Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature: bounds on the CSL parameters

Sebastiano Belli, Riccarda Bonsignori, G. D’Auria, Lorenzo Fant, M. Martini, Simone Peirone, Sandro Donadi, A. Bassi

Published Jan 28, 2016• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A recent experiment announced on Science [1] succeeded in detecting entanglement between two macroscopic specks of diamonds, separated by a macroscopic distance, at room temperature. This impressive results is a further confirmation of the validity of quantum theory in (at least parts of) the mesoscopic and macroscopic domain, and poses a challenge to collpase models, which predict a violation of the quantum superposition principle, which is the bigger the larger the system. We analyze the experiment in the light of such models. We will show that the bounds placed by experimental data are weaker than those coming from mater-wave interferometry and non-interferometric tests of collapse models.

Related papers

Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature: Bounds on the continuous-spontaneous-localization parameters

Sebastiano Belli, Riccarda Bonsignori, Giuseppe D'Auria +5 more

A recent experiment [K. C. Lee et al., Science 334, 1253 (2011)] succeeded in detecting entanglement between two macroscopic specks of diamonds, separated by a macroscopic distance, at room temperature. This impressive result is a further confirmation of the validity of quantum theory in (at least parts of) the mesoscopic and macroscopic domain, and poses a challenge to collapse models, which predict a violation of the quantum superposition principle, which is bigger the larger the system. We analyze the experiment in the light of such models. We will show that the bounds placed by experimental data are weaker than those coming from matter-wave interferometry and noninterferometric tests of collapse models.

arXiv:1601.07927•Physical Review A•Jul 12, 2016•37 citations

Entangling Macroscopic Diamonds at Room Temperature

K. C. Lee, Michael Sprague, Benjamin Sussman +9 more

Quantum entanglement in the motion of macroscopic solid bodies has implications both for quantum technologies and foundational studies of the boundary between the quantum and classical worlds. Entanglement is usually fragile in room-temperature solids, owing to strong interactions both internally and with the noisy environment. We generated motional entanglement between vibrational states of two spatially separated, millimeter-sized diamonds at room temperature. By measuring strong nonclassical correlations between Raman-scattered photons, we showed that the quantum state of the diamonds has positive concurrence with 98% probability. Our results show that entanglement can persist in the classical context of moving macroscopic solids in ambient conditions.

Science•Dec 2, 2011•398 citations

Macroscopic Quantum Coherence in Crystals and the UAT Phase-Lattice Analogy: A Conceptual Note

Miguel Percudani

This submission presents a conceptual note exploring the analogy between two phenomena: (1) the experimentally demonstrated persistence of quantum coherence and entanglement in macroscopic systems at room temperature, and (2) the phase-lattice architecture of the 8-coil interferometer developed within the UAT/UCP framework. The note cites three peer-reviewed experimental breakthroughs: Lee et al., Science 334, 1253–1256 (2011): Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature using femtosecond laser pulses and collective phonon modes. Kotler et al., Science 372, 622–625 (2021): Direct observation of quantum entanglement between macroscopic aluminum drumheads containing trillions of atoms. Aspelmeyer et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 1391 (2014): Cavity optomechanics and the geometric protection of coherence in engineered periodic structures. The common principle identified is that rigid geometric coupling of many degrees of freedom into a collective mode can shield global coherence from local thermal fluctuations. The note draws a conceptual parallel to the UAT 8-coil phase interferometer, where the precise phase step of 43.515° (derived from the quantum braking factor k_early = 0.967) creates an electromagnetic phase lattice. In this analogy, the Ivancho limit (κ_crit = 4.978) corresponds to the coherence threshold, and the 7% thermal calibration margin corresponds to the noise absorption buffer. Limitations are explicitly acknowledged: the physical substrates are different (phononic vs. electromagnetic), the coherence timescales differ, no direct experimental link exists between the two phenomena, and the UAT framework is not validated by these experiments. The note is a conceptual reflection, not a claim of experimental confirmation. The package includes the LaTeX manuscript.

