Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Two-Slit Inventions

Daniel F. Styer

Published Feb 24, 2000• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In chapter 9 we concluded that in quantal interference experiments a single atom passes through both branches of an interferometer. In chapter 10.1 we firmed up that everyday-language expression to the technical phrase “there is an amplitude for the atom to go through either branch”. Exactly what do these strange statements mean? How can our minds grow familiar with a real quantal atom, which behaves so unlike a small, hard marble? To prepare for these questions, this chapter examines two variations of the quantal interference experiment. This chapter is not absolutely essential for the logical development of the book, but it dramatically underscores that quantal interference demands a total rethinking of our picture of the atom — no simple trick will suffice. The Aharonov–Bohm effect It's possible to build a box called a “corkscrew” from a uniform magnetic field twisted into one turn of a spiral (see figure below). At the left edge of the box the magnetic field points straight out of the page (that is, in the + x direction). Moving towards the right the magnetic field slowly dips until it points straight down, then continues to twist until it points into the page, then straight up, until finally — at the right edge of the box — the magnetic field again points straight out of the page.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9781107050709.013

Related papers

Working with Amplitudes

Daniel F. Styer

The first section of this chapter shows that the mathematical representation of amplitude cannot be as simple as a real number, but must be at least as complicated as a two-dimensional arrow. If you're willing to accept this as fact, then you may skip that rather technical and involved section. But in no case should you skip over the second section of this chapter, which makes a simple but subtle and important general point. Amplitude is represented by an arrow I'm going to introduce one more type of analyzer: the “front–back analyzer” (also called the “ y analyzer”). This will be the last new analyzer, I promise. The left half of this analyzer is just like the left half of a traditional Stern–Gerlach analyzer, with its traditional non-uniform magnetic field. But while the right half of the traditional Stern–Gerlach analyzer contains only plumbing to make sure the atoms come out parallel to the sides of the box, the right half of the front–back analyzer contains also a magnetic field that changes direction slowly from place to place. Along the path towards the upper exit, the magnetic field starts by pointing straight up. A little farther on it tilts a bit to the right. The tilt angle of the field increases gradually until, just before the exit, the field points directly to the right. The path towards the lower exit is similar, except that in this case the field starts out pointing down and gradually tilts until it points directly to the left.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 24, 2000•0 citations

A Computer Simulation for Quantal Interference

Noah A. Morris, Daniel F. Styer

Interference of particles is one of the central phenomena of quantum mechanics. The computer program InterferenceSimulator demonstrates two-slit Fresnel interference patterns with one, the other, or both slits open. A magnetic flux situated between the two slits allows the demonstration of the Aharonov–Bohm effect. Simulations with short de Broglie wavelengths illustrate the classical limit of quantum mechanics. Because of the universality of wave phenomena, this program also demonstrates the geometrical-optics limit of wave optics for small wavelengths.

The Physics Educator•Jun 1, 2019•0 citations

Aptly named Aharonov-Bohm effect has classical analogue, long history

Michael Berry

Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jul 30, 2010•13 citations

Single-Slit Electron Diffraction with Aharonov-Bohm Phase: Feynman’s Thought Experiment with Quantum Point Contacts

Pradip Khatua, Bhavtosh Bansal, D. Shahar

In a "thought experiment," now a classic in physics pedagogy, Feynman visualizes Young's double-slit interference experiment with electrons in magnetic field. He shows that the addition of an Aharonov-Bohm phase is equivalent to shifting the zero-field wave interference pattern by an angle expected from the Lorentz force calculation for classical particles. We have performed this experiment with one slit, instead of two, where ballistic electrons within two-dimensional electron gas diffract through a small orifice formed by a quantum point contact (QPC). As the QPC width is comparable to the electron wavelength, the observed intensity profile is further modulated by the transverse waveguide modes present at the injector QPC. Our experiments open the way to realizing diffraction-based ideas in mesoscopic physics.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 2014•16 citations

