Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Wave optics versus wave mechanics I

Sergey V. Gaponenko

Published Apr 8, 2010• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Let us return from optics to mechanics and explore the analogy to its fullest extent. In optics the old system of mechanics corresponds to intellectually operating with isolated mutually independent light rays. The new undulatory mechanics corresponds to the wave theory of light . Erwin Schrödinger, Nobel lecture , 1933 In this chapter we shall see that electromagnetic waves and electrons feature a number of common properties under conditions of spatial confinement. Simple and familiar problems from introductory quantum mechanics and textbook wave optics are recalled in this chapter to emphasize the basic features of waves in spatially inhomogeneous media. Herewith we make a first step towards understanding the properties of electrons and electromagnetic waves in nanostructures and notice that these properties in many instances are counterparts. Different formulas and statements of this chapter can be found in handbooks on quantum mechanics and wave optics. A few textbooks on quantum mechanics do consider analogies of propagation and reflection phenomena in wave optics with those in wave mechanics. Isomorphism of the Schrödinger and Helmholtz equations In Chapter 2 we discussed that an electron in quantum mechanics is described by the wave function, the square of its absolute value giving the probability of finding an electron at a specific point in space. This function satisfies the Schrödinger equation (2.56) which is the second-order differential equation with respect to space and the first-order differential equation with respect to time.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511750502.004

Related papers

Schrödinger's Wave Quantum Mechanics

Caio Lima Firme

In the first part of this chapter, the Hamiltonian function and Hamilton-Jacobi equation are presented. The latter is the starting point of Schrödinger’s work to obtain his wave equation. Next, the derivation of the wave equation is given along with the foundations of Schrödinger’s wave mechanics, i.e., the Hamilton’s analogy between optics and mechanics. It is also introduced some applications of the Schrödinger’s new quantum theory to several problems (radial function of the hydrogen atom, Compton effect and quantum harmonic oscillator). Other applications are also indicated in this chapter. The Dirac notation is introduced followed by the derivation of the expectation value in quantum mechanics and its derivation with respect to time. Next, Born’s probability theory and the superposition principle are introduced followed by the derivation of the quantum linear momentum operator. Afterwards, the normalization of a wave function and the orthogonality of a wave function are given followed by the properties of the Hermitian operator. In the end of the chapter, several examples and exercises are presented (168 words).

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 21, 2022•0 citations

Waveguides, Resonant Cavities, Optical Fibers and Their Quantum Counterparts

Victor Bârsan

In this chapter, we shall expose several analogies between oscillatory phenomena in mecahanics and optics.The main subject will be the analogy between propagation of electromagnetic waves in dielectrics and of electrons in various time-independent potentials.The basis of this analogy is the fact that both wave equations for electromagnetic monoenergetic waves (i.e. with well-defined frequency), obtained directly from the Maxwell equations, and the time-independent Schrodinger equation are Helmholtz equations; when specific restrictions -like behaviour at infinity and boundary conditions -are imposed, they generate similar eigenvalues problems, with similar solutions.The benefit of such analogies is twofold.First, it could help a researcher, specialized in a specific field, to better understand a new one.For instance, they might efficiently explain the fiber-optics properties to people already familiar with quantum mechanics.Also, even if such researchers work frequently with the quantum mechanical wave function, the electromagnetic modal field may provide an interesting vizualization of quantum probability density field [1].Second, it provides the opportunity of cross-fertilization between (for instance) electromagnetism and optoelectronics, through the development of ballistic electron optics in two dimensional (2D) electron systems (2DESs); transferring concepts, models of devices and experiments from one field to another stimulate the progress in both domains.Even if in modern times the analogies are not credited as most creative approaches in physics, in the early days of developement of science the perception was quite different."Men's labour ... should be turned to the investigation and observation of the resemblances and analogies of things... for these it is which detect the unity of nature, and lay the fundation for the constitution of the sciences.",considers Francis Bacon, quoted by [1].Some two centuries later, Goethe was looking for the "ultimate fact" -the Urphänomenon -specific to every scientific discipline, from botanics to optics [2], and, in this investigation, attributed to analogies a central role.However, if analogies cannot be considered anymore as central for the scientific investigation, thay could still be pedagogically useful and also inspiring for active scientific research.Let us describe now shortly the structure of this chapter.The next two sections are devoted to a general description of the two fields to be hereafter investigated: metallic and dielectric waveguides (Section 2) and 2DESs (Section 3).The importance of these topics for the development of optical fibers, integrated optics, optoelectronics, transport Waveguides, Resonant Cavities, Optical Fibers and Their Quantum Counterparts