•Jul 11, 2026•1 citation

Macroscopic Quantum Coherence in Crystals and the UAT Phase-Lattice Analogy: A Conceptual Note

Miguel Percudani

This submission presents a conceptual note exploring the analogy between two phenomena: (1) the experimentally demonstrated persistence of quantum coherence and entanglement in macroscopic systems at room temperature, and (2) the phase-lattice architecture of the 8-coil interferometer developed within the UAT/UCP framework. The note cites three peer-reviewed experimental breakthroughs: Lee et al., Science 334, 1253–1256 (2011): Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature using femtosecond laser pulses and collective phonon modes. Kotler et al., Science 372, 622–625 (2021): Direct observation of quantum entanglement between macroscopic aluminum drumheads containing trillions of atoms. Aspelmeyer et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 1391 (2014): Cavity optomechanics and the geometric protection of coherence in engineered periodic structures. The common principle identified is that rigid geometric coupling of many degrees of freedom into a collective mode can shield global coherence from local thermal fluctuations. The note draws a conceptual parallel to the UAT 8-coil phase interferometer, where the precise phase step of 43.515° (derived from the quantum braking factor k_early = 0.967) creates an electromagnetic phase lattice. In this analogy, the Ivancho limit (κ_crit = 4.978) corresponds to the coherence threshold, and the 7% thermal calibration margin corresponds to the noise absorption buffer. Limitations are explicitly acknowledged: the physical substrates are different (phononic vs. electromagnetic), the coherence timescales differ, no direct experimental link exists between the two phenomena, and the UAT framework is not validated by these experiments. The note is a conceptual reflection, not a claim of experimental confirmation. The package includes the LaTeX manuscript.

•Jul 11, 2026•0 citations

Open Quantum System dynamics: Applications to Decoherence and Collapse models

Matteo Carlesso

Quantum mechanics exhibits a broad collection of theoretical results in complete agreement with experimental evidence. Besides showing unquestionable success in the description of isolated systems, it can be also successfully used to characterize non-isolated quantum system. In such a case, phenomena like dissipation, diffusion or decoherence. The theory of open quantum systems provides the framework where such features can be conveniently explained. \nThis thesis is about decoherence and collapse models. Albeit conceptually they are very far from each other, they both belong the framework of open quantum systems. Indeed, they consider systems interacting with an external entity: an environment for decoherence models, a noise for collapse models. Although the external influence has different origin, they can be described by similar dynamical equations and, to confirm or falsify them, the same experimental tests can be performed. \nThe quantum Brownian motion model can be considered the paradigm of decoherence models. We provide an exact and analytic equation for the time evolution of the operators and we show that the corresponding equation for the states is equivalent to well-known results in the literature. Our derivation allows to compute the time evolution of physically relevant quantities in a much easier way than previous formulations. Moreover, we are not bound to compute the time evolution of the state of the system, which in general is a complicated task. The explicit dependence on the initial state appears only in the initial expectation values and not in the dynamics. This makes possible the derivation of expectation values also for nontrivial states. \nAnother decoherence model we considered is a recently proposed model, based on the mass-energy equivalence. The model describes a decoherence source acting universally on every system whose superposition is extended on positions experiencing different gravitational potentials. We studied the conditions under which this mechanism becomes the dominant decoherence effect in typical interferometric experiments. We show that current experiments are off by several orders of magnitude. New ideas are needed to achieve the necessary requirements. \nThe second part of this thesis concerns collapse models, in particular the Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model. We focus on experimental tests that can probe it. In this respect, experiments can be grouped in two classes: interferometric tests and non-interferometric ones. The first class includes those experiments, which directly create and detect quantum superpositions of the center of mass of massive systems. The strongest bounds on the CSL parameters come from the second class of non-interferometric experiments, which are sensitive to small position displacements and detect CSL-induced diffusion in position. \nWe investigate how we can benefit from the non-interferometric perspective given by optomechanical setups, which have reached high sensitivities as force and position sensors. Three examples are considered.\nFirst, we compute the upper bounds on the CSL parameters, which can be inferred by the gravitational wave detectors LIGO, LISA Pathfinder and AURIGA.\nSecond, we report new results from an experiment based on a high-quality cantilever cooled to millikelvin temperature. High accuracy measurements of the cantilever thermal fluctuations reveal a nonthermal force noise of unknown origin. This excess noise is compatible with the CSL heating predicted by Adler. Several physical mechanisms able to explain the observed noise have been ruled out.\nThird, we propose an unattempted non-interferometric test aimed to investigate the still unexplored region of the CSL parameter space. Our proposal relies on torsional degrees of freedom rather than the usual vibrational ones. We believe that the test that has been put forward here, will eventually probe the unexplored CSL parameter space.

