Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Springer eBooks

Individual-particle and ensemble interpretations of quantum mechanics

Published Jan 1, 2004• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/0-306-48047-6_6

Related papers

Ensemble interpretations of quantum mechanics. A modern perspective

Dipankar Home, M. A. B. Whitaker

Physics Reports•Jan 1, 1992•101 citations

What object does the wave function describe?

Yuri A. Rylov

It is shown that the wave function describes the state of the statistical ensemble E[S] of individual particles, or the statistical average particle . This result follows from the fact that in the classical limit h=0 the Schroedinger equation turns to the dynamic equations for the statistical ensemble of classical particles. The statement that the wave function describes the state of an individual particle is incompatible with the quantum mechanics formalism. It is shown that the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics is a corollary of the fact, that the QM formalism is the technique of the statistical ensemble description, restricted by constraints of the dynamic equation linearity.

arXiv:physics/0405117•May 21, 2004•5 citations

Why Quantum Predicates Are Not Mass Terms: An Exercise in the Semantics and Metaphysics of QuantumTheory

Tomasz Bigaj

This article concerns the problem of identity and individuality of quantum particles. It has been suggested that ensembles of indistinguishable particles (e.g. electrons) can be treated in the way that is analogous to the way we refer to continuous matter using so-called mass terms (such as “water”). In the article I give several arguments against interpreting quantum predicates as mass terms. While the ontological interpretation of quantum objects as mass density fields determined by their wave functions is not uncommon in quantum mechanics (it features e.g. in the GRW interpretation of quantum theory), it is controversial to treat fragments of these fields as representing genuine entities picked out by quantum predicates. I point out that proper parts of electron matter-fields do not possess the same kinds of properties as whole electrons. Also, there are some measurable properties of ensembles of particles that cannot be recovered by describing a homogenized distribution of mass density. This problem affects both entangled and non-entangled states. In conclusion I opt for an approach (known as heterodoxy) according to which it is possible to individuate same-type particles momentarily using symmetric projectors.

Epistemology & Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Individualistic and Statistical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Peter Mittelstaedt

Boston studies in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 2000•1 citation

A reconstruction of quantum theory for nonspinning particles

U. Klein

Within the framework of the individuality interpretation of quantum theory (QT), the basic equations of QT cannot be derived from the basic equations of classical mechanics (CM). The unbridgeable gap between CM and QT is given by the fact that a certain system which is described in CM by a finite number of degrees of freedom requires an infinite number in QT. The standard quantization method, which is conceptually closely linked to the individuality interpretation, is limited to finding structural similarities between observables and operators. The fundamental question \emph{why} one must move from a finite number to an infinite number of degrees of freedom, remains unanswered. This gap can only be closed if probabilistic aspects are already taken into account in the classical area. This may be done by taking the uncertainty in initial conditions into account. In this probabilistic version of mechanics (PM), a system is mathematically described as an ensemble, with an infinite number of degrees of freedom, thus bridging the gap mentioned above. This step then enables the reconstruction of QT, in particular the derivation of the Schrödinger equation, from PM. This work is the third in a series of works in which this program is carried out. The method used here differs from the previous one and allows a better understanding of the structural differences between classical physics and QT. The derivation of the Schrödinger equation essentially takes place in two steps: a projection from phase space to configuration space and a linearization. Some contradictions of the individuality interpretation are analyzed and eliminated from the point of view of the ensemble interpretation.

arXiv:2202.13356•Feb 27, 2022•3 citations

A Real Ensemble Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Lee Smolin

arXiv:1104.2822•Foundations of Physics•Jun 5, 2012•47 citations
It is shown that the wave function describes the state of the statistical ensemble E[S] of individual particles, or the statistical average particle . This result follows from the fact that in the classical limit h=0 the Schroedinger equation turns to the dynamic equations for the statistical ensemble of classical particles. The statement that the wave function describes the state of an individual particle is incompatible with the quantum mechanics formalism. It is shown that the statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics is a corollary of the fact, that the QM formalism is the technique of the statistical ensemble description, restricted by constraints of the dynamic equation linearity.
This article concerns the problem of identity and individuality of quantum particles. It has been suggested that ensembles of indistinguishable particles (e.g. electrons) can be treated in the way that is analogous to the way we refer to continuous matter using so-called mass terms (such as “water”). In the article I give several arguments against interpreting quantum predicates as mass terms. While the ontological interpretation of quantum objects as mass density fields determined by their wave functions is not uncommon in quantum mechanics (it features e.g. in the GRW interpretation of quantum theory), it is controversial to treat fragments of these fields as representing genuine entities picked out by quantum predicates. I point out that proper parts of electron matter-fields do not possess the same kinds of properties as whole electrons. Also, there are some measurable properties of ensembles of particles that cannot be recovered by describing a homogenized distribution of mass density. This problem affects both entangled and non-entangled states. In conclusion I opt for an approach (known as heterodoxy) according to which it is possible to individuate same-type particles momentarily using symmetric projectors.
Within the framework of the individuality interpretation of quantum theory (QT), the basic equations of QT cannot be derived from the basic equations of classical mechanics (CM). The unbridgeable gap between CM and QT is given by the fact that a certain system which is described in CM by a finite number of degrees of freedom requires an infinite number in QT. The standard quantization method, which is conceptually closely linked to the individuality interpretation, is limited to finding structural similarities between observables and operators. The fundamental question \emph{why} one must move from a finite number to an infinite number of degrees of freedom, remains unanswered. This gap can only be closed if probabilistic aspects are already taken into account in the classical area. This may be done by taking the uncertainty in initial conditions into account. In this probabilistic version of mechanics (PM), a system is mathematically described as an ensemble, with an infinite number of degrees of freedom, thus bridging the gap mentioned above. This step then enables the reconstruction of QT, in particular the derivation of the Schrödinger equation, from PM. This work is the third in a series of works in which this program is carried out. The method used here differs from the previous one and allows a better understanding of the structural differences between classical physics and QT. The derivation of the Schrödinger equation essentially takes place in two steps: a projection from phase space to configuration space and a linearization. Some contradictions of the individuality interpretation are analyzed and eliminated from the point of view of the ensemble interpretation.