Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Macroscopic thermal entanglement

Nikola Paunković, Yasser Omar, Vitor Rocha Vieira

Published Jul 1, 2007• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We review recent results on the existence and use of entanglement in macroscopic systems at finite temperatures. Entanglement represents a particular quantum form of correlations and we explore the relevance of these correlations on thermodynamic properties of macroscopic systems, as well as its survival at finite temperatures. Various lower bounds for the entanglement temperature (the temperature below which entanglement surely exists in a system) are discussed and it is shown that, in some cases, macroscopic entanglement can exist even at room temperatures. Furthermore, the relevant correlations determining the macroscopic behavior of some systems are present due to entanglement only, as we show in the example of high-temperature superconductivity. Entanglement can also affect various thermodynamic properties, such as magnetic susceptibility, internal energy and pressure. Motivated by the fact that entanglement is a crucial resource for quantum information processing, we also discuss how to extract it from macroscopic systems, namely from spin-chains. Finally, we illustrate the generation and manipulation of entanglement in a macroscopic system of non-interacting hopping bosons.

DOI
10.1142/9789812772206_0021

Related papers

Macroscopic Entanglement and Phase Transitions

Janet Anders, Vlatko Vedral

This paper summarises the results of our research on macroscopic entanglement in spin systems and free Bosonic gases. We explain how entanglement can be observed using entanglement witnesses which are themselves constructed within the framework of thermodynamics and thus macroscopic observables. These thermodynamical entanglement witnesses result in bounds on macroscopic parameters of the system, such as the temperature, the energy or the susceptibility, below which entanglement must be present. The derived bounds indicate a relationship between the occurrence of entanglement and the establishment of order, possibly resulting in phase transition phenomena. We give a short overview over the concepts developed in condensed matter physics to capture the characteristics of phase transitions in particular in terms of order and correlation functions. Finally we want to ask and speculate whether entanglement could be a generalised order concept by itself, relevant in (quantum induced) phase transitions such as BEC, and that taking this view may help us to understand the underlying process of high-T superconductivity.

arXiv:quant-ph/0610268•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Mar 1, 2007•21 citations

High-temperature macroscopic entanglement

Vlatko Vedral

In this paper, we intend to show that macroscopic entanglement is possible at high temperatures. We have analysed multipartite entanglement produced by the η-pairing mechanism, which features strongly in the fermionic lattice models of high T c superconductivity. This problem is shown to be equivalent to calculating multipartite entanglement in totally symmetric states of qubits. It is demonstrated that we can conclusively calculate the relative entropy of entanglement within any subset of qubits in the overall symmetric state. Three main results are then presented. First, the condition for superconductivity, namely existence of the off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), is dependent not on two-site entanglement but just classical correlations as the sites become more and more distant. Secondly, the entanglement that does survive in the thermodynamical limit is the entanglement of the total lattice and, at half-filling, it scales with the log of the number of sites. It is this entanglement that will exist at temperatures below the superconducting critical temperature, which can currently be as high as 160 K. Finally, it is proved that a complete mixture of symmetric states does not contain any entanglement in the macroscopic limit. On the other hand, a mixture of symmetric states possesses the same two qubit entanglement features as the pure states involved, in the sense that the mixing does not destroy entanglement for a finite number of qubits, albeit it does decrease it. Furthermore, maximal mixing of symmetric states does not destroy ODLRO and classical correlations. We discuss generalizations to the subsystems of any dimensionality (i.e. higher than spin-half).

arXiv:quant-ph/0405102•New Journal of Physics•Aug 9, 2004•138 citations

Mean-field approximations and multipartite thermal correlations

Vlatko Vedral

The relationship between the mean-field approximations in various interacting models of statistical physics and measures of classical and quantum correlations is explored. We present a method that allows us to find an upper bound for the total amount of correlations (and hence entanglement) in a physical system in thermal equilibrium at some temperature in terms of its free energy and internal energy. This method is first illustrated by using two qubits interacting through the Heisenberg coupling, where entanglement and correlations can be computed exactly. It is then applied to the one-dimensional (1D) Ising model in a transverse magnetic field, for which entanglement and correlations cannot be obtained by exact methods. We analyse the behaviour of correlations in various regimes and identify critical regions, comparing them with already known results. Finally, we present a general discussion of the effects of entanglement on the macroscopic, thermodynamical features of solid-state systems. In particular, we exploit the fact that a d -dimensional quantum system in thermal equilibrium can be made to correspond to a ( d +1)-dimensional classical system in equilibrium to substitute all entanglement for classical correlations.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312104•New Journal of Physics•Feb 10, 2004•38 citations