Quantum Two-Slit Interference Applied to a Coin Part 2

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In Part 1, we tried to create a toy model involving a rotating-translating coin. We examined what kind of interaction is needed to create a typical 2-slit interference pattern. Here we examine a physical object, namely a photon, which has a built-in periodic cycle for its electric and magnetic fields. These are perpendicular and in plane perpendicular to motion and both change as cos(-Et/hbar + px/hbar). We point out that the electric and magnetic fields are both real, they are not described by exp(-iEt+ipx) and furthermore, they are deterministic, not probabilistic. We try to see how such a picture can lead to quantum two slit interference. Basically, we argue that if one only considers the electric field, long range interactions from atoms around both slits interact with a photon heading towards the center between the slits. As a result, the physical interaction must involve both slits, but one has no idea through which slit the photon passes. There is probability in the problem, but at the same time interactions with both slits before the photon passes through and also after. One needs a model which captures both the notion of probability and interaction with both slits. For probability this should be an OR situation (one slit or the other), but it cannot be the usual classical probability scheme which implies that moving through one slit only involves interaction with that slit. Interactions with both slits occur. This seems like a contradiction because one applies OR probability to one slit or another. Given that the interaction with the electric field occurs in a periodic manner cos(-Et+px) hbar=1, we suggest that exp(-iEt+ipx) with its modulus of 1 captures the idea that any electric field position as the same probability, but that there is periodic motion linked with interaction in space. . As a result, one may keep the mathematical notion of an OR probability scheme by introducing an interacting probability exp(ipx). This means that the probaiblities from each slit in the OR (add) scheme interfere or interact which is what is required because an interaction with both slits occurs. exp(ipx) captures the periodicity and also enforces conservation of momentum (exp(ip1x)exp(ip2x) = exp(I (p1+p2)x) and it seems that this is the only information needed.

•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

Duality or Unity in Quantum Mechanics

Jonathan Deutsch

In the double slit experiment - - central to quantum mechanics and thus to all of reality - - when you LOOK at the particle, it always passes through ONLY ONE slit - - EITHER the right slit OR the left slit, acting like a particle. However, when you AREN’T looking at it, it somehow always passes through BOTH slits - - the right slit AND the left slit - - at the same time, acting like a wave. All of nature is now KNOWN to be both wave and particle simultaneously - - actually, one entity (“wavicle”), not two - - at the most fundamental level of reality. However, no one seems to have ever asked the question: How can anything, much less everything, be in TW0 places at the same time AND ALSO SIMULTANEOUSLY be in ONLY ONE place at the same time? The known laws of physics make this absolutely impossible. Therefore, at least one of our laws must be wrong. In some fundamental mathematical and physical sense, 2 MUST ALSO BE (- - EQUAL- -) 1: 2 AS 1. The right and left slits, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other - - one slit, not two. Extending this argument to Schrodinger’s cat, life and death, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other, 2 AS 1. Just as all apparent opposites, it must be true that ultimately, life and death must be one thing, not two. This, then, is an all-optimistic physics - - probably the first such theory ever. But it is based entirely on firm scientific fact.

