Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

ON THE MEASURABILITY OF ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS

H. Pierre Noyes

Published Feb 1, 1995• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We revive the Bohr-Rosenfeld discussion of the measurabily of electromagnetic fields by replacing their classical apparatus with NO-YES counter firings of fixed spacial (Δx) and temporal (Δt) resolution. This gives us scale invariant commutation relations bounded from below from which we can—following the Feynman-Dyson- Tanimura proof—derive both the free space Maxwell Equations and the Einstein gravitational geodesic equations for a single test particle with Lorentz invariant charge to mass and gravitational to inertial mass ratios. We mention briefly the new fundamental theory which led us to this simple analysis of the problem.

DOI
10.1142/9789812831408_0032

Related papers

Decoherence, determinism and chaos

H. Pierre Noyes

The author claims by now to have made his case that modern work on fractals and chaos theory has already removed the presumption that classical physics is `deterministic`. Further, he claims that in so far as classical relativistic field theory (i.e. electromagnetism and gravitation) are scale invariant, they are self-consistent only if the idea of `test-particle` is introduced from outside the theory. Einstein spent the last years of his life trying to use singularities in the metric as `particles` or to get them out of the non-linearities in a grand unified theory -- in vain. So classical physics in this sense cannot be the fundamental theory. However, the author claims to have shown that if he introduces a `scale invariance bounded from below` by measurement accuracy, then Tanimura`s generalization of the Feynman proof as reconstructed by Dyson allows him to make a consistent classical theory for decoherent sources sinks. Restoring coherence to classical physics via relativistic action-at-a distance is left as a task for the future. Relativistic quantum mechanics, properly reconstructed from a finite and discrete basis, emerges in much better shape. The concept of `particles has to be replaced by NO-YES particulate events, and particle-antiparticle pair creation and annihilation properly formulated.

•Jan 1, 1994•3 citations

Time evolutions in Quantum mechanics and (Lorentzian) geometry

Paschke, Mario

As R.Feynman has shown to F. Dyson -- who published it then in 1990 under the name of "Feynman's proof of Maxwell's equations" -- the only interactions compatible with the canonical uncertainty relation (for scalar particles on flat $\R^3$) are the Lorentz covariant electromagnetic interactions. We generalize Feynman's argument to arbitrary configuration spaces, thereby clarifying its hidden assumptions as well as its geometrical significance. In addition, our result establishes a correspondence between globally hyperbolic spacetimes and solutions to our (algebraically formulated) axioms for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.

arXiv:math-ph/0301040•Jan 29, 2003•5 citations

Quantum Theory of the Electromagnetic Field

Peter W. Milonni

Abstract The electromagnetic field is quantized for free space and for dispersive dielectric media. Different quantum states of the field (thermal, laser, squeezed) are discussed and their photon-statistical properties derived. The density matrix operator for the field is introduced along with a detailed discussion of the diagonal representation of the field density operator and its properties. Field commutation relations, correlation functions, and uncertainty relations are derived and discussed. Also discussed are the historically important Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis of field commutation and uncertainty relations; energy-time uncertainty relations; simultaneous (Arthurs-Kelly) measurement of non-commuting observables; and complementarity from the perspective of probability amplitudes and probabilities for distinguishable and indistinguishable processes.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 31, 2019•1 citation

Are Maxwell's Electromagnetic Equations Probabilistic?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

We have argued in previous notes (1) that the “wave” nature of quantum mechanics follows from the Lorentz invariant for a constant p: A= -Et+px which holds for both a particle with rest mass and a photon. In A, t and x are separated indicating independence which violates the Newtonian view x(t). “A” leads to dA/dx partial = p and dA/dt= -E. Creating eigenvalue equations yields: -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx) and id/dt exp(-iEt) = E exp(-iEt). Thus, x and t may be separated. Given that exp(ipx) exists in all of space (because there is no time), it represents a somewhat spatially invariant probability. In the case of a photon, Maxwell showed one may write wave equations for the electric El and magnetic B fields using his electromagnetic equations with no charge or currents.. He showed the wave travels at the speed of light in a vacuum and thus characterized light as an electromagnetic wave. This is not the same statement as exp(ipx) which is a probability wave. One may note that Maxwell’s equations are Lorentz invariant, so the ideas of the first paragraph should hold. In this note, however, we consider the Poynting equation: d/dt partial (.5( eoElEl+1/uoBB)) + 1/uo grad dot El x B = function(charge and current). 1/uo ElxB is considered to be a momentum density. We note Maxwell’s equations contain d/dt partial and d/dx partial, so time and space are considered independent (unlike x(t)), and act on El and B. The presence of charge and current densities breaks spatial invariance i.e. creates local regions. We argue in this note that d/dx and d/dt are generators of translations in space and time. We further argue that Maxwell’s theoretical creation of a photon follows from introducing spatial invariance into the problem, i.e. removing all charge and current densities. Spatial invariance in Newtonian mechanics, however, is associated with a constant i.e. a constant speed and momentum and equal probability to be at any x. Given that d/dx and d/dt appear, one has a function of space and time which seems to be completely at odds with spatial invariance and the idea of a constant momentum. We have argued in (2), however, that constant motion, even though represented by v=constant, is associated with the force that created the momentum, and this manifests itself in a spatial density which is probabilistic. Thus the presence of d/dt and d/dx in Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations, even when charge and current densities are removed, implies the same thing. Thus we argue that Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations are probabilistic. We investigate these ideas in this note. We further argue that it is spatial invariance, together with the presence of d/dx partial which yields the periodic form exp(ipx). Thus it is not a coincidence that wave equations appear for El and B.

