Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

World Scientific series in 20th century physics

Paper 6.4: "Quantum Mechanics and Precision Measurements," N. F. Ramsey, Physica Scripta T59, 26–28 (1995)

Published Jun 1, 1998• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Philosophers and historians of science, when discussing the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, often imply that the principal effects of quantum mechanics on measurements are to reduce the attainable precision. In this paper I point out seven different ways in which quantum mechanics affects precision measurements and that six of these make highly precise measurements possible and meaningful while only one — the uncertainty principle — is a serious limitation to accuracy. The limitations of the uncertainty principle are valid and important, but they can often be partially overcome by various means, including measurements in long-lived states and observations of many atoms. The existence of quantized states and the identity principle — that two atoms in the same quantum state are not merely closely similar but truly identical — make highly precise measurements both possible and meaningful. Thus, in the commentary on Paper 2.8 the hyperfine separation of atomic hydrogen is measured to an accuracy of one part in a million million (10 12 ). The identity principle assures that observers in France and the United States will get the same answer except for known relativistic corrections. On the other hand, a classical quantity, such as the height of the Eiffel Tower, cannot be measured nearly so accurately since it changes from one moment to the next.

DOI
10.1142/9789812795717_0056

Related papers

Quantum mechanics and the science of measurements

Norman F. Ramsey

The accuracies of measurements of almost all fundamental physical constants have increased by factors of about 10,000 during the past 60 years. Although some of the improvements are due to greater care, most are due to new techniques based on quantum mechanics. In popular accounts of quantum mechanics, such great emphases is placed on the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle that it often appears that the primary effect of quantum mechanics should be to diminish measurement accuracy whereas in most cases it is the validity of quantum mechanics that makes possible the vastly improved measurement accuracies. Seven quantum features that have a profound influence on the science of measurements are: (1) Existence of discrete quantum states of energy Wi. (2) Energy conservation in transitions between two states. (3) Electromagnetic radiation of frequency ν is quantized with energy hν per quantum. (4) The identity principle. (5) The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. (6) Addition of probability amplitudes (not probabilities) so P=|ψ1 +ψ2 |2 ≠|ψ1|2 + |ψ2 |2. (7) Wave and coherent phase phenomena. Of these seven quantum features, only the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle limits the accuracy of measurements, and its affect is often negligibly small. The other six features make possible much more accurate measurements of quantum systems than with almost all classical systems and the identity principle provides meaning and significance to highly precise measurements with quantized systems. These effects are discussed and illustrated.

Journal de Physique II•Apr 1, 1992•3 citations

Quantum mechanics and precision measurements

Norman F. Ramsey

The accuracies of measurements of almost all fundamental physical constants have increased by factors of about 10 000 during the past 60 years. Although some of the improvements are due to greater care, most are due to new techniques based on quantum mechanics. Although the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle often limits measurement accuracies, in many cases the validity of quantum mechanics makes possible the vastly improved measurement accuracies. Seven quantum features that have a profound influence on the science of measurements are: (1) Existence of discrete quantum states of energy. (2) Energy conservation in transitions between two states. (3) Electromagnetic radiation of frequency v is quantized with energy hv per quantum. (4) The identity principle. (5) The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. (6) Addition of probability amplitudes (not probabilities). (7) Wave and coherent phase phenomena. Of these seven quantum features, only the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle limits the accuracy of measurements, and its affect is often negligibly small. The other six features make possible much more accurate measurements of quantum systems than with almost all classical systems. These effects are discussed and illustrated.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1995•8 citations

Remarks on Uncertainty Principles

E. U. Condon

Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, $$ \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} $$ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.

