Commutators and uncertainty relations have sparked much debate and confusion as to their physical meaning. As such, this chapter focuses partly on historical and interpretational aspects. Because it is central to the uncertainty relations, the commutator — including its manifestation in matrix mechanics — is introduced first. It is emphasized that the commutator of two operators is generally another operator. The general form of the uncertainty relations is then introduced. These relations reflect the fact that probability distributions for different observables are generally not independent. Moreover, application of the uncertainty relations generally requires knowledge of the quantum state — a fact that is obscured by the well known position-momentum uncertainty relation. Various proposed physical interpretations of the uncertainty relations are then discussed. The chapter concludes with a brief reflection on the significance of the uncertainty relations.
Commutators and uncertainty relations have sparked much debate and confusion as to their physical meaning. As such, this chapter focuses partly on historical and interpretational aspects. Because it is central to the uncertainty relations, the commutator — including its manifestation in matrix mechanics — is introduced first. It is emphasized that the commutator of two operators is generally another operator. The general form of the uncertainty relations is then introduced. These relations reflect the fact that probability distributions for different observables are generally not independent. Moreover, application of the uncertainty relations generally requires knowledge of the quantum state — a fact that is obscured by the well known position-momentum uncertainty relation. Various proposed physical interpretations of the uncertainty relations are then discussed. The chapter concludes with a brief reflection on the significance of the uncertainty relations.
Uncertainty relations are commonly praised as one of the central pillars of quantum theory. Usually, they are taught in the first weeks of a beginners lecture, and introduced in the ?rst chapters of a textbook. However, their precise operational meaning and a formulation in a general context, i.e. beyond the example of position and momentum observables, are often left out. The reasoning for this is twofold: On one hand, an exact operational definition of uncertainty, indeterminacy and a corresponding uncertainty principle has been the content of many debates since the early days of quantum mechanics until today. From a modern perspective, we have the consent that there are at least the two notions of preparation and measurement uncertainty: the first notion prohibits the existence of dissipation free states and the latter one the existence of error free joint measurements. On the other hand, we have that, the mathematical tools, which are needed for comprehensive treatment of uncertainty relations in a general context, are still under development and usually go far beyond the mathematical level of an introductory course. In this thesis we will investigate these two notions of uncertainty, their corre- sponding uncertainty relations, such as their interplay. The aim of this thesis is to give answers to the central questions: (1.) Which quantities should be used to formulate uncertainty? (2.) How can we compute uncertainty relations for those? (3.) Are there connections between the two notions of uncertainty? We will do this, whenever possible, in a most general context and with a focus on relevant examples, otherwise. Therefore, we will consider constructions of mea- surement errors and deviation measures that quantify uncertainty, based on, so called, cost functions. Commonly used uncertainty measures like variances, en- tropies, and the Hamming distance are examples for these. We will investigate the structure of the corresponding uncertainty relations and provide several methods that enable us to compute them. The third question is addressed by a theorem that shows, for sharp observables, that measurement uncertainty relations can be lower bounded by preparation uncertainty relations, whenever the same cost function is used.
In this chapter we shall mainly present the basic formalism that was initially developed by Heisenberg, also known as matrix mechanics (see Subsec. 1.5.7). We will first introduce in Sec. 2.1 the concept of quantum observables. Then, the problem of discrete and continuous spectra will be discussed and the basic non-commutability of quantum-mechanical observables will be deduced. While in Sec. 2.1 we discuss observables on a general formal level, in Sec. 2.2 some basic quantum-mechanical observables will be defined, and then different representations discussed and commutation relations derived. In Sec. 2.3 a basic uncertainty relation is derived. In the same section the relationship between uncertainty, superposition, and complementarity will be discussed. Finally, in Sec. 2.4 complete subsets of commuting observables will be shown to be Boolean subalgebras pertaining to a quantum algebra which is not Boolean. BASIC FEATURES OF QUANTUM OBSERVABLES This section is devoted to a general and formal exposition of quantum observables. In Subsec. 2.1.1 we shall learn how one can mathematically represent quantum observables as Hermitian operators. In Subsec. 2.1.2 we shall see how to change a basis, while in Subsec. 2.1.3 we shall find the relationship between eigenvalues of the observables and probabilities and learn how to calculate mean values. In Subsec. 2.1.4 we shall deal with an operator diagonalization. Finally, in Subsec. 2.1.5, the basic non-commutability of quantum observables will be presented by means of an example.
The uncertainty principle is the most important for the foundations of quantum mechanics but it still remains failed to reach a consensus of its interpretation, which gives rise to debates upon its physical nature. In this work, we address the problem of its foundation from a different aspect to present an alternative formulation for proving the uncertainty relations in a general way in terms of commutation relations and action function. The relationship between the de Broglie relation and the uncertainty principle is studied from a new angle. As a result, it is demonstrated that the de Broglie relation is the foundation of the uncertainty principle. Starting with the origin of the problem, we show that the de Broglie relation provides the form of the wave function and the determined form of the wave function in turn leads to the conception of operators for quantum mechanics, and thus it is possible to provide with the help of the operators and wave function a generalized proof of the uncertainty principle as the law governing ensemble of states. As a decisive solution to the problem, the interpretation of the uncertainty principle in terms of the action function is offered that gives one self-consistent explanation in agreement with the known physical phenomena. Eventually, we show the necessity and possibility of reassessing and improving the foundation and interpretation of the uncertainty principle as a leading principle of quantum mechanics.
Abstract In this chapter, the main features of quantum theory are presented. The chapter begins with a historical account of the invention of quantum mechanics. The meaning of position and momentum in quantum mechanics is discussed and non-commuting operators are introduced. The Schrödinger equation is presented and solved for a free particle and for a harmonic oscillator potential in one dimension. The meaning of the wavefunction is considered and the probabilistic interpretation is presented. The mathematical machinery and language of quantum mechanics are developed, including Hermitian operators, observables and expectation values. The uncertainty principle is discussed and the uncertainty relations are presented. Scattering and tunnelling by potential wells and barriers is considered. The use of variational principles to estimate ground state energies is explained and illustrated with a simple example.
A brief review of various existing mathematical formulations of the uncertainty relations in quantum mechanics, containing variances of two or more non-commuting operators, is given. In particular, inequalities for the products of higher-order moments of a coordinate and a momentum are considered, as well as inequalities making the uncertainty relations more accurate when additional information about a quantum system is available (for example, the correlation coefficient or the degree of mixing of a quantum state characterized by the trace of the squared statistical operator). The special cases of two, three, and four operators are discussed in detail.
The standard uncertainty relations (UR) in quantum mechanics are typically used for unbounded operators (like the canonical pair). This implies the need for the control of the domain problems. On the other hand, the use of (possibly bounded) functions of basic observables usually leads to more complex and less readily interpretable relations. In addition, UR may turn trivial for certain states if the commutator of observables is not proportional to a positive operator. In this letter we consider a generalization of standard UR resulting from the use of two, instead of one, vector states. The possibility to link these states to each other in various ways adds additional flexibility to UR, which may compensate some of the above-mentioned drawbacks. We discuss applications of the general scheme, leading not only to technical improvements, but also to interesting new insight.