•Feb 6, 2018•0 citations

Research on the Quantum Entanglement Mechanism

Xiangyao Wu, Benshan Wu

A quantum entangled state is a quantum superposition state. The principle of quantum superposition, and therefore the existence of quantum entanglement, is contingent upon the validity of quantum theory. Thus, the generation of quantum entanglement requires that interactions occur between small-mass particles localized in a confined spatial region, resulting in each particle’s quantum state being a bound state. In other words, the prerequisite for the validity of quantum theory must be satisfied. At the same time, conserved quantities must exist between quantum superposition states, as only quantum states with conserved quantities can undergo superposition, allowing the particle system to generate quantum entangled states. Quantum entangled states can occur between electrons within an atom, between atoms, between molecules, or between atoms and molecules. Within the atomic nucleus, quantum entanglement can exist among protons, neutrons, and the quarks. In superconductivity, superfluidity, and Bose-Einstein condensation, they manifest as macroscopic quantum entanglement, which respectively come from the statistical results of a large amount of microscopic quantum entanglement between electrons, atoms or molecules. For massive macroscopic objects, they exhibit classical properties that cannot be described by quantum theory, and the principle of quantum superposition does not hold. Therefore, no entangled state is generated. It should be particularly emphasized that even for microscopic particle systems, if they exist in a large spatial region, they cannot be described by quantum theory. In such cases, the quantum superposition principle does not hold, and quantum entanglement phenomena do not exist. Therefore, within a large spatial region, multi-electron, multi-photon, and other microscopic systems do not have quantum entangled states; under certain conditions, quantum correlated states can be generated. Consequently, in a large spatial region, the mainstream viewpoints about non-locality—such as the so-called instantaneous collapse of entangled particles during measurement, infinite propagation speed, and the “spooky action at a distance”—are all incorrect. In experiments related to quantum communication and the verification of Bell’s inequality, the quantum states used are quantum correlated states rather than quantum entangled states. Regardless of whether the systems are microscopic or macroscopic, phenomena occurring in a large spatial region must adhere to the principles of causality, realism, and locality. In other words, Einstein’s viewpoint is correct.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
A recent experiment announced on Science [1] succeeded in detecting entanglement between two macroscopic specks of diamonds, separated by a macroscopic distance, at room temperature. This impressive results is a further confirmation of the validity of quantum theory in (at least parts of) the mesoscopic and macroscopic domain, and poses a challenge to collpase models, which predict a violation of the quantum superposition principle, which is the bigger the larger the system. We analyze the experiment in the light of such models. We will show that the bounds placed by experimental data are weaker than those coming from mater-wave interferometry and non-interferometric tests of collapse models.
A recent experiment [K. C. Lee et al., Science 334, 1253 (2011)] succeeded in detecting entanglement between two macroscopic specks of diamonds, separated by a macroscopic distance, at room temperature. This impressive result is a further confirmation of the validity of quantum theory in (at least parts of) the mesoscopic and macroscopic domain, and poses a challenge to collapse models, which predict a violation of the quantum superposition principle, which is bigger the larger the system. We analyze the experiment in the light of such models. We will show that the bounds placed by experimental data are weaker than those coming from matter-wave interferometry and noninterferometric tests of collapse models.
Quantum entanglement in the motion of macroscopic solid bodies has implications both for quantum technologies and foundational studies of the boundary between the quantum and classical worlds. Entanglement is usually fragile in room-temperature solids, owing to strong interactions both internally and with the noisy environment. We generated motional entanglement between vibrational states of two spatially separated, millimeter-sized diamonds at room temperature. By measuring strong nonclassical correlations between Raman-scattered photons, we showed that the quantum state of the diamonds has positive concurrence with 98% probability. Our results show that entanglement can persist in the classical context of moving macroscopic solids in ambient conditions.