InTech eBooks•Mar 23, 2012•5 citations

Schrödinger Equation and Wave Function

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

During 1925 three different but equivalent versions of quantum theory were proposed, Schrodinger proposed wave mechanics; Heisenberg developed matrix mechanics and Dirac-introduced operator theory. Considering the de Broglie's matter waves Erwin Schrödinger, an Austrian physicist, argued that if a particle like an electron behaves as a wave then the equation of wave motion could be successfully applied to it. He postulated a function varying in both space and time in a wave-like manner. Schrodinger set up a linear and time-dependent wave-like equation, called Schrodinger wave equation, to describe the wave aspect of a particle taking account of de Broglie's relation for wavelength. This chapter discusses the Schrodinger equation and explores the general properties of the solution of the Schrodinger equation. It verifies the Ehrenfest's theorem in certain interesting systems and solves equation for linear harmonic oscillator and shows that their solutions are identical to the solutions of classical equation of motion.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 29, 2022•0 citations

Wave mechanics

Vladimir Mitin, Viatcheslav A. Kochelap, Michael A. Stroscio

Introduction In this chapter we discuss the basic physical concepts and equations related to the behavior of particles in the nanoworld. We introduce the Schrödinger wave equation for particles and determine the ways to calculate observable physical quantities. We find that, in wave mechanics, the motion of a particle confined to a finite volume is always characterized by discrete values of the energy and standing-wave-like wavefunctions, i.e., such a motion is quantized. While motion in an infinite space (i.e., free motion) is not quantized and is described by propagating waves, the energy of the particle is characterized by a continuous range of values. Keeping in mind the diverse variants of nanostructures, by using wave mechanics we analyze some particular examples, which highlight important quantum properties of particles. Many of the examples analyzed can serve as the simplest models of nanostructures and will be exploited in following chapters to understand the fundamentals of processes in nanoelectronics. The Schrödinger wave equation From the previous chapter, we conclude that nanosize physical systems are quantum-mechanical systems, inasmuch as their sizes are comparable to typical de Broglie wavelengths of the particles composing these systems. In dealing with quantum-mechanical systems, one aims at determining the wavefunction of a single particle or of the whole system. As we will demonstrate in the subsequent discussion, knowledge of the wavefunction in quantum mechanics is sufficient to describe completely a particle or even a system of particles.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 6, 2007•0 citations

The Schrödinger Equation

David K. Ferry

The properties of the wave could be expressed as basically arising from a linear differential equation of a diffusive nature. In particular, because any subsequent form for the wave function evolved from a single initial state, the equation can only be of first order in the time derivative. In Schrödinger’s formulation, a wave equation was found to provide the basic understanding of quantum mechanics. Although not appreciated at the time, Schrödinger presented the connection between the wave approaches. In a somewhat political environment, Heisenberg received the 1932 Nobel Prize for ‘discovering’ quantum mechanics, while Schrödinger was forced to share the 1933 prize with Paul Dirac for advances in atomic physics. When the energy is below the height of the barrier, the wave must decay into the region where the barrier exists. Each interface is equivalent to a dielectric interface in electromagnetics, and the thin layer is equivalent to a thin dielectric layer in which interference phenomena can occur.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 6, 2020•0 citations

