Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Phenomenological Particle Notions

Laura Ruetsche

Published Jun 2, 2011• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This chapter considers another route to a particle interpretation of quantum field theory, one mediated by the existence of techniques (such as the use of Feynman diagrams to guide calculation) and explanations (such as the appeal to cosmological particle creation to account for decelerating cosmic expansion) best understood in terms of particles. Looking close at these techniques and explanations, the chapter argues that they rely on the presence of unitarily inequivalent representations, the very presence, Chapters 8 and 9 contended, that frustrates fundamental particle interpretation.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199535408.003.0011

Related papers

Against Field Interpretations of Quantum Field Theory

David John Baker

I examine some problems standing in the way of a successful `field interpretation' of quantum field theory. The most popular extant proposal depends on the Hilbert space of `wavefunctionals.' But since wavefunctional space is unitarily equivalent to many-particle Fock space, two of the most powerful arguments against particle interpretations also undermine this form of field interpretation. 1. Introduction 2. Field Interpretations and Field Operators 3. The Wavefunctional Interpretation 4. Fields and Inequivalent Representations 4.1. The Rindler representation 4.2. Spontaneous symmetry breaking 4.3. Coherent representations 5. The Fate of Fields in Interacting QFT 6. Conclusions

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Jul 17, 2009•93 citations

Method of Quantum Field Theory

Tadashi HASEBE

Quantum field theory (QFT) provides us with one and almost only suitable language (or mathematical tool) for describing not only the motion and interaction of particles but also their “annihilation” and “creation” out of a field considered a priori in a sophisticated way, whose view seems to be suited for describing dislocations, as a particle or a string embedded within a crystalline ordered field. This chapter concisely overviews the method of QFT, emphasizing distinction from the quantum mechanics, conventionally used for a single and/or many particle problems, and its equivalence to the statistical mechanics. The alternative formalism based on Feynman path integral and its imaginary time representation are reviewed, as the foundation for our use in Chapter 10.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 14, 2023•0 citations

Interpreting quantized Yang–Mills gauge theories

Richard Healey

This chapter begins the project of interpreting quantum gauge field theories. It rejects an interesting recent interpretation and explains why it is so difficult to arrive at a better one. The difficulty stems from the problems of interpreting any quantum field theory. Even the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of particles is a theory whose interpretation remains at best controversial, and at worst simply lacking. Interpretations of quantum field theory face the additional hurdle that it is not clear what the theory is about: neither a field nor a particle ontology is readily squared with the mathematics of the theory. The chapter explores the status of loop representations in several approaches toward the interpretation of quantum field theory.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 27, 2007•0 citations

Not Particles, Not Quite Fields: An Ontology for Quantum Field Theory

Tracy Lupher

There are significant problems involved in determining the ontology of quantum field theory (QFT). An ontology involving particles seems to be ruled out due to the problem of defining localized position operators, issues involving interactions in QFT, and, perhaps, the appearance of unitarily inequivalent representations. While this might imply that fields are the most natural ontology for QFT, the wavefunctional interpretation of QFT has significant drawbacks. A modified field ontology is examined where determinables are assigned to open bounded regions of spacetime instead of spacetime points.

Humana.mente•Jan 1, 2010•4 citations

The Philosophy of Quantum Field Theory

David John Baker

This is an opinionated survey of some interpretive puzzles in quantum field theory. The problem of inequivalent representations is sketched, including its connections with competing accounts of physical equivalence. The controversy between variant formulations of the theory, algebraic versus Lagrangian, is given a conciliatory resolution. Arguments against particles are addressed, demarcating clearly between different forms of particle interpretation. Field interpretations are then considered, including wavefunctional, spacetime state realist and Heisenberg operator realist interpretations. Ruetsche’s coalesced structure interpretation is presented and juxtaposed with an alternative, more traditional view of the theory’s laws and state space. Finally, the CPT theorem is discussed, together with its implications about the nature of spacetime.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 2, 2016•20 citations

