Introduction In this chapter we apply temporal discretization to mechanical systems described by anticommuting variables rather than the commuting variables normally used in classical mechanics (CM). The anticommuting numbers representing such variables are called Grassmann(ian) numbers by mathematicians, after Hermann G. Grassmann (1809–1877), who did some pioneering work in linear algebra. On that account we shall refer to anticommuting numbers as g-numbers , in contrast to c-numbers ( c for commuting 1 ) when we refer to ordinary real or complex variables. The significant difference between g-numbers and c-numbers is that, where as any two c numbers x and y satisfy the commutative multiplication rule xy = + yx , any two g-numbers θ and ϕ satisfy the anticommutation rule θ ϕ = –ϕ θ . G-numbers and c-numbers can be multiplied together in any order, i.e., g-numbers and c-numbers commute. The product zθ of a c-number z and a g-number θ is a g-number. The values of classical variables in ordinary CM are c-numbers, so we may refer to such variables as c-variables. It is possible to construct forms of CM where the classical variables are g-numbers, in which case we shall refer to such variables as g-variables. G-variables should not be thought of as quantized versions of c-variables. They are just as classical as c-variables but much less familiar in terms of their applications to the real world. G-variables should not be confused with Dirac's q-numbers either.
Introduction In this chapter we apply temporal discretization to mechanical systems described by anticommuting variables rather than the commuting variables normally used in classical mechanics (CM). The anticommuting numbers representing such variables are called Grassmann(ian) numbers by mathematicians, after Hermann G. Grassmann (1809–1877), who did some pioneering work in linear algebra. On that account we shall refer to anticommuting numbers as g-numbers , in contrast to c-numbers ( c for commuting 1 ) when we refer to ordinary real or complex variables. The significant difference between g-numbers and c-numbers is that, where as any two c numbers x and y satisfy the commutative multiplication rule xy = + yx , any two g-numbers θ and ϕ satisfy the anticommutation rule θ ϕ = –ϕ θ . G-numbers and c-numbers can be multiplied together in any order, i.e., g-numbers and c-numbers commute. The product zθ of a c-number z and a g-number θ is a g-number. The values of classical variables in ordinary CM are c-numbers, so we may refer to such variables as c-variables. It is possible to construct forms of CM where the classical variables are g-numbers, in which case we shall refer to such variables as g-variables. G-variables should not be thought of as quantized versions of c-variables. They are just as classical as c-variables but much less familiar in terms of their applications to the real world. G-variables should not be confused with Dirac's q-numbers either.
Abstract The laws of classical mechanics must be generalised when applied to atomic systems, the generalisation being that the commutative law of multiplication, as applied to dynamical variables, is to be replaced by certain quantum conditions, which are just sufficient to enable one to evaluate xy - yx when x and y are given. It follows that the dynamical variables cannot be ordinary numbers expressible in the decimal notation (which numbers will be called c-numbers), but may be considered to be numbers of a special kind (which will be called q-numbers), whose nature cannot be exactly specified, but which can be used in the algebraic solution of a dynamical problem in a manner closely analogous to the way the corresponding classical variables are used. The only justification for the names given to dynamical variables lies in the analogy to the classical theory, e. g., if one says that x, y, z are the Cartesian co-ordinates of an electron, one means only that x, y, z are q-numbers which appear in the quantum solution of the problem in an analogous way to the Cartesian co-ordinates of the electron in the classical solution. It may happen that two or more q-numbers are analogous to the same classical quantity (the analogy being, of course, imperfect and in different respects for the different q-numbers), and thus have claims to the same name. This occurs, for instance, when one considers what q-numbers shall be called the frequencies of a multiply periodic system, there being orbital frequencies and transition frequencies, either of which correspond in certain respects to the classical frequencies. In such a case one must decide which of the properties of the classical variable are dynamically the most important, and must choose the q-number which has these properties to be the corresponding quantum variable.
Abstract The new quantum mechanics, introduced by Heisenberg and since developed from different points of view by various authors, takes its simplest form if one assumes merely that the dynamical variables are numbers of a special type (called q-numbers to distinguish them from ordinary or c-numbers) that obey all the ordinary algebraic laws except the commutative law of multiplication, and satisfy instead of this the relations qrqs – qsqr =0, prps – pspr = 0 } qrqs – psqr = 0 (r ≠ s) or ih(r = s) where the p's and q's are a set of canonical variables and h is a c-number euqal to (2π)-1 times the usual Planck’s constant. Equations (1) may be regarded as replacing the commutative law of the classical theory, as one can, with their help, build up a complete algebraic theory of quantities that are analytic functions of a set of canonical variables. Further, it may easily be seen that the quantity [x, y] defined by xy – yz = ih [x, y] is completely analogous to the Poisson bracket of the classical theory. By means of this analogy the whole of the classical dynamical theory, in so far as it can be expressed in terms of P. B.’s instead of differential coefficients, may be taken over immediately into the quantum theory.