Thermal entanglement of spin chains with quantum critical behavior

Andrei A. Zvyagin

Results for the characteristics of the macroscopic thermal entanglement for integrable spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic chain models with multispin interactions in the thermodynamic limit are presented. Such interactions cause quantum-phase transitions to incommensurate phases with partial spontaneous magnetization. We have derived exact equations, which determine the thermal and magnetic field behavior of the concurrence of spin chains. The analysis of these equations shows that there exists a critical temperature, below which the thermal entanglement of considered spin chains is nonzero. We have shown that at those quantum-phase transitions, caused by multispin interactions, the thermal entanglement is reduced. Also, we have shown that the thermal entanglement is reduced due to nonzero magnetization of spin chains in the ground state, caused by multispin interactions.

Physical Review B•Oct 12, 2009•11 citations

Entanglement in many-body systems

Luigi Amico A, Rosario Fazio, Andreas Osterloh +1 more

Recent interest in aspects common to quantum information and condensed matter has prompted a flurry of activity at the border of these disciplines that were far distant until a few years ago. Numerous interesting questions have been addressed so far. Here an important part of this field, the properties of the entanglement in many-body systems, are reviewed. The zero and finite temperature properties of entanglement in interacting spin, fermion, and boson model systems are discussed. Both bipartite and multipartite entanglement will be considered. In equilibrium entanglement is shown tightly connected to the characteristics of the phase diagram. The behavior of entanglement can be related, via certain witnesses, to thermodynamic quantities thus offering interesting possibilities for an experimental test. Out of equilibrium entangled states are generated and manipulated by means of many-body Hamiltonians.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703044•Reviews of Modern Physics•May 6, 2008•3,857 citations

Multipartite entanglement in spin chains

Otfried Gühne, Géza Tóth, Hans J. Briegel

We investigate the presence of multipartite entanglement in macroscopic spin chains. We discuss the Heisenberg and the XY model and derive bounds on the internal energy for systems without multipartite entanglement. Based on this we show that in thermal equilibrium the above-mentioned spin systems contain genuine multipartite entanglement, even at finite modest temperatures.