Science•May 31, 1929•16 citations

Uncertainty relations as Hilbert space geometry

Samuel L. Braunstein

Precision measurements involve the accurate determination of parameters through repeated measurements of identically prepared experimental setups. For many parameters there is a 'natural' choice for the quantum observable which is expected to give optimal information; and from this observable one can construct an Heinsenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) bound on the precision attainable for the parameter. However, the classical statistics of multiple sampling directly gives us tools to construct bounds for the precision available for the parameters of interest (even when no obvious natural quantum observable exists, such as for phase, or time); it is found that these direct bounds are more restrictive than those of the HUP. The implication is that the natural quantum observables typically do not encode the optimal information (even for observables such as position, and momentum); we show how this can be understood simply in terms of the Hilbert space geometry. Another striking feature of these bounds to parameter uncertainty is that for a large enough number of repetitions of the measurements all V quantum states are 'minimum uncertainty' states - not just Gaussian wave-packets. Thus, these bounds tell us what precision is achievable as well as merely what is allowed.

•May 1, 1994•0 citations

Wave-mechanical uncertainty and speed limitations

Panos A. Ligomenides

Modern science is eliminating the old, unrealistic approach to experimental errors. The Heisenberg principle of uncertainty has effected a fundamental change in the scientific attitude toward experimental errors and toward the degree of exactness in stating physical laws. Quantum physics has brought about the realization that a measurement or a mere observation at the quantum level perturbs the observed system in such a way that corrections cannot be made for the ``loading'' effect of the measuring instrument. There is something more basic and fundamental to our limitations in measurements than the lack of perfection in experimental planning and equipment. This article examines the types of uncertainty in measurements or observations. The interest then focuses on the fundamental importance of the relation between experimental uncertainty in measuring, observing, or in any way identifying a physical quantity, and the energy required to accomplish this in a certain allotted interval of time. This last relation has a direct bearing on the speed limitations of measurements.

IEEE Spectrum•Feb 1, 1967•5 citations

Anti Heisenberg—Refutation Of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Relation