•Jan 26, 2023•0 citations

On the Question of the Measurability of Electromagnetic Field Quantities [with Niels Bohr] [1933b]

Robert S. Cohen, John J. Stachel

Boston studies in the philosophy of science•Jan 1, 1979•7 citations

On the Question of the Measurability of Electromagnetic Field Quantities

L. Rosenfeld, Niels Henrik David Bohr, L. Rosenfeld

Niels Bohr•Jan 1, 1996•54 citations
We revive the Bohr-Rosenfeld discussion of the measurabily of electromagnetic fields by replacing their classical apparatus with NO-YES counter firings of fixed spacial (Δx) and temporal (Δt) resolution. This gives us scale invariant commutation relations bounded from below from which we can—following the Feynman-Dyson- Tanimura proof—derive both the free space Maxwell Equations and the Einstein gravitational geodesic equations for a single test particle with Lorentz invariant charge to mass and gravitational to inertial mass ratios. We mention briefly the new fundamental theory which led us to this simple analysis of the problem.
The author claims by now to have made his case that modern work on fractals and chaos theory has already removed the presumption that classical physics is `deterministic`. Further, he claims that in so far as classical relativistic field theory (i.e. electromagnetism and gravitation) are scale invariant, they are self-consistent only if the idea of `test-particle` is introduced from outside the theory. Einstein spent the last years of his life trying to use singularities in the metric as `particles` or to get them out of the non-linearities in a grand unified theory -- in vain. So classical physics in this sense cannot be the fundamental theory. However, the author claims to have shown that if he introduces a `scale invariance bounded from below` by measurement accuracy, then Tanimura`s generalization of the Feynman proof as reconstructed by Dyson allows him to make a consistent classical theory for decoherent sources sinks. Restoring coherence to classical physics via relativistic action-at-a distance is left as a task for the future. Relativistic quantum mechanics, properly reconstructed from a finite and discrete basis, emerges in much better shape. The concept of `particles has to be replaced by NO-YES particulate events, and particle-antiparticle pair creation and annihilation properly formulated.
As R.Feynman has shown to F. Dyson -- who published it then in 1990 under the name of "Feynman's proof of Maxwell's equations" -- the only interactions compatible with the canonical uncertainty relation (for scalar particles on flat R3\R^3R3) are the Lorentz covariant electromagnetic interactions. We generalize Feynman's argument to arbitrary configuration spaces, thereby clarifying its hidden assumptions as well as its geometrical significance. In addition, our result establishes a correspondence between globally hyperbolic spacetimes and solutions to our (algebraically formulated) axioms for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.
Abstract The electromagnetic field is quantized for free space and for dispersive dielectric media. Different quantum states of the field (thermal, laser, squeezed) are discussed and their photon-statistical properties derived. The density matrix operator for the field is introduced along with a detailed discussion of the diagonal representation of the field density operator and its properties. Field commutation relations, correlation functions, and uncertainty relations are derived and discussed. Also discussed are the historically important Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis of field commutation and uncertainty relations; energy-time uncertainty relations; simultaneous (Arthurs-Kelly) measurement of non-commuting observables; and complementarity from the perspective of probability amplitudes and probabilities for distinguishable and indistinguishable processes.
We have argued in previous notes (1) that the “wave” nature of quantum mechanics follows from the Lorentz invariant for a constant p: A= -Et+px which holds for both a particle with rest mass and a photon. In A, t and x are separated indicating independence which violates the Newtonian view x(t). “A” leads to dA/dx partial = p and dA/dt= -E. Creating eigenvalue equations yields: -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx) and id/dt exp(-iEt) = E exp(-iEt). Thus, x and t may be separated. Given that exp(ipx) exists in all of space (because there is no time), it represents a somewhat spatially invariant probability. In the case of a photon, Maxwell showed one may write wave equations for the electric El and magnetic B fields using his electromagnetic equations with no charge or currents.. He showed the wave travels at the speed of light in a vacuum and thus characterized light as an electromagnetic wave. This is not the same statement as exp(ipx) which is a probability wave. One may note that Maxwell’s equations are Lorentz invariant, so the ideas of the first paragraph should hold. In this note, however, we consider the Poynting equation: d/dt partial (.5( eoElEl+1/uoBB)) + 1/uo grad dot El x B = function(charge and current). 1/uo ElxB is considered to be a momentum density. We note Maxwell’s equations contain d/dt partial and d/dx partial, so time and space are considered independent (unlike x(t)), and act on El and B. The presence of charge and current densities breaks spatial invariance i.e. creates local regions. We argue in this note that d/dx and d/dt are generators of translations in space and time. We further argue that Maxwell’s theoretical creation of a photon follows from introducing spatial invariance into the problem, i.e. removing all charge and current densities. Spatial invariance in Newtonian mechanics, however, is associated with a constant i.e. a constant speed and momentum and equal probability to be at any x. Given that d/dx and d/dt appear, one has a function of space and time which seems to be completely at odds with spatial invariance and the idea of a constant momentum. We have argued in (2), however, that constant motion, even though represented by v=constant, is associated with the force that created the momentum, and this manifests itself in a spatial density which is probabilistic. Thus the presence of d/dt and d/dx in Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations, even when charge and current densities are removed, implies the same thing. Thus we argue that Maxwell’s electromagnetic equations are probabilistic. We investigate these ideas in this note. We further argue that it is spatial invariance, together with the presence of d/dx partial which yields the periodic form exp(ipx). Thus it is not a coincidence that wave equations appear for El and B.