A k-dependent state has been constructed from two pairs of mutually commuting Fermi-Dirac operators by replacing the Grassmann numbers in the conventional definition of a fermion coherent state. The Heisenberg time-dependent form of this state was then combined with a particular spin state to give a resultant state \G], the spin component containing a series of unknown k-dependent weights. A classical c-number field, phi(c),(r, t), was then defined by an expectation value of the quantum field, psi, using \G] and an energy and time-dependent phase. It is demonstrated that the form of the equation of motion for phi(c)(r, t) is identical to that for psi. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V.
In this chapter we set up a classical Lagrangian and Hamiltonian dynamics for matrix models. The fundamental idea is to set up an analog of classical dynamics in which the phase space variables are non-commutative, and the basic tool that allows one to accomplish this is cyclic invariance under a trace. Since no assumptions about commutativity of the phase space variables (such as canonical commutators/anticommutators) are made at this stage, the dynamics that we set up is not the same as standard quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanical behavior will be seen to emerge only when, in Chapters 4 and 5, we study the statistical mechanics of the classical matrix dynamics formulated here. In Section 1.1, we introduce our basic notation for bosonic and fermionic matrices, and give the cyclic identities that will be used repeatedly throughout the book. In Section 1.2, we define the derivative of a trace quantity with respect to an operator, and give the basic properties of this definition. In Section 1.3, we use the operator derivative to formulate a Lagrangian and Hamiltonian dynamics for matrix models. In Section 1.4, we introduce a generalized Poisson bracket appropriate to trace dynamics, constructed from the operator derivative defined in Section 1.2, and give its properties and some applications. Finally, in Section 1.5 we discuss the relation between the trace dynamics time evolution equations, and the usual unitary Heisenberg picture equations of motion obtained when one assumes standard canonical commutators/anticommutators. Bosonic and fermionic matrices and the cyclic trace identities We shall assume finite-dimensional matrices, although ultimately an extension to the infinite-dimensional case may be needed. The matrix elements of these matrices will be constructed from ordinary complex numbers, and from complex anticommuting Grassmann numbers.
Abstract The new quantum mechanics consists of a scheme of equations which are very closely analogous to the equations of classical mechanics, with the fundamental difference that the dynamical variables do not obey the commutative law of multiplication, but satisfy instead the well-known quantum conditions. It follows that one cannot suppose the dynamical variables to be ordinary numbers (c-numbers), but may call them numbers of a special type (q-numbers). The theory shows that these q-numbers can in general be represented by matrices whose elements are c-numbers (functions of a time parameter). When one has performed the calculations with the q-numbers and obtained all the matrices one wants, the question arises how one is to get physical results from the theory, i. e., how can one obtain c-numbers from the theory that one can compare with experimental values ? Hitherto this has been done with the help of a number of special assumptions. In Heisenberg’s original matrix mechanics it was assumed that the elements of the diagonal matrix that represents the energy are the energy levels of the system, and the elements of the matrix that represents the total polarisation, which are periodic functions of the time, determine the frequencies and intensities of the spectral lines in analogy to the classical theory. Schrodinger’s wave representation of the quantum mechanics has provided new ways of obtaining physical results from the theory, based on the assumption that the square of the amplitude of the wave function can in certain cases be interpreted as a probability. From this assumption one can, for instance, work out the probability of a transition being produced in a system (or the number of transitions produced in an assembly of like systems) by an arbitrary external perturbing force, and can thus, by supposing the perturbation to consist of incident radiation, obtain directly Einstein’s B coefficients. Again in Born’s treatment of collision problems it is assumed that the square of the amplitude of the wave function scattered in any direction determines the probability of the colliding electron (or other body) being scattered in that direction.
The classical system is usually quantized using the canonical formalism, i.e., in the language of coordinates and momenta. In addition to this “purely algebraic” ambiguity, there is also an ambiguity in the choice of realization of the operators p^ and q^: the commutation relations do not determine it uniquely, but up to a unitary equivalence (the well known uniqueness theorem of von Neumann pertains only to the Weyl form of the commutation relations). The realization must be chosen on the basis of additional considerations regarding the nature of the canonical variables p and q. In this book the term “theory” is used in various ways: in a broad sense (quantum field theory, relativistic theory) and in a narrow sense, to refer to a particular system or class of systems with certain dynamics. In quantum theory there are also systems whose operators corresponding to canonical variables satisfy not commutation relations, but anticommutation relations.