Ilija Barukčić, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations
Philosophers and historians of science, when discussing the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, often imply that the principal effects of quantum mechanics on measurements are to reduce the attainable precision. In this paper I point out seven different ways in which quantum mechanics affects precision measurements and that six of these make highly precise measurements possible and meaningful while only one — the uncertainty principle — is a serious limitation to accuracy. The limitations of the uncertainty principle are valid and important, but they can often be partially overcome by various means, including measurements in long-lived states and observations of many atoms. The existence of quantized states and the identity principle — that two atoms in the same quantum state are not merely closely similar but truly identical — make highly precise measurements both possible and meaningful. Thus, in the commentary on Paper 2.8 the hyperfine separation of atomic hydrogen is measured to an accuracy of one part in a million million (10 12 ). The identity principle assures that observers in France and the United States will get the same answer except for known relativistic corrections. On the other hand, a classical quantity, such as the height of the Eiffel Tower, cannot be measured nearly so accurately since it changes from one moment to the next.
The accuracies of measurements of almost all fundamental physical constants have increased by factors of about 10,000 during the past 60 years. Although some of the improvements are due to greater care, most are due to new techniques based on quantum mechanics. In popular accounts of quantum mechanics, such great emphases is placed on the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle that it often appears that the primary effect of quantum mechanics should be to diminish measurement accuracy whereas in most cases it is the validity of quantum mechanics that makes possible the vastly improved measurement accuracies. Seven quantum features that have a profound influence on the science of measurements are: (1) Existence of discrete quantum states of energy Wi. (2) Energy conservation in transitions between two states. (3) Electromagnetic radiation of frequency ν is quantized with energy hν per quantum. (4) The identity principle. (5) The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. (6) Addition of probability amplitudes (not probabilities) so P=|ψ1 +ψ2 |2 ≠|ψ1|2 + |ψ2 |2. (7) Wave and coherent phase phenomena. Of these seven quantum features, only the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle limits the accuracy of measurements, and its affect is often negligibly small. The other six features make possible much more accurate measurements of quantum systems than with almost all classical systems and the identity principle provides meaning and significance to highly precise measurements with quantized systems. These effects are discussed and illustrated.
The accuracies of measurements of almost all fundamental physical constants have increased by factors of about 10 000 during the past 60 years. Although some of the improvements are due to greater care, most are due to new techniques based on quantum mechanics. Although the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle often limits measurement accuracies, in many cases the validity of quantum mechanics makes possible the vastly improved measurement accuracies. Seven quantum features that have a profound influence on the science of measurements are: (1) Existence of discrete quantum states of energy. (2) Energy conservation in transitions between two states. (3) Electromagnetic radiation of frequency v is quantized with energy hv per quantum. (4) The identity principle. (5) The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. (6) Addition of probability amplitudes (not probabilities). (7) Wave and coherent phase phenomena. Of these seven quantum features, only the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle limits the accuracy of measurements, and its affect is often negligibly small. The other six features make possible much more accurate measurements of quantum systems than with almost all classical systems. These effects are discussed and illustrated.
Since the publication of Heisenberg’s paper1 on the “anschaulichen Inhalt” of quantum mechanics, discussions of the fundamental limitations on the accuracy of physical measurements have been much in the foreground. According to Heisenberg, the quantum mechanics implies that it is impossible to measure simultaneous values of a coordinate and its conjugate momentum with unlimited precision. Instead, if Δp be the estimated error or uncertainty in a momentum and Δq that in the associated coordinate one must have the inequality, ΔpΔq>h2π \Delta p\Delta q>\frac{h}{{2\pi}} ΔpΔq>2πh​ (1) This inequality has come to be known quite generally as Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation.
Precision measurements involve the accurate determination of parameters through repeated measurements of identically prepared experimental setups. For many parameters there is a 'natural' choice for the quantum observable which is expected to give optimal information; and from this observable one can construct an Heinsenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) bound on the precision attainable for the parameter. However, the classical statistics of multiple sampling directly gives us tools to construct bounds for the precision available for the parameters of interest (even when no obvious natural quantum observable exists, such as for phase, or time); it is found that these direct bounds are more restrictive than those of the HUP. The implication is that the natural quantum observables typically do not encode the optimal information (even for observables such as position, and momentum); we show how this can be understood simply in terms of the Hilbert space geometry. Another striking feature of these bounds to parameter uncertainty is that for a large enough number of repetitions of the measurements all V quantum states are 'minimum uncertainty' states - not just Gaussian wave-packets. Thus, these bounds tell us what precision is achievable as well as merely what is allowed.
Modern science is eliminating the old, unrealistic approach to experimental errors. The Heisenberg principle of uncertainty has effected a fundamental change in the scientific attitude toward experimental errors and toward the degree of exactness in stating physical laws. Quantum physics has brought about the realization that a measurement or a mere observation at the quantum level perturbs the observed system in such a way that corrections cannot be made for the ``loading'' effect of the measuring instrument. There is something more basic and fundamental to our limitations in measurements than the lack of perfection in experimental planning and equipment. This article examines the types of uncertainty in measurements or observations. The interest then focuses on the fundamental importance of the relation between experimental uncertainty in measuring, observing, or in any way identifying a physical quantity, and the energy required to accomplish this in a certain allotted interval of time. This last relation has a direct bearing on the speed limitations of measurements.
The quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum plays an important role in many treatments on the (philosophical, physical and other) implications of quantum mechanics. Roughly speaking, the more precisely the momentum (position) of a (quantum mechanical) object is given, the less precisely can one say what its position (momentum) is. This quantum mechanical measurement problem is not just an interpretational difficulty, it raises broader issues as well. The measurement (of a property) of a (quantum mechanical) object determines the existence of the measured. In brief, the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle challenges some fundamental principles of Science and especially the principle of causality. In particular, an independently existing (external) objective reality is denied. As we shall see, that the quantum mechanical uncertainty principle for position and momentum is based on the assumption that 1⩽0, which is a logical contradiction.