Introductory Quantum Mechanics for Nanoscience

Chandan Kumar Ghosh

In order to understand the properties of nanoparticles, it is very much required to have knowledge of quantum mechanics. This chapter introduces the basic concept of quantum mechanics. This chapter starts with quantum theory for radiation. It has been observed that the phenomena related to intense radiation like interference, diffraction, etc., could be well described with the help of Maxwell’s wave theory. But in the case of weakly intensed light, wave theory cannot be used to predict the related experimental phenomena. In this regard, quantum theory has been developed considering the particle nature of radiation. This evaluation of quantum theory has been briefly discussed in this chapter. In the world of matter, Newton’s law is successfully used to predict the position, velocity, acceleration, etc., of any macroscopic particle. But this couldn’t be used for particles of tiny dimensions like electrons, neutrons, etc. The difference is that for macroscopic particles we can measure their position and velocity with some accuracy, but for tiny particles, called quantum particles, it is difficult to determine their position and velocity at any given point in time. Wave theory has been presented by Schrödinger to predict features of quantum particles. We have given a few examples where Schrödinger’s wave theory can successfully explain quantum particles’ behavior under static as well as dynamic conditions. But in a real system, we cannot use this theory. We have discussed a few approximation methods to be used with Schrödinger’s wave theory in the case of a real system.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 18, 2017•0 citations
Let us return from optics to mechanics and explore the analogy to its fullest extent. In optics the old system of mechanics corresponds to intellectually operating with isolated mutually independent light rays. The new undulatory mechanics corresponds to the wave theory of light . Erwin Schrödinger, Nobel lecture , 1933 In this chapter we shall see that electromagnetic waves and electrons feature a number of common properties under conditions of spatial confinement. Simple and familiar problems from introductory quantum mechanics and textbook wave optics are recalled in this chapter to emphasize the basic features of waves in spatially inhomogeneous media. Herewith we make a first step towards understanding the properties of electrons and electromagnetic waves in nanostructures and notice that these properties in many instances are counterparts. Different formulas and statements of this chapter can be found in handbooks on quantum mechanics and wave optics. A few textbooks on quantum mechanics do consider analogies of propagation and reflection phenomena in wave optics with those in wave mechanics. Isomorphism of the Schrödinger and Helmholtz equations In Chapter 2 we discussed that an electron in quantum mechanics is described by the wave function, the square of its absolute value giving the probability of finding an electron at a specific point in space. This function satisfies the Schrödinger equation (2.56) which is the second-order differential equation with respect to space and the first-order differential equation with respect to time.
In the first part of this chapter, the Hamiltonian function and Hamilton-Jacobi equation are presented. The latter is the starting point of Schrödinger’s work to obtain his wave equation. Next, the derivation of the wave equation is given along with the foundations of Schrödinger’s wave mechanics, i.e., the Hamilton’s analogy between optics and mechanics. It is also introduced some applications of the Schrödinger’s new quantum theory to several problems (radial function of the hydrogen atom, Compton effect and quantum harmonic oscillator). Other applications are also indicated in this chapter. The Dirac notation is introduced followed by the derivation of the expectation value in quantum mechanics and its derivation with respect to time. Next, Born’s probability theory and the superposition principle are introduced followed by the derivation of the quantum linear momentum operator. Afterwards, the normalization of a wave function and the orthogonality of a wave function are given followed by the properties of the Hermitian operator. In the end of the chapter, several examples and exercises are presented (168 words).
In this chapter, we shall expose several analogies between oscillatory phenomena in mecahanics and optics.The main subject will be the analogy between propagation of electromagnetic waves in dielectrics and of electrons in various time-independent potentials.The basis of this analogy is the fact that both wave equations for electromagnetic monoenergetic waves (i.e. with well-defined frequency), obtained directly from the Maxwell equations, and the time-independent Schrodinger equation are Helmholtz equations; when specific restrictions -like behaviour at infinity and boundary conditions -are imposed, they generate similar eigenvalues problems, with similar solutions.The benefit of such analogies is twofold.First, it could help a researcher, specialized in a specific field, to better understand a new one.For instance, they might efficiently explain the fiber-optics properties to people already familiar with quantum mechanics.Also, even if such researchers work frequently with the quantum mechanical wave function, the electromagnetic modal field may provide an interesting vizualization of quantum probability density field [1].Second, it provides the opportunity of cross-fertilization between (for instance) electromagnetism and optoelectronics, through the development of ballistic electron optics in two dimensional (2D) electron systems (2DESs); transferring concepts, models of devices and experiments from one field to another stimulate the progress in both domains.Even if in modern times the analogies are not credited as most creative approaches in physics, in the early days of developement of science the perception was quite different."Men's labour ... should be turned to the investigation and observation of the resemblances and analogies of things... for