Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entangling dynamics beyond quantum theory

P. David, Remigiusz Augusiak

Published Nov 17, 2011• 3 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We explore the existence of entangling dynamics in a large family of theories which contains quantum theory as a special case. We classify all continuouslyreversible and locally-tomographic theories for bipartite systems where each subsystem has a state space with the geometry of a Euclidean ball (like the Bloch ball of a qubit but with dimension not necessarily equal to three). We show that the only theory in this family which has interacting dynamics is quantum theory, and all the other theories do not allow for entanglement nor violation of Bell inequalities. This suggests that, once dynamics is taken into account, entanglement and violation of Bell inequalities are very singular phenomena.

Related papers

Entanglement and the three-dimensionality of the Bloch ball

Lluís Masanes, Markus P. Müller, David Pérez-García +1 more

We consider a very natural generalization of quantum theory by letting the dimension of the Bloch ball be not necessarily three. We analyze bipartite state spaces where each of the components has a d-dimensional Euclidean ball as state space. In addition to this, we impose two very natural assumptions: the continuity and reversibility of dynamics and the possibility of characterizing bipartite states by local measurements. We classify all these bipartite state spaces and prove that, except for the quantum two-qubit state space, none of them contains entangled states. Equivalently, in any of these non-quantum theories, interacting dynamics is impossible. This result reveals that “existence of entanglement” is the requirement with minimal logical content which singles out quantum theory from our family of theories.

arXiv:1111.4060•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2014•37 citations

Bell inequalities and entanglement

Reinhard F. Werner, Michael M. Wolf

We discuss general Bell inequalities for bipartite and multipartite systems, emphasizing the connection with convex geometry on the mathematical side, and the communication aspects on the physical side. Known results on families of generalized Bell inequalities are summarized. We investigate maximal violations of Bell inequalities as well as states not violating (certain) Bell inequalities. Finally, we discuss the relation between Bell inequality violations and entanglement properties currently discussed in quantum information theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107093•Quantum Information and Computation•Oct 1, 2001•298 citations

Entanglement and Nonlocality are Inequivalent for Any Number of Parties

Remigiusz Augusiak, Maciej Demianowicz, Jordi Tura +1 more

Understanding the relation between nonlocality and entanglement is one of the fundamental problems in quantum physics. In the bipartite case, it is known that these two phenomena are inequivalent, as there exist entangled states of two parties that do not violate any Bell inequality. However, except for a single example of an entangled three-qubit state that has a local model, almost nothing is known about such a relation in multipartite systems. We provide a general construction of genuinely multipartite entangled states that do not display genuinely multipartite nonlocality, thus proving that entanglement and nonlocality are inequivalent for any number of parties.

arXiv:1407.3114•Physical Review Letters•Jul 15, 2015•67 citations

Quantum entanglement in time

Marcin L Nowakowski

In this paper we present a concept of quantum entanglement in time in a context of entangled consistent histories. These considerations are supported by presentation of necessary tools closely related to those acting on a space of spatial multipartite quantum states. We show that in similarity to monogamy of quantum entanglement in space, quantum entanglement in time is also endowed with this property for a particular history. Basing on these observations, we discuss further bounding of temporal correlations and derive analytically the Tsirelson bound implied by entangled histories for the Leggett-Garg inequalities.

arXiv:1701.08116•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2017•28 citations

Quantum steering ellipsoids

Antony Milne

Graphical representations are invaluable for visualising physical systems and processes. In quantum information theory, the Bloch vector representation of a single qubit is ubiquitous, but visualising higher-dimensional quantum systems is far less straightforward. The quantum steering ellipsoid provides a method for geometrically representing the state of two qubits, the most fundamental system for studying quantum correlations. This thesis constitutes a significant development of the steering ellipsoid formalism. As well as offering new insight into the study of two-qubit states, we extend this powerful geometric approach to explore scenarios beyond two qubits. We find necessary and sufficient conditions for when an ellipsoid inside the Bloch ball describes a valid (i.e. positive semidefinite) two-qubit state. Combined with the notion of ellipsoid chirality, this enables a geometric characterisation of entanglement. We find a family of "maximally obese" two-qubit states whose ellipsoids have maximal volume. These states have optimal correlation properties within the set of all two-qubit states with a single maximally mixed marginal. We study a three-qubit scenario and discover that ellipsoid volume obeys an elegant monogamy of steering relationship. From this we can derive the Coffman-Kundu-Wootters (CKW) inequality for concurrence monogamy, providing an intuitive geometric derivation of this classic result. Remarkably, we find that steering ellipsoids offer a fresh perspective on questions beyond quantum state space. Entanglement witnesses are also very naturally represented and classified using the formalism. This gives a physical interpretation to any ellipsoid inside the Bloch ball as a block positive two-qubit operator, which we may then classify further. We can also use steering ellipsoids to derive some highly nontrivial results in classical Euclidean geometry, extending Euler's inequality for the circumradius and inradius of a triangle.