•Aug 1, 2020•0 citations
In chapter 9 we concluded that in quantal interference experiments a single atom passes through both branches of an interferometer. In chapter 10.1 we firmed up that everyday-language expression to the technical phrase “there is an amplitude for the atom to go through either branch”. Exactly what do these strange statements mean? How can our minds grow familiar with a real quantal atom, which behaves so unlike a small, hard marble? To prepare for these questions, this chapter examines two variations of the quantal interference experiment. This chapter is not absolutely essential for the logical development of the book, but it dramatically underscores that quantal interference demands a total rethinking of our picture of the atom — no simple trick will suffice. The Aharonov–Bohm effect It's possible to build a box called a “corkscrew” from a uniform magnetic field twisted into one turn of a spiral (see figure below). At the left edge of the box the magnetic field points straight out of the page (that is, in the + x direction). Moving towards the right the magnetic field slowly dips until it points straight down, then continues to twist until it points into the page, then straight up, until finally — at the right edge of the box — the magnetic field again points straight out of the page.
The first section of this chapter shows that the mathematical representation of amplitude cannot be as simple as a real number, but must be at least as complicated as a two-dimensional arrow. If you're willing to accept this as fact, then you may skip that rather technical and involved section. But in no case should you skip over the second section of this chapter, which makes a simple but subtle and important general point. Amplitude is represented by an arrow I'm going to introduce one more type of analyzer: the “front–back analyzer” (also called the “ y analyzer”). This will be the last new analyzer, I promise. The left half of this analyzer is just like the left half of a traditional Stern–Gerlach analyzer, with its traditional non-uniform magnetic field. But while the right half of the traditional Stern–Gerlach analyzer contains only plumbing to make sure the atoms come out parallel to the sides of the box, the right half of the front–back analyzer contains also a magnetic field that changes direction slowly from place to place. Along the path towards the upper exit, the magnetic field starts by pointing straight up. A little farther on it tilts a bit to the right. The tilt angle of the field increases gradually until, just before the exit, the field points directly to the right. The path towards the lower exit is similar, except that in this case the field starts out pointing down and gradually tilts until it points directly to the left.
Interference of particles is one of the central phenomena of quantum mechanics. The computer program InterferenceSimulator demonstrates two-slit Fresnel interference patterns with one, the other, or both slits open. A magnetic flux situated between the two slits allows the demonstration of the Aharonov–Bohm effect. Simulations with short de Broglie wavelengths illustrate the classical limit of quantum mechanics. Because of the universality of wave phenomena, this program also demonstrates the geometrical-optics limit of wave optics for small wavelengths.
Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.
In a "thought experiment," now a classic in physics pedagogy, Feynman visualizes Young's double-slit interference experiment with electrons in magnetic field. He shows that the addition of an Aharonov-Bohm phase is equivalent to shifting the zero-field wave interference pattern by an angle expected from the Lorentz force calculation for classical particles. We have performed this experiment with one slit, instead of two, where ballistic electrons within two-dimensional electron gas diffract through a small orifice formed by a quantum point contact (QPC). As the QPC width is comparable to the electron wavelength, the observed intensity profile is further modulated by the transverse waveguide modes present at the injector QPC. Our experiments open the way to realizing diffraction-based ideas in mesoscopic physics.
In Part 1, we tried to create a toy model involving a rotating-translating coin. We examined what kind of interaction is needed to create a typical 2-slit interference pattern. Here we examine a physical object, namely a photon, which has a built-in periodic cycle for its electric and magnetic fields. These are perpendicular and in plane perpendicular to motion and both change as cos(-Et/hbar + px/hbar). We point out that the electric and magnetic fields are both real, they are not described by exp(-iEt+ipx) and furthermore, they are deterministic, not probabilistic. We try to see how such a picture can lead to quantum two slit interference. Basically, we argue that if one only considers the electric field, long range interactions from atoms around both slits interact with a photon heading towards the center between the slits. As a result, the physical interaction must involve both slits, but one has no idea through which slit the photon passes. There is probability in the problem, but at the same time interactions with both slits before the photon passes through and also after. One needs a model which captures both the notion of probability and interaction with both slits. For probability this should be an OR situation (one slit or the other), but it cannot be the usual classical probability scheme which implies that moving through one slit only involves interaction with that slit. Interactions with both slits occur. This seems like a contradiction because one applies OR probability to one slit or another. Given that the interaction with the electric field occurs in a periodic manner cos(-Et+px) hbar=1, we suggest that exp(-iEt+ipx) with its modulus of 1 captures the idea that any electric field position as the same probability, but that there is periodic motion linked with interaction in space. . As a result, one may keep the mathematical notion of an OR probability scheme by introducing an interacting probability exp(ipx). This means that the probaiblities from each slit in the OR (add) scheme interfere or interact which is what is required because an interaction with both slits occurs. exp(ipx) captures the periodicity and also enforces conservation of momentum (exp(ip1x)exp(ip2x) = exp(I (p1+p2)x) and it seems that this is the only information needed.
In the double slit experiment - - central to quantum mechanics and thus to all of reality - - when you LOOK at the particle, it always passes through ONLY ONE slit - - EITHER the right slit OR the left slit, acting like a particle. However, when you AREN’T looking at it, it somehow always passes through BOTH slits - - the right slit AND the left slit - - at the same time, acting like a wave. All of nature is now KNOWN to be both wave and particle simultaneously - - actually, one entity (“wavicle”), not two - - at the most fundamental level of reality. However, no one seems to have ever asked the question: How can anything, much less everything, be in TW0 places at the same time AND ALSO SIMULTANEOUSLY be in ONLY ONE place at the same time? The known laws of physics make this absolutely impossible. Therefore, at least one of our laws must be wrong. In some fundamental mathematical and physical sense, 2 MUST ALSO BE (- - EQUAL- -) 1: 2 AS 1. The right and left slits, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other - - one slit, not two. Extending this argument to Schrodinger’s cat, life and death, seemingly opposite, must at the deepest level of reality be “married” to each other, 2 AS 1. Just as all apparent opposites, it must be true that ultimately, life and death must be one thing, not two. This, then, is an all-optimistic physics - - probably the first such theory ever. But it is based entirely on firm scientific fact.