arXiv:quant-ph/0502160•New Journal of Physics•Nov 4, 2005•245 citations
We review recent results on the existence and use of entanglement in macroscopic systems at finite temperatures. Entanglement represents a particular quantum form of correlations and we explore the relevance of these correlations on thermodynamic properties of macroscopic systems, as well as its survival at finite temperatures. Various lower bounds for the entanglement temperature (the temperature below which entanglement surely exists in a system) are discussed and it is shown that, in some cases, macroscopic entanglement can exist even at room temperatures. Furthermore, the relevant correlations determining the macroscopic behavior of some systems are present due to entanglement only, as we show in the example of high-temperature superconductivity. Entanglement can also affect various thermodynamic properties, such as magnetic susceptibility, internal energy and pressure. Motivated by the fact that entanglement is a crucial resource for quantum information processing, we also discuss how to extract it from macroscopic systems, namely from spin-chains. Finally, we illustrate the generation and manipulation of entanglement in a macroscopic system of non-interacting hopping bosons.
This paper summarises the results of our research on macroscopic entanglement in spin systems and free Bosonic gases. We explain how entanglement can be observed using entanglement witnesses which are themselves constructed within the framework of thermodynamics and thus macroscopic observables. These thermodynamical entanglement witnesses result in bounds on macroscopic parameters of the system, such as the temperature, the energy or the susceptibility, below which entanglement must be present. The derived bounds indicate a relationship between the occurrence of entanglement and the establishment of order, possibly resulting in phase transition phenomena. We give a short overview over the concepts developed in condensed matter physics to capture the characteristics of phase transitions in particular in terms of order and correlation functions. Finally we want to ask and speculate whether entanglement could be a generalised order concept by itself, relevant in (quantum induced) phase transitions such as BEC, and that taking this view may help us to understand the underlying process of high-T superconductivity.
In this paper, we intend to show that macroscopic entanglement is possible at high temperatures. We have analysed multipartite entanglement produced by the η-pairing mechanism, which features strongly in the fermionic lattice models of high T c superconductivity. This problem is shown to be equivalent to calculating multipartite entanglement in totally symmetric states of qubits. It is demonstrated that we can conclusively calculate the relative entropy of entanglement within any subset of qubits in the overall symmetric state. Three main results are then presented. First, the condition for superconductivity, namely existence of the off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO), is dependent not on two-site entanglement but just classical correlations as the sites become more and more distant. Secondly, the entanglement that does survive in the thermodynamical limit is the entanglement of the total lattice and, at half-filling, it scales with the log of the number of sites. It is this entanglement that will exist at temperatures below the superconducting critical temperature, which can currently be as high as 160 K. Finally, it is proved that a complete mixture of symmetric states does not contain any entanglement in the macroscopic limit. On the other hand, a mixture of symmetric states possesses the same two qubit entanglement features as the pure states involved, in the sense that the mixing does not destroy entanglement for a finite number of qubits, albeit it does decrease it. Furthermore, maximal mixing of symmetric states does not destroy ODLRO and classical correlations. We discuss generalizations to the subsystems of any dimensionality (i.e. higher than spin-half).
The relationship between the mean-field approximations in various interacting models of statistical physics and measures of classical and quantum correlations is explored. We present a method that allows us to find an upper bound for the total amount of correlations (and hence entanglement) in a physical system in thermal equilibrium at some temperature in terms of its free energy and internal energy. This method is first illustrated by using two qubits interacting through the Heisenberg coupling, where entanglement and correlations can be computed exactly. It is then applied to the one-dimensional (1D) Ising model in a transverse magnetic field, for which entanglement and correlations cannot be obtained by exact methods. We analyse the behaviour of correlations in various regimes and identify critical regions, comparing them with already known results. Finally, we present a general discussion of the effects of entanglement on the macroscopic, thermodynamical features of solid-state systems. In particular, we exploit the fact that a d -dimensional quantum system in thermal equilibrium can be made to correspond to a ( d +1)-dimensional classical system in equilibrium to substitute all entanglement for classical correlations.
Results for the characteristics of the macroscopic thermal entanglement for integrable spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic chain models with multispin interactions in the thermodynamic limit are presented. Such interactions cause quantum-phase transitions to incommensurate phases with partial spontaneous magnetization. We have derived exact equations, which determine the thermal and magnetic field behavior of the concurrence of spin chains. The analysis of these equations shows that there exists a critical temperature, below which the thermal entanglement of considered spin chains is nonzero. We have shown that at those quantum-phase transitions, caused by multispin interactions, the thermal entanglement is reduced. Also, we have shown that the thermal entanglement is reduced due to nonzero magnetization of spin chains in the ground state, caused by multispin interactions.
Recent interest in aspects common to quantum information and condensed matter has prompted a flurry of activity at the border of these disciplines that were far distant until a few years ago. Numerous interesting questions have been addressed so far. Here an important part of this field, the properties of the entanglement in many-body systems, are reviewed. The zero and finite temperature properties of entanglement in interacting spin, fermion, and boson model systems are discussed. Both bipartite and multipartite entanglement will be considered. In equilibrium entanglement is shown tightly connected to the characteristics of the phase diagram. The behavior of entanglement can be related, via certain witnesses, to thermodynamic quantities thus offering interesting possibilities for an experimental test. Out of equilibrium entangled states are generated and manipulated by means of many-body Hamiltonians.