•Aug 1, 2016•0 citations

Hyperdense coding and superadditivity of classical capacities in hypersphere theories

Serge Massar, Stefano Pironio, Damián Pitalúa-García

In quantum superdense coding, two parties previously sharing entanglement can communicate a two bit message by sending a single qubit.We study this feature in the broader framework of general probabilistic theories.We consider a particular class of theories in which the local state space of the communicating parties corresponds to Euclidian hyperballs of dimension n (the case n = 3 corresponds to the Bloch ball of quantum theory).We show that a single n-ball can encode at most one bit of information, independently of n.We introduce a bipartite extension of such theories for which there exist dense coding protocols such that n log 1 2 + ( ) bits are communicated if entanglement is previously shared by the communicating parties.For n 3, > these protocols are more powerful than the quantum one, because more than two bits are communicated by transmission of a system that locally encodes at most one bit.We call this phenomenon hyperdense coding (HDC).Our HDC protocols imply superadditive classical capacities: two entangled systems can encode n log 1 2 2 + > ( ) bits, even though each system individually encodes at most one bit.In our examples, HDC and superadditivity of classical capacities come at the expense of violating tomographic locality or dynamical continuous reversibility.

arXiv:1504.05147•New Journal of Physics•Oct 26, 2015•13 citations
We explore the existence of entangling dynamics in a large family of theories which contains quantum theory as a special case. We classify all continuouslyreversible and locally-tomographic theories for bipartite systems where each subsystem has a state space with the geometry of a Euclidean ball (like the Bloch ball of a qubit but with dimension not necessarily equal to three). We show that the only theory in this family which has interacting dynamics is quantum theory, and all the other theories do not allow for entanglement nor violation of Bell inequalities. This suggests that, once dynamics is taken into account, entanglement and violation of Bell inequalities are very singular phenomena.
We consider a very natural generalization of quantum theory by letting the dimension of the Bloch ball be not necessarily three. We analyze bipartite state spaces where each of the components has a d-dimensional Euclidean ball as state space. In addition to this, we impose two very natural assumptions: the continuity and reversibility of dynamics and the possibility of characterizing bipartite states by local measurements. We classify all these bipartite state spaces and prove that, except for the quantum two-qubit state space, none of them contains entangled states. Equivalently, in any of these non-quantum theories, interacting dynamics is impossible. This result reveals that “existence of entanglement” is the requirement with minimal logical content which singles out quantum theory from our family of theories.
We discuss general Bell inequalities for bipartite and multipartite systems, emphasizing the connection with convex geometry on the mathematical side, and the communication aspects on the physical side. Known results on families of generalized Bell inequalities are summarized. We investigate maximal violations of Bell inequalities as well as states not violating (certain) Bell inequalities. Finally, we discuss the relation between Bell inequality violations and entanglement properties currently discussed in quantum information theory.
Understanding the relation between nonlocality and entanglement is one of the fundamental problems in quantum physics. In the bipartite case, it is known that these two phenomena are inequivalent, as there exist entangled states of two parties that do not violate any Bell inequality. However, except for a single example of an entangled three-qubit state that has a local model, almost nothing is known about such a relation in multipartite systems. We provide a general construction of genuinely multipartite entangled states that do not display genuinely multipartite nonlocality, thus proving that entanglement and nonlocality are inequivalent for any number of parties.
In this paper we present a concept of quantum entanglement in time in a context of entangled consistent histories. These considerations are supported by presentation of necessary tools closely related to those acting on a space of spatial multipartite quantum states. We show that in similarity to monogamy of quantum entanglement in space, quantum entanglement in time is also endowed with this property for a particular history. Basing on these observations, we discuss further bounding of temporal correlations and derive analytically the Tsirelson bound implied by entangled histories for the Leggett-Garg inequalities.
Graphical representations are invaluable for visualising physical systems and processes. In quantum information theory, the Bloch vector representation of a single qubit is ubiquitous, but visualising higher-dimensional quantum systems is far less straightforward. The quantum steering ellipsoid provides a method for geometrically representing the state of two qubits, the most fundamental system for studying quantum correlations. This thesis constitutes a significant development of the steering ellipsoid formalism. As well as offering new insight into the study of two-qubit states, we extend this powerful geometric approach to explore scenarios beyond two qubits. We find necessary and sufficient conditions for when an ellipsoid inside the Bloch ball describes a valid (i.e. positive semidefinite) two-qubit state. Combined with the notion of ellipsoid chirality, this enables a geometric characterisation of entanglement. We find a family of "maximally obese" two-qubit states whose ellipsoids have maximal volume. These states have optimal correlation properties within the set of all two-qubit states with a single maximally mixed marginal. We study a three-qubit scenario and discover that ellipsoid volume obeys an elegant monogamy of steering relationship. From this we can derive the Coffman-Kundu-Wootters (CKW) inequality for concurrence monogamy, providing an intuitive geometric derivation of this classic result. Remarkably, we find that steering ellipsoids offer a fresh perspective on questions beyond quantum state space. Entanglement witnesses are also very naturally represented and classified using the formalism. This gives a physical interpretation to any ellipsoid inside the Bloch ball as a block positive two-qubit operator, which we may then classify further. We can also use steering ellipsoids to derive some highly nontrivial results in classical Euclidean geometry, extending Euler's inequality for the circumradius and inradius of a triangle.
In quantum superdense coding, two parties previously sharing entanglement can communicate a two bit message by sending a single qubit.We study this feature in the broader framework of general probabilistic theories.We consider a particular class of theories in which the local state space of the communicating parties corresponds to Euclidian hyperballs of dimension n (the case n = 3 corresponds to the Bloch ball of quantum theory).We show that a single n-ball can encode at most one bit of information, independently of n.We introduce a bipartite extension of such theories for which there exist dense coding protocols such that n log 1 2 + ( ) bits are communicated if entanglement is previously shared by the communicating parties.For n 3, > these protocols are more powerful than the quantum one, because more than two bits are communicated by transmission of a system that locally encodes at most one bit.We call this phenomenon hyperdense coding (HDC).Our HDC protocols imply superadditive classical capacities: two entangled systems can encode n log 1 2 2 + > ( ) bits, even though each system individually encodes at most one bit.In our examples, HDC and superadditivity of classical capacities come at the expense of violating tomographic locality or dynamical continuous reversibility.