these it is which detect the unity of nature, and lay the fundation for the constitution of the sciences.",considers Francis Bacon, quoted by [1].Some two centuries later, Goethe was looking for the "ultimate fact" -the Urphänomenon -specific to every scientific discipline, from botanics to optics [2], and, in this investigation, attributed to analogies a central role.However, if analogies cannot be considered anymore as central for the scientific investigation, thay could still be pedagogically useful and also inspiring for active scientific research.Let us describe now shortly the structure of this chapter.The next two sections are devoted to a general description of the two fields to be hereafter investigated: metallic and dielectric waveguides (Section 2) and 2DESs (Section 3).The importance of these topics for the development of optical fibers, integrated optics, optoelectronics, transport Waveguides, Resonant Cavities, Optical Fibers and Their Quantum Counterparts
During 1925 three different but equivalent versions of quantum theory were proposed, Schrodinger proposed wave mechanics; Heisenberg developed matrix mechanics and Dirac-introduced operator theory. Considering the de Broglie's matter waves Erwin Schrödinger, an Austrian physicist, argued that if a particle like an electron behaves as a wave then the equation of wave motion could be successfully applied to it. He postulated a function varying in both space and time in a wave-like manner. Schrodinger set up a linear and time-dependent wave-like equation, called Schrodinger wave equation, to describe the wave aspect of a particle taking account of de Broglie's relation for wavelength. This chapter discusses the Schrodinger equation and explores the general properties of the solution of the Schrodinger equation. It verifies the Ehrenfest's theorem in certain interesting systems and solves equation for linear harmonic oscillator and shows that their solutions are identical to the solutions of classical equation of motion.
Introduction In this chapter we discuss the basic physical concepts and equations related to the behavior of particles in the nanoworld. We introduce the Schrödinger wave equation for particles and determine the ways to calculate observable physical quantities. We find that, in wave mechanics, the motion of a particle confined to a finite volume is always characterized by discrete values of the energy and standing-wave-like wavefunctions, i.e., such a motion is quantized. While motion in an infinite space (i.e., free motion) is not quantized and is described by propagating waves, the energy of the particle is characterized by a continuous range of values. Keeping in mind the diverse variants of nanostructures, by using wave mechanics we analyze some particular examples, which highlight important quantum properties of particles. Many of the examples analyzed can serve as the simplest models of nanostructures and will be exploited in following chapters to understand the fundamentals of processes in nanoelectronics. The Schrödinger wave equation From the previous chapter, we conclude that nanosize physical systems are quantum-mechanical systems, inasmuch as their sizes are comparable to typical de Broglie wavelengths of the particles composing these systems. In dealing with quantum-mechanical systems, one aims at determining the wavefunction of a single particle or of the whole system. As we will demonstrate in the subsequent discussion, knowledge of the wavefunction in quantum mechanics is sufficient to describe completely a particle or even a system of particles.
The properties of the wave could be expressed as basically arising from a linear differential equation of a diffusive nature. In particular, because any subsequent form for the wave function evolved from a single initial state, the equation can only be of first order in the time derivative. In Schrödinger’s formulation, a wave equation was found to provide the basic understanding of quantum mechanics. Although not appreciated at the time, Schrödinger presented the connection between the wave approaches. In a somewhat political environment, Heisenberg received the 1932 Nobel Prize for ‘discovering’ quantum mechanics, while Schrödinger was forced to share the 1933 prize with Paul Dirac for advances in atomic physics. When the energy is below the height of the barrier, the wave must decay into the region where the barrier exists. Each interface is equivalent to a dielectric interface in electromagnetics, and the thin layer is equivalent to a thin dielectric layer in which interference phenomena can occur.
In order to understand the properties of nanoparticles, it is very much required to have knowledge of quantum mechanics. This chapter introduces the basic concept of quantum mechanics. This chapter starts with quantum theory for radiation. It has been observed that the phenomena related to intense radiation like interference, diffraction, etc., could be well described with the help of Maxwell’s wave theory. But in the case of weakly intensed light, wave theory cannot be used to predict the related experimental phenomena. In this regard, quantum theory has been developed considering the particle nature of radiation. This evaluation of quantum theory has been briefly discussed in this chapter. In the world of matter, Newton’s law is successfully used to predict the position, velocity, acceleration, etc., of any macroscopic particle. But this couldn’t be used for particles of tiny dimensions like electrons, neutrons, etc. The difference is that for macroscopic particles we can measure their position and velocity with some accuracy, but for tiny particles, called quantum particles, it is difficult to determine their position and velocity at any given point in time. Wave theory has been presented by Schrödinger to predict features of quantum particles. We have given a few examples where Schrödinger’s wave theory can successfully explain quantum particles’ behavior under static as well as dynamic conditions. But in a real system, we cannot use this theory. We have discussed a few approximation methods to be used with Schrödinger’s wave theory in the case of a real system.