This submission presents a conceptual note exploring the analogy between two phenomena: (1) the experimentally demonstrated persistence of quantum coherence and entanglement in macroscopic systems at room temperature, and (2) the phase-lattice architecture of the 8-coil interferometer developed within the UAT/UCP framework. The note cites three peer-reviewed experimental breakthroughs: Lee et al., Science 334, 1253–1256 (2011): Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature using femtosecond laser pulses and collective phonon modes. Kotler et al., Science 372, 622–625 (2021): Direct observation of quantum entanglement between macroscopic aluminum drumheads containing trillions of atoms. Aspelmeyer et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 1391 (2014): Cavity optomechanics and the geometric protection of coherence in engineered periodic structures. The common principle identified is that rigid geometric coupling of many degrees of freedom into a collective mode can shield global coherence from local thermal fluctuations. The note draws a conceptual parallel to the UAT 8-coil phase interferometer, where the precise phase step of 43.515° (derived from the quantum braking factor k_early = 0.967) creates an electromagnetic phase lattice. In this analogy, the Ivancho limit (κ_crit = 4.978) corresponds to the coherence threshold, and the 7% thermal calibration margin corresponds to the noise absorption buffer. Limitations are explicitly acknowledged: the physical substrates are different (phononic vs. electromagnetic), the coherence timescales differ, no direct experimental link exists between the two phenomena, and the UAT framework is not validated by these experiments. The note is a conceptual reflection, not a claim of experimental confirmation. The package includes the LaTeX manuscript.
This submission presents a conceptual note exploring the analogy between two phenomena: (1) the experimentally demonstrated persistence of quantum coherence and entanglement in macroscopic systems at room temperature, and (2) the phase-lattice architecture of the 8-coil interferometer developed within the UAT/UCP framework. The note cites three peer-reviewed experimental breakthroughs: Lee et al., Science 334, 1253–1256 (2011): Entangling macroscopic diamonds at room temperature using femtosecond laser pulses and collective phonon modes. Kotler et al., Science 372, 622–625 (2021): Direct observation of quantum entanglement between macroscopic aluminum drumheads containing trillions of atoms. Aspelmeyer et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 1391 (2014): Cavity optomechanics and the geometric protection of coherence in engineered periodic structures. The common principle identified is that rigid geometric coupling of many degrees of freedom into a collective mode can shield global coherence from local thermal fluctuations. The note draws a conceptual parallel to the UAT 8-coil phase interferometer, where the precise phase step of 43.515° (derived from the quantum braking factor k_early = 0.967) creates an electromagnetic phase lattice. In this analogy, the Ivancho limit (κ_crit = 4.978) corresponds to the coherence threshold, and the 7% thermal calibration margin corresponds to the noise absorption buffer. Limitations are explicitly acknowledged: the physical substrates are different (phononic vs. electromagnetic), the coherence timescales differ, no direct experimental link exists between the two phenomena, and the UAT framework is not validated by these experiments. The note is a conceptual reflection, not a claim of experimental confirmation. The package includes the LaTeX manuscript.
Quantum mechanics exhibits a broad collection of theoretical results in complete agreement with experimental evidence. Besides showing unquestionable success in the description of isolated systems, it can be also successfully used to characterize non-isolated quantum system. In such a case, phenomena like dissipation, diffusion or decoherence. The theory of open quantum systems provides the framework where such features can be conveniently explained. \nThis thesis is about decoherence and collapse models. Albeit conceptually they are very far from each other, they both belong the framework of open quantum systems. Indeed, they consider systems interacting with an external entity: an environment for decoherence models, a noise for collapse models. Although the external influence has different origin, they can be described by similar dynamical equations and, to confirm or falsify them, the same experimental tests can be performed. \nThe quantum Brownian motion model can be considered the paradigm of decoherence models. We provide an exact and analytic equation for the time evolution of the operators and we show that the corresponding equation for the states is equivalent to well-known results in the literature. Our derivation allows to compute the time evolution of physically relevant quantities in a much easier way than previous formulations. Moreover, we are not bound to compute the time evolution of the state of the system, which in general is a complicated task. The explicit dependence