World Scientific series in 20th century physics
Paper 6.4: "Quantum Mechanics and Precision Measurements," N. F. Ramsey, Physica Scripta T59, 26–28 (1995)
Abstract
Philosophers and historians of science, when discussing the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, often imply that the principal effects of quantum mechanics on measurements are to reduce the attainable precision. In this paper I point out seven different ways in which quantum mechanics affects precision measurements and that six of these make highly precise measurements possible and meaningful while only one — the uncertainty principle — is a serious limitation to accuracy. The limitations of the uncertainty principle are valid and important, but they can often be partially overcome by various means, including measurements in long-lived states and observations of many atoms. The existence of quantized states and the identity principle — that two atoms in the same quantum state are not merely closely similar but truly identical — make highly precise measurements both possible and meaningful. Thus, in the commentary on Paper 2.8 the hyperfine separation of atomic hydrogen is measured to an accuracy of one part in a million million (10 12 ). The identity principle assures that observers in France and the United States will get the same answer except for known relativistic corrections. On the other hand, a classical quantity, such as the height of the Eiffel Tower, cannot be measured nearly so accurately since it changes from one moment to the next.