength distribution. When a material with a neutron-nuclear optical potential is placed in one beam path in the NI, there is a loss of fringe visibility (contrast), which depends on the coherence length. By using time-of-flight techniques, we divide the pulse into time segments. Within a given time slice, the wavelength spectrum is narrower than in the pulse as a whole. As a result, contrast remains in the time slices even when it disappears in the overall pulse. We also observe an additional contrast modulation due to the overlap of neighboring pulses.