on the initial state appears only in the initial expectation values and not in the dynamics. This makes possible the derivation of expectation values also for nontrivial states. \nAnother decoherence model we considered is a recently proposed model, based on the mass-energy equivalence. The model describes a decoherence source acting universally on every system whose superposition is extended on positions experiencing different gravitational potentials. We studied the conditions under which this mechanism becomes the dominant decoherence effect in typical interferometric experiments. We show that current experiments are off by several orders of magnitude. New ideas are needed to achieve the necessary requirements. \nThe second part of this thesis concerns collapse models, in particular the Continuous Spontaneous Localization (CSL) model. We focus on experimental tests that can probe it. In this respect, experiments can be grouped in two classes: interferometric tests and non-interferometric ones. The first class includes those experiments, which directly create and detect quantum superpositions of the center of mass of massive systems. The strongest bounds on the CSL parameters come from the second class of non-interferometric experiments, which are sensitive to small position displacements and detect CSL-induced diffusion in position. \nWe investigate how we can benefit from the non-interferometric perspective given by optomechanical setups, which have reached high sensitivities as force and position sensors. Three examples are considered.\nFirst, we compute the upper bounds on the CSL parameters, which can be inferred by the gravitational wave detectors LIGO, LISA Pathfinder and AURIGA.\nSecond, we report new results from an experiment based on a high-quality cantilever cooled to millikelvin temperature. High accuracy measurements of the cantilever thermal fluctuations reveal a nonthermal force noise of unknown origin. This excess noise is compatible with the CSL heating predicted by Adler. Several physical mechanisms able to explain the observed noise have been ruled out.\nThird, we propose an unattempted non-interferometric test aimed to investigate the still unexplored region of the CSL parameter space. Our proposal relies on torsional degrees of freedom rather than the usual vibrational ones. We believe that the test that has been put forward here, will eventually probe the unexplored CSL parameter space.
A quantum entangled state is a quantum superposition state. The principle of quantum superposition, and therefore the existence of quantum entanglement, is contingent upon the validity of quantum theory. Thus, the generation of quantum entanglement requires that interactions occur between small-mass particles localized in a confined spatial region, resulting in each particle’s quantum state being a bound state. In other words, the prerequisite for the validity of quantum theory must be satisfied. At the same time, conserved quantities must exist between quantum superposition states, as only quantum states with conserved quantities can undergo superposition, allowing the particle system to generate quantum entangled states. Quantum entangled states can occur between electrons within an atom, between atoms, between molecules, or between atoms and molecules. Within the atomic nucleus, quantum entanglement can exist among protons, neutrons, and the quarks. In superconductivity, superfluidity, and Bose-Einstein condensation, they manifest as macroscopic quantum entanglement, which respectively come from the statistical results of a large amount of microscopic quantum entanglement between electrons, atoms or molecules. For massive macroscopic objects, they exhibit classical properties that cannot be described by quantum theory, and the principle of quantum superposition does not hold. Therefore, no entangled state is generated. It should be particularly emphasized that even for microscopic particle systems, if they exist in a large spatial region, they cannot be described by quantum theory. In such cases, the quantum superposition principle does not hold, and quantum entanglement phenomena do not exist. Therefore, within a large spatial region, multi-electron, multi-photon, and other microscopic systems do not have quantum entangled states; under certain conditions, quantum correlated states can be generated. Consequently, in a large spatial region, the mainstream viewpoints about non-locality—such as the so-called instantaneous collapse of entangled particles during measurement, infinite propagation speed, and the “spooky action at a distance”—are all incorrect. In experiments related to quantum communication and the verification of Bell’s inequality, the quantum states used are quantum correlated states rather than quantum entangled states. Regardless of whether the systems are microscopic or macroscopic, phenomena occurring in a large spatial region must adhere to the principles of causality, realism, and locality. In other words, Einstein’s viewpoint is correct.