Approach to Quantum Field Theory

Hans Christian Öttinger

In this introductory chapter, which actually is the core of the entire book, we make a serious effort to bring together a variety of ideas from philosophy and physics. We first lay the epistemological foundations for our approach to particle physics. These philosophical foundations, combined with tools borrowed from the amazingly sophisticated, but still not entirely satisfactory, mathematical apparatus of present-day quantum field theory and augmented by some new ideas, are then employed to develop a mathematical representation of fundamental particles and their interactions. In this process, also the relation between “fundamental particle physics” and “quantum field theory” is going to be clarified.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 21, 2017•0 citations
This chapter considers another route to a particle interpretation of quantum field theory, one mediated by the existence of techniques (such as the use of Feynman diagrams to guide calculation) and explanations (such as the appeal to cosmological particle creation to account for decelerating cosmic expansion) best understood in terms of particles. Looking close at these techniques and explanations, the chapter argues that they rely on the presence of unitarily inequivalent representations, the very presence, Chapters 8 and 9 contended, that frustrates fundamental particle interpretation.
I examine some problems standing in the way of a successful `field interpretation' of quantum field theory. The most popular extant proposal depends on the Hilbert space of `wavefunctionals.' But since wavefunctional space is unitarily equivalent to many-particle Fock space, two of the most powerful arguments against particle interpretations also undermine this form of field interpretation. 1. Introduction 2. Field Interpretations and Field Operators 3. The Wavefunctional Interpretation 4. Fields and Inequivalent Representations 4.1. The Rindler representation 4.2. Spontaneous symmetry breaking 4.3. Coherent representations 5. The Fate of Fields in Interacting QFT 6. Conclusions
Quantum field theory (QFT) provides us with one and almost only suitable language (or mathematical tool) for describing not only the motion and interaction of particles but also their “annihilation” and “creation” out of a field considered a priori in a sophisticated way, whose view seems to be suited for describing dislocations, as a particle or a string embedded within a crystalline ordered field. This chapter concisely overviews the method of QFT, emphasizing distinction from the quantum mechanics, conventionally used for a single and/or many particle problems, and its equivalence to the statistical mechanics. The alternative formalism based on Feynman path integral and its imaginary time representation are reviewed, as the foundation for our use in Chapter 10.
This chapter begins the project of interpreting quantum gauge field theories. It rejects an interesting recent interpretation and explains why it is so difficult to arrive at a better one. The difficulty stems from the problems of interpreting any quantum field theory. Even the non-relativistic quantum mechanics of particles is a theory whose interpretation remains at best controversial, and at worst simply lacking. Interpretations of quantum field theory face the additional hurdle that it is not clear what the theory is about: neither a field nor a particle ontology is readily squared with the mathematics of the theory. The chapter explores the status of loop representations in several approaches toward the interpretation of quantum field theory.
There are significant problems involved in determining the ontology of quantum field theory (QFT). An ontology involving particles seems to be ruled out due to the problem of defining localized position operators, issues involving interactions in QFT, and, perhaps, the appearance of unitarily inequivalent representations. While this might imply that fields are the most natural ontology for QFT, the wavefunctional interpretation of QFT has significant drawbacks. A modified field ontology is examined where determinables are assigned to open bounded regions of spacetime instead of spacetime points.
This is an opinionated survey of some interpretive puzzles in quantum field theory. The problem of inequivalent representations is sketched, including its connections with competing accounts of physical equivalence. The controversy between variant formulations of the theory, algebraic versus Lagrangian, is given a conciliatory resolution. Arguments against particles are addressed, demarcating clearly between different forms of particle interpretation. Field interpretations are then considered, including wavefunctional, spacetime state realist and Heisenberg operator realist interpretations. Ruetsche’s coalesced structure interpretation is presented and juxtaposed with an alternative, more traditional view of the theory’s laws and state space. Finally, the CPT theorem is discussed, together with its implications about the nature of spacetime.
In this introductory chapter, which actually is the core of the entire book, we make a serious effort to bring together a variety of ideas from philosophy and physics. We first lay the epistemological foundations for our approach to particle physics. These philosophical foundations, combined with tools borrowed from the amazingly sophisticated, but still not entirely satisfactory, mathematical apparatus of present-day quantum field theory and augmented by some new ideas, are then employed to develop a mathematical representation of fundamental particles and their interactions. In this process, also the relation between “fundamental particle physics” and “quantum field theory” is going to be clarified.