Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Two-photon interferometry, the quantum measurement problem, and more

Marlan O. Scully, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Published Sep 4, 1997• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

As was demonstrated in the previous chapter, the process of observation and acquisition of information or at least the possibility of ‘knowing’ (whether or not we bother to ‘look’) can profoundly change the outcome of an experiment. For example, in the case of the micromaser which-path detector, we do not need to ‘look at’ or ‘interrogate’ the masers in order to lose the interference cross term; it is enough that we could have known. Experiments along these lines provide a dramatic example of the importance of which-path, or ‘Welcher-Weg’, information.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511813993.023

Related papers

Which way are the photons pointing?

Alastair I. M. Rae

The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 2012•0 citations

Which way are the photons pointing?

Alastair I. M. Rae

The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation . In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 7, 2004•0 citations

Galilei invariance and the welcher Weg problem

Rathindra Nath Sen

If it is possible to detect the path of an atom in a double-slit atom interferometer, then interference will not be observed even if path detection causes no change in the atom's momentum. This fact was explained by Scully et al and Duerr et al by using a principle ofcomplementarity that could not be formulated mathematically, together with a rather peculiar notion of entanglement. We provide an explanation based on considerations of Galilei invariance, without recourse to any notion of complementarity or entanglement. However, we do have to assume that, under conditions of the experiment, composite systems such as atoms and molecules may be regarded as single particles. This assumption is the basis of modern atom and molecule interferometry, but it lacks justification from the first principles of quantum mechanics. In our world-view the welcher Weg problem merely highlights this fact. The empirical validity of this assumption seems to reveal an aspect of quantum mechanics which can justly be termed anti-reductionist, and we conclude that use of unnecessarily strong hypotheses to explain observed phenomena can hide important physical -- and occasionally philosophical -- problems.

•Jul 18, 2013•0 citations

Measurement and entanglement

Jonathan A. Jones, Dieter Jaksch

We now have all the basic tools we need to describe systems of one and two qubits. In this final chapter of Part I we look at some of the consequences of the peculiar properties of qubits when they are used to encode information. Many of these results can be traced to the properties of quantum measurement.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 19, 2012•0 citations

Nonlocal momentum transfer inwelcher Wegmeasurements

Howard M. Wiseman, F. E. Harrison, Matthew J. Collett +3 more

A ``which-path'' (welcher Weg) measurement necessarily destroys the fringes in a double-slit interference experiment. We show that in all instances one may attribute this destruction to a disturbance of the particle's momentum by an amount equal to at least $\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2d$, where $d$ is the slit separation, in accordance with the uncertainty principle. However, this momentum transfer need not be local; that is, it need not act at either of the slits through which the particle passes. For well-known welcher Weg measurements such as Einstein's recoiling slit and Feynman's light microscope, the disturbance can be understood in terms of random classical momentum kicks that act locally. In some recent proposals, including that by Scully, Englert, and Walther [Nature (London) 351, 111 (1991)], the momentum transfer is of a peculiarly quantum, nonlocal nature. In this paper we introduce a formalism based on the Wigner function, as this describes both the local and nonlocal momentum transfer caused by any welcher Weg measurement. We show that for some examples, such as that of Scully, Englert, and Walther, there is no momentum disturbance at the slits even though the nonlocal momentum disturbance is sufficient to destroy the interference pattern. Finally, we discuss the experimental signatures of nonlocal versus local momentum transfer and demonstrate a strong similarity to the nonlocality of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1997•88 citations

Interpretation

Gennaro Auletta, Shang-Yung Wang

In this chapter, we shall collect and generalize the results of the previous three chapters. We shall come back to the issue of quantum correlations in terms of information. We shall consider now the second aspect of quantum information [see Section 11.3], that is, information selection leading to a local growth of entropy (as it is the case during ameasurement). This will be the basis for examining again the whole process of measurement and finally assign an ontological status to fundamental entities of quantum theory like states, observables, and properties.

•Jun 20, 2014•0 citations
As was demonstrated in the previous chapter, the process of observation and acquisition of information or at least the possibility of ‘knowing’ (whether or not we bother to ‘look’) can profoundly change the outcome of an experiment. For example, in the case of the micromaser which-path detector, we do not need to ‘look at’ or ‘interrogate’ the masers in order to lose the interference cross term; it is enough that we could have known. Experiments along these lines provide a dramatic example of the importance of which-path, or ‘Welcher-Weg’, information.
The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.
The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation . In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.
If it is possible to detect the path of an atom in a double-slit atom interferometer, then interference will not be observed even if path detection causes no change in the atom's momentum. This fact was explained by Scully et al and Duerr et al by using a principle ofcomplementarity that could not be formulated mathematically, together with a rather peculiar notion of entanglement. We provide an explanation based on considerations of Galilei invariance, without recourse to any notion of complementarity or entanglement. However, we do have to assume that, under conditions of the experiment, composite systems such as atoms and molecules may be regarded as single particles. This assumption is the basis of modern atom and molecule interferometry, but it lacks justification from the first principles of quantum mechanics. In our world-view the welcher Weg problem merely highlights this fact. The empirical validity of this assumption seems to reveal an aspect of quantum mechanics which can justly be termed anti-reductionist, and we conclude that use of unnecessarily strong hypotheses to explain observed phenomena can hide important physical -- and occasionally philosophical -- problems.
A ``which-path'' (welcher Weg) measurement necessarily destroys the fringes in a double-slit interference experiment. We show that in all instances one may attribute this destruction to a disturbance of the particle's momentum by an amount equal to at least $\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}/2d$, where ddd is the slit separation, in accordance with the uncertainty principle. However, this momentum transfer need not be local; that is, it need not act at either of the slits through which the particle passes. For well-known welcher Weg measurements such as Einstein's recoiling slit and Feynman's light microscope, the disturbance can be understood in terms of random classical momentum kicks that act locally. In some recent proposals, including that by Scully, Englert, and Walther [Nature (London) 351, 111 (1991)], the momentum transfer is of a peculiarly quantum, nonlocal nature. In this paper we introduce a formalism based on the Wigner function, as this describes both the local and nonlocal momentum transfer caused by any welcher Weg measurement. We show that for some examples, such as that of Scully, Englert, and Walther, there is no momentum disturbance at the slits even though the nonlocal momentum disturbance is sufficient to destroy the interference pattern. Finally, we discuss the experimental signatures of nonlocal versus local momentum transfer and demonstrate a strong similarity to the nonlocality of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.
In this chapter, we shall collect and generalize the results of the previous three chapters. We shall come back to the issue of quantum correlations in terms of information. We shall consider now the second aspect of quantum information [see Section 11.3], that is, information selection leading to a local growth of entropy (as it is the case during ameasurement). This will be the basis for examining again the whole process of measurement and finally assign an ontological status to fundamental entities of quantum theory like states, observables, and properties.